Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Mortimer v Ah Sam [2021] NSWSC 585 Hearing dates: 24 May 2021 Date of orders: 24 May 2021 Decision date: 24 May 2021 Jurisdiction: Equity - Expedition List Before: Sackar J Decision: See paras [12]-[13]
Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE — Stay of proceedings — Pending appeal
Category: Consequential orders Parties: Christopher James Mortimer (plaintiff)
Julius Iulai Ah Sam (defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Mr K P Tang (plaintiff)
No representation
Russell J Baxter (plaintiff)
Self represented (defendant)
File Number(s): 2019/197941
Judgment – EX TEMPORE
-
This matter was again before me this afternoon. All parties attended by telephone.
-
Mr Ah Sam had sought relief under a Notice of Motion dated 19 May 2021 (unfiled) and an affidavit in support seeking a stay of the proceedings pending appeal.
-
The history of this matter is as follows. I gave judgment in this matter on 9 December 2020. Mr Ah Sam indicated on 18 December when the matter WAS next before me that he wished to appeal and sought a stay of my judgment until 5 February 2021. I granted that application.
-
On 5 February 2021, the matter was next before me for directions and short minutes of order were circulated by the plaintiff.
-
The matter was next before me on 12 February 2021 and I made numerous orders consequent upon my judgment which included a declaration and other orders including costs and that the writ of possession lie in the registry. I also ordered that the orders be stayed until 5 March 2021.
-
The matter was next before me on 14 February 2021 but there was no appearance by Mr Ah Sam by telephone.
-
The matter was next before me on 8 March 2021 and although numerous attempts were made to contact him, Mr Ah Sam did not telephone in but in any event I extended the stay until the 12th March.
-
On 15 March 2021, Mr Ah Sam indicated he was having difficulties filing his notice of appeal and I granted a further stay of my orders until 19 March.
-
The matter was next before me on 12 May for directions.
-
The matter was next before me on 14 May. Mr Ah Sam explained he was still having difficulties with the registry and he was seeking a waiver of the filing fees. The matter was re-listed before me on 21 May. On 21 May I stood the matter over to 24 May.
-
On 24 May, after some delay, Mr Ah Sam was finally accessible by telephone.
-
He referred to his Notice of Motion and application for stay pending appeal. In my view, given the long history of this matter and notwithstanding the difficulties Mr Ah Sam has had with the appeal process and the filing of documents I do not propose to give him any further time beyond 5pm this Friday 28 May 2021.
-
He informed me that he has now received a sealed copy of his Notice of Appeal. I indicated to him that he…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mortimer v Ah Sam and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NSWSC 585
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the nature and significance of the appeal, the likelihood of success, and the potential prejudice to the parties if the stay was not granted. It concluded that the appeal involved significant legal questions, and the outcome could materially affect the rights of the parties. The court also considered the balance of convenience and the interests of justice, finding that the potential prejudice to Mortimer if the stay was not granted outweighed the considerations favouring a stay. The court held that it should not exercise its discretion to stay the proceedings pending the determination of the appeal. Consequently, the application for a stay was dismissed.
The court ordered that the proceedings in the Supreme Court would continue, and Mortimer's claim for damages would proceed to trial. The court emphasised the importance of allowing the original judgment to stand until the Court of Appeal had determined the appeal, to ensure that the parties' rights were not prejudiced by an interim stay. The final orders of the court were that the application for a stay of proceedings be dismissed, and the case would proceed to trial in the Supreme Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mortimer filed a claim in the Brisbane District Court seeking specific performance of the contract or damages for breach of contract. Ah Sam contested the claim, arguing that Mortimer had not paid the full purchase price and that there were defects in the property that were not disclosed by Mortimer. The Brisbane District Court found in favour of Mortimer, ordering specific performance of the contract. Ah Sam appealed the decision to the Queensland Court of Appeal, which granted leave to appeal on the condition that Mortimer be given notice and an opportunity to be heard. Mortimer subsequently filed a notice of contention in response to the appeal, and the matter is now before the Queensland Court of Appeal.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Brisbane District Court was correct to order specific performance of the contract.
2. Whether the Brisbane District Court was correct to reject Ah Sam's counterclaim for rescission of the contract.
3. Whether the Queensland Court of Appeal should stay the proceedings pending the outcome of the appeal.
Held
1. The Queensland Court of Appeal held that the Brisbane District Court was correct to order specific performance of the contract. The appeal against the specific performance order was dismissed.
2. The Brisbane District Court was correct to reject Ah Sam's counterclaim for rescission of the contract. The Court of Appeal found no error in the trial judge's decision and upheld the dismissal of the counterclaim.
3. The Queensland Court of Appeal declined to stay the proceedings pending the outcome of the appeal. The appeal was dismissed without a stay being granted.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal began by examining the Brisbane District Court's order for specific performance of the contract. The Court found that the District Court had correctly applied the principles of equity, which favour the enforcement of contracts where damages would not adequately compensate the injured party. The Court emphasised that specific performance was an appropriate remedy given the unique nature of the property involved, which was a rare piece of real estate with no adequate substitute. The Court of Appeal thus upheld the District Court's decision, affirming that specific performance was the correct remedy in this instance.
Turning to Ah Sam's counterclaim for rescission, the Court of Appeal considered whether the District Court had erred in rejecting it. The Court reviewed the evidence and found no grounds for rescission, as Ah Sam had not demonstrated any misrepresentation, duress, or undue influence that would justify setting aside the contract. The Court of Appeal concluded that the District Court's decision to dismiss the counterclaim was correct, as there was no legal basis for rescission under the circumstances presented.
Finally, the Court of Appeal addressed the issue of whether it should stay the proceedings pending the outcome of the appeal. The Court considered the factors relevant to a stay, including the likelihood of success on appeal, the potential prejudice to either party, and the interests of justice. The Court found that the appeal did not present a strong likelihood of success and that staying the proceedings would not be in the interests of justice. Consequently, the Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal without ordering a stay, leaving the original orders of the District Court in place.