Morgan v Mallard No. Scgrg-00-970

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

MORGAN V MALLARD

[2000] SASC 445

Miscellaneous Appeal (Civil)

1................ LANDER J....... The plaintiff to proceedings in the District Court has filed a Notice of Appeal against an order made by a Judge of the District Court dismissing an appeal from a decision of a Master of that Court. 

  1. The plaintiff is unrepresented.  On 12 October 1999 she commenced proceedings against the defendant in the District Court.  In her Particulars of Claim which are annexed to the summons she claimed that on 1 November 1994 she wrote a letter “to lodge an official disclosure of public interest, according the provisions of the Whistle Blower Protection Act (WPA) 1993”.

  2. She asserts that in a letter dated 3 November 1994 the defendant gave a written response to the “responsible officer” of the “appropriate authority” in defence of allegations submitted by the plaintiff to the defendant’s employer.

  3. She then pleads the defendant falsely and maliciously wrote and published of the plaintiff the words contained in that letter of 3 November 1994.

  4. There is no need, in these reasons, to refer to the terms of the letter.  The plaintiff then pleads that the letter in its natural and ordinary meaning contains a number of imputations which the plaintiff identifies in those particulars of claim. Next, she pleads, that in Action No. 95/18167 “taken out by the Defendant and his wife, the Defendant and his wife mislead the Courts and lied on oath.”  She concluded her claim in the following terms:

    “16... By reason of the publication of the letter of the 3rd of November, 1994, and by misleading the Courts in Action No. 95/18167 the Plaintiff has been injured in her character and has suffered emotional stress and has suffered damages and financial loss.”

  5. The defendant entered an appearance and at the same time delivered a request for further and better particulars seeking a more explicit Statement of Claim.

  6. On 17 November 1999, the defendant made an application to the court for an order that the plaintiff file a more explicit Statement of Claim in accordance with the request made on 27 October 1999.

  7. The application sought, in the alternative, an order striking out those paragraphs of the Particulars of Claim which addressed the claim of misleading the court.  No application was made in relation to the claim based on defamation.

  8. The plaintiff responded to that application by filing an amended Particulars of Claim.

  9. She pleaded, in the amended Particulars of Claim in relation to the claim based on defamation:

    “4.1.. All statements made about the Plaintiff in the letter dated 3/11/94 were misleading, malicious, dishonest and deceitful and intended to cause injury and harm to the Plaintiff, and hinder a full and proper investigation into Defendant’s wife’s affairs.”

  10. In the amended Particulars of Claim she identified the misleading evidence given by the defendant in court and she pleads the falsity of that evidence.

  11. She then referred to decisions of Mr Hiskey SM and Prior J and Olsson J of this Court apparently…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Morgan v Mallard No. Scgrg-00-970 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] SASC 445
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Morgan, sought to appeal a decision of the District Court dismissing her appeal against an order made by a Master of that Court. Morgan's original action against the defendant, Mallard, was dismissed on the basis that it was an abuse of process and that she had failed to disclose a cause of action. Morgan's appeal against the District Court's decision was dismissed by a Judge of the District Court. Morgan then appealed to the Supreme Court of South Australia against the Judge's decision. The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the appeal was competent. The Court found that the appeal was not competent as of right and that Morgan was required to obtain leave from the Supreme Court to appeal the interlocutory decision of the District Court. The Court found that leave should be granted on the basis that the appeal involved a point of law of difficulty which justified it being reviewed on an interlocutory appeal. The Court found that the Master and the District Court Judge had erred in their application of the principles in Port of Melbourne Authority v Anshun Pty Ltd (1980) 147 CLR 589 to the facts of this case. The Court found that Morgan's claim in defamation was not precluded by the principles in Port of Melbourne Authority v Anshun Pty Ltd as it was a separate cause of action which could have been raised as a counterclaim in the earlier proceedings. The Court found that the proceedings should be stayed on the basis that Morgan was not entitled to rely upon a document which she had obtained by discovery in the earlier proceedings for her claim of defamation in the current proceedings without the leave of the Court. The Court found that the implied undertaking not to use documents discovered for any collateral or ulterior purpose applied to Morgan's use of the document in the current proceedings. The Court dismissed the appeal and stayed the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established