Moreton Bay Regional Council v Giffin

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

PLANNING & ENVIRONMENT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Moreton Bay Regional Council v Giffin & Anor  [2022] QPEC 20

PARTIES:

MORETON BAY REGIONAL COUNCIL

(applicant)

v
LEE STEWART GIFFIN

(first respondent)
LINDA ANGELA BOYDELL
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

4/2022

DIVISION:

Planning and Environment Court

PROCEEDING:

Originating Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Maroochydore

DELIVERED ON:

16 June 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Marooochydore

HEARING DATE:

9 June 2022

JUDGES:

Long SC DCJ

ORDER:

As per draft.

CATCHWORDS:

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT – ORIGINATING APPLICATION – ENFORCEMENT ORDERS – where the first and second respondents own land as joint tenants – where the second respondent owns an adjacent lot in his own right – where both lots are utilised for the purposes of operating an automotive spare parts business by the second respondent – where no development approval had been sought nor granted to permit such use – whether a development offence has been committed – whether discretionary relief is granted

LEGISLATION:

Planning Act 2016, ss 4, 5, 163, 165, 180, 181

CASES:

AAD Design Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [2011] QPELR 626
AAD Design Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [2013] 1 Qd R 1
Bassingthwaighte v Roma Town Council & Ors [2010] QPEC 91
Benfer v Sunshine Coast Regional Council [2019] QPEC 6
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
Booth v Yardley [2007] QPELR 229
Caloundra City Council v TaperPty Ltd and Anor [2003] QPELR 558
Chiefari v Brisbane City Council [2005] QPELR 500
Cuthbert v Moreton Bay Regional Council [2016] QPELR 179
Gold Coast City Council v Adrian’s Metal Management Pty Ltd & Ors [2018] QPEC 45
Gympie Regional Council v Bennett (P&E Application No. 830 of 2017)
Gympie Regional Council v Pye [2016] QPEC 65
Gympie Regional Council v Tregoning (P&E Application No. 118 of 2017)
Livingstone Shire Council v Hooper [2004] QPELR 308
Mudie v Gainriver [2002] 2 Qd R 53
Lockyer Valley Regional Council v MacAndrews Industries Pty Ltd & Ors (P&E Application No. 1330 of 2019)
Project Blue Sky Inv v Australian Broadcasting Authority (1998) 194 CLR 355
Sunshine Coast Regional Council v Werchon (P&E Application No. 177 of 2015)
Shire of Perth v O’Keefe (1964) 110 CLR 529
Warringah Shire Council v Sedevic [1987] 10 NSWLR 335
Yu v Brisbane City Council [2006] QPELR 102

COUNSEL:

Rix, B for the applicant

SOLICITORS:

Thynne & Macartney Lawyers for the applicant
Koolik & Associates Lawyers for the first respondent

Introduction

  1. By originating application filed 4 January 2022, the applicant seeks enforcement orders pursuant to s 180 of the Planning Act 2016 (“PA”). 

  2. The proceedings relate to land situated at 546 – 550 Morayfield Road, Burpengary, more particularly described as Lot 5 on RP85776 (“Lot 5”) and Lot 6 on RP85776 (“Lot 6”) (collectively “the land”).

  3. Pursuant to s 180(2) of the PA:

    “An enforcement order is an order that requires a person to do either or both of the following –

    (a)    refrain from committing a development offence;

    (b)    remedy to the effect of a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moreton Bay Regional Council v Giffin and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QPEC 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Moreton Bay Regional Council has brought this application against the respondents seeking enforcement orders for development offences. The Council claims that the respondents have used land for the purpose of operating an automotive spare parts business without the necessary development approval. The respondents own the land in question as joint tenants, with one of the respondents also owning an adjacent lot in their own right. The Council argues that the use of the land for the automotive business has been ongoing since 2005, and the respondents have been aware of the need to obtain approval or cease the activities since 2010. The Council argues that the respondents have been given sufficient time to remedy the matter and now seek orders to require the use to cease and the land to be remediated. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the present use of the land is one that requires approval and that there being no such extant approval, the use of the land is unlawful. The court considered the evidence and found that the present use of the land is one that requires approval, and the lack of such approval renders the use unlawful. The court also found that the respondents had been on notice about the contended unlawfulness of the activities since at least December 2010, the activities are ongoing, and the unlawful use of the land is ongoing. The court found that the respondents had been given sufficient time to remedy matters without intervention of the Court, and an order is now required to cease the use and remediate the land. The court found in favour of the Council and made orders requiring the respondents to cease the use of the land for the automotive business and to remediate the land. The court also ordered the respondents to pay the Council's costs of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

As per draft.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

At the outset it may be noted that despite the originating application seeking orders upon the alternative bases of identification of development offences pursuant to both ss 163 and 165 of the PA, the application is only pressed in relation to the application of s 165 and therefore upon the basis that the Court would ultimately be satisfied that:(a)the present use of the land is one that requires approval and that there being no such extant approval, the use of the land is unlawful;(b)that the uncontested evidence before the court is that the matters the subject of the application have been extant since about 2005, with the respondents being on notice about the contended unlawfulness of the activities and the need to either obtain approval or cease the activities, since at least December 2010;[6](c)that the activities are ongoing and the unlawful use of the land is ongoing; and(d)the respondents have been given sufficient time to remedy matters without intervention of the Court, with the need now for an order to require the use to cease and the land to be remediated. [6]See CEO Certificate at p. 3. Ex. GC-03.The Evidence Particularly having regard to the history of the use of the land predating the introduction of the PA, on 3 July 2022, the evidence as to the history of the use of the land is largely relied upon as being contextual to an understanding of the evidence as to the present and ongoing use of the land. An appropriate summary of that evidence is provided in the applicant’s written submission,[7] as follows:[7]The second respondent himself made reference to much of this essential history in the course of his addresses to the Court upon the hearing of this application, on 9/6/22.(a)In about 1999, the first respondent began to conduct an automotive spare parts business on premises located at Lot 1 Dickson Road, Caboolture (i.e. not the land presently in question) under the business name 'Japanese 4x4 Spares and Repairs';[8][8]Affidavit of Antony Calligeros (CD 16), Exhibit APC-10.(b)In about 2002, the first respondent moved his automotive spare parts business to operate from premises located at 20 Reynolds Court, Burpengary and then, sometime thereafter, to 38 Kayleigh Road, Maroochydore;[9] [9]Affidavit of Antony Calligeros (CD 16), Exhibit APC-10.(c)Sometime after the first respondent and second respondent purchased Lot 5 (that purchase occurring in late 2004), the first respondent moved his automotive spare parts business and commenced operating the business from Lot 5.[10] The historical aerial imagery, to hand, suggests that the use may have been operating (or at least preparations were underway to commence operations) from the land in January 2005,[11] and that the use certainly was operating by September 2009;[12] [10]Affidavit of Antony Calligeros (CD 16), Exhibit APC-10.[11]Certificates pursuant to s 131(2) Survey and Mapping Infrastructure Act 2003, CDs 6 and 7.[12]Certificate pursuant to s 131(2) Survey and Mapping Infrastructure Act 2003, CD 3.(d)Consistent with the above suggestion of the use of the land commencing in about 2005, from July 2005 through to 2021 the Council has received complaints from local residents with respect to the use of the land, including complaints that are clearly related to the use in question in this proceeding;[13] [13]Affidavit of Richard Konarski (CD 18), para. [8] and Exhibit RJK-03.(e)The first respondent purchased Lot 6 in about October 2008 and eventually expanded the operation of his automotive spare parts business over both Lots 5 and 6;[14] [14]Certificates pursuant to s 131(2) Survey and Mapping Infrastructure Act 2003, CD 3 and CD 4.(f)On or about 2 December 2010 the Council issued a Show Cause Notice to the First and second respondents asserting that Council reasonably believed that a development offence was being carried out on Lot 5, as it was being used for the storage of over 40 vehicles, a use which Council considered was assessable development (the use of Storage Facility) under its planning scheme as in force at the time (being the immediate predecessor to the current planning scheme).[15] [15]CEO Certificate, pp. 3-5 and Affidavit of Leo Mewing (CD 20).(g)On or about 14 April 2011, the Council issued an Enforcement Notice to the First and second respondents in relation to the matters outlined in paragraph (f) above;[16][16]CEO Certificate, pp. 6-10.(h)On or about 22 January 2013 the Council issued a Show Cause Notice to the First and second respondents asserting that Council reasonably believed that a development offence was being carried out on Lot 5 as it was being used for the sale, repair, fitting of accessories, storage and wrecking of between 40 and 60 vehicles, uses which Council considered were assessable development under its planning scheme as in force at the time and that use being carried out in the absence of a requisite development approval thereby constituted a development offence within the meaning of the then current SPA;[17] (i)On or about 23 April 2013 the Council issued an Enforcement Notice to the first and second respondents in relation to the matters outlined in (h) above;[18] (j)On or about 19 September 2013 the Council issued an Enforcement Notice to the first and second respondents asserting that Council reasonably believed that a development offence was being carried out on Lot 5 as it was being used for the sale, repair, fitting of accessories, storage and wrecking of between 40 and 60 vehicles, uses which Council considered were assessable development under its planning scheme as in force at the time and that use being carried out in the absence of a requisite development approval thereby constituted a development offence within the meaning of the then current SPA;[19] (k)On or about 29 January 2015 the Council issued a Show Cause Notice to the first respondent asserting that Council reasonably believed that a development offence was being carried out on Lot 6 as it was being used for the storage of vehicles associated with the business being carried out on Lot 5, a use which Council considered was assessable development (the use of Storage Facility) under its planning scheme as in force at the time and that use being carried out in the absence of a requisite development approval thereby constituted a development offence within the meaning of the then current SPA;[20] (l)The historical aerial imagery that is available to the Court reveals that the number of vehicles present on the land has increased over time;[21] (m)Inspections of the land on 10 March 2022 and 11 March 2022 revealed that, inter alia:[22] (i)signage at the front of the land advertised ‘Japanese 4x4 Spares & Repairs’; (ii)multiple vehicles (in the order of 50 or more) and vehicle parts in various states of repair and disrepair were present on the land; (iii)equipment (including a truck and forklift) and a shipping container with a vehicle on it were also present on the land (such equipment and shipping container clearly forming part of the ongoing use). [17]CEO Certificate, para. [13] and pp. 11-19. [18]CEO Certificate, pp. 20-28.[19]CEO Certificate, para. [13] and pp. 29-37.[20]CEO Certificate, para. [13] and pp. 38-40.[21]Certificates pursuant to s 131(2) Survey and Mapping Infrastructure Act 2003, CDs 3-9.[22]Affidavits of Shane Hattersley (CD 17) and Richard Konarski (CD 18).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.