Moree Plains Shire Council v Goater

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Moree Plains Shire Council v Goater

[2016] FCAFC 135

Appeal from: Goater v Moree Plains Shire Council [2015] FCCA 2594
File number: NSD 1718 of 2015
Judges: RARES, KATZMANN AND MARKOVIC JJ
Date of judgment: 6 October 2016
Catchwords: BANKRUTPCY AND INSOLVENCY – appeal from a decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia setting aside a bankruptcy notice – where respondent claims to have a counter-claim, set-off or cross demand of greater value than the creditor’s judgment debt – where funds not appropriated by debtor whether creditor has right to apply funds as it chooses – whether the primary judge properly considered the legal and factual merits of the respondent’s claim to set aside the bankruptcy notice – appeal allowed
Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 40(1)(g)

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) sch 2 s 18

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 27

Cases cited:

Bourns Inc v Raychem Corp [1999] 3 All ER 154

Caltabiano v Electoral Commission of Queensland (No 1) [2010] 1 Qd R 100

Cory Brothers & Company Limited v The Owners of the Turkish Steamship “Mecca” [1897] AC 286

Ebert v The Union Trustee Co of Australia Limited (1960) 104 CLR 346

Goater v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (2014) 88 NSWLR 362

Guss v Johnstone (2000) 171 ALR 598

Hearne v Street (2008) 235 CLR 125

Knysh & Anor v Corrales Pty Ltd (1989) 15 ACLR 629

Leeson v Leeson [1936] 2 KB 156

Date of hearing: 15 August 2016
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: General and Personal Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 84
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr S Bell
Solicitor for the Appellant: SR Law
Solicitor for the Respondent: Mr N Hill of Austral Legal

ORDERS

NSD 1718 of 2015
BETWEEN:

MOREE PLAINS SHIRE COUNCIL

Appellant

AND:

SHIRLEY GOATER

Respondent

JUDGES:

RARES, KATZMANN AND MARKOVIC JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

6 OCTOBER 2016

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be allowed.

2.The orders made by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on 9 December 2015 be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that:

(a)The application be dismissed.

(b)The applicant pay the respondent's costs.

(c)The time for compliance with bankruptcy notice BN183075 be extended to 27 October 2016.

3.The respondent pay the appellant's costs.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE COURT:

  1. On 21 August 2015, Shirley Goater filed an application in the Federal Circuit Court to set aside a bankruptcy notice that the appellant, Moree Plains Shire Council, had served on her on 30 July 2015.  The bankruptcy notice required Mrs Goater to pay the balance, of $6,822.97 outstanding, from a judgment debt for unpaid burial fees entered in the Local Court of New South Wales on 21 September 2012.  The original judgment was entered for an amount of $10,712.60 inclusive of costs.  The schedule of post-judgment interest…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moree Plains Shire Council v Goater and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCAFC 135
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the appeal of Moree Plains Shire Council v Goater, the Court was tasked with assessing an appeal from a decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia which had set aside a bankruptcy notice. Mrs Goater, the respondent, sought to have the bankruptcy notice set aside on the basis that she had a counter-claim, set-off, or cross demand greater than the creditor’s judgment debt. The central issue before the court was whether the primary judge had properly evaluated both the legal and factual merits of Mrs Goater’s claim to have the bankruptcy notice set aside. The court also needed to determine whether the creditor had the right to apply funds as it chose when the debtor had not appropriated the payment.

The court held that the primary judge had erred in his consideration and determination of Mrs Goater’s claim. The judge had acknowledged that Mrs Goater’s statement of claim, as filed in the District Court, appeared to establish a genuine claim with reasonable prospects of success. However, he failed to properly assess the legal and factual merits of her claim. In particular, Mrs Goater’s various versions of the alleged payment arrangements with the Council did not align with the evidence presented regarding the payments made to reduce the arrears. The court highlighted that if a debtor does not communicate an intention to appropriate a payment to a creditor, the creditor is free to apply the money as it chooses. The court found that the primary judge's failure to weigh the merits of Mrs Goater’s claim against the justice of continuing with the bankruptcy proceedings constituted an error.

The appeal was allowed, and the orders made by the Federal Circuit Court were set aside. In their place, the court ordered that the application be dismissed, Mrs Goater pay the Council’s costs, and the time for compliance with the bankruptcy notice be extended to 27 October 2016. Additionally, Mrs Goater was ordered to pay the Council's costs of the proceedings below.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The orders made by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on 9 December 2015 be set aside and in lieu thereof it be ordered that:

(a) The application be dismissed.

(b) The applicant pay the respondent's costs.

(c) The time for compliance with bankruptcy notice BN183075 be extended to 27 October 2016.

3. The respondent pay the appellant's costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

If the debtor applies to the Court for an order setting aside the bankruptcy notice before the time fixed for compliance on the ground that he or she has a counter-claim, set-off or cross demand of the kind specified in s 40(1)(g), then s 41(7) deems that the time for compliance with the notice is extended up to the day that the Court decides whether it is satisfied as to the existence of the debtor’s claim.Background Mrs Goater and her husband, Terry, ran a funeral business. Their residential and business premises were adjacent to each other in Moree and were registered in Mr Goater’s name. Mrs Goater claimed in her affidavit sworn on 20 August 2015 in support of the application to set the bankruptcy notice aside, from which we have taken most of the matters referred to below, that she and her husband had entered into a business loan agreement with the Commonwealth Bank of Australia that was secured by a first registered mortgage over the two properties. She said that in about 2011 and 2012 she and her husband experienced financial difficulties and that in October 2012 her husband received a default notice from the bank in respect of the loan. They filed a dispute claim with the Financial Ombudsman Service concerning the bank’s claim. That dispute was not resolved until 18 October 2013. On 26 August 2013, the Council cut the water supply to Mr and Mrs Goater’s home using a restrictor device, because by that day their arrears in payment of water rates totalled over $4,500. They had not made any payment for water rates for about two years. They were also in arrears of their Council rate payment obligations on that day to the tune of $14,653.27. In addition, Mrs Goater remained indebted to the Council for over $6,800 on the judgment debt. Mrs Goater said that on 2 September 2013 she requested that Suzie Treloar, the rates officer of the Council who had been dealing with their accounts, make a payment arrangement because she and her husband could not bring their accounts up to date immediately. She said that Ms Treloar said that the Council would accept $500 per month to pay the debt off and that, because of the inconsistent payment history of Mr and Mrs Goater, it would not remove the restrictor blocking their water supply until they had paid half the water rates outstanding. Ms Goater said that about one hour later “I received an email from Suzie with the bank account details and details of our arrangement”. Ms Treloar wrote that the restrictor had been placed on the meter “due to the fact that there has been no money paid to your water bill since 21/09/2011 and prior to that 21/10/2010”. The email recorded that the Council and its solicitors had sent reminder letters but that they had received no satisfactory proposal to pay. Accordingly, Ms Treloar wrote, the Council would not remove the restrictor until it received at least half of the $4,535.05 owing in respect of the water debt. The email recorded that Mrs Goater had said that she would pay $500 per month to reduce that debt.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is not necessary in the circumstances to deal with the other grounds of the Council’s appeal.Conclusion The appeal should be allowed with costs and the orders made by the trial judge should be set aside. The time for compliance with the bankruptcy notice should be extended by 21 days and Mrs Goater should be ordered to pay the Council’s costs of the proceedings below.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

She contended that his Honour was correct in his findings about the mutuality of the parties’ claims, the lack of any joint indebtedness, particularly given that she had made a claim for personal injury, and the Council’s breach of its obligation of confidence or the implied undertaking.Consideration – the prima facie case issue The trial judge correctly identified the principles governing the determination of the question whether he could be satisfied that Mrs Goater, as the debtor, had a counter-claim, set-off or cross demand under s 40(1)(g) of the Act. However, in our opinion, his Honour erred in his consideration and determination of that question. In substance, his Honour considered that Mrs Goater’s statement of claim, as filed in the District Court, established a genuine claim with reasonable prospects of success. But he did not consider the legal, and particularly, the factual merit of her claim. Thus, he could not have weighed those considerations with the justice of allowing the bankruptcy proceedings to continue: Guss 171 ALR at 606 [40]. The problem with Mrs Goater’s case was that the various versions of arrangements that she alleged that she (and Mr Goater) had with the Council lacked coherence with the material in the evidence in respect of what payments they both had to make, and had made, to reduce the arrears so as to make incorrect what Ms Treloar had written in the 6 November email to the bank. First, Mrs Goater’s pleaded case centred on the Council’s alleged misrepresentation of her and Mr Goater’s default in compliance with an arrangement to pay instalments of $500 to reduce arrears of their water rates. But she gave or relied on evidence of several different versions of the applicable arrangement. In any event, none of those answered the difficulty that no payments that she and her husband had made to the Council, after the $2,270 paid on 3 September 2013, specified to the Council in the electronic funds transfer advice or otherwise any allocation by them. In Cory Brothers & Company Limited v The Owners of the Turkish Steamship “Mecca” [1897] AC 286 at 293, Lord Macnaghten said:When a debtor is making a payment to his creditor he may appropriate the money as he pleases, and the creditor must apply it accordingly. If the debtor does not make any appropriation at the time when he makes the payment the right of application devolves on the creditor. (emphasis added) However, a mere intention to appropriate a payment that the debtor does not communicate to the creditor is not sufficient, and the creditor is free to apply the money, when received, as it chooses: Leeson v Leeson [1936] 2 KB 156 at 161 per Greer LJ, 162-163 per Greene LJ, with both of whom Talbot J agreed. Nonetheless, in Knysh v Corrales Pty Ltd (1989) 15 ACLR 629 at 633-634, Morling, Pincus and Lee JJ explained that the debtor’s intention to appropriate a payment can be inferred from all of the circumstances, even though the debtor does not expressly state that intention at the time of making the payment; see too Caltabiano v Electoral Commission of Queensland (No 1) [2010] 1 Qd R 100 at 114-116 [28]-[38] per Muir JA, 130-132 [107]-[110] per Fraser JA, 135 [129]-[130] per Fryberg J.