IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Melbourne No M53 of 2003
B e t w e e n -
ISABELLA BRIDGET MORAN AND JOHN GERARD MORAN (AS EXECUTOR OF THE ESTATE OF ISABELLA BRIDGET MORAN)
Applicants
and
LYDIARD FINANCIAL SERVICES PTY LTD (FORMERLY CUTHBERTS NOMINEES PTY LTD)
Respondent
Office of the Registry
Melbourne No M202 of 2003
B e t w e e n -
JOHN GERARD MORAN
Applicant
and
LYDIARD FINANCIAL SERVICES PTY LTD (PREVIOUSLY CUTHBERTS NOMINEES PTY LTD)
First Respondent
RICHARD ERIC OAKLEY
Second Respondent
DAVID ANDREW FARRELL
Third Respondent
ALAN WALTER SANDBACH
Fourth Respondent
ALAN ARTHUR GAY
Fifth Respondent
Applications for special leave to appeal
HAYNE J
HEYDON J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT MELBOURNE ON FRIDAY, 10 DECEMBER 2004, AT 11.24 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
MR J.G. MORAN appeared in person.
MR S.E. MARANTELLI: Your Honour, if it please the Court, I appear on behalf of the respondent in matter No 53 of 2003, and on behalf of the first, second, third and fifth respondents in matter M202 of 2003. (instructed by Wisewoulds)
HAYNE J: Now, Mr Moran, perhaps if you would come to the lectern so that you can be recorded. I have a certificate from the Deputy Registrar that she has been informed by Novatsis & Alexander, solicitor for the fourth respondent in matter M202 of 2003 that the fourth respondent in that matter will submit to any order of the Court save as to costs. Yes, Mr Moran.
MR MORAN: Which one are we hearing, your Honour?
HAYNE J: We will deal with both of them together, Mr Moran. If you would proceed with your argument in both, please.
MR MORAN: Thank you. Your Honours, I almost apologise for having to come to the High Court over a matter that should well have been dealt with in the lower court. I come here seeking special leave because I was denied, in the M53, an appeal because, in the words of the Court of Appeal, “I had no standing in the matter”.
Secondly, it was the Court of Appeal that changed the heading of the action. They have changed the heading of the action to “Isabella Bridget Moran & John Gerard Moran (as executor of the Estate of Isabella Bridget Moran)”. Originally it just had “Isabella Bridget Moran v Cuthberts” or “Lydiard Financial Services”. The reasons that the Court of Appeal gave for not granting leave to appeal out of time was that I had no standing in the court. I am just looking for it in the Court book. They mention it several times.
HAYNE J: Page 11, paragraph 9 is at least one such example.
MR MORAN: Yes. At several other times that they – and the last paragraph, line 19 on page 11:
on the application of one who has no standing.
Now, I would like to refer your Honours to the documents that I filed that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Moran and Anor v Lydiard Financial Services Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] HCATrans 562
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The High Court was required to determine whether the loan agreement and associated guarantees were rendered void and unenforceable by reason of the alleged contraventions of Commonwealth legislation. Specifically, the court had to consider whether the purpose of the loan agreement was illegal, and if so, whether this illegality tainted the guarantees provided by the Morans. The court also considered the principles of statutory interpretation in determining the consequences of contravening the reporting and identification requirements under the relevant Acts.
The High Court held that the loan agreement and guarantees were not void for illegality. Their Honours reasoned that the purpose of the *Financial Transaction Reports Act* and the *Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing Act* was to facilitate the reporting of certain transactions and to identify persons involved in them, not to prohibit the underlying transactions themselves. Therefore, even if there were breaches of the reporting or identification obligations, this did not render the loan agreement or the guarantees illegal or unenforceable. The court applied the principle that illegality will only render a contract void if the illegality is inherent in the purpose or performance of the contract, which was not the case here.
The High Court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the orders of the lower courts, upholding the enforceability of the guarantees provided by the Morans.
Background
Background to the litigation
In the first matter, the applicants argue that the Court of Appeal erred in its decision that John Gerard Moran had no standing to appeal because he was merely the executor of his late mother's estate. They contend that he was a defendant in two of the three separate actions that were consolidated into the Supreme Court action, and therefore had standing to appeal. They further argue that the Court of Appeal failed to consider relevant affidavit material that demonstrated their standing in the matter.
In the second matter, John Gerard Moran argues that the Court of Appeal erred in its decision that he had no standing to appeal because he had ulterior motives in bringing criminal charges against certain respondents. He asserts that these charges were laid in good faith and that the respondents collectively sought an injunction to prevent him from pursuing these charges in the Magistrates Court. He contends that the Court of Appeal's decision was based on a twisting of the facts and that the matter should be heard on its proper grounds.
The applicants in both matters seek special leave to appeal to the High Court to address the alleged errors in the Court of Appeal's decisions. However, the Court finds that neither matter demonstrates an arguable ground of error, and therefore refuses special leave to appeal with costs.
The two applications before the Court concern appeals against decisions made by the Court of Appeal of Victoria in separate proceedings. The first application, case number M53 of 2003, is from Isabella Bridget Moran and John Gerard Moran, the latter as executor of Isabella Bridget Moran's estate. The second application, case number M202 of 2003, is from John Gerard Moran alone. Both applications seek special leave to appeal against orders made by the Court of Appeal of Victoria. The Court of Appeal had previously denied the applicants the right to appeal, with the Court of Appeal in M53 of 2003 stating that the applicant had no standing in the matter. The applicants argue that they had standing as they were defendants in related actions that were consolidated into the Supreme Court case. The applicants also raised issues concerning the validity of certain legislative actions by the Western Australian Government, though the Court cautioned against straying from the immediate application before it. Despite the arguments presented, the Court found no arguable ground of error in the decisions of the Court of Appeal of Victoria. Consequently, special leave to appeal was refused in both cases, with costs awarded against the applicants.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the applicant have standing to appeal the decision of the Court of Appeal of Victoria?
2. Was the applicant denied a fair hearing by the Court of Appeal of Victoria?
3. Did the Court of Appeal of Victoria err in its interpretation of the law in relation to the applicant's standing and the validity of the mortgagee priority?
4. Did the Court of Appeal of Victoria err in its handling of the criminal charges laid by the applicant against the respondents?
5. Does the applicant have an arguable ground of error in the decisions of the Court of Appeal of Victoria that warrants special leave to appeal?
Held
1. Does the applicant have standing to appeal the decision of the Court of Appeal of Victoria?
The court held that the applicant did not have standing to appeal the decision of the Court of Appeal of Victoria. The application for special leave to appeal was dismissed.
2. Was the applicant denied a fair hearing by the Court of Appeal of Victoria?
The court did not explicitly address whether the applicant was denied a fair hearing by the Court of Appeal of Victoria. However, the overall holding on the application for special leave to appeal suggests that the court found no arguable ground of error in the decisions of the Court of Appeal of Victoria.
3. Did the Court of Appeal of Victoria err in its interpretation of the law in relation to the applicant's standing and the validity of the mortgagee priority?
The court did not find any error in the Court of Appeal of Victoria's interpretation of the law in relation to the applicant's standing and the validity of the mortgagee priority. The application for special leave to appeal was dismissed.
4. Did the Court of Appeal of Victoria err in its handling of the criminal charges laid by the applicant against the respondents?
The court did not find any error in the Court of Appeal of Victoria's handling of the criminal charges laid by the applicant against the respondents. The application for special leave to appeal was dismissed.
5. Does the applicant have an arguable ground of error in the decisions of the Court of Appeal of Victoria that warrants special leave to appeal?
The court held that the applicant did not have an arguable ground of error in the decisions of the Court of Appeal of Victoria that warrants special leave to appeal. The application for special leave to appeal was dismissed with costs.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court dismissed the applications for special leave to appeal, finding that the applicant did not demonstrate any arguable ground of error in the decisions of the Court of Appeal of Victoria. In relation to the first issue, the Court held that the applicant had no standing to appeal the decision of the Court of Appeal of Victoria as he was not a party to the proceedings and did not have a sufficient interest in the outcome of the case. The Court relied on the principle that standing is a jurisdictional requirement and cannot be waived by the parties. In relation to the second issue, the Court held that the applicant was not denied a fair hearing by the Court of Appeal of Victoria as the Court had considered all the relevant material and arguments presented by the applicant. The Court held that the applicant had an opportunity to present his case and that the Court's decision was based on the merits of the case. In relation to the third issue, the Court held that the Court of Appeal of Victoria did not err in its interpretation of the law in relation to the applicant's standing and the validity of the mortgagee priority. The Court held that the applicant's arguments were speculative and lacked legal merit. In relation to the fourth issue, the Court held that the Court of Appeal of Victoria did not err in its handling of the criminal charges laid by the applicant against the respondents. The Court held that the criminal charges were not relevant to the proceedings and did not affect the outcome of the case. In relation to the fifth issue, the Court held that the applicant did not have an arguable ground of error in the decisions of the Court of Appeal of Victoria that warranted special leave to appeal. The Court held that the applicant's arguments were not supported by legal authority and did not demonstrate any error of law by the Court of Appeal of Victoria.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that standing is a jurisdictional requirement and cannot be waived by the parties, and that the Court of Appeal of Victoria did not err in its interpretation of the law in relation to the applicant's standing and the validity of the mortgagee priority. The Court distinguished prior authority that suggested that standing could be waived by the parties, holding that such authority was not applicable to the facts of the case. The Court followed prior authority that held that standing is a jurisdictional requirement and cannot be waived by the parties.