MOQ Ltd, in the matter of MOQ Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

MOQ Ltd, in the matter of MOQ Ltd [2022] FCA 1160

File number(s): NSD 760 of 2022
Judgment of: HALLEY J
Date of judgment: 27 September 2022
Date of publication of reasons: 29 September 2022
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – members’ scheme of arrangement – first court hearing – application under ss 411 and 1319 of the Corporations Act (Cth) for orders convening a meeting of members to consider and agree a proposed scheme of arrangement – performance risk – exclusivity arrangements – break fee – deemed warranty – hybrid meeting – application granted
Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 411, 1319
Cases cited:

Absolute Equity Performance Fund Ltd, in the matter of Absolute Equity Performance Fund Ltd [2022] FCA 834

Amcom Telecommunications Limited, in the matter of Amcom Telecommunications Limited [2015] FCA 341

Australian Securities Commission v Marlborough Gold Mines Ltd (1993) 177 CLR 485; [1993] HCA 15

CSR Limited, in the matter of CSR Limited (2010) 183 FCR 358; [2010] FCAFC 34

Dealt Holdings Ltd, in the matter of Dealt Holdings Ltd [2022] FCA 1104

Dragontail Systems Limited, in the matter of Dragontail Systems Limited [2021] FCA 834

FT Eastment & Sons Pty Ltd v Metal Roof Decking Supplies Pty Ltd (1977) 3 ACLR 69

Integra Mining Limited, in the matter of Integra Mining Limited [2012] FCA 1414

Re Archaean Gold NL (1997) 23 ACSR 143

Re Central Pacific Minerals NL [2002] FCA 239

Xplore Wealth Limited, in the matter of Xplore Wealth Limited [2020] FCA 1868

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Corporations and Corporate Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 30
Date of hearing: 27 September 2022
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr M Oakes SC
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Thomson Geer

ORDERS

NSD 760 of 2022

IN THE MATTER OF MOQ LIMITED ACN 050 240 330

MOQ LIMITED ACN 050 240 330

Plaintiff

ORDER MADE BY:

HALLEY J

DATE OF ORDER:

27 SEPTEMBER 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to ss 411(1) and 1319 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act):

(a)the plaintiff convene a meeting (Scheme Meeting) of the holders of its fully paid ordinary shares (other than Excluded Shareholders as defined in the proposed scheme) (Participating Shareholders) for the purpose of considering, and if thought fit, agreeing (with or without modification) to the proposed scheme of arrangement to be made between the plaintiff and its Participating Shareholders (Scheme) substantially in the form of that contained in Exhibit 1 (Scheme Booklet);

(b)the Scheme Meeting be held 9.30 am (AEDT) on Friday, 4 November 2022 as a hybrid meeting,  in person at Thomson Geer, Level 14, 60 Martin Place, Sydney NSW 2000 and virtually via Automic Pty Ltd’s investor portal at chairperson of the Scheme Meeting be David Shein, or failing him, Alexander James White;

(d)the chairperson appointed to the Scheme Meeting has the power to adjourn or postpone the Scheme Meeting in his absolute…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MOQ Ltd, in the matter of MOQ Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1160
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of MOQ Ltd, the company sought approval from the Federal Court to convene a meeting of its members to consider and potentially approve a proposed scheme of arrangement. The scheme, if approved, would result in the acquisition of all ordinary shares in the company by Brennan VDI Pty Ltd, leading to the delisting of MOQ from the Australian Securities Exchange. The application was brought under sections 411 and 1319 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The primary legal issues before the court were whether the scheme was fair and reasonable to the participating shareholders and whether the formal requirements of the Corporations Act were satisfied to convene the meeting.

The court examined the evidence provided by MOQ, including affidavits from MOQ's directors and CEO, an expert report from Lonergan Edwards & Associates, and correspondence with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission. The court considered the strategic benefits and value of the scheme, the terms of the exclusivity arrangements, the reimbursement fee, and the deemed warranty. The court also noted that ASIC did not propose to make any submissions at the hearing nor intervene to oppose the scheme. After reviewing the evidence, the court found that the scheme was fair and reasonable and that the formal requirements of the Corporations Act were met.

Accordingly, the court granted the application and made orders convening a meeting of MOQ's members to consider and potentially approve the proposed scheme of arrangement. The meeting was to be held as a hybrid meeting, both in person and virtually, on November 4, 2022. The court also made orders regarding the distribution of the scheme booklet and proxy forms to the participating shareholders and exempted MOQ from certain advertising requirements. The proceeding was stood over to November 8, 2022, for the hearing of any application to approve the scheme.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to ss 411(1) and 1319 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act):

(a) the plaintiff convene a meeting (Scheme Meeting) of the holders of its fully paid ordinary shares (other than Excluded Shareholders as defined in the proposed scheme) (Participating Shareholders) for the purpose of considering, and if thought fit, agreeing (with or without modification) to the proposed scheme of arrangement to be made between the plaintiff and its Participating Shareholders (Scheme) substantially in the form of that contained in Exhibit 1 (Scheme Booklet);

(b) the Scheme Meeting be held 9.30 am (AEDT) on Friday, 4 November 2022 as a hybrid meeting, in person at Thomson Geer, Level 14, 60 Martin Place, Sydney NSW 2000 and virtually via Automic Pty Ltd’s investor portal at www.investor.automic.com.au;

(c) the chairperson of the Scheme Meeting be David Shein, or failing him, Alexander James White;

(d) the chairperson appointed to the Scheme Meeting has the power to adjourn or postpone the Scheme Meeting in his absolute discretion for such time and to such date as the chairperson considers appropriate;

(e) at the Scheme Meeting, the resolution to approve the Scheme be decided by way of a poll; and

(f) the Scheme Booklet and the proxy forms for the Scheme Meeting and the (substantially in the form of the pro forma copy which is Annexure PW-6 to the Affidavit of Peter Ward affirmed 23 September 2022 in these proceedings) (Proxy Forms) be approved for distribution to Shareholders.

2. Pursuant to s 1319 of the Corporations Act, the plaintiff is to cause to be issued on or before Tuesday, 4 October 2022:

(a) to each Participating Shareholder who, in accordance with the Corporations Act, has nominated an electronic address for the purposes of receiving notices of meeting from the plaintiff, at such address, an email substantially in the form of the document which is Annexure PW-10 to the Affidavit of Peter Ward affirmed 23 September 2022 in these proceedings, including:

(i) electronic hyperlink to download the Scheme Booklet; and

(ii) electronic hyperlink to the webpage where that Shareholder can electronically lodge proxies for the Scheme Meeting;

(b) to each Participating Shareholder who has elected to receive documents in hard copy pursuant to s 253RB of the Corporations Act, by ordinary post or in case of Shareholders whose registered address is outside of Australia, by pre-paid airmail, addressed to the shareholder's address set out in the plaintiff's register of members:

(i) a hard copy of the Scheme Booklet;

(ii) a hard copy of a Proxy Form; and

(iii) a reply paid envelope addressed to the Plaintiff's share registry;

(c) all remaining Participating Shareholders (that is, other than those referred to in (a) and (b) above, be sent by pre-paid post (or in the case of a Participating Shareholder whose registered address is outside Australia, by pre-paid air mail) the address recorded in MOQ share register (or, in the case of joint holders, to the holder whose name appears first in the plaintiff’s share register), a letter substantially in the form of Annexure PW-10 to the Affidavit of Peter Ward affirmed 23 September 2022 with the URL address of the Scheme Booklet, the proxy form substantially in the form included with the Scheme Booklet and a reply paid envelope addressed to the plaintiff..

3. Rule 2.15 of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) shall not apply to the Scheme Meeting.

4. Notice of the hearing of any application pursuant to s 411(4)(b) of the Corporations Act for orders approving the Scheme be published once in “The Australian” newspaper, by advertisement substantially in the form of Annexure “A” to these orders, such advertisement to be published on or before 31 October 2022, and the plaintiff be otherwise exempted for compliance with the requirement to publish a notice of the hearing of the application pursuant to rule 3.4 of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth).

5. The proceeding be stood over to 10.15 am on Tuesday, 8 November 2022 for the hearing of any application to approve the Scheme.

6. There be liberty to apply.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Annexure “A”

MOQ Limited

ACN 050 240 330

Notice of hearing to approve scheme of arrangement

TO all the creditors and members of MOQ Limited ACN 050 240 330 (MOQ).

TAKE NOTICE that at 10:15am (Sydney time) on Tuesday, 8 November 2022, the Federal Court of Australia at Law Courts Building, 184 Phillip Street, Queens Square, Sydney NSW 2000, Australia will hear an application by MOQ seeking the approval of a compromise or arrangement between MOQ and its members as proposed by the resolution to be considered at the meeting of the members of the company to be held on Friday, 4 November 2021.

If you wish to oppose the approval of the compromise or arrangement, you must file and serve on MOQ a notice of appearance, in the prescribed form, together with any affidavit on which you wish to rely at the hearing. The notice of appearance and affidavit must be served on MOQ at its address for service at least 1 day before the date fixed for the hearing of the application.

The address for service of MOQ is: c/- Thomson Geer, Level 14, 60 Martin Place, Sydney NSW 2000, Australia (Attention: Sylvia Fernandez).

Sylvia Fernandez, Thomson Geer

Solicitor for MOQ Limited

Background

Background to the litigation

MOQ Ltd, formerly Montech Holdings Limited, is a company focused on developing IT solutions, particularly cloud-focused technology solutions, and has offices in Sydney, Brisbane, Melbourne, Perth, and Colombo. The company was founded in June 2015 through a recapitalisation of a shell company listed on the ASX and was renamed MOQ Limited in July 2016. MOQ employs approximately 394 staff, with a significant portion based in its Sri Lankan office, which serves as an offshore delivery centre. MOQ proposes a scheme of arrangement under which Participating Shareholders will receive $0.075 for every ordinary share held as at the record date for the Scheme. The scheme, if implemented, will result in the acquisition of all the ordinary shares in MOQ by Brennan VDI Pty Ltd and the subsequent delisting of MOQ from the ASX. The scheme is described as providing compelling strategic benefits and value to Participating Shareholders.

This case involves an application by MOQ Ltd under sections 411 and 1319 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for orders convening a meeting of members to consider and agree to the proposed scheme of arrangement. The application was supported by affidavits from various individuals, including directors and experts, as well as the lodgement of the proposed scheme booklet with ASIC. The matter came before the court for the first time on the date of the hearing, with no prior decisions or proceedings noted in the provided text.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should grant the application for orders convening a meeting of members to consider and agree to the proposed scheme of arrangement.
2. Whether the scheme meeting should be held as a hybrid meeting, both in person and virtually.
3. Whether the specified chairpersons should be appointed to the scheme meeting, with the power to adjourn or postpone the meeting.
4. Whether the resolution to approve the scheme should be decided by way of a poll at the scheme meeting.
5. Whether the scheme booklet and proxy forms should be approved for distribution to shareholders.
6. Whether Rule 2.15 of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) should not apply to the scheme meeting.
7. Whether notice of the hearing of any application for orders approving the scheme should be published in "The Australian" newspaper and the proceeding stood over for the hearing of the application.

Held
1. The court granted the application for orders convening a meeting of members to consider and agree to the proposed scheme of arrangement.
2. The court allowed the scheme meeting to be held as a hybrid meeting, both in person and virtually.
3. The court appointed David Shein as the chairperson of the scheme meeting, or failing him, Alexander James White, with the power to adjourn or postpone the meeting.
4. The court ordered that the resolution to approve the scheme should be decided by way of a poll at the scheme meeting.
5. The court approved the scheme booklet and proxy forms for distribution to shareholders.
6. The court ruled that Rule 2.15 of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth) should not apply to the scheme meeting.
7. The court ordered that notice of the hearing of any application for orders approving the scheme should be published in "The Australian" newspaper and the proceeding stood over for the hearing of the application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Scheme is a conventional cash acquisition scheme under which Participating Shareholders will receive $0.075 for every ordinary share held as at the record date for the Scheme (Scheme Consideration). The Scheme, if implemented, will result in the acquisition of all the ordinary shares in MOQ (Scheme Shares) by Brennan VDI Pty Ltd (Brennan) and the subsequent delisting of MOQ from the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX). MOQ was founded as Montech Holdings Limited following a recapitalisation of a shell company listed on the ASX in June 2015. MOQ has since focused on developing IT solutions, and specifically cloud-focused technology solutions, both internally and through acquisitions. It changed its name to MOQ Limited in July 2016. MOQ’s head office is located in Sydney, with other offices located in Brisbane, Melbourne and Perth in Australia and Colombo in Sri Lanka. MOQ employs approximately 394 staff, with 140 of these based in its Sri Lankan office, which serves as an offshore delivery centre that critically supports MOQ’s managed services operations. The commercial purpose of the Scheme is described in the proposed explanatory statement (Scheme Booklet) as providing compelling strategic benefits and value to Participating Shareholders. EVIDENCE RELIED UPON BY MOQ The application is supported by the following affidavits:(a)the affidavit of Mr Peter Ward affirmed on 23 September 2022. Mr Ward is the director and Chief Executive Officer of MOQ. He gives evidence of MOQ’s operations and capital structure, the details of the Scheme Implementation Deed with Brennan (SID), that the Scheme Booklet was lodged with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), the details of the exclusivity provisions and reimbursement fee in the SID, a deed poll undertaken by Brennan, the Scheme Consideration, MOQ’s directors’ interest in MOQ shares, the implementation of the Scheme, the proposed Scheme Meeting and the proposed despatch of the Scheme Booklet;(b)the affidavit of Mr Craig Edwards affirmed on 23 September 2022. Mr Edwards is the managing director of Lonergan Edwards & Associates (LEA). He annexes to his affidavit the expert report prepared by LEA (LEA Expert Report), in which LEA concluded that the Scheme is fair and reasonable and in the best interest of Participating Shareholders in the absence of a superior proposal; (c)the affidavit of Mr David William Stevens affirmed on 23 September 2022. Mr Stevens is the sole director and company secretary of Brennan, and gives evidence of Brennan’s capital structure and in support of the orders sought;(d)two affidavits of Mr Timothy James Flahvin affirmed on 26 September 2022 and 27 September 2022. Mr Flahvin is a partner of Thomson Geer, the plaintiff’s solicitors. In his 26 September affidavit, Mr Flahvin gives evidence of the lodgement of documents in relation to the Scheme with ASIC and correspondence relating to that lodgement. In his 27 September affidavit, Mr Flahvin gives evidence of amendments made to the Scheme Booklet and ASIC’s comments in relation to those amendments. He also annexed ASIC’s letter of intent dated 26 September 2022, confirming that ASIC did not propose to make any submissions at the first court hearing nor intervene to oppose the Scheme;(e)the affidavit of Mr David Shein affirmed on 26 September 2022. Mr Shein is a director and the non-executive chairman of MOQ. Mr Shein gives evidence of his consent to act as chairperson at the Scheme Meeting; and(f)two affidavits of Mr Alexander James White, both affirmed on 26 September 2022. Mr White is a non-executive director of MOQ. He gives evidence of his nomination to act as alternate chairperson of the Scheme Meeting and his express consent to do so.CONSIDERATIONFormal requirements to exercise s 411(1) power