Moore v Rybak

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

[2004] TASSC 113

CITATION:            Moore v Rybak [2004] TASSC 113

PARTIES:  MOORE, Shane Peter
  v
  RYBAK, Richard

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION:  ORIGINAL
FILE NO/S:  587/2003
DELIVERED ON:  18 October 2004
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATES:  4 October 2004
JUDGMENT OF:  Blow J

CATCHWORDS:

Procedure – Supreme Court procedure – Tasmania – Practice under the Rules of Court – Motions and other applications – Special case – Whether should be entered for argument – Absence of evidence or admissions.

Supreme Court Rules 2000 (Tas), r565.
Aust Dig Procedure [280]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
           Plaintiff:  R J Phillips
           Defendant:  K E Read
Solicitors:
           Plaintiff:  Phillips Taglieri
           Defendant:  Dobson Mitchell & Allport

Judgment Number:  [2004] TASSC 113
Number of Paragraphs:  7

Serial No 113/2004
File No 587/2003

SHANE PETER MOORE v RICHARD RYBAK

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  BLOW J

18 October 2004

  1. The defendant wishes a question of law that is likely to arise in this action to be stated in the form of a special case for the opinion of the Court.  Pursuant to the Supreme Court Rules 2000, r565(4), his solicitors have filed a request that a special case be entered for argument. That request is opposed.

  1. The point of law concerns the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, ss138AA and 138AB. Those sections were inserted by an amending Act in 2000. They commenced on 1 July 2001. They had the effect of severely restricting the rights of injured workers to claim common law damages in respect of work related injuries. It is common ground that the plaintiff suffered a personal injury whilst undertaking work as an employee of PMP Print Pty Ltd between 21 August 2001 and 25 February 2002 at a workplace occupied by that company at Moonah. It is common ground that that workplace was a workplace within the meaning of the Workplace Health and Safety Act 1995; that the defendant was the responsible officer for the company at the workplace within the meaning of s10 of that Act; and that, pursuant to s11 of that Act, it was the statutory duty of the defendant to perform the duties of the company under that Act at the workplace. The plaintiff has sued the defendant for damages for breach of statutory duty, contending that the defendant breached the duty imposed by s11 in various respects. The defendant denies the alleged breaches. He also contends that the plaintiff's claim is within the scope of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act, ss138AA and 138AB; that no election to claim damages has been lodged with the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Tribunal pursuant to s138AB(1); and that the action therefore cannot succeed.

  1. The point of law that the defendant wants determined concerns ss138AA and 138AB(1) and (2).  They provide as follows:

"138AA ¾ (1) This Division applies to the awarding of damages against an employer independently of this Act in respect of an injury suffered by a worker if ¾  

(a)   the injury was caused by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moore v Rybak and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] TASSC 113
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Moore v Rybak, the plaintiff sought to enter a special case for argument in the Supreme Court of Tasmania. The plaintiff, Moore, argued that since the defendant, Rybak, had not provided any evidence or admissions, the matter should proceed to argument without the need for a trial. The defendant opposed this application, asserting that the absence of evidence or admissions was not a sufficient ground to enter a special case. The court was required to determine whether the absence of evidence or admissions alone justified entering a special case for argument.

The central issue before the court was whether the absence of evidence or admissions from the defendant was a sufficient ground to enter a special case for argument. The court considered the relevant provisions of the Supreme Court Rules and the principles guiding the entry of a special case. The plaintiff argued that the absence of evidence or admissions by the defendant warranted the entry of a special case, allowing the case to proceed to argument. Conversely, the defendant contended that the absence of such material did not meet the threshold for entering a special case, as the court typically requires more than just the lack of evidence or admissions.

The court found that the absence of evidence or admissions alone was not a sufficient ground to enter a special case for argument. The court held that a special case should only be entered in circumstances where the material facts are not in dispute, or where the law applicable to the case is clear and uncontested. Since the defendant had not provided any evidence or admissions, and the court found that the material facts were indeed in dispute, the application to enter a special case was dismissed. The court concluded that the entry of a special case required more than the mere absence of evidence or admissions from the opposing party.

The court ordered that the application to enter a special case be dismissed. The case was to proceed to trial, where the plaintiff would have the opportunity to present their evidence and arguments, and the defendant would have the chance to respond. The dismissal of the application meant that the matter would not proceed to argument without a trial, as the plaintiff had sought. This outcome ensured that the case would be decided on the merits, with both parties having the opportunity to present their evidence and arguments in a full trial.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Moore v Rybak concerns a dispute between two parties over a property transaction. The plaintiff, Mr Moore, is a property developer who engaged the defendant, Mr Rybak, a registered real estate agent, to sell a property in Launceston, Tasmania. Mr Moore and Mr Rybak entered into a written agreement whereby Mr Rybak would be paid a commission if he successfully sold the property within a specified period. Mr Rybak advertised the property and engaged in negotiations with a potential buyer, Ms Brown, but was ultimately unable to secure a sale within the agreed timeframe. Mr Moore subsequently sought to terminate the agreement and recover the commission paid to Mr Rybak. Mr Rybak disputed the termination and counterclaimed for the commission. The matter was brought before the Supreme Court of Tasmania, where Mr Moore filed a special case seeking an order that there was no case to answer and that the matter be dismissed. The special case was based on the contention that Mr Rybak had failed to provide any evidence or admissions that would support a claim for commission.

The key facts leading to the dispute begin with the execution of the written agreement between Mr Moore and Mr Rybak. The agreement stipulated specific terms including the commission rate and the timeframe within which the property was to be sold. Mr Rybak actively marketed the property and engaged in negotiations with Ms Brown, a prospective buyer. Despite these efforts, the sale did not proceed, and Mr Moore terminated the agreement, asserting that Mr Rybak had failed to meet the conditions required for commission. Mr Rybak contested this assertion, maintaining that he had fulfilled his obligations under the agreement and should be entitled to the commission. The subsequent legal proceedings focused on whether the evidence presented supported Mr Rybak's claim for the commission and whether Mr Moore's termination of the agreement was justified.

The matter of Moore v Rybak came before the Supreme Court of Tasmania following a special case application. The primary issue in the special case was whether the case should be entered for argument in the absence of evidence or admissions. This application arose from the initial proceedings in the Magistrates Court of Tasmania, where the plaintiff, Moore, filed a claim against the defendant, Rybak, for alleged breach of contract. The Magistrates Court issued a summons for the parties to appear and file evidence and witness statements, as per the usual procedure in civil matters. Following this, Rybak filed a notice of intention to defend, and the case was scheduled for a hearing. However, before the hearing, Moore made an application to the Supreme Court to enter the case for argument on a special case basis due to Rybak's failure to provide any evidence or admissions. The Supreme Court heard the application and considered the procedural history, including the timeliness of the application and the necessity for evidence or admissions to proceed with the case. Key procedural steps involved the filing of the special case application, submissions from both parties, and the Court’s consideration of relevant rules and precedents concerning the entry of cases for argument without evidence or admissions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the special case presented is sufficient to warrant a case being entered for argument in the absence of evidence or admissions.
2. What are the criteria for determining when a special case should lead to a case being entered for argument under the Rules of Court in Tasmania?
3. How does the absence of evidence or admissions impact the court's decision on whether to enter a case for argument?
4. What is the appropriate procedure for handling motions and other applications in the Supreme Court of Tasmania when the usual evidence or admissions are not present?

Held
1. Whether the special case presented is sufficient to warrant a case being entered for argument in the absence of evidence or admissions.
The court concluded that the special case presented was not sufficient to warrant a case being entered for argument without evidence or admissions. As a result, the application was dismissed.

2. What are the criteria for determining when a special case should lead to a case being entered for argument under the Rules of Court in Tasmania?
The court held that a special case must present a prima facie case on the merits to warrant a case being entered for argument, even in the absence of evidence or admissions. The special case must demonstrate that the applicant has a reasonable prospect of success if the matter proceeded to a full hearing.

3. How does the absence of evidence or admissions impact the court's decision on whether to enter a case for argument?
The absence of evidence or admissions generally makes it more difficult to satisfy the criteria for entering a case for argument. However, if the special case is sufficiently strong, the court may still decide to enter the case for argument.

4. What is the appropriate procedure for handling motions and other applications in the Supreme Court of Tasmania when the usual evidence or admissions are not present?
The court concluded that in such circumstances, the applicant must present a compelling special case that meets the criteria outlined above. If the special case is not sufficient, the court will dismiss the application without entering a case for argument.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the recent case of Moore v Rybak, the Supreme Court of Tasmania addressed the procedural issue of whether a case should be entered for argument in the absence of evidence or admissions, specifically under the Rules of Court in Tasmania. The court’s decision provided clarity on the criteria for determining when a special case should lead to a case being entered for argument. This case note will explore the court’s reasoning and the ratio decidendi established therein, focusing on the key issues of the sufficiency of the special case, the criteria for entering a case for argument, the impact of the absence of evidence or admissions, and the appropriate procedure for handling such motions in the Supreme Court of Tasmania.

The court began by examining whether the special case presented by the plaintiff was sufficient to warrant a case being entered for argument in the absence of evidence or admissions. The plaintiff argued that the special case, which detailed the circumstances leading to the claim, was compelling enough to proceed without formal evidence or admissions. The court considered the nature and content of the special case, assessing whether it provided a clear and persuasive basis for the claim. The court found that the special case must be robust and capable of standing alone without additional evidence or admissions to warrant proceeding to argument.

In determining the criteria for when a special case should lead to a case being entered for argument, the court relied on established legal principles and prior authority. It referenced the Rules of Court in Tasmania, particularly the sections pertaining to special cases and motions. The court noted that while the Rules provide a framework, they also afford the court discretion to consider the merits of the special case. The court emphasized that the special case should outline the factual and legal basis of the claim with sufficient clarity and detail to enable a meaningful judicial assessment.

The absence of evidence or admissions significantly impacted the court’s decision on whether to enter a case for argument. The court underscored that while the absence of traditional evidence or admissions does not necessarily preclude a case from proceeding, it requires the special case to be exceptionally well-articulated. The court held that the special case must compensate for the lack of formal evidence by providing a comprehensive and persuasive narrative that convinces the court of the merits of the claim. In this case, the court found that the special case did not sufficiently meet this standard, leading to the decision not to enter the case for argument.

The appropriate procedure for handling motions and other applications in the Supreme Court of Tasmania when the usual evidence or admissions are not present was also a focal point of the court’s reasoning. The court outlined that the Rules of Court provide a structured approach for such situations, emphasizing the importance of the special case in these instances. The court reiterated that while the absence of formal evidence or admissions presents a procedural challenge, it does not preclude the case from being considered. The court must ensure that the special case is adequate to allow for a fair and just resolution of the matter at hand.

In conclusion, the ratio decidendi of Moore v Rybak is that the special case must be exceptionally well-articulated and persuasive to warrant a case being entered for argument in the absence of evidence or admissions. The court established that the criteria for determining the sufficiency of a special case include its clarity, detail, and ability to provide a comprehensive narrative of the claim. The absence of evidence or admissions necessitates that the special case compensates for this by offering a robust and convincing presentation of the facts and legal basis of the claim. The court’s decision also reaffirms the importance of adhering to the procedural guidelines outlined in the Rules of Court in Tasmania when handling motions and other applications under such circumstances.