Moore v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read
DETERMINATION OF REVIEW PANEL
CITATION: Moore v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2024] NSWPICMP 808
CLAIMANT: Kristy Moore
INSURER: Allianz Australia Insurance Limited
REVIEW PANEL
MEMBER: Susan McTegg
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Alan Home
MEDICAL ASSESSOR: Drew Dixon
DATE OF DECISION: 29 November 2024
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS – Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; medical review of certificate of Medical Assessor (MA) Kuru; the claimant suffered injury in an accident on 5 October 2020; the dispute related to the assessment of whole person impairment (WPI) of cervical spine, lumbar spine, left shoulder and left hip; MA Karu assessed 0% WPI for cervical spine; 5% WPI for lumbar spine, 0% WPI for left shoulder and 0% WPI for the left hip; Held – notwithstanding lack of contemporaneous complaint causation of injury to left shoulder and the lumbar spine established; Briggs v IAG Limited trading as NRMA Insurance; injury to left shoulder secondary to injury to cervical spine as per Nguyen v the Motor Accidents Authority of NSW & Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd; soft tissue injury to cervical spine; soft tissue injury to lumbar spine; labral tear of the left hip; cervical spine assessed as 0% WPI; using range of motion method left shoulder assessed as 1% WPI; lumbar spine assessed as 5% WPI; left hip assessed as 2% WPI; total WPI 8% caused by the accident; certificate MA Kuru revoked.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:  

MOTOR ACCIDENT INJURIES ACT 2017

WHETHER THE DEGREE OF PERMANENT IMPAIRMENT OF THE INJURED PERSON AS A RESULT OF THE INJURY CAUSED BY THE MOTOR ACCIDENT IS GREATER THAN 10%

Certificate issued under s 7.23(1) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017

1.     The Review Panel revokes the certificate of Medical Assessor Robert Kuru dated 31 May 2024 and issues a new certificate determining that the following injuries were caused by the motor accident and give rise to a whole person impairment of 8% which is not greater than 10%:

·        cervical spine – soft tissue injury;

·        lumbar spine – soft tissue injury;

·        left hip – labral tear, and

·        left shoulder – soft tissue injury secondary to the injury to the cervical spine.

REVIEW PANEL REASONS FOR DECISION

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 5 October 2020 Ms Kristy Moore (the claimant) was a passenger in a vehicle travelling on the Princes Highway Corrimal when another vehicle collided with the front driver’s side of the vehicle causing the vehicle in which the claimant was a passenger to collide with a power pole (the accident).

  2. Ms Moore was 27 years of age at the date of accident and is now 31 years of age.

  3. Ms Moore has brought a claim for common law damages under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act).

  4. Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (the insurer) is the relevant insurer with liability to pay any damages to Ms Moore under the MAI Act.

  5. Section 4.11 of the MAI Act provides that there is no entitlement to damages for non-economic loss unless the degree of permanent impairment of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moore v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPICMP 808
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Moore v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, the Court was tasked with reviewing the assessment of whole person impairment (WPI) by Medical Assessor (MA) Kuru following a motor accident on 5 October 2020. The claimant, Ms Moore, sought to challenge the MA’s assessment of WPI for injuries to her cervical spine, lumbar spine, left shoulder, and left hip. The MA had assessed 0% WPI for the cervical spine, 5% WPI for the lumbar spine, 0% WPI for the left shoulder, and 0% WPI for the left hip. Ms Moore argued that these assessments were incorrect and that the total WPI should be higher.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the injuries sustained by Ms Moore in the motor accident were properly assessed by MA Kuru and if the WPI was correctly calculated. The Court considered the evidence of the injuries and the contemporaneous complaints made by Ms Moore, as well as the applicable legal principles and precedents. The Court held that the MA’s assessment was flawed and that the injuries to the left shoulder and lumbar spine, although not contemporaneously complained of, were indeed caused by the accident. The Court applied Briggs v IAG Limited trading as NRMA Insurance and Nguyen v the Motor Accidents Authority of NSW & Zurich Australian Insurance Ltd to establish causation. It was determined that the injury to the left shoulder was secondary to the injury to the cervical spine. The Court found that the injuries to the cervical spine and lumbar spine were soft tissue injuries, the left shoulder had a soft tissue injury secondary to the cervical spine, and the left hip had a labral tear. The Court re-assessed the WPI using the range of motion method and determined that the cervical spine should be assessed as 0%, the left shoulder as 1%, the lumbar spine as 5%, and the left hip as 2%, resulting in a total WPI of 8%. Consequently, the Court revoked the certificate of MA Kuru and issued a new certificate reflecting the correct assessment of WPI.

The final orders of the Court were that the certificate of MA Kuru was revoked and a new certificate was issued determining that the claimant's injuries were caused by the motor accident and gave rise to a WPI of 8%, which is not greater than 10%.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Treating medical evidence Following the accident on 5 October 2020 the NSW Ambulance Service attended the scene.[7] Ms Moore was trapped in the vehicle and was extricated. Relevantly, she complained of spine tenderness and pain in the left hip. [7] Claimant’s documents p 113. Ms Moore was conveyed to Shoalhaven Hospital where she was admitted overnight. She was reported to be complaining of cervical spine pain and left hip pain. She was amnesic to events and was noted to have microscopic haematuria. Imaging was reported as follows:· CT scan of the cervical spine – normal examination; · chest X-ray – no trauma identified; · X-ray pelvis – no bony abnormality demonstrated; · CT scan brain – no intracranial evidence of trauma demonstrated, and · renal ultrasound – no evidence of any acute renal injury. Ms Moore consulted Dr Innocent Nwali of Corrimal Healthcare Centre on 8 October 2020 when she reported the claimant’s involvement in the accident. She reported she had no structural injuries, but she still had hip pain and was walking with crutches.[8] On 12 October 2021 Dr Nwali reported Ms Moore still had aches and pains. Notwithstanding regular attendances there was no specific record of complaint pertaining to the neck, lower back or left shoulder between 8 October 2020 and 9 April 2021 when Ms Moore changed medical practitioner. All complaints related to the left hip. [8] Claimant’s documents p 175. On 23 December 2020 Dr Shaikh referred the claimant to Dr Aziz Bhimani, orthopaedic surgeon in respect of the left hip injury. On 1 February 2021 Dr Bhimani reported the MRI scans demonstrated an anterior labral tear and chondral defect with some associated marrow oedema of the left hip.[9] He reported significant pain in the left hip and buttock radiating into the groin and thigh. He reported the hip was tender to touch across the peritrochanteric anterior thigh and posterior buttock. [9] Claimant’s documents p 159. On 11 February 2021, 11 March 2021 and 13 April 2021 Ms Moore had CT guided platelet rich plasma (PRP) injections to the left hip. Ms Moore commenced treatment with East Corrimal Medical Centre.[10] On 21 April 2021 Dr Lakshmi Gribble recorded the car accident in October the preceding year and noted Ms Moore had had three platelet-rich plasma injections (PRP) injections into the left hip, an injury to the kidneys and back pain since the accident.[11] She also noted the history of depression. On 28 April 2021 Dr Gribble reported the claimant was still getting back pain, but it was better than before. On 10 May 2021 Dr Mehrotra reported the claimant had ongoing left back/flank pain which was unresponsive to physiotherapy. On 10 August 2021 Dr Fernandez reported a flare up of chronic hip symptoms.[12][10] Insurer’s documents p 119.[11] Claimant’s documents p 126.[12] Insurer’s documents p 131. Ms Moore attended physiotherapy with PhysioHealth and Sports Injury Clinic between 17 June 2021 and 16 January 2023 in respect of the left hip and groin pain although the claimant also underwent treatment for right hip pain.[13] The Pain Diagram completed on 17 June 2021 shows injury to the left hip, groin region and lower back region. There is no indication of injury to either the neck or left shoulder.[14][13] Claimant’s documents p 249 and claimant’s documents dated 4 November 2024 p 7.[14] Claimant’s documents p 261.

Decision

Reasons for decision

CONCLUSION The Panel revokes the certificate of Medical Assessor Robert Kuru dated 31 May 2024 and issues a new certificate determining that the following injuries were caused by the motor accident and give rise to a WPI of 8% which is not greater than 10%:· cervical spine – soft tissue injury;· lumbar spine – soft tissue injury; · left hip – labral tear, and· left shoulder – soft tissue injury secondary to the injury to the cervical spine.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established