Moore-McQuillan v WorkCover & Ors No. Scgrg-98-1512

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

MOORE-McQUILLAN v WORKCOVER, ROYAL SUN ALLIANCE
INSURANCE, WOLF AIR AND DIVE SHOP
[2000] SASC 228

Full Court: Olsson, Wicks and Gray JJ

1................ OLSSON J....... This is an application to the Full Court for leave to appeal against a decision of Millhouse J, on 27 November 1998, refusing leave to appeal against a decision of a presidential member of the Workers Compensation Appeal Tribunal, pronounced as long ago as 6 November 1998. It has been considered in private in accordance with the SCR by a Full Court as presently constituted.  The applicant filed the requisite documentation to initiate the present proceeding on 10 December 1998, but the matter has only just come before the Full Court.  This very considerable delay appears to be the consequence of the fact that the applicant has not taken steps to prosecute his application in a timely manner, by lodging all of the documentation required by the Supreme Court Rules.  He seeks to explain that situation by reference to what he says is a continuing psychiatric condition which he has suffered since late 1997.

  1. The relevant history is summarised in detail in the decision sought to be appealed against.  A copy of this is attached.

  2. In essence, a dispute arose concerning a claim for workers compensation arising from a disability which the applicant alleged that he had sustained to his left knee on 9 September 1990, in the course of his employment.  This related to what was contended to be the correct rate of income maintenance having regard to certain benefits said to have been provided to the applicant, in addition to the money component of his remuneration, as an employee of Wolf Air and Dive Shop.

  3. The matter came before Review Officers, as to the correct rate of income maintenance payable to the applicant, on two occasions.  This resulted in the publication of two decisions, the first being on 27 August 1991; and the second being some time in 1995.

  4. Early in 1997 the applicant sought to lodge appeals to the Tribunal against the decisions of both Review Officers, on the ground that each had a omitted a component of his earnings, namely accommodation expenses said to be worth $120 a week in addition to his monetary wage.  Both appeals were grossly out of time.  An extension of time was refused in relation to the 1991 decision, but an extension was granted in relation to the 1995 decision.

  5. The appeal against the latter decision was duly heard by the Tribunal which, on 2 May 1997, dismissed it.  The basis of such dismissal was that the issue of the accommodation component had never before been raised by the applicant and had not been in issue before the Review Officer.  The Tribunal pointed out that even the transcript of the proceedings in relation to the 1991 decision was totally devoid of any reference to such an issue.

  6. In 1998, after a further gross delay, the applicant sought to appeal against the 1991 decision in relation to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moore-McQuillan v WorkCover & Ors No. Scgrg-98-1512 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] SASC 228
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Moore-McQuillan v WorkCover, Royal Sun Alliance Insurance, Wolf Air and Dive Shop [2000] SASC 228, involves an applicant seeking leave to appeal against a decision of Millhouse J, which in turn was an appeal against a decision of a presidential member of the Workers Compensation Appeal Tribunal. The applicant, Moore-McQuillan, filed the requisite documentation to initiate the proceeding on 10 December 1998, but the matter has only recently come before the Full Court due to significant delays attributed to the applicant's inaction and a claimed continuing psychiatric condition.

The primary legal issue before the Full Court was whether the applicant, Moore-McQuillan, should be granted leave to appeal against the decision of Millhouse J, who had refused leave to appeal against a decision of the Workers Compensation Appeal Tribunal. The court had to determine if there was a question of law that warranted the attention of the Full Court. The applicant argued that the Deputy President had erred in exercising their discretion based on the merits of the case, but the Full Court needed to ascertain if this constituted a question of law or was merely an appeal on the merits.

The Full Court, consisting of Olsson, Wicks, and Gray JJ, held that there was no question of law that warranted the grant of leave. Olsson J, delivering the judgment, found that Millhouse J was correct in refusing leave to appeal, as the applicant was essentially seeking to challenge the Deputy President's exercise of discretion on the merits of the case. The Full Court agreed with Olsson J's assessment that the applicant was merely seeking to re-litigate an issue that had already been decided against him and there was no legal basis to warrant revisiting the matter.

The Full Court refused the applicant's application for leave to appeal against the decision of Millhouse J. The court found that the applicant had not demonstrated any question of law that would warrant the attention of the Full Court and that the matter had already been decided on its merits by the Workers Compensation Appeal Tribunal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute over a claim for workers' compensation related to an alleged disability to the left knee sustained by the applicant on 9 September 1990 while employed by Wolf Air and Dive Shop. The applicant had previously sought to appeal decisions concerning the correct rate of income maintenance, which included benefits such as accommodation expenses. The appeals were deemed to be out of time, with one appeal being dismissed by the Workers Compensation Appeal Tribunal on 2 May 1997. In 1998, the applicant again sought to appeal a 1991 decision, which was refused on 6 November 1998 by Deputy President Parsons on the grounds that the issue had already been determined against the applicant and the reasons for delay were unsatisfactory.

The case originated with the applicant's appeals to the Workers Compensation Appeal Tribunal against decisions made by Review Officers regarding the correct rate of income maintenance. These appeals were dismissed, with one being out of time and the other being dismissed on the merits. The applicant then sought leave to appeal the Tribunal's decision to the Supreme Court of South Australia. The application for leave was initially refused by Millhouse J on 27 November 1998. The applicant subsequently sought leave to appeal Millhouse J's decision to the Full Court, which heard the matter on 10 December 1998.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Full Court should grant leave to appeal against the decision of Millhouse J refusing leave to appeal the decision of the Workers Compensation Appeal Tribunal.
2. Whether there is a question of law that warrants the Full Court's attention in this matter.

Held
1. The Full Court refused leave to appeal against the decision of Millhouse J, who had refused leave to appeal the decision of the Workers Compensation Appeal Tribunal.
2. The Full Court found that there was no question of law that warranted its attention in this matter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Full Court considered the application for leave to appeal against the decision of Millhouse J, who had dismissed the applicant's application to appeal the Workers Compensation Appeal Tribunal's decision. The Full Court found that Millhouse J was correct in his assessment that the application did not present a question of law fit for the Full Court's attention. The Deputy President of the Tribunal had dismissed the applicant's appeal on the merits, based on the evidence presented. The Full Court found that the applicant was attempting to re-litigate an issue that had already been determined adversely to him, and that there was no legal basis for revisiting the matter. The Full Court also noted the significant delays in the applicant's attempts to prosecute the appeal, which did not warrant granting leave. The Full Court ultimately refused leave to appeal, finding no grounds for the appeal based on the merits or legal questions presented.