Moore and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 390

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No Q99/1211

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )       
           Re      SHOEBNA ANN MOORE
  Applicant

And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Deputy President DP Breen, Presidential Member      

Date19 May 2000  

PlaceBrisbane

Decision      The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution therefor determines that the applicant, Shoebna Ann Moore, be allowed to remain in Australia.   

(Sgd)          DP BREEN
  PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION – deportation – Section 200 Migration Act 1958 – abhorrence of crime – rehabilitation of applicant – balancing of consideration – extreme hardship to applicant.
Migration Act 1958 s 200
Bustescu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 1713

REASONS FOR DECISION

19 May 2000        Deputy President DP Breen, Presidential Member                  

  1. This is a review of a decision made on 1 April 1998 by a Delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs to deport the applicant, Ms Shoebna Ann Moore, under Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958.

  2. The matter was heard before me in Brisbane over six days.  The hearing began on 15 and 16 March 2000.  It resumed on 24 March, 4 and 5 May and concluded with oral submissions on 11 May 2000.  The applicant was represented by Mr Greg Milles of the Caboolture Legal Aid Office.  Mr Murray Belcher of the Australian Government Solicitor's Office represented the respondent Minister.  Both representatives were of significant assistance to the Tribunal in this difficult case.

  3. Oral evidence was given by the applicant; her mother, Dianne Tapsall; her stepfather, Kevin Smith; her brother, Scott Smith; her Aunt, Veronica Moore, and her Uncle, Colin Moore.  Evidence was also given by Dr Wendell Rosevear, a Doctor and Counsellor in the prisons, and Major Bruce Buckmaster, an officer of the Salvation Army and a chaplain in the prisons.

  4. The following documents were placed into evidence:

  • Exhibit 1            "T" Documents

  • Exhibit 2            Supplementary "T" Documents

  • Exhibit 3            Report of Dr W Rosevear dated 13/3/00

  • Exhibit 4            Letter from the Applicant dated 7/9/97

  • Exhibit 5            Progress Notes dated 4/3/98

  • Exhibit 6            Extracts from the Corrective Services File

  • Exhibit 7            Cognitive Skills and Anger Management Program Reports

  • Exhibit 8            Court of Appeal Transcript

  • Exhibit 9            Block Officer Report 30/4/99

  • Exhibit 10          Letter from the Applicant dated 16/11/99

  • Exhibit 11          Progress Report from Occupational Health and Safety Program

    dated 30/8/99

  • Exhibit 12          Sentence Management Educational/Vocational Review Report

  • Exhibit 13          Case Management Review Report dated 23/8/99

  • Exhibit 14          Sentence Management Review Report dated 23/8/99

  • Exhibit 15          Drug Offender Intervention and Treatment Certificate 1999

  • Exhibit 16          Sentence Management Review Report dated 2/9/99

  • Exhibit 17          Progress Notes dated 17/9/99 to 3/12/99

  • Exhibit 18          Submission to Parole Board

  • Exhibit 19          Letter to Parole Board on 16/2/00

  • Exhibit 20          Letter Granting Parole 23/2/00

  • Exhibit 21          Case Management Review Report dated 26/10/99

  • Exhibit 22          Work Report dated 16/11/99

  • Exhibit 23          Welding and Thermal Course Report dated 19/11/99

  • Exhibit 24          Bundle of Documents relating to prison behaviour and programs

    undertaken

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Moore and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 390
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves the applicant, Ms Shoebna Ann Moore, who is challenging the decision of a Delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs to deport her under Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958. The decision was made on 1 April 1998, and the case was heard by the court over six days in Brisbane, beginning on 15 March 2000. The applicant was represented by Mr Greg Milles, and the Minister was represented by Mr Murray Belcher. Several witnesses gave evidence, including the applicant, her family members, and professionals who have assessed her rehabilitation progress. The case centres on the balance between the abhorrence of the crime committed by the applicant and her efforts towards rehabilitation, as well as the potential hardship that deportation would cause to her and her family.

The central legal issues that the court had to address were whether the applicant’s criminal history warranted deportation under Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958 and whether the Tribunal should consider the hardship to the applicant and her family as a mitigating factor. The court had to assess the weight of the applicant's criminal conduct against her demonstrated efforts at rehabilitation and the potential consequences of deportation on her and her family. The court also had to consider the primary considerations outlined in Direction 9 – General Direction – Criminal Deportation, which include the expectations of the Australian community and, in cases involving children, the best interests of those children.

In deciding the case, the court considered the extensive criminal history of the applicant, which included theft, drug usage, and a violent robbery. Despite this, the court also noted the applicant's significant efforts at rehabilitation, her positive influence on other prisoners, her ongoing education, and her genuine remorse. The court found that the applicant had made a considerable turnaround in her life and was actively working to remain drug-free and reintegrate into society. The court also acknowledged the potential extreme hardship that deportation would cause to the applicant and her family, which was a crucial factor in their decision-making process.

The court concluded that the weight of the applicant's criminal conduct, while serious, was balanced by her significant efforts at rehabilitation and the potential hardship of deportation. The court found that the deportation order should be set aside, allowing the applicant to remain in Australia.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This is a review of a decision made on 1 April 1998 by a Delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs to deport the applicant, Ms Shoebna Ann Moore, under Section 200 of the Migration Act 1958. The matter was heard before me in Brisbane over six days. The hearing began on 15 and 16 March 2000. It resumed on 24 March, 4 and 5 May and concluded with oral submissions on 11 May 2000. The applicant was represented by Mr Greg Milles of the Caboolture Legal Aid Office. Mr Murray Belcher of the Australian Government Solicitor's Office represented the respondent Minister. Both representatives were of significant assistance to the Tribunal in this difficult case. Oral evidence was given by the applicant; her mother, Dianne Tapsall; her stepfather, Kevin Smith; her brother, Scott Smith; her Aunt, Veronica Moore, and her Uncle, Colin Moore. Evidence was also given by Dr Wendell Rosevear, a Doctor and Counsellor in the prisons, and Major Bruce Buckmaster, an officer of the Salvation Army and a chaplain in the prisons. The following documents were placed into evidence: The applicant is 23 years of age and a New Zealand citizen. She arrived in Australia to join her mother, stepfather and stepbrother in 1989. She returned to New Zealand to live with her father in late 1990 and then returned to Australia in 1994. Apart from two brief trips to Taiwan, she has remained here since. This has been a difficult and borderline case. On the one hand, there is an applicant with an extensive criminal history, which she accumulated over a very short period of time. Included in that history are offences of theft and drug usage as well as the deportable offence, which was constituted by a cowardly robbery involving the stalking of, and the violent physical abuse of, a defenceless young woman. On the other hand, there is an applicant who, despite a very dysfunctional childhood, has, four years later, made a significant turn-around in her life, according to the assessments of those best placed to make that appraisal of her. She is currently drug-free. She is a positive influence on other prisoners. She is studying at a tertiary level. She expresses genuine remorse for her actions and empathy for her victims. She has re-established a close and loving relationship with her mother and stepfather and has realistic plans for her future re-integration into society. She is aware that her drug habit is not entirely dealt with, although she has been drug-free for nearly two and a half years. She is aware of the risks of relapsing and is prepared to continue counselling to help her remain drug free. The applicable Ministerial Direction is Direction 9 – General Direction – Criminal Deportation. This Direction states that the primary considerations are the expectations of the Australian Community and in cases involving children, those children's best interest. Despite some argument on the matter, the Tribunal finds that the latter consideration does not apply in this case. As a matter of general construction, the consideration only applies where a parental or like relationship exists, not in the case of a brother/sister relationship.