Montesa Investments Pty Ltd v Certane CT Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal to a Single Judge)

MONTESA INVESTMENTS PTY LTD v CERTANE CT PTY LTD

[2022] SASC 43

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Blue  

6 May 2022

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - MORTGAGES, CHARGES AND ENCUMBRANCES

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - MORTGAGES, CHARGES AND ENCUMBRANCES - EQUITABLE MORTGAGES

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - MORTGAGES, CHARGES AND ENCUMBRANCES - RIGHTS, LIABILITIES AND REMEDIES OF MORTGAGOR

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY - DEFAULT JUDGMENT - SETTING ASIDE - PROCEDURAL AND OTHER MATTERS

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - ADMISSION OF FURTHER EVIDENCE

Appeal against an order for possession made by a Master in favour of the respondent against the appellant.

The appellant is the registered proprietor of land that was subject to a mortgage in favour of First Mortgage Capital Pty Ltd. The appellant fell into default under the loan terms. As at March 2019 it owed $479,150 to First Mortgage Capital. Interest was accruing at the higher rate of 36 per cent per annum.

The respondent agreed to lend $336,000 to the appellant, secured by a first mortgage over the land, for the purpose of refinancing the First Mortgage Capital loan. Interest would accrue at a higher rate of 30 per cent per annum, which was lower than under the First Mortgage Capital loan.

The appellant and First Mortgage Capital entered into a forbearance deed under which the appellant agreed to pay $310,000 and First Mortgage Capital agreed upon receipt of that payment to release its first mortgage; the appellant agreed to make subsequent bi-monthly instalments totalling $80,000 and First Mortgage Capital agreed upon receipt of the final payment to release any security interest over the land.

The respondent advanced $336,000 to the appellant, of which $310,000 was paid to First Mortgage Capital, which discharged its mortgage. First Mortgage Capital lodged a caveat to secure what was now a second mortgage over the land.

The appellant defaulted in payment of interest instalments and the principal under the loan. The respondent applied for an order under section 192 of the Real Property Act 1886 for possession of the land. An order for possession was made by the Master without substantive opposition by the appellant.

The appellant seeks leave to adduce new evidence on appeal and leave to appeal against the possession order on the ground that the respondent engaged in unconscionable conduct under section 12CA or 12CB of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) and in equity in providing the loan. It seeks orders on appeal setting aside the possession order and for the matter to proceed to trial on pleadings and discovery.

Held:

1       The appellant has failed to adduce sufficient evidence to establish a reasonably arguable case of special disadvantage and unconscionable conduct (at [111]).

2       In any event, the respondent had a clear entitlement to possession of the land when the Master made the possession order. Even…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Montesa Investments Pty Ltd v Certane CT Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] SASC 43
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Montesa Investments Pty Ltd v Certane CT Pty Ltd, Montesa sought leave to adduce new evidence on appeal and to appeal against a possession order made by Certane. Montesa alleged unconscionable conduct by Certane in providing the Certane loan and sought to set aside the possession order and have the matter proceed to trial on pleadings and discovery. Certane, a part of the Australian Secure Capital Fund group, acts as custodian for funds or companies within the group and carries on business as a mortgage-secured lender. Montesa borrowed $319,714 from Certane, secured by a mortgage over a property. Montesa fell into default and Certane applied to the Supreme Court for an order for possession of the property. The court was required to decide whether Montesa could adduce new evidence on appeal, whether Montesa had a reasonably arguable counterclaim, and whether the possession order should be stayed pending the determination of the counterclaim. The court found that Montesa had failed to adduce sufficient evidence to establish a reasonably arguable case of special disadvantage and unconscionable conduct. The court also found that even if Montesa had established a reasonably arguable counterclaim, it was inevitable that the property must be sold and there was no reason to stay an order for possession pending the hearing and determination of the counterclaim. The appeal was dismissed.

The court granted Montesa an extension of time to institute the appeal, granted leave to appeal, and dismissed the appeal. The court will hear the parties as to costs and any other orders sought. The court held that Montesa had failed to adduce sufficient evidence to establish a reasonably arguable case of special disadvantage and unconscionable conduct, that Certane had a clear entitlement to possession of the property, and that even if Montesa had established a reasonably arguable counterclaim, it was inevitable that the property must be sold and there was no reason to stay an order for possession pending the hearing and determination of the counterclaim. The appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held:

1 The appellant has failed to adduce sufficient evidence to establish a reasonably arguable case of special disadvantage and unconscionable conduct (at [111]).

2 In any event, the respondent had a clear entitlement to possession of the land when the Master made the possession order. Even if the appellant had established a reasonably arguable counterclaim, it is inevitable that the land must be sold. There is no reason to stay an order for possession pending the hearing and determination of a counterclaim (at [121]).

3 Appeal dismissed (at [123]).

Background

Background to the litigation

Montesa seeks leave to adduce new evidence on appeal and leave to appeal against the possession order on the ground that Certane engaged in unconscionable conduct under section 12CB of the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (the ASIC Act) and in equity in providing the Certane loan. It seeks orders on appeal setting aside the possession order and for the matter to proceed to trial on pleadings and discovery.Background Certane is part of the Australian Secure Capital Fund (ASCF) group and acts as custodian for funds or companies within that group. The group carries on business as a mortgage-secured lender. Summer Lawyers act as solicitors for ASCF (including Certane). Mr Durovic previously owned a Foodworks Supermarket in metropolitan Adelaide. Evidence was not adduced as to the legal ownership of that business, but I assume that it was conducted by a company owned and/or controlled by Mr Durovic. In 2017 Mr Durovic closed the supermarket due to volatile business market conditions and large competitors entering the industry. At some point, Mr Durovic became involved in Warehouse Connect Pty Ltd (Warehouse Connect). In February 2019 Mr Durovic became its sole director. Warehouse Connect provided services to clients of bulk storage, order dispatch, pick and pack, container unloading and delivery services. Its clients included Visy Board and Toll Group. As at March 2019 Warehouse Connect had been operating for at least one year. Before October 2017 Mr Durovic’s parents were the registered proprietors of the Land. They became the registered proprietors in 2008; however they have apparently lived at the property for over 40 years. In October 2017 Mr Durovic’s parents executed a transfer of the Land to Montesa, and Montesa borrowed $319,714 from FMC secured by the FMC mortgage over the Land. Evidence was not adduced concerning the reason for this transfer or how the proceeds of the FMC loan were used. Mr Durovic’s parents continued to reside at the property. The FMC mortgage was prepared by Summer Lawyers. It was executed by Mr Durovic on behalf of Montesa and by a solicitor from Summer Lawyers on behalf of FMC. Under the FMC mortgage, interest was chargeable in respect of the loan at a higher rate of interest of 36 per cent per annum or lower rate of interest of 18 per cent per annum. Evidence was not adduced as to the term of the FMC Loan. The terms of the FMC mortgage were contained in document reference 12758935. That document comprises Mortgage Common Provisions registered at the Lands Titles Registration Office entitled “Summer Lawyers 2017 Memorandum” (the Standard Terms). In November 2017 the transfer to Montesa and the FMC mortgage were registered over the Land. Montesa fell into default in compliance with the terms of the FMC loan. Summer Lawyers on behalf of FMC applied to the Supreme Court for an order under Part 17 of the Real Property Act for possession of the Land. In July 2018 a Master made an order (the FMC possession order) that Montesa give up possession of the Land within 70 days of service of the order (by October 2018).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the present case, even if Montesa had established a reasonably arguable counterclaim, it is inevitable that the Land must be sold. There is no reason to stay an order for possession pending the hearing and determination of a counterclaim. If Montesa chooses to bring an action for unconscionable conduct, it can obtain an order for payment of monies by Certane if it demonstrates an entitlement to such relief. There is no good reason to defer the sale and realisation of the value of the Land in the meantime.Conclusion I make the following orders:1.Montesa is granted an extension of time until 9 November 2021 to institute this appeal.2.Montesa is granted leave to appeal.3.The appeal is dismissed. I will hear the parties as to costs and as to any other orders sought.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established