| [2025] FWC 727 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
Monte Elissa
v
S Thomas Health Care Pty Ltd
(U2024/15250)
| DEPUTY PRESIDENT SAUNDERS | NEWCASTLE, 13 MARCH 2025 |
Unfair dismissal application – no dismissal – application dismissed.
Introduction
This decision concerns an application by Mr Monte Elissa for an unfair dismissal remedy pursuant to s 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act) against his employer, S Thomas Health Care Pty Ltd trading as Australian Health Professionals (AHP).
Mr Elissa alleges that he was dismissed on 15 May 2024 when he saw an advertisement for what he believed was his job. AHP denies that Mr Elissa was dismissed and says, in the alternative, that Mr Elissa’s unfair dismissal application was lodged out of time and it would not be appropriate in the circumstances of this case to grant an extension of time.
Dismissal
The question of when a person has been dismissed is governed by s 386 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (Act). It relevantly provides:
“(1) A person has been dismissed if:
(a) the person’s employment with his or his employer has been terminated on the employer’s initiative; or
(b) the person has resigned from his or his employment, but was forced to do so because of conduct, or a course of conduct, engaged in by his or his employer.”
Mr Elissa contends that his employment with AHP was terminated on his employer’s initiative. There is no suggestion in the material before the Commission that Mr Elissa resigned from his employment with AHP.
The expression termination “on the employer’s initiative” in s 386(1)(a) is a reference to a termination of the employment relationship and/or termination of the contract of employment[1] that is brought about by an employer and which is not agreed to by the employee.[2]
In circumstances where the employment relationship is not left voluntarily by the employee, the focus of the inquiry under s 386(1)(a) is whether an action on the part of the employer was the principal contributing factor which results, directly or consequentially, in the termination of the employment.[3]
Relevant facts re dismissal
On 11 March 2024, Mr Elissa alleges that his manager was verbally aggressive towards him.
On 14 May 2024, Mr Elissa participated in a meeting with AHP representatives in relation to the incident which took place on 11 March 2024.
A letter dated 15 May 2024 addressed to Mr Elissa was prepared by AHP.[4] It concerned allegations of misconduct against Mr Elissa and stated that “if proven, this misconduct may result in a written warning, a first and final written warning or the termination of your employment”. The letter was never sent to Mr Elissa.
On 15 May 2024, AHP advertised the position of Physiotherapist, located at Teralba, Newcastle, Maitland and Hunter Valley, New South Wales, commencing in June 2024. Mr Elissa thought that AHP was planning to recruit a new employee to replace him. The fact that the advertisement referred to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Monte Elissa v S Thomas Health Care Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] FWC 727
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Fair Work Commission examined the events surrounding the alleged dismissal and the employer's recruitment activities. It was noted that Mr Elissa continued to work and be paid by S Thomas Health Care Pty Ltd until 23 May 2024, when he took pre-approved annual leave. Despite Mr Elissa's belief that the advertisement was for his job, the Commission found that S Thomas Health Care Pty Ltd did not intend to terminate his employment. The employer’s constant recruitment efforts for physiotherapists, coupled with the fact that Mr Elissa's manager was unaware of the specific advertisement, supported the conclusion that the advertisement was not intended to replace Mr Elissa. The employer’s willingness to support Mr Elissa's return to work when he was fit further negated any claim of dismissal. Consequently, the Commission determined that Mr Elissa was not dismissed and, therefore, not unfairly dismissed.
The Deputy President dismissed Mr Elissa's unfair dismissal application, concluding that S Thomas Health Care Pty Ltd did not terminate his employment on their initiative. The Commission found no evidence to support Mr Elissa's claim of dismissal and rejected the notion that the employer's actions led to the termination of his employment relationship. The employer remained willing to have Mr Elissa return to work when he was medically fit to do so.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi