Replacement Transcript
IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Melbourne No M134 of 2010
B e t w e e n -
VERA MOMCILOVIC
Appellant
and
THE QUEEN
First Respondent
ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR THE STATE OF VICTORIA
Second Respondent
VICTORIAN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY AND HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION
Third Respondent
FRENCH CJ
GUMMOW J
HEYDON J
CRENNAN J
KIEFEL J
BELL J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT CANBERRA ON THURSDAY, 10 FEBRUARY 2011, AT 10.03 AM
(Continued from 9/2/2011)
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
__________________
FRENCH CJ: Yes, Mr Solicitor.
MR GAGELER: I turn to proposition 2 of my outline, and here I can be quite brief. The question raised by section 109 on the Ex parte McLean, Victoria v The Commonwealth view of its operation comes down to this. Is or is not section 302.4 of the Criminal Code, on its true construction, an exhaustive statement of the law governing criminal liability for the conduct with which it deals? The answer to that question is necessarily informed by the express terms of section 300.4. It is an interpretative provision, and it is a statement by the Parliament of what the Parliament actually intended in enacting section 302.4. Any possible ambiguity about the operation of subsection (1) can for present purposes be put to one side. Go straight to subsection (2), and what subsection (2) is saying, translated into the language of the cases, is that section 302.4 is not intended to be exhaustive or complete.
The Commonwealth criminal liability that section creates is intended to be cumulative upon such criminal liability as might exist under a law of a State or a Territory governing the same conduct or similar conduct. Ordinary principles of construction dictate, in our submission, that that solemn statement of legislative intention be decisive of the substantive operation of section 302.4, unless two possibilities come into play. One is that section 302.4 is somehow incapable of bearing that operation, and it is not, or that that operation is somehow contradicted or overridden or falsified by some other element of the Code, and there is none.
Absent section 300.4, it would be necessary to engage in an inferential interpretative exercise of the kind that was engaged in, quite properly, in Dickson and before that in Hume v Palmer and in Blacklock and the nature of that interpretative exercise is really spelt out by Sir Owen Dixon in Victoria v The Commonwealth in the passage that gets quoted in Dickson and in the page or two which follow that passage.
You would be looking at the nature of the conduct, you would be looking at the purpose of Part 9.1 as spelt out in section 300.1, you would be looking at the context in which Part 9.1 was enacted, you would be looking at the pre‑existing state of the law, you would be looking at the mischief to which the Part and, in particular, the relevant section, 302.4 were directed and you…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Momcilovic v The Queen & Ors [2011] HCATrans 17 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] HCATrans 17
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the statutory presumptions, which reversed the onus of proof onto the accused to demonstrate they did not possess the prohibited substance, were inconsistent with the implied constitutional prohibition against the legislative impairment of the judicial power of the Commonwealth. The Court was required to consider whether these presumptions, by requiring an accused to prove a negative, infringed upon the fundamental right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty, and whether such an infringement was constitutionally permissible.
A majority of the High Court held that the presumptions did not contravene the implied constitutional prohibition. The reasoning focused on the distinction between the legislative power to define criminal offences and the judicial power to determine guilt. The Court found that the presumptions did not usurp the function of the judiciary but rather defined the elements of the offence and the circumstances in which guilt could be established. The majority distinguished between presumptions that were conclusive and those that were rebuttable, with the latter being permissible as they allowed for the accused to present evidence to displace the presumption. The Court also considered the scope of the implied prohibition, noting it did not render all reversals of onus of proof unconstitutional.
The appeal was dismissed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter before the High Court is an appeal against the appellant's conviction for trafficking in a drug of dependence under the Drugs, Poisons and Controlled Substances Act 1981 (Vic). The appellant was convicted in the County Court of Victoria and subsequently appealed to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria. The Court of Appeal upheld the conviction but certified a question to the High Court under section 35 of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) regarding the interpretation of the relevant statutory provisions and their consistency with the Commonwealth Constitution. The High Court heard the appeal from the appellant, Vera Momcilovic, against the conviction and sentence imposed by the County Court, with the Attorney-General for the State of Victoria and the Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission as respondents. The appeal involves complex legal arguments concerning the interpretation of Commonwealth and State legislation, the operation of section 109 of the Commonwealth Constitution, and the reconciliation of potentially inconsistent statutory provisions under the Victorian Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities Act 2006 (Vic). The appellant argues that the Victorian legislation is inconsistent with the Commonwealth Criminal Code and therefore invalid under section 109 of the Constitution. The respondents contend that there is no inconsistency and that the Victorian legislation is valid. The High Court's decision will determine the validity of the Victorian legislation and the appropriate legal principles for interpreting and reconciling potentially inconsistent Commonwealth and State laws.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is section 302.4 of the Criminal Code an exhaustive statement of the law governing criminal liability for the conduct it deals with?
2. Does section 300.4 of the Criminal Code indicate that Part 9.1 of the Code is intended to be cumulative and overlap with State criminal laws?
3. Are there differences between the Commonwealth and State laws that give rise to an inconsistency within the meaning of section 109 of the Constitution?
4. Does section 5 of the Victorian Drugs Act alter, impair or detract from the offence created by section 302.4 of the Criminal Code?
5. Does section 5 of the Victorian Drugs Act trespass upon an area of liberty designedly left by the Criminal Code?
6. Does section 300.4 of the Criminal Code have work to do in the interpretation of section 5 of the Victorian Drugs Act?
7. Is there inconsistency between the Victorian Drugs Act and the Criminal Code due to the evidential burden placed on the accused by section 5?
8. What remedies should be applied if there is an error in the trial that leads to an appeal, and the accused has already served the custodial portion of their sentence?
Held
1. Section 302.4 of the Criminal Code is not an exhaustive statement of the law governing criminal liability for the conduct it deals with, as indicated by section 300.4 which states that Part 9.1 of the Code is not intended to exclude or limit the concurrent operation of any law of a State or Territory.
2. Section 300.4 of the Criminal Code indicates that Part 9.1 of the Code is intended to be cumulative and overlap with State criminal laws, as it is a non-exhaustive statement of the law with respect to drug trafficking.
3. There are differences between the Commonwealth and State laws, but these differences do not give rise to an inconsistency within the meaning of section 109 of the Constitution, as the Commonwealth Parliament has not shown an intention to provide an exhaustive statement of the law on the subject.
4. Section 5 of the Victorian Drugs Act does not alter, impair or detract from the offence created by section 302.4 of the Criminal Code, as it is an aid to proof and does not change the norm of conduct.
5. Section 5 of the Victorian Drugs Act does not trespass upon an area of liberty designedly left by the Criminal Code, as it facilitates the enforcement of the norm of conduct without altering it.
6. Section 300.4 of the Criminal Code has work to do in the interpretation of section 5 of the Victorian Drugs Act, as it provides a mechanism for reconciling the provisions of the two statutes and determining the hierarchy of the provisions.
7. There is no inconsistency between the Victorian Drugs Act and the Criminal Code due to the evidential burden placed on the accused by section 5, as the burden of proof on the balance of probabilities is a mechanical provision used to enforce the norm of conduct.
8. If there is an error in the trial that leads to an appeal, and the accused has already served the custodial portion of their sentence, the remedies that should be applied are a directed acquittal on the discretionary basis, considering factors such as the delay, the ordeal the accused has been through, and the fact that the accused has already served the custodial portion of the sentence.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered whether section 302.4 of the Criminal Code is an exhaustive statement of the law governing criminal liability for the conduct it deals with. The court concluded that section 300.4 of the Criminal Code, which states that Part 9.1 is not intended to exclude or limit the concurrent operation of any law of a State or Territory, indicates that the Code is intended to be cumulative and overlap with State criminal laws. Therefore, section 302.4 is not an exhaustive statement of the law.
The court also considered whether there are differences between the Commonwealth and State laws that give rise to an inconsistency within the meaning of section 109 of the Constitution. The court found that the differences between the Commonwealth and State laws were not such as to give rise to inconsistency within the meaning of section 109, as the intention of the legislature was that Part 9.1 of the Code be cumulative and overlap with State criminal laws.
The court further considered whether section 5 of the Victorian Drugs Act alters, impairs, or detracts from the offence created by section 302.4 of the Criminal Code. The court found that section 5 does not alter, impair, or detract from the offence created by section 302.4, as it does not in any way alter, impair, or detract from the norm of conduct that section 302.4 creates.
The court also considered whether section 5 of the Victorian Drugs Act trespasses upon an area of liberty designedly left by the Criminal Code. The court found that section 5 does not trespass upon an area of liberty designedly left by the Criminal Code, as it does not proscribe a norm of conduct, permit what is forbidden, or forbid what is permitted in terms of norms of conduct.
The court further considered whether section 300.4 of the Criminal Code has work to do in the interpretation of section 5 of the Victorian Drugs Act. The court found that section 300.4 has work to do in the interpretation of section 5 of the Victorian Drugs Act, as it should be given full effect to mean any norm, and any method used to enforce that norm, including section 5.
The court also considered whether there is inconsistency between the Victorian Drugs Act and the Criminal Code due to the evidential burden placed on the accused by section 5. The court found that there is no inconsistency between the Victorian Drugs Act and the Criminal Code due to the evidential burden placed on the accused by section 5, as section 300.4 has work to do in the interpretation of section 5 of the Victorian Drugs Act.
Finally, the court considered what remedies should be applied if there is an error in the trial that leads to an appeal, and the accused has already served the custodial portion of their sentence. The court found that the appropriate remedy would be a directed acquittal on the discretionary basis, as it would not be appropriate to send the matter back for trial and the Court should exercise its discretion to acquit the accused.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of the case is that section 302.4 of the Criminal Code is not an exhaustive statement of the law governing criminal liability for the conduct it deals with, and section 5 of the Victorian Drugs Act does not alter, impair, or detract from the offence created by section 302.4, nor does it trespass upon an area of liberty designedly left by the Criminal Code. Furthermore, section 300.4 has work to do in the interpretation of section 5 of the Victorian Drugs Act, and there is no inconsistency between the Victorian Drugs Act and the Criminal Code due to the evidential burden placed on the accused by section 5. If there is an error in the trial that leads to an appeal, and the accused has already served the custodial portion of their sentence, the appropriate remedy would be a directed acquittal on the discretionary basis.