Mohinder Singh and Administrative Appeals Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

[2014] AATA 460

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2014/2312

Re

Mohinder Singh

APPLICANT

And

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President J W Constance

Date 9 July 2014 
Place Melbourne

The application filed in the Tribunal by Mr Singh on 7 May 2014 is dismissed as the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to hear and determine the application.

.........................[sgd]..................................

Deputy President J W Constance

CATCHWORDS

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - frivolous and vexatious application – request for referral to Federal Court of Australia - request for referral refused - Tribunal has no power to review its own decisions - no jurisdiction - application dismissed

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) sub-ss 42B(1), 45(1)

CASES

Singh v Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations (2006) 95 ALD 569

Singh and Administrative Appeals Tribunal [2013] AATA 897
Singh and Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations (2006) 90 ALD 789

Singh and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2013] AATA 954

REASONS FOR DECISION

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Singh has applied to set aside a decision of the Tribunal made on 3 July 2006.  In that decision the Tribunal dismissed Mr Singh’s application to set aside a decision of the Social Security Appeals Tribunal relating to a debt owed by Mr Singh to the Department of Social Security.

  2. I have decided that Mr Singh’s application before me should be dismissed. 

  3. My reasons for this decision follow. In part these reasons repeat reasons I gave on 15 January 2014 (see [2013] AATA 954), however for clarity I set them out again.

    BACKGROUND

    The decision of the Tribunal made 3 July 2006

  4. In April 2006 Mr Singh filed in the Tribunal an application (No. V2006/314) to review the decision of the Social Security Appeals Tribunal to which I have referred.

  5. On 3 July 2006, following a hearing of the application, the Tribunal made the following decision and direction:

    (1)The application issued on 20 April 2006 to review a decision of the Social Security Appeals Tribunal made on 22 March 2006 is frivolous and vexatious and shall be dismissed.

    (2)The applicant must not without leave of the Tribunal make any application with respect to recovery of sickness allowance, disability support pension or wife pension paid between 28 October 1991 and 26 October 1999.[1]

    [1] Singh and Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations (2006) 90 ALD 789.

  6. In the reasons for the decision of 3 July 2006 the Tribunal set out in detail Mr Singh’s previous applications to the Tribunal which related to the decision that he was indebted to the Department in the sum claimed.  These applications dated back to 2000.

    The present application

  7. The present application was filed on 7 May 2014.  It seeks to have the decision of 3 July 2006 set aside on the ground that “[t]he AAT made an error of law (jurisdictional error) in dismissing my application V314/2006 under section 42B of the AAT Act 1975 as being an abuse of process.” 

  8. The application also seeks to have a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mohinder Singh and Administrative Appeals Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 460
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Mohinder Singh and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) involves the latter's decision made on 3 July 2006, which dismissed Singh's application as frivolous and vexatious. The matter has been the subject of multiple applications by Singh seeking review of the AAT's decision. The latest application, filed on 7 May 2014, claims that the AAT erred in dismissing the application under section 42B of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 and seeks to have the decision set aside. Additionally, Singh requests that a question of law arising from the requirement that he obtain leave from the AAT to make further applications be referred to the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issue the court had to address was whether the AAT had jurisdiction to hear and determine Singh's latest application. Given the history of similar applications made by Singh, all of which were either withdrawn or dismissed, the court needed to assess whether this application was an abuse of process or if it presented a legitimate legal question. Furthermore, the court examined the extent of its jurisdiction to review its own decisions and the applicability of section 42B of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

The court concluded that the AAT did not have jurisdiction to hear Singh's application as it was an abuse of process. The court noted that this was the fifth application Singh had made since August 2013, all of which were either withdrawn or dismissed. The court emphasised that the Tribunal does not have the power to review its own decisions and that Singh had exhausted his rights of appeal. Consequently, the application was dismissed. The court also clarified that while the power to make a direction under section 42B(1)(b) of the Act was not activated in this instance, it would likely be invoked if Singh were to make a similar application in the future.

The court's final order was to dismiss Singh's application as the AAT lacked the jurisdiction to hear and determine it. The reasoning provided underscored the principle that the Tribunal cannot review its own decisions and that Singh's repeated attempts to challenge the AAT's decision were considered an abuse of process.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

My reasons for this decision follow. In part these reasons repeat reasons I gave on 15 January 2014 (see [2013] AATA 954), however for clarity I set them out again.BACKGROUNDThe decision of the Tribunal made 3 July 2006 In April 2006 Mr Singh filed in the Tribunal an application (No. V2006/314) to review the decision of the Social Security Appeals Tribunal to which I have referred. On 3 July 2006, following a hearing of the application, the Tribunal made the following decision and direction:(1)The application issued on 20 April 2006 to review a decision of the Social Security Appeals Tribunal made on 22 March 2006 is frivolous and vexatious and shall be dismissed.(2)The applicant must not without leave of the Tribunal make any application with respect to recovery of sickness allowance, disability support pension or wife pension paid between 28 October 1991 and 26 October 1999.[1][1] Singh and Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations (2006) 90 ALD 789. In the reasons for the decision of 3 July 2006 the Tribunal set out in detail Mr Singh’s previous applications to the Tribunal which related to the decision that he was indebted to the Department in the sum claimed. These applications dated back to 2000.The present application The present application was filed on 7 May 2014. It seeks to have the decision of 3 July 2006 set aside on the ground that “[t]he AAT made an error of law (jurisdictional error) in dismissing my application V314/2006 under section 42B of the AAT Act 1975 as being an abuse of process.” The application also seeks to have a claimed question of law arising from the requirement that Mr Singh obtain the leave of the Tribunal (set out in paragraph (2) of the decision referred to) referred to the Federal Court of Australia. CONSIDERATION This is the fifth application made by Mr Singh since August 2013 in which he has sought to have the Tribunal review its decision made 3 July 2006. All of the four previous applications have been either withdrawn by Mr Singh or dismissed by the Tribunal.Application filed 16 August 2013 In this application Mr Singh sought to have the decision of 3 July 2006 set aside and the direction requiring that he obtain the leave of the Tribunal discharged.[2] A jurisdiction hearing was listed for 30 September 2013. On 25 September 2013 Mr Singh withdrew his application.[2] Application no.2013/4118.Application filed 30 September 2013 On this occasion Mr Singh applied to have the direction requiring the leave of the Tribunal set aside. On 22 October 2013 the Tribunal conducted a hearing at which Mr Singh appeared, and made the following decision:The Tribunal is satisfied that the application for review of the decision is frivolous and dismisses the application in accordance with s 42B(1)of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.[3][3] Application 2013/4940.Application filed 28 October 2013 Mr Singh applied to the Tribunal to review its decision of 3 July 2006. On 20 November 2013 I dismissed Mr Singh’s application as I decided that the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to deal with it.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Notwithstanding the conclusion I have reached, the power to make a direction under section 42B(1)(b) is not enlivened in this application. As the application was listed to deal with the question of jurisdiction, no other party was involved. As there has been no application by a party to the proceedings for a direction under subsection 42B(1)(b), there is no basis for the Tribunal to make such a direction. However, had such an application been before me I would have made a direction. Should Mr Singh make another application in similar terms to the present and an application is made for a direction under subsection 42B(1)(b), in my opinion it is likely that such a direction would be made. The direction would be likely to require Mr Singh to seek the leave of the Tribunal to make an application to set aside the Tribunal’s decision contained in paragraph (1) of its decision of 3 July 2006.CONCLUSION The application filed in the Tribunal by Mr Singh on 7 May 2014 will be dismissed as the Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to hear and determine the application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The application also seeks to have a claimed question of law arising from the requirement that Mr Singh obtain the leave of the Tribunal (set out in paragraph (2) of the decision referred to) referred to the Federal Court of Australia. CONSIDERATION This is the fifth application made by Mr Singh since August 2013 in which he has sought to have the Tribunal review its decision made 3 July 2006. All of the four previous applications have been either withdrawn by Mr Singh or dismissed by the Tribunal.Application filed 16 August 2013 In this application Mr Singh sought to have the decision of 3 July 2006 set aside and the direction requiring that he obtain the leave of the Tribunal discharged.[2] A jurisdiction hearing was listed for 30 September 2013. On 25 September 2013 Mr Singh withdrew his application.[2] Application no.2013/4118.Application filed 30 September 2013 On this occasion Mr Singh applied to have the direction requiring the leave of the Tribunal set aside. On 22 October 2013 the Tribunal conducted a hearing at which Mr Singh appeared, and made the following decision:The Tribunal is satisfied that the application for review of the decision is frivolous and dismisses the application in accordance with s 42B(1)of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.[3][3] Application 2013/4940.Application filed 28 October 2013 Mr Singh applied to the Tribunal to review its decision of 3 July 2006. On 20 November 2013 I dismissed Mr Singh’s application as I decided that the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to deal with it. In providing written reasons for this decision I said, in part:7. In 2007 Mr Singh appealed to the Federal Court to review the decision of 3 July 2006. The Court varied the decision of the Tribunal by adding the words “to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal” after the words “the applicant must not without leave of the Tribunal make any application” and otherwise dismissed the appeal. An appeal to the Full Court of the Federal Court was dismissed.8. Mr Singh then applied to the High Court of Australia for special leave to appeal the judgement of the Federal Court. On 15 May 2008 special leave was refused. The Court said, in part:The applicant’s draft notice of appeal fails to raise any ground with respect to the decision of the Full Court. He does not identify a special leave question but returns to the alleged failure by the SSAT to review the decision of Centrelink refusing to review the decision of 4 November 1999. It is clear that the matters put forward by the applicant have been previously decided, and it was open to the AAT to dismiss the application summarily. The applicant has insufficient prospects of success in this Court to warrant a grant of special leave to appeal.9. The power to set aside a decision of this Tribunal is conferred on the Federal Court of Australia by section 44 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). This section gives an applicant in the Tribunal a right of appeal on a question of law from any decision of the Tribunal in the proceeding lodged by him or her. Clearly Mr Singh has exhausted his rights of appeal. The Tribunal does not have the power to review its own decisions.[4][4] [2013] AATA 897.Application filed 6 December 2013