Mohebi and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 4098 (8 October 2019)
Division:GENERAL DIVISION
File Numbers: 2018/4149
2018/4148
2018/4152
2018/4155
Re:Mrs Nafisa Mohebi
Mr Noorulla Mohebi
Mr Hamidullah Mohebi
Mr Haseebullah Mohebi
APPLICANT
AndMinister for Home Affairs
RESPONDENT
Decision
Tribunal:Ms Anna Burke AO, Member
Date:8 October 2019
Place:Melbourne
- 1. The Tribunal affirms the decision of the Minister dated 18 June 2018 refusing Mrs Mohebi’s application for Australian citizenship by conferral.
- 2. The Tribunal sets aside the decision of the Delegate dated 29 May 2018 refusing Hamidulla, Noorullah, and Haseebullah Mohebi’s applications for Australian citizenship by conferral; and remits the matter to the Minister for reconsideration in accordance with a Direction from the Tribunal, pursuant to s 43(1)(c)(ii) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) for consideration individually in their own right as at the date of application.
......................[sgd]..................................................
Ms Anna Burke AO, Member
Catchwords
CITIZENSHIP – refusal of approval for Australian citizenship by conferral – citizenship test exemption – whether applicant suffers from a permanent or enduring mental incapacity at the time of application – medical evidence considered – consideration for children under the age of 16 applying in their own right - best interest of the child – decision 2018/4149 under review affirmed and decisions 2018/4148, 4152, 4155 remitted secondary consideration
Legislation
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth)
Cases
Aston and Secretary, Department of Primary Industry, Re (1985) 8 ALD 366
Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2), Re (1979) 2 ALD 634
Khodeir and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 499
Secondary Materials
Australian citizenship instructions (ACI)
Department of Immigration and Border Protection, Citizenship Policy (1 June 2016)
REASONS FOR DECISION
Ms Anna Burke AO, Member
INTRODUCTION and BackGround
1. Mrs Nafisa Mohebi, aged 47, and her three sons Hamidulla aged 19, Noorullah aged 17 and Haseebullah aged 12 are Afghan citizen (the Applicants). They all arrived in Australia on 2 July 2008 on a Permanent Global Special Humanitarian visa (subclass 202). At the time of application Mrs Mohebi held a Permanent Five Year Resident Return visa (subclass 155).
2. On 29 October 2014, Mrs Mohebi lodged an application for Australian citizenship by conferral under s 21 of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (the Act). Mrs Mohebi included four of her eight children on her citizenship application: Palwasha, Noorullah, Hamidulla and Haseebullah.
3. On 10 April 2015, 16 June 2015, 12 October 2015, 4 November 2015 and 2 May 2018 Mrs Mohebi sat and failed the approved citizenship test.
4. On 18 June 2018, a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs ('the Respondent') refused Mrs Mohebi’s application for citizenship as she did not meet the criteria under ss 21(2)(d),(e) and (f) of the Act ('the Reviewable Decision') as she had not successfully completed an approved test.
5. On 29 May 2018, a delegate of the Respondent refused Noorullah, Hamidulla and Haseebullah Mohebi’s applications for citizenship in accordance with the Citizenship…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Mohebi and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] AATA 4098
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine if Mrs. Mohebi had a permanent or enduring mental incapacity at the time she lodged her citizenship application in 2014, as contemplated by section 21(3)(d) of the *Australian Citizenship Act 2007* (Cth). This section provides an exemption from the citizenship test requirements if an applicant's incapacity prevents them from understanding the nature of the application, demonstrating basic English language knowledge, or showing adequate knowledge of Australia and its citizenship. A secondary issue concerned the applications of the three minor children, requiring the Tribunal to consider whether their applications had been assessed individually and in accordance with the relevant policy concerning children under 16 applying in their own right, particularly regarding the consent and status of their responsible parent.
The Tribunal reasoned that while medical evidence from 2018 indicated Mrs. Mohebi suffered from major depressive disorder and anxiety, with compromised memory and concentration, this evidence did not establish that she had a permanent or enduring mental incapacity at the time of her 2014 application. The Tribunal noted that Mrs. Mohebi had not reported any mental health issues or sought medical treatment until 2018, and had not raised any special considerations when lodging her application. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the decision to refuse Mrs. Mohebi's application. Regarding the children's applications, the Tribunal found that the delegate had not considered them individually as required, particularly concerning the father's status as an Australian citizen and his consent. Therefore, the Tribunal set aside the delegate's decision for the three children and remitted their applications for reconsideration by the Minister.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
25. Palwasha also advised the Tribunal that:• the family had noticed a significant decline in her mother’s well-being since her last trip to Afghanistan; and• Afghanis do not think of mental illness as a big thing and it would not be a reason that they would go and seek medical help.ConsiderationMrs Mohebi 26. Ms Palwasha Mohebi, on behalf of her mother, indicated that Mrs Mohebi was suffering considerable stress and anxiety at her inability to gain Australian citizenship and that her father had become an Australian citizen sometime in 2008, prior to the extended families’ arrival in Australia. Whilst it may appear obvious the Tribunal noted Ms Mohebi’s father, Mr Sameullah Mohebi, was also the father of Hamidulla, Noorullah and Haseebullah. She also indicated that her mother had a great desire to return to Afghanistan and the family believed this would assist her mother’s mental health condition, as she ruminates on this considerably. Palwasha could not provide medical records indicating that her mother had sought treatment for depression prior to 2018 but said her mother had been unwell for many years and argued that granting her an exemption to sitting the citizenship test would be a benefit to her mother’s health and well-being. 27. Mr Orchard contended that there was no dispute that Mrs Mohebi had sat and failed the citizenship test on numerous occasions, the question before the Tribunal was whether Mrs Mohebi had a permanent incapacity at the time of her application for citizenship in 2014 which would exempt her from the requirement under the Act to sit and pass the citizenship test. 28. Mr Orchard contended that Mrs Mohebi was not diagnosed with any mental health condition at the time of her application 2014 and that she had not reported any mental health issues or sought any medical treatment until 2018 some ten years after she arrived in Australia and some four years after she applied to become a citizen. He further noted that when Mrs Mohebi applied for citizenship by conferral she did not raise any special concerns or considerations for the delegate to consider when assessing her application. The respondent contended that therefore the Tribunal could not, based on the evidence before it, be satisfied that at the time of her application she had a permanent incapacity that meant she was not capable of satisfying citizenship test. 29. The Tribunal observes the current Citizenship Policy which states that successful completion of the citizenship test is an integral requirement for the consideration of granting of citizenship. The test is designed to establish that an applicant understands the rights and responsibilities of citizenship and the nature of their application. It also establishes a basic requirement in regard to competency in the English language. 30. The operation and effect of s 21 was outlined by Senior Member Taylor SC in Khodeir and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 499:Ordinarily a person’s eligibility for Australian citizenship depends on satisfaction that they meet each of the eight cumulative criteria set out in s 21(2) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007... I paraphrase those three matters as(a) AWARENESS: — understanding the nature of the citizenship application: - ACA 2007 s21(2)(d) (b) ENGLISH: — possessing a basic knowledge of the English language; - ACA 2007 s21(2)(e)(c) KNOWLEDGE: — having an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibility and privileges of Australian citizenship: - - ACA 2007 s21(2)(f)As a result of recommendations of the Australian Citizenship Test Review Committee, and amendments effected first by the Migration Legislation Amendment Act (No 1) 2008 (Cth) and subsequently by the Australian Citizenship Amendment (Citizenship Test Review and Other Measures) Act 2009 (Cth), those three ordinary eligibility criteria may not apply where a citizenship applicant has a significant incapacity (either physical or mental, and either permanent or enduring). In such a case the person is eligible for citizenship if they both (i) comply with the five other ordinary eligibility criteria in ACA 2007 s 21(2) and (ii) satisfy the Minister that, because of their incapacity, when they applied for citizenship they were not capable of satisfying any one of the other three ordinary criteria (ie “awareness“, “English” and “knowledge”).