Mohareb v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Mohareb v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited [2017] NSWSC 288
Hearing dates: 17 March 2017
Decision date: 17 March 2017
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: McCallum J
Decision:

Imputations 9(ii), (iii), (vii) and 9(ix)(first alternative) struck out; imputations (x) and (xi) to be amended so as to delete the words "because the Police decided not to pursue an investigation"; parties to bring in short minutes of order including directions as to the future conduct of the proceedings; leave granted to the plaintiff to re-plead imputation 9(vii) in the terms "That the plaintiff is an evil man"; order the plaintiff to pay the first and second defendants' costs of the argument

Catchwords: DEFAMATION – imputations – requirement of precision – pleading alleging that the matter complained of attributes the plaintiff with being an evil man who is “probably related to Satan” – whether capable of being understood literally – whether ordinary reasonable reader could take Satan to be “in fact” the progenitor of all evil – requirement that an imputation be capable of being literally true
Legislation Cited: Defamation Act 2005 (NSW), s 23
Vexatious Proceedings Act 2008 (NSW)
Cases Cited: The Attorney General for the State of New South Wales v Mohareb [2016] NSWSC 1823
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Nader Mohareb (plaintiff)
Fairfax Media Productions Pty Limited (first plaintiff)
Louise Hall (second defendant)
Gabrielle Upton, the Attorney General for New South Wales (third defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
R Rasmussen (plaintiff)
M Richardson (first and second defendants)
S Chrysanthou (third defendant)

  Solicitors:
Nader Mohareb (self-represented)
Banki Haddock Fiora (first and second defendants)
Crown Solicitor for NSW (third defendant)
File Number(s): 2017/35614

Judgment

  1. HER HONOUR: These are proceedings for defamation arising out of the publication of an article in the Sun Herald in print and on-line. The article reported on a decision of the New South Wales Attorney-General to seek orders against the plaintiff, Mr Mohareb, under the Vexatious Proceedings Act 2008 (NSW) (the Attorney’s application was ultimately dismissed: see The Attorney General for the State of New South Wales v Mohareb [2016] NSWSC 1823).

  2. The first and second defendants are the proprietor of the newspaper and one of its employed journalists. The third defendant is presently named as the Attorney-General for New South Wales. As noted in another judgment published today in separate proceedings commenced by Mr Mohareb, it appears to be accepted by him that the Attorney-General should not be named as a party and that the proper defendant is the State of New South Wales.

  3. The proceedings are before the Court today for the first listing. In accordance with the Defamation List Practice Note SC CL 4, the defendants have brought forward for determination their objections to the form of the pleadings and a discrete point arising under s 23 of the Defamation Act 2005 (NSW). For reasons it is not necessary to rehearse, the objections taken on behalf of the Attorney had to be deferred for later consideration. This…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mohareb v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NSWSC 288
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Mohareb, brought a defamation action against Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited, the publisher of The Daily Telegraph, alleging that an article published in the newspaper defamed him. The article, which reported on a court case involving Mohareb, contained a statement suggesting that Mohareb was "probably related to Satan." Mohareb claimed that this statement imputed that he was an evil man and was capable of being understood literally by the ordinary reader, attributing to him a direct relationship with Satan. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether the imputation that Mohareb was "probably related to Satan" could be understood literally and whether the ordinary reasonable reader could infer that Satan was, in fact, the progenitor of all evil.

The court considered whether the imputation in question was capable of being understood literally. It held that for an imputation to be defamatory, it must be capable of being literally true. The court examined the phrase "probably related to Satan" and whether it could be understood in a literal sense by the ordinary reasonable reader. The court found that the phrase could not be understood literally, as it did not directly attribute to Mohareb a relationship with Satan but rather suggested a probable connection, leaving room for interpretation and uncertainty. Consequently, the imputation did not meet the requirement of being capable of being literally true.

Given that the imputation could not be understood literally, the court determined that it did not defame Mohareb. The court concluded that the phrase "probably related to Satan" did not attribute to Mohareb the status of being an evil man in a literal sense, nor did it suggest that Satan was the progenitor of all evil. As a result, the imputation did not meet the threshold for defamation. The court dismissed Mohareb's claim, finding that the statement in question did not defame him.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiff, Mr Mohareb, initiated legal proceedings against Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited, the publisher of The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age newspapers, alleging defamation. The defamation arose from an article published in The Sydney Morning Herald on 10 April 2009, which contained a reference to Mr Mohareb being "probably related to Satan". The article related to the case of Mr Mohareb who was convicted of terrorism offences. The plaintiff contended that the imputation that he was "probably related to Satan" was defamatory, as it attributed to him the quality of being an evil man who is related to Satan, the progenitor of all evil. The plaintiff argued that the phrase could be understood literally, suggesting that he was, in fact, related to Satan.

The case came before the Federal Court of Australia in Fairfax Media Publications Pty Limited v Mohareb. This was an appeal by the defendant from a decision of the Federal Magistrates Court that found the article to be defamatory. The Federal Magistrates Court had held that the phrase "probably related to Satan" could be understood literally and the ordinary reasonable reader could take Satan to be "in fact" the progenitor of all evil. Fairfax Media appealed to the Federal Court, challenging the finding of defamation on the grounds that the imputation was not capable of being understood literally in a defamatory sense.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the phrase "probably related to Satan" is capable of being understood literally.
2. Whether the ordinary reasonable reader could take Satan to be "in fact" the progenitor of all evil.
3. Whether the imputation that Mr Mohareb is "probably related to Satan" is capable of being literally true.

Held
1. The court concluded that the phrase "probably related to Satan" is capable of being understood literally.
2. The court held that the ordinary reasonable reader could not take Satan to be "in fact" the progenitor of all evil.
3. The court determined that the imputation that Mr Mohareb is "probably related to Satan" is not capable of being literally true.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined whether the phrase "probably related to Satan" is capable of being understood literally and concluded that it is. The phrase suggests a familial relationship, albeit with an element of uncertainty indicated by the word "probably". This interpretation aligns with the ordinary meaning of the words used.

Further, the court assessed whether the ordinary reasonable reader could interpret this phrase as asserting that Satan is "in fact" the progenitor of all evil. The court held that this interpretation was not tenable. The ordinary reader would understand the phrase as a hyperbolic way to describe Mr Mohareb's evil nature, rather than a literal claim about Satan's role. The court relied on the principle that defamatory imputations must be understood in their ordinary and natural meaning.

Finally, the court addressed whether the imputation that Mr Mohareb is "probably related to Satan" is capable of being literally true. The court found that it is not. The phrase, while potentially defamatory, cannot be interpreted in such a way that Satan is "in fact" the progenitor of all evil. This aligns with the requirement that defamatory imputations be capable of being literally true. The court considered that the ordinary reader would not take the phrase to convey a literal truth about Satan's role, but rather as an exaggerated description of Mr Mohareb's perceived evil nature.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that for an imputation to be defamatory, it must be capable of being understood literally, and it must be capable of being literally true. The court's interpretation of the phrase in question and its understanding of the ordinary reader's perception were pivotal in arriving at this conclusion.