Mohammed Rahman and Offshore Marine Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

[2013] AATA 57  

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2012/3668

Re

Mohammed Rahman

APPLICANT

And

Offshore Marine Services Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President RP Handley

Date 4 February 2013
Place Sydney

Decision Summary

The Tribunal affirms the Respondent’s decision to refuse Mr Rahman’s claim for compensation under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992.

........[sgd]....................................

Deputy President RP Handley

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – Applicant injured during an intra-State voyage – Applicant compensated under Workers Compensation and Injury Management Act 1981 (WA) – whether Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) or Workers Compensation and Injury Management Act 1981 (WA) applies in respect of Applicant’s injury – Decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Commonwealth Constitution

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth)

Legislative Instruments Act 2003 (Cth)

Navigation Act 1912 (Cth)

Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth)

Workers Compensation and Injury Management Act 1981 (WA)

CASES

Tiwi Barge Services Pty Ltd v Stark (1997) 78 FCR 218

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President RP Handley

February 2013

  1. Mr Rahman has applied to the Tribunal for a review of a decision of Offshore Marine Services Pty Ltd (OMS) dated 26 June 2012 to refuse Mr Rahman’s application for compensation under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) (the Seafarers Act) on the ground that the Act did not apply in his case.

    BACKGROUND

  2. Mr Rahman, who is aged 52, made a claim for compensation under the Seafarers Act dated 23 February 2012 in respect of an injury to his left ribs on 28 January 2012 while he was employed by OMS as a Second Officer and serving on an ocean-going tug, the PB Konui.

  3. On 19 March 2012, OMS denied liability in respect of the claim on the ground that s 19 of the Seafarers Act did not apply in respect of Mr Rahman’s injury. However, OMS found the claim to be covered by the Workers Compensation and Injury Management Act 1981 (WA) (the WA Act) and Mr Rahman was paid weekly compensation by OMS’s workers compensation insurer, CGU Workers Compensation. OMS states that it “topped up” the compensation payments made to Mr Rahman under the WA Act so that Mr Rahman received the same compensation he would have received had his claim been accepted under the Seafarers Act.

  4. On 4 July 2012, Mr Rahman was certified fit to undertake his pre-injury duties by Dr NC Khoo, the Medical Inspector of Seamen. On 3 September 2012, the Conciliation Service of WorkCover WA suspended Mr Rahman’s weekly compensation payments for a period of 12 weeks “or until the dispute has been determined by an Arbitrator, whichever is the sooner”.

  5. Mr Rahman sought a reconsideration of OMS’s decision to deny liability under the Seafarers Act. On 26 June 2012, a ‘Reconsiderations Officer’ of OMS affirmed the original decision after a review. Mr Rahman states that he received notification of this decision on 10 July 2012 and, on 24 August 2012, he lodged an application with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mohammed Rahman and Offshore Marine Services Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 57
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Mohammed Rahman against Offshore Marine Services Pty Ltd, the Federal Circuit Court considered the applicability of the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) to Mr Rahman’s claim for compensation resulting from an injury sustained during his employment on the PB Konui, an ocean-going tug. The central issue before the court was whether the Seafarers Act applied to Mr Rahman’s employment and injury, considering the nature of the voyage undertaken by the PB Konui at the time of the injury.

The court examined the scope of the Seafarers Act, particularly section 19, which stipulates the conditions under which the Act applies. The court noted that the Act applies to voyages between Australia and places outside Australia, between two places outside Australia, between states, or within a territory, but does not cover voyages within a single state. Mr Rahman's injury occurred during an intra-State voyage between Fremantle and Barrow Island in Western Australia, which does not fall within the categories specified in the Act. Additionally, the Navigation Act 1912 excludes intra-State voyages from its scope, further supporting the conclusion that the Seafarers Act does not apply to Mr Rahman’s case. The court also considered the effect of the Offshore Oil and Gas Enterprise Agreement (EA) between OMS and the Australian Maritime Officers Union, but concluded that this agreement does not override the primary legislation of the Seafarers Act.

Based on the evidence and submissions, the court affirmed the decision of OMS to deny Mr Rahman’s claim for compensation under the Seafarers Act. The court found that since the Seafarers Act did not apply to Mr Rahman’s employment on the PB Konui at the time of his injury, he was not eligible to make a claim under the Act. Although OMS had "topped up" Mr Rahman’s compensation payments under the Workers Compensation and Injury Management Act 1981 (WA) to match what he would have received under the Seafarers Act, the court held that this compliance did not alter the fundamental issue of the Act’s applicability. Consequently, the court upheld OMS's decision, rejecting Mr Rahman’s application for review.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Rahman has applied to the Tribunal for a review of a decision of Offshore Marine Services Pty Ltd (OMS) dated 26 June 2012 to refuse Mr Rahman’s application for compensation under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992 (Cth) (the Seafarers Act) on the ground that the Act did not apply in his case.BACKGROUND Mr Rahman, who is aged 52, made a claim for compensation under the Seafarers Act dated 23 February 2012 in respect of an injury to his left ribs on 28 January 2012 while he was employed by OMS as a Second Officer and serving on an ocean-going tug, the PB Konui. On 19 March 2012, OMS denied liability in respect of the claim on the ground that s 19 of the Seafarers Act did not apply in respect of Mr Rahman’s injury. However, OMS found the claim to be covered by the Workers Compensation and Injury Management Act 1981 (WA) (the WA Act) and Mr Rahman was paid weekly compensation by OMS’s workers compensation insurer, CGU Workers Compensation. OMS states that it “topped up” the compensation payments made to Mr Rahman under the WA Act so that Mr Rahman received the same compensation he would have received had his claim been accepted under the Seafarers Act. On 4 July 2012, Mr Rahman was certified fit to undertake his pre-injury duties by Dr NC Khoo, the Medical Inspector of Seamen. On 3 September 2012, the Conciliation Service of WorkCover WA suspended Mr Rahman’s weekly compensation payments for a period of 12 weeks “or until the dispute has been determined by an Arbitrator, whichever is the sooner”. Mr Rahman sought a reconsideration of OMS’s decision to deny liability under the Seafarers Act. On 26 June 2012, a ‘Reconsiderations Officer’ of OMS affirmed the original decision after a review. Mr Rahman states that he received notification of this decision on 10 July 2012 and, on 24 August 2012, he lodged an application with the Tribunal for review of this decision. The parties have requested that the Tribunal make a decision ‘on the papers’ on the preliminary issue of whether the Seafarers Act applies in respect of Mr Rahman’s claim for compensation. THE RELEVANT LEGISLATION Section 19(1) of the Seafarers Act states:(1) This Act applies to the employment of employees on a prescribed ship that is engaged in trade or commerce: (a) between Australia and places outside Australia; or (aa) between 2 places outside Australia; or (b) among the States; or (c) within a Territory, between a State and a Territory or between 2 Territories. The word ‘employee’ is defined in s 4(1) to include a ‘seafarer’, a word which is in turn defined in s 3 to include “a person employed in any capacity on a prescribed ship”. The term ‘prescribed ship’ is defined in s 3 as meaning “a ship to which Part II of the Navigation Act applies”. The Navigation Act 1912 (Cth) (the 1912 Act) specifies the ships to which it applies by specifically excluding certain categories of ship, including in s 2(1)(a) “a trading ship proceeding on a voyage other than an overseas voyage or an inter-State voyage”. SUBMISSIONS AND EVIDENCE

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The word ‘employee’ is defined in s 4(1) to include a ‘seafarer’, a word which is in turn defined in s 3 to include “a person employed in any capacity on a prescribed ship”. The term ‘prescribed ship’ is defined in s 3 as meaning “a ship to which Part II of the Navigation Act applies”. The Navigation Act 1912 (Cth) (the 1912 Act) specifies the ships to which it applies by specifically excluding certain categories of ship, including in s 2(1)(a) “a trading ship proceeding on a voyage other than an overseas voyage or an inter-State voyage”. SUBMISSIONS AND EVIDENCE OMS contends that at the time of Mr Rahman’s injury, while the PB Konui was a ‘prescribed ship’ as defined in s 10 of the Navigation Act 1912, the provisions of that Act did not apply because of the exclusion contained in s 2(1) of the Act. More particularly, the PB Konui was not engaged in a voyage of a kind identified in any of subparagraphs (a) to (c) of s 19(1) of the Seafarers Act; rather, it was engaged in intra-State trade between the ports of Fremantle and Barrow Island in Western Australia. Thus, the Seafarers Act does not apply in respect of Mr Rahman’s injury. OMS referred to the decision of the Full Federal Court in Tiwi Barge Services Pty Ltd v Stark (1997) 78 FCR 218 and in Hingston v Pacific Tug (Australia) Pty Ltd (2012) 204 FCR 472 (Hingston). In the latter case, the Court emphasised that it is the purpose of the ship proceeding on the voyage that is critical in determining the application of the provisions of the Navigation Act. Here the purpose of the voyage was to travel between two ports in Western Australia. OMS submitted that the fact that in order to avoid adverse weather conditions resulting from a cyclone, the PB Konui may have ventured outside Western Australian waters did not change the intra-State nature of the voyage. OMS noted that no declaration of the kind referred to in s 19(1A) the Seafarers Act is in force in relation to the PB Konui. This subsection states:(1A) This Act also applies to the employment of employees on any prescribed ship that is: (a) an off-shore industry vessel in relation to which a declaration under subsection 8A(2) of the Navigation Act is in force; or (b) a trading ship in relation to which a declaration under subsection 8AA(2) of that Act is in force. In his submissions dated 21 November 2012, Mr Rahman referred to the ‘Offshore Oil and Gas Enterprise Agreement’ (the EA) dated 2010 between OMS and the Australian Maritime Officers Union which was approved by Commissioner Williams of Fair Work Australia on 9 August 2010. Mr Rahman said that notwithstanding that a declaration has not been made in respect of the PB Konui under s 8A(2) of the Navigation Act 1912 (Cth), cl 26.4 of the EA states:26.4 For the purpose of the application of the SRC Act, Officers and the Employer bound by this Agreement, will carry out all obligations and receive all entitlements in accordance with the SRC Act as if the employment was in connected with a “Prescribed Ship” as defined and applied in the SRC Act, notwithstanding that a declaration under subsection 8A(2) of the Nav Act is not in force. Mr Rahman said his letter of engagement by OMS stated the terms and conditions of engagement are as per the current union agreement.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In conclusion, since s 19 of the Seafarers Act did not apply to Mr Rahman’s employment on the PB Konui at the time of his injury, he is not able to make a claim under the Act. I note that according to OMS the compensation paid to Mr Rahman under the WA Act was “topped up” so that he received the same compensation he would have received under the Seafarers Act. OMS contends that it thereby complied with the cl 26.4 of the EA and that Mr Rahman suffered no prejudice as a result of his claim being dealt with under the WA Act. By contrast, as noted above, Mr Rahman contends that he has been “severely disadvantaged”. However, whether or not OMS complied with the terms of the EA is not a matter which is within the jurisdiction of this Tribunal and it is therefore not a matter on which I can comment.DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision by OMS to refuse Mr Rahman’s claim for compensation under the Seafarers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1992.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Thornton stated that in about March 2012, he formed the view that the provisions of the Seafarers Act did not apply to Mr Rahman’s claim because his injury was sustained on an intra-State voyage but, rather, the provisions of the WA Act applied. Mr Thornton therefore referred the claim to OMS’s relevant insurer on that basis. However, he said that OMS made such further weekly compensation payments to Mr Rahman so as to place him in the same position that he would have been in had his claim been dealt with under the provisions of the Seafarers Act. Mr Thornton said that Mr Rahman’s claim was the first such claim dealt with by OMS under the provisions of the WA Act rather than the Seafarers Act. DISCUSSION/CONSIDERATION The preliminary issue for the Tribunal to determine is whether, pursuant to s 19, the Seafarers Act applies in Mr Rahman’s case. For the Seafarers Act to apply in his case, his employment must fall within the terms of s 19 of the Act. Section 19(1) is set out in paragraph 7 above and requires both that the employee is employed “on a prescribed ship”, and that the ship is engaged in trade or commerce on a voyage of a kind specified in subparagraphs (a) to (c). It is notable that voyages within a State – intra-State trade – are not included. In Mr Rahman’s case, the PB Konui was engaged in a voyage between two ports in Western Australia. The purpose of the voyage was to travel from the port of Freemantle to the port of Barrow Island, both within Western Australia (see above the reference to Hingston at paragraph 10). It matters not that in the course of the voyage, the ship may have travelled outside Western Australian waters to avoid cyclonic weather conditions. I also note that pursuant to s 2(1) of the Navigation Act 1912, that Act does not apply in relation to “(a) a trading ship proceeding on a voyage other than an overseas voyage or an inter-State voyage”. Thus, a ship engaged in intra-State trade is not a ‘prescribed ship’ and s 19(1) of Seafarers Act does not apply. Mr Rahman accepts that no declaration had been made under subsection 8A(2) of the Navigation Act 1912 in respect of the PB Konui that would bring his employment within the terms of s 19(1A) of the Seafarers Act: see above paragraph 11. Mr Rahman’s principal argument is that he can claim compensation under the Seafarers Act pursuant to cl 26.4 of the EA, set out at paragraph 12, above. Whilst approval by the Fair Work Commission may give the EA the status of a ‘fair work instrument’, as defined in s 12 of the Fair Work Act 2009, it does not have the status of a ‘legislative instrument’ pursuant to s 7(1) of the Legislative Instruments Act 2003 (Cth). Section 7(1) lists instruments that are not legislative instruments within the meaning of the Act, and includes ‘fair work instruments’. In terms of Commonwealth legislation, a fair work instrument can only operate subject to the terms of relevant primary legislation. The terms of the EA do not over-ride the terms of the Seafarers Act, which is of course primary legislation, but, rather, the EA must operate subject to the terms of the Seafarers Act. The Tribunal also has no jurisdiction in relation to the Fair Work Act 2009 and, as OMS submits, the EA only has legal effect and can only be enforced pursuant to the terms of that Act.