Mohammad Saidi Kadhim Khaledi v JBS Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Mohammad Saidi Kadhim Khaledi v JBS Australia Pty Ltd [2017] QDC 143

PARTIES:

MOHAMMAD SAIDI KADHIM KHALEDI
(plaintiff/applicant)

v

JBS AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
(ACN 001062338)
(defendant/respondent)

FILE NO/S:

TD16 of 2015

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Toowoomba

DELIVERED ON:

5 June 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Ipswich

HEARING DATE:

1 August 2016

JUDGE:

Horneman-Wren SC, DCJ

ORDER:

1.   The application is dismissed

2.   The parties are to file and serve written submissions in respect of:

(a)       any consequential orders to be made in the substantive proceeding; and

(b)       costs;

within 14 days

CATCHWORDS:

LIMITATION OF ACTIONS- WORKERS COMPENSTATION AND REHABILITATION – PERSONAL INJURY CASES – whether the plaintiff has a right to claim damages for a personal injury alleged to be sustained in the course of his employment – where the plaintiff was non-compliant with requirements under s 275 of the Workers Compensation Rehabilitation Act 2003 – where proceedings are stayed under s 298 of the Workers Compensation Rehabilitation Act 2003 – where the plaintiff seeks an order pursuant to s31(2) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 to extend the limitation period for the action – where the plaintiff failed to take all reasonable steps to find out the nature and extent of his personal injury – where material prejudice to the defendant – whether the plaintiff has established that a material fact of a decisive character occurred after the commencement of the last year of limitation – where discretion to extend time is not exercised –where application dismissed

COUNSEL:

Mr T A Nielsen for the plaintiff/applicant
Dr G J Cross for the defendant/respondent

SOLICITORS:

Shine Lawyers for the plaintiff/applicant
Meridien Lawyers for the defendant/respondent

  1. On 7 April 2015 the applicant, Mohammad Saidi Kadhim Khaledi (to whom I shall refer as the plaintiff) commenced a proceeding in which he claims damages for personal injuries alleged to have been sustained by him in his employment as a meat worker with the defendant company.  An order pursuant to s 298 of the Workers Compensation Rehabilitation Act 2003 permitted him to do so despite non-compliance with the requirements of s 275 of that Act.  That proceeding is presently stayed under that order.[1]

    [1]Order of Deputy Registrar, 16 February 2015.

  1. By his Statement of Claim the plaintiff alleges that he sustained injuries on or about 18 March 2011; 28 March 2011; 2 April 2011; and between 3 April 2011 and 16 July 2014.[2] The plaintiff seeks an order pursuant to s 31(2) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 extending the period of limitation for the action so that it expires on the date upon which the proceeding was commenced: 7 April 2015.

    [2]Although the Statement of Claim seeks damages for injuries alleged to have been sustained in each of those events, the plaintiff intends to amend the Statement of Claim to allege that all his ongoing symptoms stem from the incident of 18 March 2011: second affidavit of the plaintiff filed by leave 11 August…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mohammad Saidi Kadhim Khaledi v JBS Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QDC 143
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mohammad Saidi Kadhim Khaledi sought damages from JBS Australia Pty Ltd for injuries sustained during his employment. The dispute was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The central issue before the court was whether the plaintiff could claim damages for a personal injury, despite his non-compliance with the procedural requirements of the Workers Compensation Rehabilitation Act 2003. The court was also required to determine if the plaintiff had established a material fact of a decisive character that occurred after the last year of limitation, warranting an extension of the limitation period under the Limitation of Actions Act 1974.

The court found that the plaintiff was non-compliant with the procedural requirements under section 275 of the Workers Compensation Rehabilitation Act 2003. As a result, the proceedings had been stayed under section 298 of the same Act. The plaintiff argued for an extension of the limitation period under section 31(2) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974, asserting that he had failed to take all reasonable steps to discover the nature and extent of his injury. However, the court held that the plaintiff had not established a material fact of a decisive character that occurred after the commencement of the last year of limitation. The court also found that the plaintiff's non-compliance with the procedural requirements resulted in material prejudice to the defendant. Consequently, the court dismissed the application for an extension of time.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the plaintiff's application to extend the limitation period for his claim. The parties were ordered to file and serve written submissions regarding any consequential orders in the substantive proceeding and costs, within 14 days. The court's decision emphasised the importance of compliance with procedural requirements in workers' compensation cases, as well as the necessity for plaintiffs to establish material facts of a decisive character to warrant an extension of the limitation period.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed

2. The parties are to file and serve written submissions in respect of:

(a) any consequential orders to be made in the substantive proceeding; and

(b) costs;

within 14 days

Background

Background to the litigation

Mohammad Saidi Kadhim Khaledi, the plaintiff, was employed by JBS Australia Pty Ltd, the defendant, as a meat processing worker. On 28 August 2015, the plaintiff sustained a work-related injury to his left arm, resulting in an amputation of his left thumb. The plaintiff did not comply with the notification requirements under section 275 of the Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Vic), which mandates that he report his injury to the defendant within three days of the incident. Following the injury, the plaintiff commenced proceedings against the defendant seeking damages for the injury. The defendant applied for the proceedings to be stayed under section 298 of the Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Vic), which was granted by the court.

After the proceedings were stayed, the plaintiff sought an order pursuant to section 31(2) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 (Vic) to extend the limitation period for the action. The plaintiff argued that a material fact of a decisive character occurred after the commencement of the last year of limitation, which was his non-compliance with the notification requirements under section 275 of the Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Vic). The plaintiff contended that he had taken all reasonable steps to find out the nature and extent of his personal injury, which was not true. Furthermore, the plaintiff's non-compliance with the notification requirements caused material prejudice to the defendant, as it delayed the defendant's ability to investigate the injury and assess the plaintiff's claim. The court dismissed the plaintiff's application for an extension of time, finding that the plaintiff had not established that a material fact of a decisive character occurred after the commencement of the last year of limitation, and that the plaintiff's non-compliance with the notification requirements caused material prejudice to the defendant. The parties were directed to file and serve written submissions in respect of any consequential orders to be made in the substantive proceeding and costs within 14 days.

The matter of Mohammad Saidi Kadhim Khaledi v JBS Australia Pty Ltd involves an application for an extension of the limitation period under s31(2) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974. The plaintiff, Khaledi, seeks damages for personal injuries allegedly sustained during his employment, a matter which he first sought to address by filing proceedings against the defendant, JBS Australia Pty Ltd. However, the proceedings were stayed under s 298 of the Workers Compensation Rehabilitation Act 2003 due to Khaledi's non-compliance with the requirements of s 275 of the same Act, which pertains to the notification of injuries to the employer and the relevant workers' compensation authority. The procedural history of the case thus far includes the plaintiff's initial application to extend the limitation period, which he argues should be granted due to the occurrence of a material fact of a decisive character after the commencement of the last year of limitation. The defendant opposes the application, asserting that Khaledi failed to take all reasonable steps to ascertain the nature and extent of his injuries, and that granting the application would cause material prejudice to the defendant. The matter came before the court for a decision on the application, with the court ultimately dismissing the plaintiff's request for an extension of time, and directing the parties to file written submissions on consequential orders and costs within 14 days.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the plaintiff have a right to claim damages for a personal injury alleged to be sustained in the course of his employment under the circumstances of non-compliance with s 275 of the Workers Compensation Rehabilitation Act 2003?

2. Is the stay of proceedings under s 298 of the Workers Compensation Rehabilitation Act 2003 a valid reason to dismiss the plaintiff's application for an extension of the limitation period?

3. Has the plaintiff failed to take all reasonable steps to find out the nature and extent of his personal injury, and does this failure affect the court's discretion to extend the limitation period?

4. Is there material prejudice to the defendant, and does this prejudice impact the court's decision on the plaintiff's application for an extension of the limitation period?

5. Has the plaintiff established that a material fact of a decisive character occurred after the commencement of the last year of limitation, thereby justifying the exercise of discretion to extend the time?

6. Should the court exercise its discretion under s 31(2) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 to extend the limitation period, and if not, should the application be dismissed?

Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiff does not have a right to claim damages for a personal injury alleged to be sustained in the course of his employment under the circumstances of non-compliance with s 275 of the Workers Compensation Rehabilitation Act 2003. The result was that the plaintiff's claim for damages was not entertained by the court.

2. The court held that the stay of proceedings under s 298 of the Workers Compensation Rehabilitation Act 2003 was not a valid reason to dismiss the plaintiff's application for an extension of the limitation period. The stay did not impede the court's consideration of the plaintiff's application.

3. The court found that the plaintiff had failed to take all reasonable steps to find out the nature and extent of his personal injury, and this failure affected the court's discretion to extend the limitation period. The court concluded that the plaintiff's lack of due diligence in investigating his injury was a factor in denying the extension.

4. The court determined that there was material prejudice to the defendant, and this prejudice impacted the court's decision on the plaintiff's application for an extension of the limitation period. The court found that the defendant would suffer significant disadvantage if the limitation period were extended.

5. The court found that the plaintiff had not established that a material fact of a decisive character occurred after the commencement of the last year of limitation, thereby not justifying the exercise of discretion to extend the time. The plaintiff's argument that new facts arose was not convincing enough to warrant an extension.

6. The court concluded that it should not exercise its discretion under s 31(2) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 to extend the limitation period, and therefore dismissed the application. The result was that the plaintiff's application to extend the limitation period was unsuccessful.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Mohammad Saidi Kadhim Khaledi v JBS Australia Pty Ltd was tasked with determining whether the plaintiff, who alleged personal injury sustained in the course of employment, had a right to claim damages despite non-compliance with certain statutory provisions. The primary issue was whether the plaintiff's failure to adhere to the requirements under s 275 of the Workers Compensation Rehabilitation Act 2003 precluded his right to seek damages. The court examined the legislative framework and held that non-compliance with s 275 did not strip the plaintiff of his entitlement to damages if the injury was sustained during employment. The court underscored the importance of compliance with rehabilitation requirements but clarified that it did not automatically bar a damages claim, thus preserving the plaintiff's rights under the statute.

The court also considered whether the stay of proceedings under s 298 of the Workers Compensation Rehabilitation Act 2003 justified dismissing the plaintiff's application for an extension of the limitation period. The stay provision mandates that proceedings be halted if a claim for workers' compensation is pending. However, the court noted that the stay did not preclude the plaintiff from seeking an extension of time under s 31(2) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974. The court applied the principle that statutory stays do not equate to a waiver of procedural rights to seek extensions. This interpretation allowed the plaintiff to pursue his application for an extension, despite the stay, provided other criteria were met.

The plaintiff's failure to take all reasonable steps to ascertain the nature and extent of his personal injury was another pivotal issue. The court examined whether this lapse affected its discretion to extend the limitation period. While acknowledging the plaintiff's responsibility to investigate his injury, the court held that this alone did not bar an extension. The court applied the principle that diligence in pursuing knowledge of one's injury is not a prerequisite to seeking an extension but is one factor among others in exercising discretion. The court found that the plaintiff's lack of proactive steps did not conclusively deny him the right to an extension, given the potential for other factors to justify such a decision.

Material prejudice to the defendant was also scrutinized in the context of the plaintiff's application for an extension of the limitation period. The court weighed whether the defendant would suffer significant detriment if the limitation period were extended. The court determined that the defendant had demonstrated potential for prejudice, as the delay could impair their ability to defend the claim effectively due to the passage of time and potential loss of evidence. The court applied the principle that material prejudice is a critical consideration in the exercise of discretion to extend time. While recognizing the plaintiff's arguments, the court found that the potential prejudice to the defendant outweighed the plaintiff's justifications for an extension.

The court examined whether the plaintiff had established the occurrence of a material fact of a decisive character after the commencement of the last year of limitation, thereby justifying the exercise of discretion to extend the time. The plaintiff argued that new information regarding the injury's severity only came to light recently, which warranted an extension. The court applied the principle that a decisive material fact must be of significant importance and not merely a matter of degree. The court found that while the plaintiff's new information was relevant, it did not reach the threshold of a decisive material fact necessary to justify an extension. This conclusion was pivotal in the court's decision-making process.

Ultimately, the court deliberated on whether to exercise its discretion under s 31(2) of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 to extend the limitation period. The court considered the totality of the circumstances, including the plaintiff's non-compliance, the stay of proceedings, the lack of reasonable steps taken by the plaintiff, material prejudice to the defendant, and the absence of a decisive material fact. The court held that the factors against extending the limitation period outweighed those in favor. The court's decision to dismiss the application was grounded in the principle that discretion to extend time must be exercised judiciously and only in exceptional circumstances. The court's ratio decidendi is that non-compliance with statutory requirements, the potential for material prejudice, and the lack of a decisive material fact are significant factors that may lead to the dismissal of an application to extend the limitation period in workers' compensation cases.