Mohamed Ali v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Mohamed Ali v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 34

File number: PEG 6 of 2024
Judgment of: JUDGE LADHAMS
Date of judgment: 17 January 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION – application for judicial review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal affirming a decision to refuse to grant the applicants employer nomination (permanent) visas – whether the Tribunal misunderstood or misapplied the test in Public Interest Criterion 4007(2) – whether the Tribunal constructively failed to exercise its jurisdiction – jurisdictional error established – writs issued.     
Legislation:

Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No. 1) Act 2024 (Cth)

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 359AA, 476, 477

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) Sch 2 cl 186.224, Sch 4 PIC 4007

Cases cited:

Applicant Y v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2008) 100 ALD 544; [2008] FCA 367

Bui v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) 85 FCR 134

Dang v Administrative Appeals Tribunal (2019) 273 FCR 87; [2019] FCAFC 220

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259; [1996] HCA 6

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 79
Date of hearing: 7 November 2024
Place: Perth
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr M Guo
Solicitor for the Applicants: Estrin Saul Lawyers
Counsel for the First Respondent: Ms A Martyn
Second Respondent: Submitting appearance, save as to costs
Solicitor for the Respondents: MinterEllison

ORDERS

PEG 6 of 2024

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

SAFIULLA MOHAMED ALI

First Applicant

SUHANA NASREEN SAFIULLA

Second Applicant

MOHAMED THARIQ ALI SAFIULLA (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE LADHAMS

DATE OF ORDER:

17 JANUARY 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.A writ of certiorari issue quashing the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal made on 29 November 2023 (case number 2100408).

2.A writ of mandamus issue directed to the Administrative Review Tribunal requiring it to reconsider the matter according to law.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE LADHAMS:

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicants are non-citizens who applied for Employer Nomination (Permanent) visas (employer nomination visas). The first applicant was the primary visa applicant and the second, third and fourth applicants, who are respectively the daughter, son and wife of the first applicant, were included in the visa application as members of the same family unit. A delegate of the Minister refused to grant the applicants employer…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mohamed Ali v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Aff... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 34
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, Mohamed Ali and others sought judicial review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) affirming a decision to refuse their employer nomination (permanent) visas. The primary issue was whether the AAT misunderstood or misapplied the test in Public Interest Criterion 4007(2). A secondary issue was whether the AAT constructively failed to exercise its jurisdiction. The applicants argued that the AAT should have considered the particular circumstances of the second applicant when assessing the likelihood of undue cost to the Australian community, rather than relying on a hypothetical person with the same condition.

The Court found that the AAT did indeed misunderstand or misapply the test in PIC 4007(2). The Court relied on the case of Dang v Administrative Appeals Tribunal, which clarified that the test under PIC 4007(2) requires consideration of the particular circumstances of the applicant, not hypothetical persons or general assessments. The Court determined that the AAT's reliance on a hypothetical person’s circumstances rather than the specific circumstances of the second applicant constituted a jurisdictional error. The Court held that the AAT’s approach did not reflect an understanding that the waiver could only apply if it could be predetermined that the parents would have the financial and physical capacity to provide appropriate care.

The Court concluded that the AAT’s failure to properly apply the test in PIC 4007(2) amounted to a jurisdictional error. Consequently, the Court issued writs in favour of the applicants.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the reasons explained below, I have found that the Tribunal made a jurisdictional error by misunderstanding or misapplying the test in PIC 4007(2). VISA APPLICATION AND ADMINISTRATIVE DECISIONS The applicants applied for employer nomination visas on 12 November 2019. On 13 May 2020 the Minister’s department sent a letter to the applicants requesting further information, including requiring the second applicant to undergo further health examinations. The letter enclosed a document dated 10 December 2019 headed ‘Form 884: Opinion of a medical officer of the Commonwealth’, which indicated that the second applicant’s health assessment had been deferred as a Medical Officer of the Commonwealth (MOC) required further information from a specialist paediatrician and/or developmental psychologist. The document set out the further information that was required. The applicants provided a report from a consultant paediatrician/neonatologist dated 5 June 2020. By a report dated 11 June 2020, a MOC expressed the view that the second applicant did not meet the requirements of PIC 4007(1)(c)(ii)(A). The MOC estimated that the likely cost to the Australian community for the provision of health services would be $855,600 and that granting a visa to the second applicant would not be likely to prejudice the access of an Australian citizen or permanent resident to health care or community services. On 10 August 2020 an officer of the Minister’s department invited the applicants to comment on the information in the MOC. The applicants were invited to provide information within 28 days in relation to any claim that the opinion of the MOC was incorrect or in relation to the possible waiver of the health requirements. The applicants provided further information in response to the invitation to comment on 21 September 2020. On 7 January 2021 a delegate of the Minister refused to grant the applicants employer nomination visas. The delegate found that the applicants did not meet the requirements of cl 186.224 in Sch 2 to the Regulations, which relevantly required that each applicant satisfy PIC 4007, on the basis that the second applicant did not meet the requirements of PIC 4007(1)(c)(ii)(A) and that exercising the waiver would be likely to result in a significant undue cost to the Australian community in the areas of health care and/or community services. The applicants applied to the Tribunal for merits review of the delegate’s decision on 13 January 2021. The applicants provided to the Tribunal a further report from a paediatrician dated 19 November 2021. On 12 September 2023 the Tribunal offered the applicants an opportunity to obtain a further opinion from a MOC in relation to the second applicant. The applicants accepted this offer and they also provided additional submissions and evidence to the Tribunal on 28 September 2023. A MOC provided a further opinion dated 2 November 2023 in relation to the second applicant. The MOC expressed the view that the second applicant did not satisfy PIC 4007(1)(c)(ii)(A) and estimated that the provision of health care and/or community service costs to a hypothetical person with the condition of the second applicant to be $1,120,900. A copy of the opinion of the MOC was provided to the applicants by the Tribunal on 23 November 2023.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In advancing this ground, the applicants relied on Dang v Administrative Appeals Tribunal (2019) 273 FCR 87; [2019] FCAFC 220 (Dang). In that case, the Full Court of the Federal Court explained the different approach required by PIC 4007(1)(c) and PIC 4007(2) and said at [37]-[38] (emphasis added):37.The power conferred by cl 4007(2) is a power to waive the requirements of cl 4007(1)(c). It is dependent upon the Minister’s satisfaction that the granting of the visa would be unlikely to result in undue cost to the Australian community or undue prejudice to access to services by Australian citizens and permanent residents. Expressed in those terms, it requires consideration of the particular circumstances of the applicant, not the circumstances of an hypothetical person or a general assessment of what would usually be the case for a person with the relevant type of condition. Therefore, the test is different to that to be applied under cl 4007(1)(c). It will encompass whether the applicant is likely to be provided with certain of the services privately, such as through private schooling or therapies paid for without any cost to the community. It presupposes that the requirement the subject of the opinion of the Medical Officer is not met and then directs the Minister to undertake a different form of inquiry.38.In the above circumstances, the Minister is not required to take the opinion of the Medical Officer to be correct for the purpose of considering whether to exercise the power to waive. To the extent that there is to be a consideration of cost or use of services then it must be undertaken by reference to the particular circumstances of the applicant. The Minister (or the Tribunal on review) must undertake that assessment by reference to all of the available material. It may be expected that given the nature of the inquiry to be undertaken, the opinion of the Medical Officer, though relevant, will be given weight that reflects its character. In any event, for reasons already given, the opinion of the Medical Officer concerning the requirements of cl 4007(1)(c) would not extend to any calculation of the likely cost to be incurred in providing services required by the applicant. It can readily be accepted that, for the purposes of PIC 4007(2), the Tribunal was required to consider the particular circumstances of the applicants and not a hypothetical person with the same condition of the same severity as the second applicant. I also accept the applicants’ submission that the terms of PIC 4007(2) require the Tribunal to consider the likelihood of whether there would be, in the future, undue cost to the Australian community and does not require the Tribunal to be able to make any exact determination of what will occur in the future. However, when the Tribunal’s reasons are read fairly and as a whole, I do not consider that the Tribunal has erred in the manner alleged by the applicants in ground 2. When read in its proper context, the Tribunal’s statement at [27] of its reasons that it is not possible to predetermine the future financial and physical capacity of the parents and their ongoing ability to provide appropriate care, does not appear to reflect any understanding on the part of the Tribunal that the waiver can only apply if the Tribunal can predetermine the future financial and physical capacity of the first and fourth applicants to provide appropriate ongoing care to the second applicant. Rather, when read in context, it appears to reflect an assessment that the cost to the community is likely be a ‘considerable burden’ notwithstanding the applicants’ belief that they will continue to care for the second applicant, financially and physically, albeit that the precise extent of the financial and physical support cannot be determined.