MMI General Insurance Ltd v Donnelly [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

[2000] TASSC 163

CITATION:           MMI General Insurance Ltd v Donnelly [No 2] [2000] TASSC 163

PARTIES:  MMI GENERAL INSURANCE LTD
  v
  DONNELLY, Mervyn Maxwell [No 2]

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION:  APPELLATE
FILE NO/S:  LCA 16/2000
DELIVERED ON:  23 November 2000
DELIVERED AT:  Launceston
HEARING DATE/S:  16 November 2000
JUDGMENT OF:  Underwood J

CATCHWORDS:

Workers Compensation - Assessment and amount of compensation - Weekly earnings - Tasmania - Application to review a weekly payment - Rights determinable as at the date of the application.

In re Keystone Knitting Mills' Trade Mark [1929] 1 Ch 92; George Gibson & Co v Wishart [1915] AC 18, followed.
Australian Newsprint Mills Ltd v Williams [1979] Tas R 234, applied.
Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Tas), s88.
Aust Dig Workers Compensation [227]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
           Appellant:  C N Dockray
           Respondent:  B C Hilliard
Solicitors:
           Appellant:  C N Dockray
           Respondent:  Watling Roche

Judgment ID Number:  [2000] TASSC 163
Number of paragraphs:  12

Serial No 163/2000

File No LCA 16/2000

MMI GENERAL INSURANCE LTD v MERVYN MAXWELL DONNELLY [NO 2]

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  UNDERWOOD J
  23 November 2000

  1. On 21 October 1997, the respondent suffered a low back sprain arising out of and in the course of his employment.  Liability to pay compensation was not disputed and weekly payments were made upon the basis that the respondent was totally incapacitated for work.  On 13 March 1998 the respondent was examined by Dr Stewart, a medical practitioner retained by the respondent's employer.  Dr Stewart issued a certificate dated 22 April 1998, certifying that in his opinion, the respondent had wholly or substantially recovered from the effects of the relevant injury.  The notice of intention to cease making weekly payments that accompanied Dr Stewart's certificate was referred to the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Tribunal ("the Tribunal").  The Tribunal held that the respondent had not recovered as opined by Dr Stewart.  Accordingly, the only basis upon which the respondent's employer could lawfully terminate or reduce weekly payments was pursuant to an order for same made by the Tribunal upon an application made pursuant to the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ("the Act"), s88(1). See Viney v Roney Management Pty Ltd (1996) 6 Tas R 240.

  1. In October 1998 video surveillance film of the respondent was taken.  In it he was depicted (inter alia) loading and unloading firewood from his four wheel drive vehicle.  On 12 April 1999 the respondent was examined, again on behalf of his employer, by consultant physician, Dr Ulman.  It was Dr Ulman's opinion that the worker was unfit to resume his pre-injury occupation which involved unrestricted heavy manual work, but that he was fit for a variety of occupations, including factory process worker, taxi driver, delivery driver, storeman, salesman, gardener, caretaker, service station attendant and clerk.  Dr Ulman expressed the view that notwithstanding his capacity to engage in that kind of work, the respondent would be restricted in lifting certain weights and in doing certain heavier work. 

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MMI General Insurance Ltd v Donnelly [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] TASSC 163
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Supreme Court of Tasmania, MMI General Insurance Ltd, the licensed insurer of Mervyn Maxwell Donnelly's employer, sought to terminate or reduce the weekly compensation payments being made to Donnelly. Donnelly, who had suffered a low back sprain in October 1997, was deemed to be totally incapacitated for work. The insurer argued that Donnelly had recovered from his injury, while the insurer contended that he had not. The matter was referred to the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Tribunal which found that Donnelly had not recovered. The insurer subsequently applied to the Tribunal to review the weekly compensation payments, which was dismissed. The insurer appealed to the Supreme Court, which allowed the appeal and quashed the Tribunal's order. The Court then proceeded to determine the appropriate order for the Tribunal to make.

The central legal issue was determining the effective date of the order to reduce the weekly compensation payments to Donnelly. The insurer argued that the order should be effective from the date of the referral to the Tribunal, while Donnelly contended that the order should be effective from the date of the hearing before the Tribunal. The court had to decide whether the order could be made effective from the date of the referral, which would be retrospective, or whether it had to be effective from a later date.

The court held that the order could be made effective from the date of the referral to the Tribunal, as it was consistent with the general principle that courts determine the rights of parties as they existed at the time of the institution of legal proceedings. This principle was applied to workers' compensation cases in Australian Newsprint Mills Ltd v Williams. The court found that there was no reason to deviate from this principle in this case, and that there were no circumstances that would make it unjust to make the order effective from the date of the referral. The court noted that the insurer did not have the necessary evidence to establish its case until shortly after the referral was made, but that this did not affect the general principle. The court found that the evidence before the Tribunal showed that Donnelly had recovered from his injury, and that it would be unjust to make the insurer pay weekly payments for an incapacity that had been found not to exist.

In conclusion, the court ordered that the insurer's application to review the weekly compensation payments be allowed, and that the weekly payment to Donnelly be reduced to $257.85 as from 12 April 1999, the date of the medical certificate that supported the insurer's case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established