MLTR and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

MLTR and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 4128 (2 December 2022)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2021/6454

Re:MLTR

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal:Ms T Bubutievski

Date:2 December 2022

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal disallows:

(a)the Applicant’s objection to the issue of summons on Triple 333 Medical Centre and Word By Word Speech Therapy; and

(b)the Applicant’s objection to the Respondent’s inspecting the documents produced on the summonses on Triple 333 Medical Centre and Word By Word Speech Therapy.

............................[SGD]......................................

Ms T Bubutievski

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – objection by the Applicant to the issue of summons and the Respondent’s inspection of material produced under summons – relevance of the material produced under summons to the issues raised by the reviewable decision – objections disallowed.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 40A, 40B

Cases
ZFCC and Comcare [2018] AATA 1358
Comcare v Maganga 101 ALD 68

Panagiotou and TNT Australia Pty Ltd [2011] AATA 565

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms T Bubutievski

2 December 2022

  1. The Applicant, MLTR, has sought merits review by the Tribunal of a decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Agency) to approve a statement of participant supports which does not include several items sought by the Applicant. The Applicant is a teenage boy and is represented in these proceedings by his mother, Ms MLTR. He has a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder, which necessitates additional support.

  2. On 21 September 2021 a delegate of the CEO of the Agency decided on internal review that the following requested supports were not reasonable and necessary and would not be funded:

    ·increased core funding for continence supports and a support worker for three nights per week;

    ·increased capacity building funding for occupational therapy, positive behaviour supports, speech therapy and a dietician;

    ·home modifications.

    MLTR has proceeded to this Tribunal in respect of the decision not to fund the above supports.

  3. In the course of these proceedings the Agency served a summons on the medical practice where MLTR has received treatment, the Triple 333 Medical Centre; and on Dr SK, MLTR’s paediatrician. It also sought to serve a summons on Word by Word Speech Therapy, where MLTR has previously received treatment. Ms MLTR does not object to the service of the summons on Dr SK, nor the Respondent inspecting documents produced on that summons. She did, however, object to the service of summons on the Triple 333 Medical Centre and Word by Word Speech Therapy and the Respondent inspecting any documents produced on these summonses.

  4. After hearing the parties, the Tribunal has decided to disallow MLTR’s objection to the Agency serving summonses on the Triple 333 Medical Centre and Word by Word Speech Therapy. It has also decided to disallow the objection to the Agency inspecting any of the documents produced on these summonses, for the reasons given below.

    Relevant legislation 

  5. The power to issue a summons is conferred by s 40A of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MLTR and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 4128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerning a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). The applicant, MLTR, objected to the issue of summonses to two medical providers, Triple 333 Medical Centre and Word by Word Speech Therapy, and to the NDIA inspecting the documents produced under those summonses.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the summonses issued to the medical providers were relevant to the proceedings and whether the NDIA should be permitted to inspect the documents produced. The Tribunal considered the power to issue summonses under section 40A of the *Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975* (Cth) and the power to grant leave for inspection of documents produced under summons under section 40B of the same Act. The Tribunal also referred to established principles regarding the issuance of summonses and the subsequent inspection of documents, noting that such documents are typically issued without question initially, assuming relevance to the issues to be decided.

The Tribunal reasoned that while MLTR had a right to privacy regarding his medical information, this needed to be balanced against the need for both the Tribunal and the NDIA to be satisfied that the supports requested were reasonable and necessary. The Tribunal found that the conditions for which MLTR received medical treatment were not irrelevant to the review of the NDIA's decision. Specifically, documents from Word by Word Speech Therapy were considered relevant to assessing the request for increased speech therapy funding, even if the service was not currently being received. The Tribunal concluded that the documents sought could reasonably be expected to shed light on the issues requiring resolution and were therefore not irrelevant or unrelated to the application for review, serving a legitimate forensic purpose.

Ultimately, the Tribunal disallowed MLTR's objection to both the issue of the summonses and the NDIA's inspection of the documents produced. The Tribunal determined that making the complete records available to the NDIA would assist in satisfying the agency that the claimed supports were reasonable and necessary, thereby best serving the objective of merits review.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of MLTR and National Disability Insurance Agency involves the issuance of summonses by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) to compel the production of medical and speech pathology records from two separate entities, Triple 333 Medical Centre and Word By Word Speech Therapy. These summonses were issued to ascertain the relevance and admissibility of the documents in question to the merits review of a decision made by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA). The Applicant, Ms MLTR, raised objections to both the issuance of the summonses and the subsequent inspection of the documents by the NDIA. Ms MLTR argued that the documents from Triple 333 Medical Centre would be irrelevant as she visits the doctor for various health issues, not solely for her autism diagnosis. Despite her objections, she could not pinpoint any specific irrelevant information that might appear in those documents.

The Tribunal addressed Ms MLTR's concerns by weighing them against the necessity for both the Tribunal and the NDIA to be assured that the support services requested by Ms MLTR are reasonable and necessary. The Tribunal ruled that the conditions for which Ms MLTR has received medical treatment are not irrelevant to the proceedings. Furthermore, the Tribunal accepted the NDIA's stance that documents from Word By Word Speech Therapy would facilitate a more comprehensive evaluation of the request for increased therapy funding, particularly for speech therapy, even though such services are not currently being provided. The Tribunal concluded that the documents produced under the summonses for both organisations would likely shed light on the issues pertinent to the review of the decision. Consequently, the Tribunal found the documents to be neither irrelevant nor unrelated to the application for review and deemed them necessary for a legitimate forensic purpose.

The matter before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) in MLTR and National Disability Insurance Agency involves a review application by MLTR, challenging the decision of the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) regarding the provision of certain supports. MLTR lodged an application for review of the NDIA's decision, leading to the current proceedings in the AAT. During the course of these proceedings, the NDIA issued summonses to two medical providers, Triple 333 Medical Centre and Word By Word Speech Therapy, requiring them to produce specific medical and therapy records relevant to the review. MLTR objected to the issuance of these summonses and the subsequent inspection of the produced documents by the NDIA. The AAT was tasked with determining the admissibility and relevance of these documents to the issues at hand. In reaching its decision, the Tribunal considered statutory provisions, including sections 40A and 40B of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), which confer the authority to issue summonses and grant inspection access, respectively. The Tribunal also reviewed relevant case law, notably Panagiotou and TNT Australia Pty Ltd, to understand the procedural steps and principles guiding the issuance and inspection of documents under summons. Ultimately, the Tribunal disallowed MLTR's objections, allowing the inspection of the documents by the NDIA to aid in the merits review process.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The power to issue a summons is conferred by s 40A of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), which provides:Power to summon person to give evidence or produce documents (1)For the purposes of a proceeding before the Tribunal, the President, an authorised member or an officer of the Tribunal may summon a person to do either or both of the following, on the day, and at the time and place, specified in the summons: (a)appear before the Tribunal to give evidence; (b)produce any document or other thing specified in the summons. Note: This section does not apply in relation to proceedings in the Social Services and Child Support Division, as a result of provisions in the enactments that authorise applications for reviews that will be heard in that Division. (2)The President or an authorised member may refuse a request to summon a person. (3)A person may, before the day specified in the summons, comply with a summons to produce a document or thing by producing the document or thing at the Registry from which the summons was issued. If the person does so, the person is not required to attend the hearing of the proceeding unless: (a)the summons or another summons requires the person to appear before the Tribunal; or (b)the Tribunal directs the person to attend the hearing. The Tribunal may, but is not compelled, to provide access to the parties to inspect documents produced under summons. Its power to do so is contained in s 40B:Inspection of documents produced under summons (1)Any of the following persons may give a party to a proceeding leave to inspect a document or other thing produced under a summons in relation to the proceeding: (a)the President; (b)an authorised member; (c)an authorised officer. Note: This section does not apply in relation to proceedings in the Social Services and Child Support Division, as a result of provisions in the enactments that authorise applications for reviews that will be heard in that Division. (2)However, an authorised officer must not make a decision about giving leave, and must instead arrange for the President or an authorised member of the Tribunal to make the decision, if: (a)the officer considers that it is not appropriate for the officer to make the decision; or (b)a party to the proceeding applies to the officer to have the decision made by a member of the Tribunal. (3)If an authorised officer decided whether to give a party to a proceeding leave to inspect a document produced under a summons: (a)a party to the proceeding may apply to the Tribunal, within 7 days or an extended time allowed by the Tribunal, to reconsider the decision; and (b)the Tribunal may reconsider the decision on such an application or its own initiative; and (c)the Tribunal may make such order as it thinks fit in relation to the giving of leave to inspect the document. relevant principles The purpose and process with respect to the issuing of a summons and subsequent access to documents produced pursuant thereto was summarised by Deputy President Forgie in Panagiotou and TNT Australia Pty Ltd [2011] AATA 565 at [19]-[20]:19. A summons issued by the Tribunal has many similarities to a subpoena issued by a court. Both compel either a person to give evidence or produce documents or things for the purpose of, in the case of a subpoena, a court and, in the case of a summons issued under the AAT Act, the Tribunal to carry out its functions. Failure to comply with either a subpoena or a summons is an offence. Other parties to the action or matter in which a party requests that a subpoena or summons be issued may object to their being issued. Those to whom they are addressed may object to complying with them. 20. Whether a subpoena or a summons, it is usually issued without question in the first instance. That assumes that there is no reason from the description of the documents or the identity of the person to be summonsed to question the relevance of the documents to the issues to be decided in the particular court or Tribunal proceeding. Three steps follow the issue of a summons. The first two precede the substantive hearing of the issue by the court or Tribunal and the third occurs during the course of, and as part of, that hearing. They have been identified by Moffit P in Waind and Hill v National Employers’ Mutual General Association Ltd:The first is obeying the subpoena, by the witness bringing the documents to the court and handing them to the judge. This step involves the determination of any objections of the witness to the subpoena, or to the production of the documents to the court pursuant to the subpoena. The second step is the decision of the judge concerning the preliminary use of the documents, which includes whether or not permission should be given to a party or parties to inspect the documents. The third step is the admission into evidence of the document in whole or in part; or the use of it in the process of evidence being put before the court by cross-examination or otherwise. It is the third step which alone provides material upon which ultimate decision in the case rests. In these three steps the stranger and the parties have different rights, and the function of the judge differs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Making the complete records available to the Agency may well assist in satisfying it that the claimed supports are indeed reasonable and necessary. Denying the Agency access to those records may lead it to maintain its current position. Whatever the outcome, the objective of merits review of this decision is best served by having MLTR’s medical and speech pathology records available to the Agency for inspection.Conclusion The Tribunal will disallow MLTR’s objection to both the issue of summons to Triple 333 Medical Centre and Word By Word Speech Therapy and the Respondent inspecting the documents produced through the summonses on both organisations.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms MLTR also argued that the documents produced under summons from the Triple 333 Medical Practice would be irrelevant to the proceedings as MLTR sees this doctor for many things other than his autism diagnosis. She was unable to identify any particularly irrelevant information which may appear in those documents.CONSIDERATION The Tribunal considered Ms MLTR’s argument carefully, noting the tension between MLTR’s right to keep his medical information private and the need for both the Tribunal and the Agency to be satisfied that the supports requested by MLTR are reasonable and necessary if MLTR is to get the outcome he seeks. The Tribunal is satisfied that it would be correct to issue summonses on both the Triple 333 Medical Centre and Word by Word Speech Therapy. Conditions for which MLTR has received medical treatment are not irrelevant. The Tribunal accepts the Respondent’s argument that documents from Word by Word Speech Therapy would enable it to more fully consider the request for increased therapy funding, in particular speech therapy, even though this service is not presently being received. The documents produced under summons for both organisations can reasonably be expected to throw light on the issues that need to be resolved in reviewing the decision. They are not irrelevant or unrelated to the application for review. They are issued and served for a legitimate forensic purpose. Making the complete records available to the Agency may well assist in satisfying it that the claimed supports are indeed reasonable and necessary. Denying the Agency access to those records may lead it to maintain its current position. Whatever the outcome, the objective of merits review of this decision is best served by having MLTR’s medical and speech pathology records available to the Agency for inspection.Conclusion The Tribunal will disallow MLTR’s objection to both the issue of summons to Triple 333 Medical Centre and Word By Word Speech Therapy and the Respondent inspecting the documents produced through the summonses on both organisations.