MKJ v Queensland Police Service Weapons Licensing

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND


ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

CITATION:

MKJ v Queensland Police Service – Weapons Licensing [2023] QCAT 84

PARTIES:

MKJ

(applicant/appellant)

v

QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE – WEAPONS LICENSING

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

GAR463-20

MATTER TYPE:

General administrative review

DELIVERED ON:

2 March 2023

HEARING DATE:

22 February 2023

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

 Member Richard Oliver

1.     The decision of the respondent is set aside.

2.     The applicant be issued a weapons licence for category A and B weapons for Occupational – Primary Producer on Rural Lands.

3. Publication of any information that might identify the applicant, the applicant’s former partner and the police officer referred to in these reasons, other than to the parties to this proceeding, is prohibited pursuant s 66 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009

CATCHWORDS:

FIRE, EXPLOSIVES AND FIREARMS – FIREARMS- LICENCES AND REGISTRATION – REVOCATION OF LICNCE – where applicant applied for a weapons licence for occupational purposes primary-producer – where applicant charged with breaches of domestic violence orders in 2012 – where applicant admitted breaches – where breaches did not involve violence, threats of violence or harm – where applicant failed to include history of mental health treatment in 2010/2011 on the application for a her license – where applicant persistently emailed the investigating police officer – where application for weapons licence rejected – whether applicant a fit and proper person to hold a weapons licence – whether in the public interest for the applicant to hold a weapons license.

Queensland Civil and Administrative TribunalAct 2009 (Qld), s 20, s 24, s 66

Weapons Act 1990 (Qld), s 3, s 10B

Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012 (Qld), s 159

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 94 ALR 11

Moye v Queensland Police Service – WeaponsLicensing [2017] QCAT 79

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Mr Quin solicitor of Gilshenan & Luton

Respondent:

Sergeant Baur of Queensland Police Service – Weapons Licencing.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The applicant is a mature lady who lives alone on about 43 hectares in the west of Toowoomba. She is all but retired from a long and unblemished teaching career and runs about 30 cattle and a similar number of sheep on the property. The land ranges from open grazing into wooded areas which she is gradually opening up within reason. It is bordered on the foothills of heavily timbered ridge country. Her livestock is subjected to attacks from dingos and/or wild dogs. There is a feral pig problem as well as foxes. Just recently she lost about a dozen sheep to dog attacks. She is proficient in the use of a small calibre firearm and needs one to help control the feral animals on her land.

  2. In 2020 she applied to the respondent for weapons licence. It was rejected because the authorised officer of the respondent contends she is not a fit and proper person to hold a weapons licence. Also, it would not be in the public interest to issue her with one. It…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MKJ v Queensland Police Service Weapons Licensing and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCAT 84
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

MKJ sought judicial review of the Queensland Police Service Weapons Licensing's decision to reject her application for a weapons licence, on the basis that she was not a fit and proper person to hold a licence. The applicant, a woman in her early 60s with a background in education and rural property management, applied for a weapons licence for occupational purposes as a primary producer. The application was rejected due to the applicant's history of breaching domestic violence orders in 2012, her failure to disclose past mental health treatment on her application form, and her persistent communication with the investigating police officer. The court had to determine whether these factors rendered the applicant unfit to hold a weapons licence and whether it was in the public interest for her to hold one.

The primary legal issue was whether the applicant, given her history of breaching domestic violence orders, her undisclosed mental health treatment, and her persistent communication with the police, was a fit and proper person to hold a weapons licence. The court considered the nature of the breaches, which did not involve violence, threats of violence, or harm, and the applicant's otherwise law-abiding and community-involved life. The court also had to weigh the potential impact of the applicant's ongoing communication with the police on her suitability for a licence.

The court concluded that the applicant was a fit and proper person to hold a weapons licence. It found that the breaches of the domestic violence orders did not involve violence or threats of violence, and the applicant's persistent communication with the police, while concerning, was not indicative of a threat to public safety. The court accepted that the applicant would not pose a threat to the public or to police visiting her premises. The court also noted that the applicant's undisclosed past mental health treatment did not affect her current fitness to hold a licence.

The court set aside the decision of the authorised officer and substituted it with a decision that the applicant be issued a weapons licence for category A and B weapons for Occupational – Primary Producer on Rural Lands. The court also made a non-publication order to protect the identity of persons involved in the domestic violence proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Therefore, the question for determination in this review application is whether, in all the circumstances, the applicant is a fit and proper person to be issued with a weapons licence. The specific matters to be considered is the effect of the breaches of the domestic violence orders, the applicant’s interaction with Sgt Pat, her failure to disclose psychological treatment in 2010 on her application form and whether there are any ongoing mental health issues which need to be considered.The applicant’s background The applicant is in her early 60s. She grew up in south-western Queensland on her family agricultural property. Her family had been involved in the pastoral industry since the 1950s and she is familiar with all aspects of rural life. She qualified as a high school teacher after leaving school and has spent most of her life as an educator in Queensland and the Northern Territory. She has had responsible administrative positions in schools. Having mainly taught in country schools, she has been on school boards, engaged with the local community, including local authorities and church groups. Presently, she is a member of the local Agricultural Show Society and both as a community member and school teacher engages with the local police without any difficulty. Although she has reduced her availability for teaching to spend more time running her small agricultural enterprise, she is still available for “call out” teaching when needed. The applicant manages her small property herself. She has made improvements to her property by some timber clearing, weed control, improving water supply and refurbishing her residence. She has trouble with feral animals, such as dingos/wild dogs, pigs, rabbits and foxes. She seems proficient in animal husbandry and sells the cattle she grows out to market, as well as the lambs she produces, save for the ones she slaughters for her own consumption. An example of her proficiency is when dogs recently attacked and mortally injured about a dozen of her sheep. Rather than wait for assistance, and because the sheep were suffering, she humanely destroyed them straight away they with a knife. This takes a heavy toll. Other than the domestic violence issues, the applicant has no history with the QPS. She is otherwise a law-abiding citizen and an asset to the community within which she resides. There was no suggestion to the contrary by the respondent.Protection Orders That then brings me to the domestic violence orders that were made in 2010. She commenced a relationship with Jane (a pseudonym) in 2005 and they co-habited until 2010. The breakdown of their relationship was acrimonious and as a consequence Sgt Pat (a pseudonym) became involved and applied for domestic violence orders against both Jane and the applicant in April 2010. Temporary orders were made against the applicant and Jane. Then in August 2010, further temporary orders were made naming both the applicant and Jane as applicant and respondent. In other words, orders were taken out by each of them against the other.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This then led to a fixation, in the mind of the applicant, that she was being ignored to the benefit of Jane. She then embarked on a series of emails to Sgt Pat personally, complaining about his conduct. The emails span a period from November 2012 to 2021.[5] There is little point in traversing the content of each email, but importantly not one contains any threat to Sgt Pat but reiterates what the applicant perceives to be his incompetence, dereliction of duty, lack of integrity and favouring the situation of Jane as opposed to herself.[6] I was particularly concerned by the email of 22 July 2021 whilst these proceedings were on foot and directly asked her the motivation for this. The applicant said she frustrated by the need to undergo a psychological examination, as directed by the Tribunal and, again, blamed this on Sgt Pat so took out this frustration with another email. [5]Emails dated: 01.11.2012, 16.04.2015, 25.05.2015, 09.06.2015, 27.04.2017, 28.01.2019, 22.10.2020 and 22.07.2021.[6]My summation of the content of the emails.Evidence of Sergeant Pat Sgt Pat has filed an affidavit setting out his experiences with the applicant. He records in detail the circumstances surrounding the obtaining of the orders obtained in the Magistrates Court. He records the complaints received from Jane about the applicant’s breaches of the orders and steps he took in relation to the breaches. He records other complaints from Jane about the applicant’s behaviour, but no other charges were laid against the applicant. He summarises his interactions with the applicant as follows:During my dealings with the applicant I found her to be indignant and belligerent towards me. When pressed on specifics of complaints the applicant became defensive and argumentative. I recorded all interactions with the applicant. On occasion she would yell, scream and rant at me, accuse me of corruption and tell me I was a disgrace to the police force. I found the applicant's version of events, whilst possibly true in her own mind, were her version of the truth and often self-serving in nature sometimes only partially true, on occasion totally false. He also records the accusation of being a bully and threatening the applicant with a gun which he deals with in his affidavit. He rejects entirely any suggestion of threatening the applicant with a gun conceding his action of placing his hand on his sidearm was an innocent and normal stance for him. He also rejects any suggestion of being influential in attempting to influence the authorised officer about the applicant’s weapons licence application. He did provide a letter with the accompany emails to the authorised officer as background information for consideration during the course of the application process. This was entirely appropriate. Sgt Pat expressed strong views as to the applicant's suitability for a weapons licence having regard to his experience with her during her personal conflict with Jane and of course, the ongoing email stream to which he has been subjected. He expressed concern for other police who might be required to attend her premises for a normal weapons audit which is carried out periodically on those who have weapons licences. He also described the layout of the applicant’s residence which necessitated a visitor having to drive to the rear of her house, which is obscured from the main roadway, to speak with the applicant. Given her attitude to police, he expressed concern that if the applicant was surprised by an unexpected visit by police she may act irrationally.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Her obsession with Sgt Pat is obviously a concern, but I am confident that with the resolution of this review application that interaction will cease. If it does not and there is cause for Sgt Pat to take action to protect his privacy this may adversely impact the applicant’s suitability to be hold or be issued a weapons licence in the future. Decision Having regard to the history provided by the applicant, the reasons for her interactions with Sgt Pat, the Lumsdem Report and her reasons for not including the previous psychological treatment on the application form, I have come to the view that the applicant is a fit and proper person to be issued a weapons licence. I do not accept that she would be any threat to police who might visit her premises, even Sgt Pat. No reason has been established to my reasonable satisfaction that the applicant would be a threat to the public. I therefore do not accept it would be in the public interest to refuse to issue her with a weapons licensee in the category applied for. During the hearing I enquired what type of weapon she had. She only has and has always had the one. It is a .22 calibre bolt action single shot rifle. The licence will issue for that type of weapon, the serial number of which will appear on the licence. I realise she can add other category A and B weapons to her license if she satisfies the requirements of a Permit to Acquire. Under s 24 of the QCAT Act the Tribunal can set aside the decision and substitute its own decision. Therefore, I propose to set aside the decision of the authorised officer and substitute that decision with the decision that the applicant be issued with a weapons licence for category A and B weapons for Occupational – Primary Producer on Rural Lands as that is what was applied for in her application. Under s 159 of the Domestic and Family Violence Protection Act 2012 (Qld), publication of any information that is likely to identify a person or witness involved in a proceeding under that Act is prohibited. As one of the main issues in this case involved the making of orders made under that Act I propose to make a non-publication order pursuant to s 66(1)(c) of the QCAT Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.