MJWZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

MJWZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2024] AATA 846 (24 April 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2022/9206

Re:MJWZ

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndKXNT

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

Date:24 April 2024

Place:Perth

The Reviewable Decision, being the AAT1 Decision dated 26 September 2022, is set aside and is substituted with the new decision that:

(a)the Existing Care Determination is revoked;

(b)new care determinations are made that the Father had 70% care and the Mother had 30% care of A from 1 July 2021 for the care period, being 1 July 2021 to 31 December 2022; and

(c)the date of effect of the revocation of the Existing Care Determination is 3 November 2021 for the Father, and 1 July 2021 for the Mother.

..................[Sgd]......................................................

Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth).


CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care decision – whether there was a change in care – dispute about percentage of care – Tribunal satisfied there was a change in care – existing care determination revoked – new care determinations made – Father notified Agency more than 28 days after the date of the change of care – date of effect of revocation – AAT1 decision set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) ss 49, 50, 54A, 54B, 54F, 54F(3)(b), 54G, 54H, 54H(1)(c)

CASES

Polec & Staker & Anor [2011] FMCAfam 959

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Guides to Social Policy: Child Support Guide [2.2.1]

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Dr M Evans-Bonner

24 April 2024

BACKGROUND

  1. The Father (MJWZ), and the Mother (KXNT), are the separated parents of a minor child, A, born on 25 February 2009.

  2. There is a dispute between the Father and the Mother regarding the percentage of care provided to A from 1 July 2021.

  3. The Existing Care Determination was that the Father had 14% care, and the Mother had 86% care of the child from 24 September 2015 (T45/269).

  4. On 3 November 2021 the Father notified Centrelink that there was a change in care. He advised that he had 44% care from 1 July 2021 (T6/75).

  5. On 12 January 2022, an authorised review officer (ARO) decided to reject the Father’s request for a new care decision (T18/130).

  6. On 20 January 2022, the Father objected to the ARO’s decision (T20/137).

  7. On 22 March 2022, a delegate of the Respondent decided to partly allow the objection (the Objection Decision) (T36/217).

  8. Specifically, the delegate decided that the Mother had 67% care, and the Father had 33% care of A from 1 July 2021. This change was to be applied from 3 November 2021. There was no impact…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MJWZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 846
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a review of a child support percentage of care decision before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The parties involved were the Father (the applicant) and the Child Support Registrar, with the Mother also participating in the proceedings. The core dispute revolved around the correct percentage of care for the child, A, and the date from which any revised determination should take effect, following an earlier decision by the Tribunal (AAT1) that had set aside an objection decision and made new care determinations.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether a change in the pattern of care for A had occurred on 1 July 2021, necessitating the revocation of an existing care determination and the making of new ones. If a change was found, the Tribunal also had to determine the appropriate percentage of care to be attributed to each parent and the effective date for these new determinations. The legal framework for these determinations was primarily found in sections 49 and 50 of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth), which outline the circumstances under which a pattern of care is established and how percentages of care are to be determined.

The Tribunal found that, based on the evidence presented by both parents, including detailed calendars of care and other documentary evidence, there had been a pattern of care established during the relevant period, thus engaging section 50 of the Assessment Act. The Tribunal agreed with the parties that a change of care occurred on 1 July 2021. The Father's evidence indicated that A had been living with him from July 2021 due to difficulties at school and issues with the Mother's new partner, with the Father asserting he had care of A every night during 2022. While the parties' calendars presented conflicting figures regarding the exact percentages of care, they both indicated a significant shift from the previous determination.

The Tribunal set aside the decision of AAT1, which had determined the Mother had 65% care and the Father 35% care from 3 November 2021. The Tribunal substituted its own decision, finding that from 1 July 2021, the Father had 70% of the care of A, and the Mother had 30% of the care of A. This new determination was to take effect from 1 July 2021.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Father’s evidence was that A started living with him from July 2021 when A started having difficulties at school and that she lived with him in 2022 as well. He stated that A did not want to live with the Mother because A did not get along with the Mother’s new partner. His evidence was that during 2022, A stayed with him every night. He stated that during school holidays, A would spend half the time with him and half the time with the Mother. On odd occasions A would spend some nights with the Mother. The Father stated that from 2022 A went to a private tutor and had another tutoring session at the library. He stated that A’s cat had been living with him since the beginning of January 2023 (transcript/20-27). Documentary evidence As mentioned above, the Father filed calendars of care in these proceedings. More specifically, I have had regard to his calendars of care and work shifts from:·1 July 2021 to January 2022 (T13/111-119).·December 2021 to January 2022 (T28/158-159).·January 2022 to February 2022 (T30/202-203). ·Calendar for March 2022 which also noted expenses for tutoring for A on 3 March 2022, 9 March 2022, 15 and 16 March 2022. The handwritten note also referred to ongoing tutoring on Monday for one hour, and group tutoring of three hours on Tuesday and Wednesday (T35/213).·A tally of nights A spent with each parent between July and March 2022 (T39/239).·A calendar for March 2022 with handwritten entries showing the Father had overnight care of A for the entire month and that A had five tutoring sessions totalling $260 (T39/240).·A calendar of care from 1 July 2021 to 30 June 2022 (T41/244-245).·A calendar of care filed on 18 November 2022 and another calendar of care from July 2021 to February 2023 (A1).·Further calendars showing care (A3, A7, A9, A10). The Father also filed a handwritten list of “out of pocket money” spent on A between 3 March 2022 and 7 April 2022 for tutoring, an ultrasound and “child wellbeing centre” totalling $625 (T39/236). The Father filed copies of text messages between himself and the mother of a friend of A’s where he tried to organise “sleepovers” for the two children, as well as texts with the Mother regarding A’s absences from school, which both suggest she was staying with the Father. These text messages relate to Friday 9 July 2021, Saturday 10 July 2021, Tuesday 27 July to Thursday 29 July 2021, Saturday 31 July 2021, 1 August 2021, Friday 17 and Saturday 18 September 2021 (T43/257-264). The Father provided emails that he has sent to A’s school advising that she was absent due to illness, personal reasons and medical appointments (T30/167-201). The dates of absence were Friday 23 July 2021, Monday 2 August 2021, Tuesday 17 August 2021, Thursday 19 August 2021, Tuesday 24 August 2021, Wednesday 25 August 2021, Wednesday 15 September 2021, Thursday 16 September 2021, Thursday 16 and Friday 17 September 2021, Wednesday 27 October 2021, Wednesday 3 November 2021, Thursday 4 November 2021, Friday 5 November 2021, Thursday 18 November 2021, Friday 19 November 2021, Tuesday 23 November 2021, Wednesday 24 November 2021, Thursday 25 November 2021, Friday 26 November 2021, Tuesday 30 November 2021, Wednesday 1 December 2021, Thursday 2 December 2021, Friday 3 December 2021, Monday 6 December 2021, Tuesday 7 December 2021, Wednesday 8 December 2021, Thursday 9 December 2021, Friday 10 December 2021.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 26 September 2022, the AAT1 set aside the Objection Decision and substituted a decision that from 1 July 2021 the Mother had 65% care, and from 3 November 2021 the Father had 35% care, of A (T2/8). The AAT1 decision is the Reviewable Decision. On 1 October 2022, the Father lodged an application seeking review of the Reviewable Decision (T1/1-6) in the General Division of this Tribunal (AAT2). THE ISSUE The issue before me is whether:(a)there was a change in the pattern of care for A on 1 July 2021 which required the Existing Care Determination to be revoked and new determinations to be made;(b)and if so, what percentage of care for A should be attributed to the Father and to the Mother;(c)and if so, the date that the new percentage of care determinations should take effect. EVIDENCE OF CARE PERCENTAGES Both parties filed calendars with the Tribunal during the review process on which each had recorded they had 70% care of A from 1 July 2021 to December 2022. These calendars were helpfully summarised by the Respondent at paragraphs [55] and [56] of their Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (RSFIC) as follows:The Applicant’s [Father’s] care calendar filed with this Tribunal on 16 February 2023 provides:- For the period 1 July 2021 to 30 June 2022 (365 days), the Applicant had care 253 days. This equates to the Applicant having 69% care.- For the period 1 July 2021 to 31 December 2022 (549 days), the Applicant had care 397 days. This equates to the Applicant having 72% care.The Other Party’s [Mother’s] care calendar filed with this Tribunal on 15 March 2023 and the calendar she lodged with the AAT1 provides:- For the period 1 July 2021 to 30 June 2022 (365 days), the Other Party had 256 nights of care. This equates to the Other Party having 70% care.- For the period 1 July 2021 to December 2022 (549 days), the Other Party had 384 nights of care. This equates to the Other Party having 70% care. The Father’s calendars do not always show whether he had days or nights of care. In contrast, the Mother’s calendars specify nights of care. However, in a statement filed on 15 March 2023 (A3), the Father stated that he had endeavoured to “keep track of the days she was sleeping at my house” so I infer that his calendars reflect nights of care. Although they conflict, the calendars do assist to some extent because the Mother’s calendar concedes that the Father had 30% care of A during the period 1 July 2021 to December 2022 which is a significant increase from the Existing Care Determination which found that the Father had 14% care (OP1). The Father Evidence at the hearing The Father’s evidence was that A started living with him from July 2021 when A started having difficulties at school and that she lived with him in 2022 as well. He stated that A did not want to live with the Mother because A did not get along with the Mother’s new partner. His evidence was that during 2022, A stayed with him every night. He stated that during school holidays, A would spend half the time with him and half the time with the Mother. On odd occasions A would spend some nights with the Mother. The Father stated that from 2022 A went to a private tutor and had another tutoring session at the library. He stated that A’s cat had been living with him since the beginning of January 2023 (transcript/20-27). Documentary evidence

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Mother also submitted that A “did not attend many of her private tuition sessions due to illness and anxiety”, which she stated was confirmed in the email from the tutor filed by the Father. However, as I mentioned above, that email stated that A attended tutoring “3 times a week throughout 2022 with some absence days due to illness and anxiety”. My inference from the wording was that despite some absences, A was regularly attending tutoring, sometimes three times a week. CONSIDERATION Sections 49 and 50 of the Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) (Assessment Act) set out when a percentage of care determination must be made.Does s 49 or 50 apply? Section 49 applies if, having regard to all the circumstances, a responsible parent for a child had, or is likely to have, no pattern of care for the child during the care period. Section 50 applies if, having regard to all the circumstances, the Registrar is satisfied that a responsible parent has had, or is likely to have, a pattern of care during the care period. Section 50 provides:Determination of percentage of care–responsible person has had etc. a pattern of care for a child(1) This section applies if:(a) either of the following applies:(i) an application is made under section 25 or 25A for a parent to be assessed in respect of the costs of the child;(ii) a parent is taken under section 73A to have had a relevant dependent child from a day specified in that section;and the Registrar is satisfied that a responsible person for the child has had, or is likely to have, a pattern of care for the child during such period (the care period) as the Registrar considers to be appropriate having regard to all the circumstances; or(b) both of the following apply:(i) the determination of a responsible person’s percentage of care for a child that was made under section 49 or this section is revoked or suspended under Subdivision C of this Division, except under paragraph 54FA(3)(b) or 54HA(3)(b);(ii) the Registrar is satisfied that the responsible person has had, or is likely to have, a pattern of care for the child during such period (the care period) as the Registrar considers to be appropriate having regard to all the circumstances.(2)The Registrar must determine the responsible person’s percentage of care for the child during the care period.(3)The percentage determined under subsection (2) must be a percentage that corresponds with the actual care of the child that the Registrar is satisfied that the responsible person has had, or is likely to have, during the care period.(4)Subsection (3) does not apply if section 51 applies in relation to the responsible person. I am satisfied, as demonstrated by the calendars submitted by both parties, that there has been a pattern of care during the care period, although the parties disagree as to the details. Therefore s 50 applies. The change of care date and the care period The Mother, Father and Respondent agree that there was a change of care on 1 July 2021. I agree, and so find, noting that in their evidence, the Father and the Mother both referred to there being a change in care on 1 July 2021.