MJDH v Director of Public Prosecutions (SA)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Criminal)

MJDH v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS (SA)

[2013] SASC 68

Judgment of The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis

10 May 2013

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - SENTENCING PROCEDURE - FACTUAL BASIS FOR SENTENCE - EVIDENCE - BURDEN AND STANDARD OF PROOF

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT - GROUNDS - GENERALLY

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE - POWERS OF APPELLATE COURT - GENERALLY

This is an appeal against the sentence imposed by a Magistrate following the appellant’s plea of guilty to one count of gross indecency – the Magistrate sentenced the appellant to imprisonment for 12 months, suspended on the condition that the appellant enter into a supervised bond to be of good behaviour for two years – the Magistrate also made an order for compensation and an order that the appellant register his name with the Australian National Child Offender Register (ANCOR).

Whether the sentence is manifestly excessive – whether the Magistrate was correct to reject the account of the offending put by the appellant – whether the order for the appellant to register with ANCOR should have been made.

Held (Kourakis CJ):  Appeal allowed and the sentence imposed by the Magistrate set aside for the purpose of giving the appellant an opportunity to give evidence in support of his account – the appellant’s account not proved on the balance of probabilities – the same sentence as was imposed by the Magistrate, save as to the making of the ANCOR order, imposed on appeal – a suspended sentence of 12 months imprisonment imposed.

Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) s 58(1)(a); Child Sex Offenders Registration Act 2006 (SA) s 4, s 6, s 6(1)(a), s 6(3)(a), s 9, Sch 1, referred to.
The Queen v Olbrich (1999) 199 CLR 270; Law v Deed [1970] SASR 374; The Queen v Morse (1979) 23 SASR 98; R v AWL [2003] SASC 416, considered.

MJDH v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS (SA)
[2013] SASC 68

Magistrates Appeal:   Criminal

  1. Kourakis CJ:           The appellant, MJDH, appeals against the sentence imposed in the Magistrates Court on 7 December 2012.

  2. On 23 November 2012 the appellant pleaded guilty in the Adelaide Magistrates Court to one count of gross indecency in satisfaction of a number of other charges.[1]  The prosecution case was based on the appellant’s admission to his wife that he had masturbated in the presence of their four-and-a-half-year-old daughter (D). Following the appellant’s plea, sentencing was adjourned to enable a psychological report to be prepared.  Submissions on sentence were made before the Magistrate on 7 December 2012.  The Magistrate received by way of sentencing materials the psychological report of Dr White, dated 4 December 2012, and a victim impact statement of the appellant’s wife.

    [1]The charge remaining was that of committing an act of gross indecency in the presence of his child, being a person under the age of sixteen years, pursuant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MJDH v Director of Public Prosecutions (SA) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] SASC 68
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of MJDH v Director of Public Prosecutions (SA) involves the appellant, who was found guilty of one count of gross indecency by a Magistrate. The Magistrate sentenced the appellant to imprisonment for 12 months, suspended on the condition that the appellant enter into a supervised bond to be of good behaviour for two years. The Magistrate also made an order for compensation and an order that the appellant register his name with the Australian National Child Offender Register (ANCOR). The appeal against the sentence was brought before the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The primary legal issues the court had to decide were whether the sentence was manifestly excessive, whether the Magistrate was correct to reject the appellant's account of the offending, and whether the order for the appellant to register with ANCOR should have been made. The court examined the evidence presented and the appellant's sworn testimony in support of his account. The court determined that the appellant's account was not proved on the balance of probabilities and that the Magistrate's decision to reject the account was correct.

The court allowed the appeal and set aside the sentence imposed by the Magistrate, granting the appellant an opportunity to give evidence in support of his account. The court determined that the appellant's account was not proved on the balance of probabilities. The court imposed the same sentence as the Magistrate, except for the ANCOR order, which was not made. A suspended sentence of 12 months imprisonment was imposed on appeal.

The court's final orders were that the appeal be allowed, and the sentence imposed by the Magistrate be set aside for the purpose of giving the appellant an opportunity to give evidence in support of his account. The court imposed the same sentence as was imposed by the Magistrate, save as to the making of the ANCOR order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held (Kourakis CJ): Appeal allowed and the sentence imposed by the Magistrate set aside for the purpose of giving the appellant an opportunity to give evidence in support of his account – the appellant’s account not proved on the balance of probabilities – the same sentence as was imposed by the Magistrate, save as to the making of the ANCOR order, imposed on appeal – a suspended sentence of 12 months imprisonment imposed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

During the course of the hearing of the appeal I was persuaded that the uncertainty over the position which the Magistrate would adopt deprived the appellant of an adequate opportunity to support his account in the witness box. I indicated to counsel that I would allow the appeal on that ground. After hearing submissions I determined that the matter should not be remitted to the Magistrates Court. I also intimated that I was not prepared to accept the appellant’s account unless it was proved on the balance of probabilities by sworn evidence. I invited the appellant to give sworn evidence in support of his account.Evidence on Appeal The appellant was sworn and gave the following evidence. He married in 2003. He described a deterioration in the relationship with his wife following the death of her mother who passed away, just after D was born, in 2007. The appellant described supporting his wife as best he could through the periods of her depression that followed. They were both working long hours, the appellant in his Thebarton sound recording studio and his wife in a pre-school day care centre operated from their home. The appellant gave evidence that he “became addicted to masturbation” as the sexual relationship with his wife deteriorated. With respect to the offence itself, the appellant explained that D had been moved from the parental bed where she had slept from birth into her own room just two weeks before the incident. On the night of the offending the appellant arrived home at about 11.00 pm. His wife was asleep. The appellant went to bed and made sexual advances that were rejected by his wife. Later, at about 3.00 am, D called out for him. He went to her bed to settle her. D complained to him of discomfort between her legs. The appellant testified that D suffered a vaginal rash that was being treated by both he and his wife with the topical application of paw paw cream. The appellant gave evidence that it was too cold for him to get the paw paw cream from another part of the room. He testified:A… It was up in the shelf and it was freezing cold and it was warm in her bed and I didn’t get up and get it. I just rubbed her and said “is that better, [D]”. She said “thanks Daddy, that’s it”. I rubbed her back. I always massaged her back to put her back to sleep.His Honour: … Q Had you ever rubbed her vagina without paw paw cream before.ANo, this was the first time, only because I couldn’t be bothered going to get it.Q… What made you think that rubbing her in the vulval area without paw paw cream or other cream would help.AI just did what she told me to do.QI am asking you as an adult and father why you thought that rubbing that area without paw paw cream would help.AI didn’t really think about it at the time, I just did what she said and I said “Is that better” and she said “Yes, that’s better”. There was nothing sexual involved, you’ve got to understand that. This whole thing isn’t anything to do with [D] and me getting off on a young child. It’s my daughter. I made some inappropriate behaviour, I accept that, but this is nothing to do with children, this has never happened before, it’s about being sexually frustrated and making some inappropriate behaviour and some bad decisions. My head wasn’t straight at the time and that’s what this is all about, basically.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established