MJ Hanna & Sons Pty Limited v Woodyard

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:MJ Hanna & Sons Pty Limited v Woodyard [2007] NSWWCCPD 202

APPELLANT:  MJ Hanna & Sons Pty Limited

RESPONDENT:  Walter Woodyard

INSURER:CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited.

FILE NUMBER:  WCC10209-06

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          16 April 2007

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  27 September 2007

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Section 40 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987; impact of a psychiatric/psychological condition; exercise of discretion; adequacy of evidence.

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Acting Deputy President Deborah Moore

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:      Lyons Barnett Kennedy

Respondent:   Carroll & O’Dea

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  The decision of the Arbitrator dated 16 April 2007 is revoked and the matter is remitted to another Arbitrator for determination afresh in accordance with these reasons.

Costs of the proceedings before the Arbitrator on 17 October 2006 should follow the event when the matter is determined.

No order as to costs of the appeal.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. On 14 May 2007 M J Hanna & Sons Pty Limited (‘the Appellant’) sought leave to bring an ‘Appeal Against Decision of an Arbitrator’ in the Workers Compensation Commission (‘the Commission’) against a decision of a Commission Arbitrator dated 16 April 2007.

  1. The Respondent to the Appeal is Walter Woodyard (‘the Respondent/Mr Woodyard’).

  1. Mr Woodyard was born on 12 August 1960 and is presently 47 years old. He left school at 18 years of age, having completed his Higher School Certificate. He commenced a Bachelor of Arts Degree majoring in psychology at NSW University the following year but then deferred after approximately six months and went to live in the USA. He was married in America and remained working there for some years before returning to Australia. After a period operating a restaurant in Sydney for some four years, Mr Woodyard then took over a family business and remained working there until about 1992. In 1993, he went to Armidale in order to recommence his university degree at the University of New England. He stated that he remained at the University until 1998 and then, due to matrimonial difficulties, again deferred his studies. He commenced work with the Appellant as a sales assistant on 5 March 1999 working 26.5 hours per week, usually Mondays to Wednesdays and four hours on Saturdays.

  1. On 30 August 1999 whilst walking up stairs to a storeroom to collect stock, he slipped and fell, sustaining an injury to his back.

  1. He was off work for about a week, made several attempts to return to work but on each occasion ceased because of pain.

  1. Mr Woodyard reported the injury on 31 August 1999 and submitted a Workers Compensation Claim Form on 21 September 1999. The Appellant’s workers compensation insurer, CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited (‘CGU’) accepted the claim and commenced weekly payments of compensation.

  1. On 6 April 2000 CGU wrote to Mr Woodyard advising that liability was denied from 6 April 2000, with weekly payments to be made until 19…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MJ Hanna & Sons Pty Limited v Woodyard and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWWCCPD 202
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

MJ Hanna & Sons Pty Limited v Woodyard is a case that involves an appeal by the appellant, MJ Hanna & Sons Pty Limited, against a decision made by a Workers Compensation Commission Arbitrator in favour of the respondent, Walter Woodyard. The primary issue in this case is the calculation of the weekly compensation amount payable to Mr Woodyard under section 40 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The appeal was allowed and the decision of the Arbitrator was revoked. The matter was remitted to another Arbitrator for determination afresh.

The Arbitrator's decision was challenged on several grounds, including the calculation of comparable earnings, the acceptance of evidence not admitted in the proceedings, and the finding that there was no allegation of any intervening stress factor in the applicant's life. The Acting Deputy President found that the Arbitrator erred in the application of section 40 of the 1987 Act in two respects: firstly, by incorrectly calculating comparable earnings and secondly, by failing to provide adequate reasons or properly identify factors taken into account in the exercise of his discretion. The Arbitrator further erred in his apparent reliance upon "evidence" not admitted in the proceedings, and his finding that "...there is no allegation of any intervening stress factor in the Applicant's life" in concluding that "...the effects of the physical injury are a substantial contributing cause of his continuing depression..." was against the weight of the evidence.

The Acting Deputy President concluded that the appeal is allowed and the Arbitrator's decision was revoked. The matter was remitted to another Arbitrator for determination afresh in accordance with the reasons provided. No order was made as to the costs of the appeal, and the costs of the proceedings before the Arbitrator on 17 October 2006 should follow the event when the matter is determined.

Background

Background to the litigation

Walter Woodyard commenced part-time employment with MJ Hanna & Sons Pty Limited on 5 March 1999, working 26.5 hours per week. On 30 August 1999, he slipped and fell while walking up stairs at work, sustaining a back injury. He reported the injury on 31 August 1999 and submitted a Workers Compensation Claim Form on 21 September 1999. MJ Hanna & Sons Pty Limited accepted the claim and began making weekly compensation payments. However, on 6 April 2000, the insurer, CGU Workers Compensation (NSW) Limited, denied liability for the claim from that date. An Application to Resolve a Dispute was registered on 6 July 2006, seeking weekly benefits compensation from 20 April 2000 onwards and the payment of medical expenses. The principal issue in dispute was the incapacity of Mr Woodyard due to the injury and associated conditions.

MJ Hanna & Sons Pty Limited sought leave to appeal a decision of a Commission Arbitrator, dated 16 April 2007, which found in favour of Mr Woodyard and awarded compensation. The appeal was heard by Acting Deputy President Deborah Moore on the papers. The appeal was allowed, and the Arbitrator's decision was revoked and the matter was remitted to another Arbitrator for a fresh determination.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Arbitrator err in the application of section 40(2)(a) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 by incorrectly calculating comparable earnings?
2. Did the Arbitrator err in adopting evidence not before him in these proceedings?
3. Did the Arbitrator err in finding that there was no allegation of any intervening stress factor in the Applicant’s life?
4. Did the Arbitrator err in the application of section 40(1) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 discretion?
5. Did the Arbitrator err in his acceptance of the worker’s psychiatric/psychological condition throughout the period claimed?

Held
1. The appeal is allowed. The decision of the Arbitrator dated 16 April 2007 is revoked and the matter is remitted to another Arbitrator for determination afresh in accordance with these reasons.
2. The Arbitrator erred in the application of section 40(2)(a) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 by incorrectly calculating comparable earnings.
3. The Arbitrator erred in adopting evidence not before him in these proceedings.
4. The Arbitrator erred in finding that there was no allegation of any intervening stress factor in the Applicant’s life.
5. The Arbitrator erred in the application of section 40(1) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 discretion by failing to provide adequate reasons or properly identify factors taken into account in the exercise of his discretion.
6. The Arbitrator erred in his acceptance of the worker’s psychiatric/psychological condition throughout the period claimed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal against the decision of the Arbitrator was allowed by Acting Deputy President Deborah Moore. The Arbitrator's decision dated 16 April 2007 was revoked and the matter was remitted to another Arbitrator for determination afresh. The appeal was allowed on four grounds: the Arbitrator's incorrect calculation of comparable earnings under section 40(2)(a) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, the reliance on inadmissible evidence, the finding that there was no allegation of any intervening stress factor in the Applicant's life, and the inadequate exercise of discretion under section 40(1) of the Act. Additionally, the Arbitrator's acceptance of the worker's psychiatric/psychological condition throughout the period claimed was found to be erroneous.

In calculating comparable earnings, the Arbitrator incorrectly assessed the Applicant's earning capacity based on a full-time position instead of the part-time basis of his employment at the time of injury. The evidence clearly indicated that the Applicant was working part-time and had no intention of transitioning to full-time work. The Arbitrator's conclusion was unsupported by the evidence and was considered an error of law.

The Arbitrator also erred by relying on evidence not before him in the proceedings. The Appellant argued that the Arbitrator accepted information from experts in other cases and from evidence heard in other contexts. The Appellant further submitted that the Arbitrator's acceptance of the worker's assertion that he had recovered from the effect of his marital breakdown was against the weight of medical evidence.

Moreover, the Arbitrator's finding that there was no allegation of any intervening stress factor in the Applicant's life was against the weight of the evidence. The Appellant submitted that there was a plethora of material demonstrating other stressors that continued to impact the Applicant's psychiatric state, such as marital difficulties, limited access to children, restricted income, and multiple health issues unrelated to the injury.

Lastly, the Arbitrator failed to provide adequate reasons or properly identify factors taken into account in the exercise of his discretion under section 40(1) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987. The Appellant submitted that the Arbitrator should have considered factors such as the Applicant's obesity, diabetes, cardiovascular problems, and other illnesses unrelated to the injury. The Arbitrator's reasons were insufficient to determine the essential grounds upon which his decision was based.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that an Arbitrator must correctly apply the relevant statutory provisions, rely only on admissible evidence, and provide adequate reasons for their decisions. In this case, the Arbitrator failed to do so in multiple respects, leading to the revocation of his decision and the remission of the matter for a fresh determination.