Mitchell v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Mitchell v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2025] NSWPIC 378
CLAIMANT: Robert Maxwell Mitchell
INSURER: Allianz Australia Insurance Limited
MEMBER: Gary Patterson
DATE OF DECISION: 6 August 2025

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; claim for statutory benefits; insurer denied ongoing benefits on the basis the claimant wholly or mostly at fault; claimant riding a bicycle when struck by the insured vehicle whilst claimant crossing road at marked crossing for cyclists; nothing the insured driver could reasonably have done in the agony of the moment to prevent the collision; AAI Limited t/as GIO v Evic cited regarding approach to fault disputes in statutory benefits; Stuart v Walsh cited regarding response to emergency situation created by the claimant; insurer discharged its onus in proving that the claimant was wholly at fault for the subject accident; Held – for the purposes of sections 3.11 and 3.28 the motor accident the subject of these proceedings was caused wholly by the fault of the claimant.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

MISCELLANEOUS CLAIMS ASSESSMENT CERTIFICATE

issued in accordance with section 7.36 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 and clause 7.36 of the Motor Accident Guidelines

Determination of a matter declared under Scheule 3, clauses (d) and (e) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 to be a miscellaneous claims assessment matter

In accordance with Division 6 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act) , the Personal Injury Commission’s assessment is:

For the purposes of section 3.11 of the MAI Act, the motor accident the subject of these proceedings was caused wholly or mostly by the fault of the claimant.1.     

For the purposes of section 3.28 of the MAI Act, the motor accident the subject of these proceedings was caused wholly or mostly by the fault of the claimant.2.     

As the claimant was self-represented, there is no order as to costs.3.     

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. The claimant is an 80-year-old male who suffered injuries on 18 September 2024 when his bicycle was struck by the insured vehicle on Lyons Road West in Concord at the location of a marked bicycle crossing just as the road curves to become Crane Street.

  2. On 30 January 2025, the insurer issued a liability notice denying the liability for benefits after 52 weeks. The claimant sought internal review of the decision which was affirmed. The insurer alleges that the claimant was wholly or mostly at fault for the subject accident.

  3. The claimant says that he sustained the following injuries in the motor accident:

    ·        Fractured pelvis

    ·        Shattered right ankle

    ·        Broken femur leading to a hip replacement

    The claimant was hospitalised and in rehabilitation for about three weeks after the accident. He says that, fortunately, he has made a good recovery from his injuries, with some residual hip problems.

  4. The claimant is a retired gentleman who was not working at the time of the accident. He was a keen bicyclist and was a member of a social bicycling club. He has…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mitchell v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPIC 378
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Mitchell v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited involved a dispute over a claim for statutory benefits under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. Mr Mitchell, a cyclist, claimed benefits after being struck by an insured vehicle while crossing a road at a designated cycle crossing. The insurer, Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, denied the claim, arguing that Mr Mitchell was wholly at fault for the accident. The matter was brought before the court to determine the fault of the parties and the entitlement to statutory benefits.

The central legal issue was whether Mr Mitchell was wholly or mostly at fault for the accident, which would disqualify him from receiving statutory benefits under the Act. The court needed to consider the evidence provided by both parties, including statements from the police, the insured driver, and Mr Mitchell himself, as well as the internal review conducted by Allianz. The court also had to assess the reliability and weight of this evidence, particularly in light of Allianz's argument that the driver could not have reasonably prevented the collision.

The court found that Allianz had discharged its onus in proving that Mr Mitchell was wholly at fault for the accident. Despite Mr Mitchell's arguments about the reliability of the driver's account and the significance of road markings and signs, the court determined that nothing the driver could reasonably have done in the moment of the accident could have prevented the collision. The court's reasoning was influenced by previous cases such as AAI Limited t/as GIO v Evic and Stuart v Walsh, which addressed the approach to fault disputes in statutory benefits and responses to emergency situations. Ultimately, the court concluded that for the purposes of sections 3.11 and 3.28 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017, the accident was caused wholly by Mr Mitchell's fault.

As a result of the court's decision, Mr Mitchell's claim for statutory benefits was dismissed. Allianz Australia Insurance Limited was found to be not liable for the statutory benefits claimed by Mr Mitchell.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Mitchell wrote to the insurer on or about 22 February 2025 saying:“I note firstly that Police and Ambulance (whose statements have been quoted informing a conclusion regarding fault) did not witness the accident, and Police have not at any time sought my description of events, in spite of my request for them to do so. They are thus, essentially, unable to report anything other than the description given by the vehicle driver.The reliability of the driver’s explanation is questionable, given the following words from a text message he sent to me three days after the accident:“….. please be aware that in Australia, as a pedestrian, if you are at fault in an accident, you generally cannot claim against the driver’s CTP insurance for your injuries. Your own insurance would need to cover any person expenses and damage to my car.”This is clearly wrong, but appears to be a pre-empted attempt to implant the idea that I was wholly to blame.Importantly, I was not in the Lyons Road cycle lane as alleged by the internal reviewer, and I did not ride across the road. As I have done many times at this crossing, I did ride from the Southern Creek side cycle trail and across the footpath and gutter-crossing, but stopped at the edge of the marked westbound cycle lane in preparation for crossing the road.My implicit assumption was that any drivers would pay full attention to staying well within the marked traffic lane and avoiding drifting into the marked cycle lane (where I was hit and where I also landed after bouncing several times) near a sign-posted and arrow-marked crossing.Note particularly this photograph of the accident scene showing me (right side paralysed) laying in the cycle lane, and the vehicle still overlapping the cycle lane. The point of impact was near the island visible on the passenger side of the vehicle.Cyclists use cycle lanes on the reasonable assumption that drivers (who are not always visible to cyclists) will keep a look out for them and drive within the marked traffic lane. If a driver doesn’t do that, and makes contact with a cyclist as a result, then the driver must, logically, have contributed to any resulting accident.If cycle and vehicle lanes, sign posts and markers have no significance, why bother to create them?The accident in which I was injured could have been avoided if the driver had taken note of the crossing signs and arrow markers, and kept his vehicle well within the main traffic lane, thus avoiding contact with me and my bike, clearly visible to vehicular traffic for at least 100 meters before the point of impact.My “contribution” was to (reasonably) assume drivers would, indeed, keep a good look out, take note of warning signs, and would drive well within the main traffic lane.On this basis, the driver’s failure to avoid drifting into the cycle lane, in spite of full visibility and warning of “crossing ahead”, was a significant contribution to the accident.” On 20 February 2025, after receiving a request for an internal review, Allianz conducted its internal review about fault. The internal reviewer referred to the claimant’s statement, the statement of the insured driver and his Police interview and then said:· “Having considered the totality of the evidence, I am of the view that the most probable and logical circumstances of the accident are as follows:­You were riding on the cycle lane along Lyons Road West and proceeded to attempt to cross the road to continue on your cycle. When you proceeded to enter the roadway, the front of your bike collided with the front passenger side of the insured vehicle.· I have considered your actions, and I am of the view that you have failed to exercise reasonable care and caution when entering the roadway.· The Police confirmed that you did not have right of way ….. In particular, Police outlined it was a pedestrian island and not a marked pedestrian crossing.· The Police have held you at fault for not looking. No further action such as impingement notice was issued due to your injuries;· I am of the view that a reasonable person in the same situation would have stopped and checked for vehicles on the road, particularly, when proceeding to cross at a pedestrian island. I am therefore of the view you have failed to take sufficient care in crossing the roadway and have not entered when it was safe to do so.· As a result, I am satisfied that you were wholly at fault for the subject accident.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.