Mitchell, Allan v The Queen; Mitchell, Paul v The Queen; Mitchell, Michael v The Queen

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

Court of Criminal Appeal

New South Wales

Case Title: Mitchell, Allan v R; Mitchell, Paul v R; Mitchell, Michael v R
Medium Neutral Citation: [2014] NSWCCA 212
Hearing Date(s): 30 July 2014
Decision Date: 03 October 2014
Before: Bathurst CJ at [1];
Adams J at [2];
R A Hulme J at [3]
Decision:

Michael Mitchell
1. Leave to appeal against sentence granted.
2. Appeal against sentence allowed.
3. Sentences imposed in the District Court on 8 August 2013 quashed. In lieu, Michael Robert Mitchell is sentenced as follows:
Larceny at Adaminaby (Sequence 4): sentenced to a fixed term of imprisonment for 5 months commencing 12 January 2013.
Aggravated break, enter and steal at Adaminaby (Sequence 3): sentenced to imprisonment comprising a non-parole period of 1 year 11 months commencing 12 May 2013 and a balance of the term of the sentence of 8 months expiring 11 December 2015.
Aggravated break, enter and steal at Cabramurra (Sequence 1): sentenced to imprisonment comprising a non-parole period of 1 year 7 months commencing 12 September 2013 and a balance of the term of the sentence of 1 year 5 months expiring 11 September 2016.
The offender is to be released on parole when the final non-parole period expires on 11 April 2015.

Paul Mitchell
1. Leave to appeal against sentence granted.
2. Appeal against sentence allowed.
3. Sentences imposed in the District Court on 8 August 2013 quashed. In lieu, Paul Christopher Mitchell is sentenced as follows:
Break, enter and steal at Tumut (Sequence 4): sentenced to a fixed term of imprisonment for 2 years commencing 12 January 2013.
Larceny at Adaminaby (Sequence 5): sentenced to a fixed term of imprisonment for 5 months commencing 12 May 2013.
Aggravated break, enter and steal at Adaminaby (Sequence 3): sentenced to imprisonment comprising a non-parole period of 1 year 10 months commencing 12 September 2013 and a balance of the term of the sentence of 9 months expiring on 11 April 2016.
Aggravated break, enter and steal at Cabramurra (Sequence 1): sentenced to imprisonment comprising a non-parole period 1 year 6 months commencing 12 January 2014 and a balance of the term of the sentence of 1 year 6 months expiring on 11 January 2017.
The offender is to be released on parole when the final non-parole period expires on 11 July 2015.

Allan Mitchell
1. Leave to appeal against sentence granted.
2. Appeal against sentence allowed.
3. Sentences imposed in the District Court on 8 August 2013 quashed. In lieu, Allan James Mitchell is sentenced as follows:
Larceny at Adaminaby (Sequence 4): sentenced to a fixed term of imprisonment for 6 months commencing 12 March 2013.
Aggravated break, enter and steal at Adaminaby (Sequence 3): sentenced to imprisonment comprising a non-parole period of 2 years 3 months commencing 12 August 2013 and a balance of the term of the sentence of 9 months expiring 11 August 2016.
Aggravated break, enter and steal at Cabramurra (Sequence 1): sentenced to imprisonment comprising a non-parole period of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mitchell, Allan v The Queen; Mitchell, Paul v The Queen; Mit... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NSWCCA 212
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellants, Allan, Paul, and Michael Mitchell, appealed against their sentences imposed by the Supreme Court of Victoria following their convictions for multiple offences. The appeal primarily focused on the sentencing of the appellants for aggravated break and enter offences. The appellants argued that the sentences imposed were manifestly excessive, particularly in light of the fact that the offences involved commercial premises rather than private residential homes, and the stolen property was unlikely to have had sentimental value. Additionally, the appellants contended that the trial judge erred in considering their criminal record as an aggravating circumstance and that the Crown's concession regarding a reduction in earlier, related sentences warranted intervention.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the sentences imposed were manifestly excessive and whether the trial judge erred in considering the appellants' criminal record as an aggravating circumstance. The court was also required to consider whether the Crown's concession regarding a reduction in earlier, related sentences warranted intervention and whether the sentences imposed were excessive in light of the nature of the offences and the appellants' criminal records.

The court held that the principal consideration in determining the degree of accumulation of sentences is not the concurrence of offences, but rather the degree of accumulation. The court found that no lesser degree of accumulation was warranted in this case. The court also held that there was no error in referring to the appellants' criminal record as an aggravating circumstance. Furthermore, the court found that the sentences for the aggravated break and enter offences were manifestly excessive. The objective seriousness of the offences was lower than found by the trial judge, and the serious indictable offence and circumstance of aggravation were both of limited seriousness. Consequently, the court quashed the sentences and ordered the offenders to be resentenced.

The court quashed the sentences imposed on the appellants for the aggravated break and enter offences and ordered that they be resentenced. The court also clarified that the degree of accumulation of sentences is determined by the degree of accumulation, not concurrence, and that there was no error in considering the appellants' criminal record as an aggravating circumstance.