Miroslawski v Housing Choices SA

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal to a Single Judge)

MIROSLAWSKI v HOUSING CHOICES SA

[2023] SASC 162

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Kimber  

17 November 2023

LANDLORD AND TENANT - RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES LEGISLATION - OBLIGATIONS, PROHIBITED MATTERS AND PROTECTION FOR LESSEES - INSPECTION AND REPAIR

LANDLORD AND TENANT - RESIDENTIAL TENANCIES LEGISLATION - RECOVERY OF POSSESSION - GENERALLY

The applicant resides at a property with respect to which the respondent is the landlord.  The applicant has been a tenant at that property since October 2016. 

On 10 March 2023, the applicant was served with a notice of breach which referenced a failure to remove hard refuse and other rubbish including food scraps from inside the property.  The respondent sought vacant possession.  On 8 May 2023, the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal made an order for possession in favour of the respondent.  On 7 July 2023, that decision was upheld on review by a Senior Member of the Tribunal.  It is that decision from which the applicant seeks permission to appeal. 

The applicant seeks permission to appeal on grounds that the decision of the Senior Member was infected by error and was not the correct and preferable decision. 

Held:

1.The Senior Member did not fail to take into account any relevant consideration nor did he take into account any irrelevant consideration. 

2.It is not reasonably arguable that the decision of the Senior Member was not the correct and preferable decision. 

3.      The application for permission to appeal is dismissed. 

South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) ss 39, 70, 71; Residential Tenancies Act 1995 (SA) ss 93, 110, referred to.
Jackson v Lepp Investments Pty Ltd (2016) 125 SASR 1; Pix v South Australia Housing Trust (2016) 125 SASR 10; Upton & Anor v Fynes [2021] SACAT 84, applied.

MIROSLAWSKI v HOUSING CHOICES SA

[2023] SASC 162

Civil: Single Judge Appeal

KIMBER J:

Introduction

  1. This is an application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court pursuant to s 71(1) of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (SA) (the SACAT Act) against a decision of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (the Tribunal).  The Tribunal was constituted by a Senior Member (the Senior Member) and the decision being appealed will be referred to as the decision of the Senior Member. That decision was made on 7 July 2023. Pursuant to s 71(2) of the SACAT Act, the applicant requires permission to appeal.

  2. The decision of the Senior Member was a result of the applicant applying to the Tribunal under s 70 of the SACAT Act for an internal review of a decision made on 8 May 2023 by the Tribunal (the first decision).  The applicant is the tenant of a residential property at Windsor Gardens (the premises).  In the first decision, the Tribunal made an order for possession in favour of the landlord.  Having also found that an immediate order…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Miroslawski v Housing Choices SA and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 162
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Miroslawski v Housing Choices SA, the tenant, Miroslawski, appeals against a decision of the Senior Member of the South Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (SACAT) affirming an order for possession of the premises by the landlord, Housing Choices SA. The dispute concerns the condition of the rented property, which the landlord claims was not maintained in a clean and safe condition as required under the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 (SA). The tenant argues that the Tribunal erred in its assessment of the time needed for decluttering, the calculation of the compliance period, and in not considering the hardship caused by the order. The appeal also challenges the Senior Member's handling of the tenant's request regarding the involvement of support persons in the hearing.

The legal issues before the court include whether the Tribunal correctly assessed the tenant's ability to remedy the condition of the premises within the given timeframe, the accuracy of the compliance period provided, the impact of the order on the tenant's mental health and well-being, and the procedural fairness of the hearing. Additionally, the court considers the tenant's request that two support persons not participate in the hearing and whether the Senior Member's reliance on their input affected the outcome.

The court finds that the Tribunal's decision was not in error. The Senior Member appropriately considered the extent of the tenant's obligations under the RT Act and the evidence presented regarding the condition of the premises. The court holds that the Senior Member's assessment of the time required for decluttering and compliance was reasonable and that the order for possession was justified given the serious breach of tenancy terms. The court further determines that the Senior Member's decision to proceed with the hearing despite the tenant's request was procedurally fair, and the outcome was not influenced by the support persons' input. The court also notes that the Senior Member's handling of the risk of fire did not constitute an error. Therefore, the appeal is dismissed.

The final orders of the court are that the appeal is dismissed, the decision of the Senior Member is affirmed, and the order for possession remains in effect. The court directs the parties to comply with the existing timelines and conditions as previously determined by the Tribunal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The grounds of appeal are not the only matters which must be addressed. In the first set of written submissions on behalf of the applicant, what also may be treated as an additional ground of appeal complains about the approach taken by the Senior Member to the risk of fire presented by the condition of the premises. In addition, before the hearing of the appeal, an application to adjourn the appeal was refused. That issue is also addressed in this judgment. Background The matters below are not the subject of challenge. They are set out in the reasons of the Senior Member and within other uncontested material. The tenancy commenced on 22 October 2016 and is under the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 (SA) (the RT Act). The respondent in this application is the landlord. An obligation of the tenant is to ‘keep the premises and any surrounding area clean and in good tenantable condition, free from vermin and free from refuse’. On 10 March 2023, the applicant was served with a notice of breach and the landlord sought vacant possession. The breach specified within the notice was the ‘[F]ailure to remove hard refuse and other rubbish including food scraps from inside the property. Failure to comply with the tenant’s obligations by keeping the premises in a reasonably clean, tidy, safe and hygienic condition’. In the first decision on 8 May 2023, the Tribunal found it was appropriate to make an order for possession in favour of the landlord. The reasons for making that order were: 3.1.A valid notice of breach requiring the tenant to clean the property was served. 3.2.The landlord organised a couple of inspections and took photographs. Given the extent of possessions, accessibility issues, cleaning issues, and hygiene issues the landlord was concerned about health and safety, and that it was unlikely, even with supports, that the tenant could remedy what had been a long-standing situation. 3.3.The notice of breach coupled with the failure to remedy the breach meant that the tenancy has been terminated. The breach was in any event serious enough to justify vacant possession. The application for vacant possession the subject of the first decision was not the first such application with respect to the applicant and the premises. An earlier application had been made in 2020. With respect to that application, on 30 January 2020, the outcome was the tenant was permitted to return to the property on the condition that it be returned to a reasonable and clean condition with access to all doors and windows. Following those orders, the landlord was satisfied the tenant made an attempt to clean the property and did not return to the Tribunal until the application the subject of this appeal. In his decision on 7 July 2023, the Senior Member found that in 2020 the property had been in ‘appalling condition in terms of the amount of rubbish and belongings in the house’; that photos taken in May 2019, June 2019 and January 2020, showed the property in ‘a condition that can only be described as filthy, appalling and unhygienic, inside and out’ and which revealed there was potential for rodent and pest infestations and safety issues for both the tenant and visitors.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The decision of the Senior Member was a result of the applicant applying to the Tribunal under s 70 of the SACAT Act for an internal review of a decision made on 8 May 2023 by the Tribunal (the first decision). The applicant is the tenant of a residential property at Windsor Gardens (the premises). In the first decision, the Tribunal made an order for possession in favour of the landlord. Having also found that an immediate order for possession would give rise to hardship, the operation of that order was suspended until 22 June 2023. On 7 July 2023, the Senior Member affirmed the decision made on 8 May 2023 but stayed the order for possession until 15 September 2023 to enable the applicant to find alternative accommodation. This Court has subsequently extended that date on two occasions, most recently to 5pm on the day on which judgment is delivered. The applicant was unrepresented by counsel before me. However, Mr Tavitian had appeared for the applicant before the Senior Member and was granted permission to appear on behalf of the applicant in this Court. Mr Tavitian made submissions orally and in writing. There were three sets of submissions in writing, one provided before the hearing of the appeal and two after. I have had regard to all submissions. For the reasons which follow, I refuse permission to appeal. The grounds of appeal The amended notice of appeal sets out four grounds in the following terms: 1.The Order of the Tribunal has no provision to extend the time of compliance in the event suitable alternative accommodation is not found.2.There is a miscalculation by the Senior Member of the required time for decluttering of the premises.3.The Appellant's present anxiety, stress, insecurity could have been prevented by reinstatement of the tenancy.4.The Senior Presiding Member has been requested by the Appellant on the 30th June 2023, not to have any input in the hearing by two (2) Mr Miroslawski’s support persons and SACAT to inform them they were no 1onger required to participate in the matter. Had the Senior Presiding Member complied with the request the outcome could have been different, because he relied on their input. The grounds of appeal are not the only matters which must be addressed. In the first set of written submissions on behalf of the applicant, what also may be treated as an additional ground of appeal complains about the approach taken by the Senior Member to the risk of fire presented by the condition of the premises. In addition, before the hearing of the appeal, an application to adjourn the appeal was refused. That issue is also addressed in this judgment. Background The matters below are not the subject of challenge. They are set out in the reasons of the Senior Member and within other uncontested material. The tenancy commenced on 22 October 2016 and is under the Residential Tenancies Act 1995 (SA) (the RT Act). The respondent in this application is the landlord. An obligation of the tenant is to ‘keep the premises and any surrounding area clean and in good tenantable condition, free from vermin and free from refuse’.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.