Mirco Bros Pty Ltd v Palermo Nominees Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   MIRCO BROS PTY LTD -v- PALERMO NOMINEES PTY LTD [2002] WASC 145

CORAM:   MASTER SANDERSON

HEARD:   28 & 31 MAY 2002

DELIVERED          :   7 JUNE 2002

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1963 of 1999

BETWEEN:   MIRCO BROS PTY LTD (ACN 008 831 294)

Plaintiff

AND

PALERMO NOMINEES PTY LTD (ACN 008 871 618)
Defendant

Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Application for leave to amend statement of claim - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Leave refused

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff:     Mr D L Barker

Defendant:     Mr A Metaxas

Solicitors:

Plaintiff:     Mackinlays

Defendant:     Metaxas & Vernon

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Nil

Case(s) also cited:

BP Refinery v Shire of Hastings (1977) 16 ALR 363

Briggs v Curtis Quick & Associates [1999] WASCA 139

Dare v Pulham (1982) 148 CLR 658

Eade v Jacobs (1877) 3 EXD 335

Hawkins v Clayton (1988) 78 ALR 69

Murchison Zinc Co Pty Ltd v Thiess Contractors Pty Ltd [2000] WASCA 267

  1. MASTER SANDERSON:  This is the plaintiff's application for leave to amend the writ and statement of claim.  When the matter first came on for hearing the plaintiff sought leave to amend the statement of claim in terms of a minute of proposed amended statement of claim filed 16 May 2002.  During the course of the hearing I indicated that I would allow certain of the amendments and not others.  I then reserved my decision on whether or not to allow amendments to pars 10 and 39 of the minute.  In the context of the action as a whole these paragraphs were of particular significance.  Prior to the resumed hearing and without leave, the plaintiff filed a further minute of proposed amended statement of claim.  This further minute addressed a number of concerns with respect to par 10 and removed an allegation of fraud which had been pleaded in the earlier minute.  It nonetheless left live the issue between the parties as to whether pars 10 and 39 as they appeared in the later minute should be allowed.

  2. To understand the nature of the dispute between the parties it is necessary only to touch briefly on the facts.  At all material times the plaintiff and the defendant were partners in running the Rockingham Beach Resort Hotel.  By agreement the defendant was charged with running the day to day affairs of the business on behalf of the partnership.  It is pleaded by the plaintiff that the partners orally agreed that the defendant would manage the hotel and that "it would be paid out of profits a fee of $70,000 per annum" for doing so:  see par 5.4.  This agreement is referred to in the pleadings as "the Management provisions".  The proposed par 10 is then in the following form.  (I have omitted the marking up in the minute as it is not relevant to this dispute): 

    "10.It was implied in the management provisions that:

    10.1The defendant would exercise reasonable care and skill in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mirco Bros Pty Ltd v Palermo Nominees Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] WASC 145
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the plaintiff, Mirco Bros Pty Ltd, sought leave from the Supreme Court of Western Australia to amend its statement of claim against the defendant, Palermo Nominees Pty Ltd. The primary issue before the court was whether the plaintiff should be granted permission to amend the statement of claim to include specific terms that were implied in their partnership agreement. The amendment, if allowed, would significantly impact the length and complexity of the trial, potentially extending it from two days to ten days.

The court examined the proposed amendments, particularly clauses 10 and 39, which dealt with the implied terms of the management agreement and the alleged breaches of these terms. Clause 10 outlined several implied duties of the defendant, including maintaining the premises in good condition, while clause 39 detailed specific instances of alleged non-compliance, such as faulty acoustics in the nightclub. The defendant objected to these amendments, arguing that some terms could not be implied into the agreement and that the evidence required to support the claims would vastly extend the trial duration.

The court found that while some of the proposed amendments were arguable and could stand, clause 39(h) regarding faulty acoustics was not covered by the implied term of maintaining the premises. The court concluded that the requirement to improve acoustics went beyond routine maintenance and introduced a new, positive duty. Given the significant impact on the trial duration and the potential for confusion and delay, the court decided to refuse leave to amend clause 39. However, the court acknowledged the importance of the matter to the plaintiff and was willing to hear further submissions on the form of orders and costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between Mirco Bros Pty Ltd and Palermo Nominees Pty Ltd, partners in the operation of the Rockingham Beach Resort Hotel. The plaintiff, Mirco Bros, alleges that the defendant, Palermo Nominees, was responsible for managing the hotel's day-to-day operations under an oral agreement, receiving an annual management fee of $70,000 from the hotel's profits. The plaintiff further alleges that the defendant breached this management agreement by failing to maintain the hotel's buildings, fixtures, and fittings to an attractive standard for patrons, and specifically by not addressing faulty acoustics in the nightclub, which allegedly resulted in significant financial losses for the plaintiff.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of Western Australia in chambers for a hearing on an application for leave to amend the statement of claim. Initially, the plaintiff sought permission to amend the statement of claim on 16 May 2002. The Master reserved decision on certain amendments, particularly those related to paragraphs 10 and 39 of the proposed amended statement of claim. Despite the reservation, the plaintiff proceeded to file a further minute of proposed amended statement of claim without leave. The Master subsequently heard arguments on the application and reserved decision, indicating a willingness to allow the plaintiff to reformulate its claim while considering the impact on the trial's length and consistency with earlier pleadings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to leave to amend the statement of claim to include an implied term that the defendant would exercise reasonable care and skill in the management of the business, including causing repairs to be carried out in a timely manner to the buildings, fixtures, and fittings.
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to leave to amend the statement of claim to include a breach of the implied term by the defendant failing to maintain the attractiveness of the business to its patrons, specifically addressing faulty acoustics in the nightclub.
3. The impact of the proposed amendments on the length of the trial and the consistency of the amended claim with earlier pleadings.

Held
1. The court refused the plaintiff leave to amend the statement of claim to include an implied term that the defendant would exercise reasonable care and skill in the management of the business, including causing repairs to be carried out in a timely manner to the buildings, fixtures, and fittings.
2. The court refused the plaintiff leave to amend the statement of claim to include a breach of the implied term by the defendant failing to maintain the attractiveness of the business to its patrons, specifically addressing faulty acoustics in the nightclub.
3. The court considered the impact of the proposed amendments on the length of the trial and the consistency of the amended claim with earlier pleadings in its decision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In addressing the plaintiff's application for leave to amend the statement of claim, the court considered the implications of the proposed changes to the claim on the overall proceedings. Regarding the proposed amendment to include an implied term that the defendant would exercise reasonable care and skill in the management of the business, including timely repairs, the court found it arguable that such a term could be implied into the management provisions. However, the court noted that the determination of what, if any, agreement was reached between the parties would require evidence of the surrounding circumstances. The court allowed the plaintiff the opportunity to reformulate this claim, indicating a willingness to reconsider the matter with a more carefully framed amendment.

On the issue of whether the plaintiff could amend the statement of claim to include a breach of the implied term concerning the maintenance of the attractiveness of the business to its patrons, specifically addressing faulty acoustics in the nightclub, the court found that the requirement to rectify faulty acoustics went beyond routine maintenance and required a positive duty to enhance the amenity of the hotel. The court held that such a requirement was not covered by the implied term of the agreement and thus refused the plaintiff leave to amend the statement of claim in this regard. The court highlighted the potential significant impact on the length of the trial if this aspect of the claim proceeded, noting that the proposed amendments would add considerable complexity and duration to the proceedings.

The court emphasised the need for any amendment to be consistent with earlier pleadings and framed with care, considering the extensive nature of the losses claimed and the potential for increased hearing time. Ultimately, the court refused the plaintiff leave to amend the statement of claim to include the proposed changes, while allowing the plaintiff the opportunity to reformulate its claims in a manner that would address these concerns more effectively.