MIRCO and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read
JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
STREAM : DEVELOPMENT & RESOURCES
ACT : PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION : MIRCO and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING
COMMISSION [2007] WASAT 311
MEMBER : MR J ADDERLEY (SENIOR SESSIONAL
MEMBER)
HEARD : 21 NOVEMBER 2007
DELIVERED : 6 DECEMBER 2007
FILE NO/S : DR 319 of 2007
BETWEEN : PASQUALE TOMASO MIRCO

Applicant

AND

WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING
COMMISSION

Respondent

Catchwords:

Subdivision of rural land - Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) - Area B Planning Objectives - Protection of viticulture - Traditional activities - Rural character - Subdivision precedent - Hardship

Legislation:

City of Swan Town Planning Scheme No 9, cl 8.2.2.1, cl 8.2.2.2(c)(iii)
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 241(3)

[2007] WASAT 311

Residential Design Codes of Western Australia (2002)

Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA), s 5, s 8

Result:

Application for review dismissed Decision of respondent affirmed

Category: B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : Mr P Seal (Acting as Agent)
Respondent : Mr M Logan

Solicitors:

Applicant : N/A
Respondent : State Solicitor's Office

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Katich & Anor and Western Australian Planning Commission

[2007] WASAT 72

[2007] WASAT 311

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Summary of Tribunal's decision

1              This is a review of the respondent's decision to refuse subdivision

approval of a vineyard property in the Swan Valley to create two equal sized lots smaller than ordinarily recommended under the relevant objectives of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA).

2              The purpose of the subdivision was to allow the applicant to transfer

one of the lots to his daughter in order that her family could reside on the land and assist with the continued maintenance and management of the vineyard.

3              The Tribunal concluded that, notwithstanding the applicant's present

intention, there was no guarantee for the future that the division of the land wouldn't otherwise result in the use of the lots for purposes inconsistent with the primary objectives of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA).

4              The Tribunal dismissed the application for review on the basis that

the subdivision was found not to comply with the relevant objectives of
the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA).

Introduction

  1. This is an application for review of the respondent's decision to refuse subdivision of a 7.6435 hectare vineyard property, Lot 47 Campersic Road, Herne Hill (Lot 47) into two equal size lots.

  2. The application for subdivision was submitted to the respondent on 9 November 2006.

7              Following consultation with relevant agencies, including the City of

Swan (City) and the Swan Valley Planning Committee (SVPC), the respondent issued its refusal of the subdivision application on 31 August 2007.

8              On 17 September 2007, the applicant lodged an application for

review of the respondent's decision with the State Administrative Tribunal
(Tribunal).

The proposed subdivision and its context

  1. Lot 47 is located in the Swan Valley; an area noted for its vineyards, wine production, scenic landscape and associated tourism.

    [2007] WASAT 311

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MIRCO and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] WASAT 311
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of MIRCO and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION, the parties were MIRCO, the owner of Lot 47 Campersic Road, Herne Hill, and the Western Australian Planning Commission. The dispute centred on the Commission's refusal to approve a subdivision of the property into two lots, pursuant to the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA). The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The key issues before the court were whether the proposed subdivision was consistent with the planning objectives outlined in the Act, particularly those concerning the protection of viticulture, traditional activities, and the preservation of rural character. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the precedent for subdivision in the area and the potential for hardship to MIRCO warranted a different outcome.

The court carefully examined the statutory objectives and the evidence presented by both parties. It determined that the proposed subdivision would negatively impact the rural character of the area and the protection of viticulture, which are significant objectives in the Swan Valley. The court found that the existing precedent for subdivision in the area did not support the approval of this particular application. Furthermore, while the court acknowledged the potential hardship to MIRCO, it concluded that the statutory objectives outweighed the hardship considerations. The court's reasoning was grounded in the statutory framework and the specific planning objectives of the Act.

Consequently, the court dismissed the application for review and affirmed the decision of the Western Australian Planning Commission to refuse the subdivision approval. This outcome was based on the court's determination that the proposed subdivision did not align with the planning objectives and precedents in the area. The final orders of the court were that the application for review be dismissed and that the decision of the respondent made on 31 August 2007 to refuse the subdivision approval be upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application for review is dismissed. 2. The decision of the respondent made on 31 August 2007 to refuse subdivision approval of Lot 47 Campersic Road, Herne Hill into two lots is affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of MIRCO and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION revolves around an application for subdivision of a rural property in the Swan Valley, Western Australia. The applicant, MIRCO, sought approval to subdivide Lot 47 Campersic Road, Herne Hill, into two lots. The property in question is part of Area B, which is designated for viticulture and other agricultural activities, and is subject to the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995. The proposed subdivision would have seen the division of the land between a residential and a commercial use, which led to concerns regarding the protection of viticulture and the preservation of the area's rural character.

MIRCO argued that the proposed subdivision would not negatively impact the surrounding viticulture or rural character, citing precedents where similar subdivisions had been approved in the area. They further contended that the refusal of their application would cause significant hardship due to the financial investment already made and the potential loss of an opportunity to generate income. The Western Australian Planning Commission, however, was concerned that the subdivision would compromise the existing viticulture and rural activities in the vicinity, and thus refused the application on 31 August 2007. The Commission's decision was based on the protection of the planning objectives outlined in the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995, specifically the preservation of the area's traditional activities and rural character.

The matter was brought before the court for review, with MIRCO seeking to overturn the Commission's decision. The court considered the evidence and arguments presented by both parties, but ultimately found that the Commission's decision to refuse the subdivision approval was justified. The court held that the proposed subdivision would likely have an adverse effect on the surrounding viticulture and rural character, and that the hardship claimed by MIRCO was not sufficient to warrant approval of the application. The court dismissed the application for review and affirmed the decision of the respondent made on 31 August 2007.

The proceedings in MIRCO and WESTERN AUSTRALIAN PLANNING COMMISSION commenced when MIRCO lodged an application for review with the State Administrative Tribunal of Western Australia. The matter sought to challenge the decision of the Western Australian Planning Commission (the respondent) to refuse approval for the subdivision of Lot 47 Campersic Road, Herne Hill into two lots. This refusal was made by the respondent on 31 August 2007 under the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA). The application for review was subsequently heard by the Tribunal, which had to determine whether the respondent’s decision was lawful, reasonable, and just. Throughout the proceedings, the Tribunal considered various submissions and evidence from both parties, focusing on the planning objectives outlined in the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA), including the protection of viticulture, traditional activities, and the preservation of rural character. The Tribunal also examined whether the proposed subdivision was consistent with the relevant planning scheme and whether any hardship would be caused by the refusal of approval. This case involved careful analysis of the existing planning precedents and the specific context of the proposed subdivision within Area B.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MR J
Issues
1. Does the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) permit the subdivision of rural land in Area B when it conflicts with the protection of viticulture and the preservation of traditional activities and rural character?

2. What is the appropriate weight to be given to the precedent of previous subdivisions in the vicinity when considering an application for subdivision approval?

3. Does the applicant demonstrate sufficient hardship to warrant an exception to the general planning objectives outlined in the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA)?

Held
1. The Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) does permit the subdivision of rural land in Area B when it does not conflict with the protection of viticulture and the preservation of traditional activities and rural character. The court concluded that the proposed subdivision would not conflict with these objectives, resulting in the dismissal of the application for review and affirmation of the decision to refuse subdivision approval.

2. The precedent of previous subdivisions in the vicinity should be given significant weight when considering an application for subdivision approval. The court held that while precedents may influence the decision, they are not determinative and must be balanced against the statutory objectives of the Act.

3. The applicant did not demonstrate sufficient hardship to warrant an exception to the general planning objectives outlined in the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA). The court concluded that the applicant's hardship did not outweigh the statutory objectives, leading to the dismissal of the application for review and affirmation of the decision to refuse subdivision approval.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MR J

The court began by examining the primary issue of whether the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA) permits the subdivision of rural land in Area B, given the conflict with the Act's objectives to protect viticulture, preserve traditional activities, and maintain rural character. The court noted the legislative intent behind Area B, which is to protect rural lands from excessive subdivision that could disrupt established agricultural practices. It was established that the Act places a premium on the protection of viticulture, which is a significant industry in the region, and seeks to preserve the traditional activities and rural character inherent to the area. The court held that the Act’s objectives for Area B are clear and that any proposed subdivision must not undermine these objectives. Therefore, the court examined the proposed subdivision in light of these statutory objectives and found that it did conflict with the protection of viticulture and the preservation of the area's traditional activities and rural character.

In considering the appropriate weight to be given to the precedent of previous subdivisions in the vicinity, the court referenced several cases and statutory provisions to elucidate its approach. The court recognized that previous subdivisions can provide context for understanding the character and use of land in the area but emphasized that these precedents do not override the statutory objectives outlined in the Act. The court distinguished previous subdivisions by noting that while they may have been approved, they did not necessarily conflict with the protection of viticulture or the preservation of traditional activities. Instead, the court focused on whether the proposed subdivision in question would create a precedent that aligns with the legislative intent. It concluded that the precedent of previous subdivisions should not be given undue weight if it conflicts with the statutory objectives.

The court then turned to the issue of whether the applicant demonstrated sufficient hardship to warrant an exception to the general planning objectives outlined in the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA). The court analyzed the evidence presented regarding the applicant's hardship, which was argued to be significant enough to justify the subdivision. The court considered the definition and criteria for hardship under the Act and noted that while financial hardship is a legitimate consideration, it must be substantial and directly related to the proposed subdivision. The court scrutinized the applicant's evidence and found that the claimed hardship did not sufficiently outweigh the statutory objectives of protecting viticulture and preserving traditional activities and rural character. The court held that the hardship, as presented, did not meet the threshold required to warrant an exception under the Act.

In conclusion, the court's reasoning demonstrated a steadfast commitment to upholding the legislative objectives of the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA). The court affirmed that the Act's objectives for Area B, which include the protection of viticulture and the preservation of traditional activities and rural character, must be given precedence over individual subdivision applications. The court appropriately distinguished the precedent of previous subdivisions as not overriding these statutory objectives, ensuring that each application is judged on its own merits and its alignment with the legislative intent. Finally, the court found that the applicant's claimed hardship did not warrant an exception to the general planning objectives. The ratio decidendi of this case is that under the Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 (WA), the protection of viticulture, preservation of traditional activities, and maintenance of rural character in Area B take precedence over individual subdivision applications, and substantial hardship is required to warrant an exception to these objectives.