Minister for Territory Health Services v CC and KK

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read
CITATION: Minister for Territory Health Services v CC & KK [2004] NTMC 028

PARTIES: MINISTER FOR TERRITORY HEALTH SERVICES

v

CC

AND

KK

TITLE OF COURT: Family Matters Court

JURISDICTION: Family Matters Court – Alice Springs

FILE NO(s): 9725549

DELIVERED ON: 3 February 2004

DELIVERED AT: Alice Springs

HEARING DATE(s): 14/15 May, 24/25/26/27 June 2003

JUDGMENT OF: JWA Birch

CATCHWORDS:

Family matters; care application; application to vary order.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
Applicant: A Young
First Respondent: R Goldflam
Second Respondent: A Whitelum

Solicitors:
Applicant: Heitmann
First Respondent: NTLAC
Second Respondent: Morgan Buckley

Judgment category classification:
Judgment ID number: 028
Number of paragraphs: 101


IN THE FAMILY MATTERS COURT
AT ALICE SPRINGS IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 9725549

BETWEEN:

MINISTER FOR TERRITORY HEALTH SERVICES
Applicant

AND:

CC
First Respondent

And

KK
Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 3 February 2004)

Mr JWA BIRCH SM:

Introduction
1. This matter is a hearing of two proceedings arising under the Community Welfare Act. (The Act). Firstly, the review of an order made on the 29th of May 2002 pursuant to s.49 of the Act. Secondly, an application by the Minister for Family and Children’s Services for a variation of the order made on the 29th of May 2002 pursuant to s.48 (1) of the Act.
2. Section 49 of the Act provides “that the Court shall review the circumstances of a child in relation to whom an order under s.43 (4) is made containing a direction referred to in s.43 (5) (d) –
(a) where the sole rights in relation to the custody of the child are vested in the Minister – at intervals not exceeding 2 years.”
3. Section 48 of the Act provides for the application for variation of an order as follows:
“ (1) The Minister or the parents, or the persons who were, immediately before the order, the guardians or persons having the custody of a child, or any other person who has an interest in the welfare of, or acting on behalf of and at the requested of, the child in relation to whom the application under this Part was made, may apply to the Court for the variation as further variation of an order made under s.43.
(3) On an application under subsection (1), the Court may vary or revoke the order, or make any other order it could have made under s.43 on the original application.”
4. These proceedings involve the care of KK who was born in Alice Springs on the 11th of November 1997. She is now 6 years old and is currently in foster care and has been so, on and off, since her birth. Throughout the proceedings the child’s mother, CC, has been present with her legal representative. K’s father, AK, is an Aboriginal man who was not present or represented during these proceedings. He has taken little or no interest in the entire Court proceedings involving his daughter since her birth. Although from time to time he did have some contact…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Territory Health Services v CC and KK and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NTMC 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Minister for Territory Health Services v CC and KK, the Family Matters Court in Alice Springs dealt with two proceedings arising under the Community Welfare Act. The first was a review of an order made on 29 May 2002 pursuant to s.49 of the Act, and the second was an application by the Minister for Family and Children’s Services for a variation of the same order pursuant to s.48 (1) of the Act. The case involved the care of KK, a six-year-old child who had been in foster care since her birth and was currently under the sole guardianship of the Minister. The mother, CC, sought an increase in access to her daughter, while the Minister argued for continued supervised access and sole guardianship.

The court considered the history of the case, the evidence presented by both parties, and the submissions made by counsel. The court found that KK was indeed a child in need of care, and that the circumstances had not changed significantly since the previous finding. However, the court dismissed the application for variation, noting that other options were available and that the proceedings had been subsumed in the review. The court made no orders on the application for variation and dismissed it.

In the review, the court considered the evidence and submissions of the parties and found that KK had suffered serious emotional impairment and that to leave her in her previous surroundings would expose her to continued substantial risk of further emotional impairment. The court concluded that sole guardianship was the only order that would adequately provide for the welfare of KK and made orders for sole guardianship to be with the Minister for a period of 2 years, with a graded increase in supervised access for the mother. The court also made provisions for a review of the orders in 2 years and for the mother to complete a parenting course and continue counselling. The court emphasised the need for flexibility in dealing with the changing needs of KK and the importance of maintaining a bond between mother and daughter.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established