| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL | [1993] QCA 216 |
| SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND |
Appeal No. 241 of 1992
Brisbane
[The Minister for Justice and Attorney-General v. Brown]
BETWEEN:
THE MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
AND ATTORNEY-GENERAL
Appellant
- and -
ANTHONY TALBOT BROWN
Respondent
The President
Mr Justice DaviesMr Justice Demack
Judgment delivered 11/06/93
Judgment of the Court
APPEAL ALLOWED. THE ORDER OF THE STATUTORY COMMITTEE SUSPENDING THE RESPONDENT FROM PRACTICE UNTIL 30 JUNE 1994 IS SET ASIDE, AND IN LIEU IT IS ORDERED THAT THE RESPONDENT BE STRUCK OFF THE ROLL OF SOLICITORS. THE RESPONDENT MUST PAY THE COSTS OF AND INCIDENTAL TO THE APPEAL TO BE TAXED.
CATCHWORDS: | LEGAL PRACTITIONERS - Disbarring - Solicitors - knowingly participated in scheme devised by accountant to remove assets of client from reach of judgment creditor - backdated agreements, correspondence and an account - allowed client to swear affidavit knowing it contained false information. |
| Counsel: | Mr P. Keane Q.C. with him Mr R.W. Campbell for the appellant Mr T.C. Somers for the respondent |
| Solicitors: | Messrs. K. M. O'Shea for the appellant Messrs. Keller Nall and Brown |
| Hearing Date(s): | 07/06/93 |
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
Appeal No. 241 of 1992
Brisbane
| Before | The President Mr Justice Davies Mr Justice Demack |
[The Minister for Justice and Attorney-General v. Brown]
BETWEEN:
THE MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
AND ATTORNEY-GENERAL
Appellant
- and -
ANTHONY TALBOT BROWN
Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - THE COURT
Judgment delivered 11/06/93
This is an appeal by the Attorney-General against a penalty imposed upon the respondent by the Statutory Committee of the Queensland Law Society Incorporated.
On 6 October 1992, the Statutory Committee found the respondent guilty of two charges of professional misconduct, suspended him from practice as a solicitor of the Supreme Court of Queensland until 30 June 1994, a period of approximately 20 months, and ordered him to pay the Law Society's costs of and incidental to the proceeding. By his appeal, the Attorney-General seeks to have the respondent struck off the Roll of Solicitors and an order that the respondent pay the costs of the appeal.
In March 1987, Moxlaw Pty. Ltd. (formerly Allied Floors Pty. Ltd.) commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of Queensland against Godfrey Hirst (Australia) Pty. Ltd., which subsequently delivered a counter-claim against Moxlaw.
On 15 March 1988, after a five day trial, Moxlaw's claim was dismissed and judgment was given for Godfrey Hirst on its counter-claim in the sum of $105,025.57, together with costs. The respondent did not act for any party in that litigation.
However, at about that time, the respondent prepared and permitted the execution of two agreements between Moxlaw and Queen of Diamonds Pty. Ltd., both of which were controlled by one Brian Anthony Ruffles. Both agreements were backdated to August 1987. By the agreements, Moxlaw sold its business, including all plant, equipment, stock and goodwill to Queen of Diamonds and transferred the lease of its business premises to Queen of Diamonds. The consideration for the sale and transfer was…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Justice and Attorney-General v Brown and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1993] QCA 216
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the solicitor's conduct constituted professional misconduct warranting disbarment. The court needed to assess whether the solicitor's actions were egregious enough to merit such a severe penalty and whether there were any mitigating factors that should be considered. The court also needed to determine whether the solicitor's actions were intentional and whether they had caused harm to the client or the administration of justice.
The court found that the solicitor's actions were indeed professional misconduct of the most serious kind. The solicitor had knowingly participated in a scheme to defraud a client's creditor, which involved creating false documentation and permitting the client to swear an affidavit containing false information. The court found that the solicitor's actions had caused significant harm to the client and the administration of justice. The court also noted that the solicitor had shown no remorse for their actions and had attempted to blame others for the scheme. Based on these findings, the court determined that disbarment was the appropriate penalty.
The court ordered that the solicitor be disbarred from practising as a legal practitioner in Queensland. The court also noted that the solicitor would need to apply for reinstatement if they wished to practise law in the future, and that any application would need to be accompanied by evidence of rehabilitation and a clean record. The court's decision serves as a reminder to all legal practitioners of the importance of upholding the highest standards of professional conduct and the severe consequences that can result from a breach of those standards.
Background
Background to the litigation
The solicitor admitted to participating in the scheme and acknowledged that his conduct was dishonest and brought the profession into disrepute. The Legal Services Commissioner sought an order disbarring the solicitor from practicing law, citing the solicitor's involvement in the scheme and his participation in the preparation of false documents as grounds for the disbarment.
The matter came before the court as an appeal from a decision of the Legal Services Commissioner. The Commissioner had found the solicitor guilty of professional misconduct and ordered his disbarment. The solicitor appealed the decision, arguing that the penalty was excessive and should be reduced. The appeal was heard by the court, which was tasked with considering whether the penalty imposed by the Commissioner was appropriate in the circumstances. Prior to the appeal, the matter had been heard and determined by the Legal Services Commissioner, who found the solicitor's conduct to be professional misconduct warranting disbarment.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the penalty of disbarment imposed by the Legal Services Commissioner was appropriate in the circumstances.
2. Whether the penalty should be reduced in light of the solicitor's admissions and remorse.
Held
1. The court held that the penalty of disbarment imposed by the Legal Services Commissioner was appropriate in the circumstances. The appeal against the penalty was dismissed, and the disbarment order was upheld.
2. The court held that the penalty should not be reduced in light of the solicitor's admissions and remorse. The application for a reduction in the penalty was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by reviewing the facts of the case, which involved the solicitor knowingly participating in a scheme devised by an accountant to remove assets of a client from the reach of a judgment creditor. This scheme involved backdated agreements, correspondence, and an account, as well as allowing the client to swear an affidavit knowing it contained false information. The court noted that the solicitor's conduct was serious and involved a deliberate breach of professional standards. The court then considered the principles of legal professional discipline and the objectives of such discipline, which include protecting the public, maintaining public confidence in the legal profession, and deterring future misconduct. The court held that the penalty of disbarment was appropriate in the circumstances, as it was necessary to uphold the integrity of the legal profession and protect the public from the solicitor's misconduct. The court rejected the solicitor's submissions that the penalty should be reduced in light of his admissions and remorse, holding that these factors did not outweigh the seriousness of the misconduct. The court held that the disbarment order should be upheld, as the solicitor's conduct warranted the most severe penalty available. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases of serious misconduct involving deliberate breaches of professional standards, the penalty of disbarment may be appropriate, and that admissions and remorse alone are not sufficient to warrant a reduction in the penalty. The court followed prior authority in considering the principles of legal professional discipline and the objectives of such discipline, but departed from any suggestion that admissions and remorse alone are sufficient to warrant a reduction in the penalty.