Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Reza

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs v Reza [2001] FCA 1321

IMMIGRATION – review of a decision of Refugee Review Tribunal – question as to whether applicant a national of Afghanistan – not necessarily an error to fail to refer to domestic law of alleged country of nationality to determine whether an applicant qualifies for nationality of that country.

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s 36(3)

Applicant C v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs [2001] FCA 229, followed

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS v MOHAMMAD REZA

N936 of 2001

MADGWICK J
22 AUGUST 2001
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N936 of 2001

BETWEEN:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
APPLICANT

AND:

MOHAMMAD REZA
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MADGWICK J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 AUGUST 2001

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the respondent’s costs.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N936 of 2001

BETWEEN:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
APPLICANT

AND:

MOHAMMAD REZA
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MADGWICK J

DATE:

22 AUGUST 2001

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
(revised from transcript)

HIS HONOUR:

  1. In this matter the applicant Minister seeks the form of judicial review available in this Court, of a favourable decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”), given on 17 May 2001, in relation to the respondent whose application for a protection visa had been initially rejected by a delegate of the applicant Minister.  The Tribunal set aside the decision of the delegate and remitted the matter for reconsideration with the direction that the respondent was a person to whom Australia had protection obligations under the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees as amended by the 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees (“the Convention”). 

    Background

  2. The respondent is a young man who claims to be an Afghani national of the Hazara ethnic group who fears persecution by the notoriously authoritarian Taliban regime in Afghanistan on account of his Hazaran ethnicity and of his being a follower, like most Afghan Hazaras, of the Shiite branch of Islam.  He claimed that he departed Afghanistan via Pakistan en route to Australia.

  3. The applicant Minister’s delegate did not accept that the applicant originated from Afghanistan and as he had not made claims against any other country found in effect that Australia did not owe him any protection obligation. 

    The Tribunal’s decision

  4. The Tribunal Member disbelieved the respondent’s actual story as to his background and in particular his claims that he had resided all his life in Afghanistan.  Instead the Tribunal Member relied on an expert analysis of the respondent’s speech patterns.  The evidence of that expert was that the respondent spoke “Dari” [an Afghan language] with a typical Hazaragi accent, but that some of his pronunciation was consistent with his having “lived for a long time in Pakistan”.

  5. Primarily on the basis of the expert’s evidence, the Tribunal Member found that the respondent was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Reza and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1321
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant Minister, in this case, challenged a decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal that granted the respondent a protection visa. The respondent, an Afghan national of the Hazara ethnic group, sought asylum in Australia, claiming persecution by the Taliban due to his ethnicity and religious beliefs. The Tribunal overturned the Minister's initial rejection of the respondent's application, finding that he was a person to whom Australia had protection obligations under the 1951 Refugee Convention.

The central legal issue was whether the Tribunal correctly determined that the respondent was a citizen of Afghanistan and whether subsection 36(3) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) or the common law principles of effective protection applied to him. Subsection 36(3) excludes Australia from having protection obligations to a non-citizen who has not availed themselves of a right to enter and reside in any country apart from Australia. The Tribunal found that the respondent's claims about his continuous residency in Afghanistan were not credible, based on expert evidence and independent reports, and suspected he had residency rights in Pakistan.

The court found that the Tribunal did not err in its assessment of the respondent's credibility or in concluding that subsection 36(3) did not apply as the term "right" in the Act means a "legally enforceable right," and there was no evidence of such a right for the respondent in Pakistan. The court also accepted the Tribunal's finding that the respondent had no effective protection in any country, as there was no evidence to support this.

Accordingly, the court dismissed the Minister's application and ordered that the applicant pay the respondent's costs. The Tribunal's decision to grant the respondent a protection visa was upheld, as it was satisfied that the respondent was a Shiite Hazara with a well-founded fear of persecution in Afghanistan.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

In this matter the applicant Minister seeks the form of judicial review available in this Court, of a favourable decision of the Refugee Review Tribunal (“the Tribunal”), given on 17 May 2001, in relation to the respondent whose application for a protection visa had been initially rejected by a delegate of the applicant Minister. The Tribunal set aside the decision of the delegate and remitted the matter for reconsideration with the direction that the respondent was a person to whom Australia had protection obligations under the 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees as amended by the 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees (“the Convention”). Background The respondent is a young man who claims to be an Afghani national of the Hazara ethnic group who fears persecution by the notoriously authoritarian Taliban regime in Afghanistan on account of his Hazaran ethnicity and of his being a follower, like most Afghan Hazaras, of the Shiite branch of Islam. He claimed that he departed Afghanistan via Pakistan en route to Australia. The applicant Minister’s delegate did not accept that the applicant originated from Afghanistan and as he had not made claims against any other country found in effect that Australia did not owe him any protection obligation. The Tribunal’s decision The Tribunal Member disbelieved the respondent’s actual story as to his background and in particular his claims that he had resided all his life in Afghanistan. Instead the Tribunal Member relied on an expert analysis of the respondent’s speech patterns. The evidence of that expert was that the respondent spoke “Dari” [an Afghan language] with a typical Hazaragi accent, but that some of his pronunciation was consistent with his having “lived for a long time in Pakistan”. Primarily on the basis of the expert’s evidence, the Tribunal Member found that the respondent was a Hazara of Shiite Muslim faith and either was born and apparently had lived for some significant period of time in Afghanistan or was the child of people from Afghanistan. The independent evidence, noted by the Tribunal, was that there are Hazaras who have resided in Pakistan for generations and these have indeed been accepted by the Pakistani authorities as a “local tribe”. The Tribunal Member was satisfied that the respondent was “not one of those Hazaras whose ancestors had resided in Pakistan for generations”. The Tribunal Member no doubt also had regard to the respondent’s appearance. The evidence was that the Hazaras typically have features commonly associated with Mongolian people. As to how the respondent came to be in Pakistan, and whether or not he had any residency rights there, the Tribunal Member said:“Given the Tribunal’s findings above, it strongly suspects that the applicant has concocted his entire story, and that he may well have residency rights in Pakistan … The Tribunal has before it no information whatsoever to support a finding that the applicant has residency rights in Pakistan … Similarly, as the Tribunal has no evidence about the applicant’s status, legal or otherwise in Pakistan (or, indeed, in any third country), the Tribunal is unable to conclude that he has effective protection in any country.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

MADGWICK J
The applicant Minister’s delegate did not accept that the applicant originated from Afghanistan and as he had not made claims against any other country found in effect that Australia did not owe him any protection obligation. The Tribunal’s decision The Tribunal Member disbelieved the respondent’s actual story as to his background and in particular his claims that he had resided all his life in Afghanistan. Instead the Tribunal Member relied on an expert analysis of the respondent’s speech patterns. The evidence of that expert was that the respondent spoke “Dari” [an Afghan language] with a typical Hazaragi accent, but that some of his pronunciation was consistent with his having “lived for a long time in Pakistan”. Primarily on the basis of the expert’s evidence, the Tribunal Member found that the respondent was a Hazara of Shiite Muslim faith and either was born and apparently had lived for some significant period of time in Afghanistan or was the child of people from Afghanistan. The independent evidence, noted by the Tribunal, was that there are Hazaras who have resided in Pakistan for generations and these have indeed been accepted by the Pakistani authorities as a “local tribe”. The Tribunal Member was satisfied that the respondent was “not one of those Hazaras whose ancestors had resided in Pakistan for generations”. The Tribunal Member no doubt also had regard to the respondent’s appearance. The evidence was that the Hazaras typically have features commonly associated with Mongolian people. As to how the respondent came to be in Pakistan, and whether or not he had any residency rights there, the Tribunal Member said:“Given the Tribunal’s findings above, it strongly suspects that the applicant has concocted his entire story, and that he may well have residency rights in Pakistan … The Tribunal has before it no information whatsoever to support a finding that the applicant has residency rights in Pakistan … Similarly, as the Tribunal has no evidence about the applicant’s status, legal or otherwise in Pakistan (or, indeed, in any third country), the Tribunal is unable to conclude that he has effective protection in any country.” The Tribunal Member accepted the overwhelming evidence that a Shiite Hazara would have a well founded fear of persecution in Afghanistan at the hands of the Taliban and, accordingly, the Tribunal Member found that the respondent should be granted a protection visa and that he satisfied the criterion set out in s 36(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) to be given such a visa. Consideration The applicant Minister complains of legal errors. It is certainly the case that the respondent was fortunate in the findings made by the Tribunal. The Tribunal Member posed the task for himself as follows:“The Tribunal finds that any fears of persecution by the Taliban, on the part of an Afghan citizen who is a Shiite Hazara would be well-founded.The issues for the Tribunal to determine, therefore, are whether the applicant is a citizen of Afghanistan, and, if so, whether or not subsection 36(3) of the Act or the common law principles of effective protection apply to him.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MADGWICK J

The Tribunal Member accepted the overwhelming evidence that a Shiite Hazara would have a well founded fear of persecution in Afghanistan at the hands of the Taliban and, accordingly, the Tribunal Member found that the respondent should be granted a protection visa and that he satisfied the criterion set out in s 36(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”) to be given such a visa. Consideration The applicant Minister complains of legal errors. It is certainly the case that the respondent was fortunate in the findings made by the Tribunal. The Tribunal Member posed the task for himself as follows:“The Tribunal finds that any fears of persecution by the Taliban, on the part of an Afghan citizen who is a Shiite Hazara would be well-founded.The issues for the Tribunal to determine, therefore, are whether the applicant is a citizen of Afghanistan, and, if so, whether or not subsection 36(3) of the Act or the common law principles of effective protection apply to him.” Section 36(3) provides:“Australia is taken not to have protection obligations to a non-citizen who has not taken all possible steps to avail himself or herself of a right to enter and reside in, whether temporarily or permanently and however that right arose or is expressed, any country apart from Australia, including countries of which the non-citizen is a national.” The Tribunal Member went on to discuss the evidence shortly, including the evidence to which I have already referred. The Tribunal Member continued:“For all these reasons, the Tribunal is not satisfied that the applicant has lived in Afghanistan continuously up until late 2000. The Tribunal finds that the applicant has resided in Pakistan for a long time. It follows that the Tribunal cannot be satisfied as to the truth of the applicant’s claims.”The Tribunal then went on to record its acceptance that the respondent was either born in Afghanistan or was a child of people from that country, findings to which I have referred above. The Tribunal Member then continued, “[t]he question remains open as to how the applicant came to be in Pakistan, and whether or not he has any residency rights in Pakistan”. The Member referred to his suspicions, as indicated above, and said that suspicion was not enough because there was no evidence whatsoever to support his suspicions. The Member then referred to the lack of information to support a finding that the applicant had residency rights in Pakistan and continued:“Following the reasoning of Carr J in Applicant C v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (citation omitted) that the term ‘right’ in s 36(3) of the Act means a ‘legally enforceable right’, the Tribunal finds that that subsection does not apply to the applicant in this case. Similarly, as the Tribunal has no evidence about the applicant’s status, legal or otherwise, in Pakistan (or, indeed, in any third country), the Tribunal is unable to conclude that he has effective protection in any country.”