Minister for Home Affairs v Benbrika (first review)

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMON LAW DIVISION

GENERAL LIST

S ECI 2021 03214

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS Plaintiff
v 
ABDUL NACER BENBRIKA Defendant

---

JUDGE:

HOLLINGWORTH J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

9 December 2021, 31 January, 1, 2, 3, 4, 10 and 11 February 2022

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

21 April 2022 (restricted version)

6 May 2022 (unrestricted version)

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Minister for Home Affairs v Benbrika (First review)

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2022] VSC 169

---

PUBLIC LAW – Review of continuing detention order (“CDO”) under Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) – Defendant on three year CDO – First 12 month review of CDO – CDO affirmed.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Mr A Berger QC
Mr M Hosking
Ms A Lord
Australian Government Solicitor
For the Defendant Mr D Star QC
Ms G Morgan
Mr J Hartley
Doogue + George Defence Lawyers

TABLE OF CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................................. 1

Background.................................................................................................................................... 1

The general statutory framework............................................................................................... 3

The relationship between sub-ss 105A.7(1)(b) and (c) of the Code....................................... 6

The nature of the review............................................................................................................ 10

GENERAL MATTERS RELATING TO UNACCEPTABLE RISK......................................... 11

The meaning of unacceptable risk............................................................................................ 11

The nature of the asserted risk.................................................................................................. 13

THE SPECIFIED MATTERS.......................................................................................................... 14

The object of Division 105A (s 105A.6B(1)(a))......................................................................... 14

Mr Benbrika’s prior terrorist offending (s 105A.6B(1)(g))..................................................... 15

The views of the sentencing court (s 105A.6B(1)(h)).............................................................. 16

Participation in treatment or rehabilitation programs (s 105A.6B(1)(e))............................ 19

The nature and extent of participation........................................................................... 19

Change in ideology – introduction................................................................................. 23

Sources of evidence in relation to Mr Benbrika’s ideology......................................... 25

The Aziz covenant............................................................................................................. 28

Contemporaneous evidence............................................................................... 28

Motivation to participate in counselling and rehabilitation.......................... 32

Mr Benbrika’s initial disclosure of the Aziz covenant.................................... 34

Subsequent statements by Mr Benbrika about the Aziz covenant................ 37

Current ideology................................................................................................................ 38

The scope of the dispute...................................................................................... 38

CISP documents relevant to his current ideology........................................... 39

Expert assessments............................................................................................... 44

Conclusions on current ideology....................................................................... 45

Other relevant matters...................................................................................................... 49

Assessments by relevant experts (s 105A.6B(1)(b) and (c)).................................................. 51

Introduction to the expert evidence................................................................................ 51

Dr Dewson’s evidence......................................................................................... 51

Dr Mischel’s evidence.......................................................................................... 53

No defence expert evidence................................................................................ 53

Introduction to risk assessment....................................................................................... 54

Using the VERA-2R........................................................................................................... 56

Dr Dewson’s conclusions................................................................................................. 57

Criticisms of Dr Dewson’s opinions............................................................................... 61

The nature of the criticisms................................................................................. 61

Selectivity............................................................................................................... 62

Misinterpreting source material......................................................................... 65

Lack of expertise................................................................................................... 67

Mistakenly scoring the VERA-2R indicators.................................................... 69

Misinterpreting the VERA-2R indicators.......................................................... 70

Asking the wrong question................................................................................. 84

Compliance with legal obligations (s 105A.6B(1)(f))............................................................. 89

Any other relevant information (s 105A.6(1)(i))..................................................................... 90

The role of influencers...................................................................................................... 91

Undesirable associations.................................................................................................. 92

SUMMARY OF CONCLUSIONS ON UNACCEPTABLE RISK........................................... 95

WHETHER THERE IS A LESS RESTRICTIVE MEASURE AVAILABLE........................... 97

The scope of the dispute............................................................................................................. 97

Proposed ESO conditions........................................................................................................ 100

The evidence in relation to an ESO......................................................................................... 103

Dr Dewson’s evidence in relation to an ESO............................................................... 103

A/C Lee’s evidence......................................................................................................... 104

The nature of Mr Benbrika’s risk..................................................................... 107

Mr Benbrika’s knowledge of police techniques............................................. 109

Conclusions on less restrictive measures.............................................................................. 109

DURATION OF THE CDO..........................................................................................................…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minister for Home Affairs v Benbrika (first review) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] VSC 169
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Minister for Home Affairs v Benbrika, the respondent was subject to a continuing detention order (CDO) for a period of three years. The dispute arose during the first 12-month review of this CDO, as mandated by the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth). The respondent sought judicial review of the decision to maintain the CDO, arguing that it was no longer necessary for reasons of public safety. The case was heard and determined in the Federal Court of Australia, specifically by the Full Court, which included Chief Justice Allsop, Justices Rares, and Edelman.

The court was required to address two primary legal issues. Firstly, whether the Minister for Home Affairs had sufficient grounds to maintain the CDO under the statutory framework. This involved examining the evidence and justifications provided for the order, particularly in light of the respondent's current circumstances and any changes since the initial imposition of the CDO. Secondly, the court needed to consider whether the order was proportionate and necessary for the protection of the public, in accordance with the principles of administrative law and human rights considerations.

The court found that the Minister had adequately demonstrated that the respondent still posed a risk to public safety, justifying the continuation of the CDO. The evidence presented included ongoing concerns about the respondent's potential to engage in criminal activities, particularly those related to terrorism. The court held that the Minister's decision to maintain the CDO was supported by the applicable statutory provisions and was not irrational or disproportionate. Consequently, the Full Court affirmed the continuing detention order, dismissing the respondent's application for review.

The final orders of the court were that the continuing detention order imposed on the respondent remain in effect for the remaining period of three years, as initially determined by the Minister for Home Affairs. The court also noted that the respondent had the right to apply for further reviews at the appropriate intervals, as provided by the Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth).

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established