Minea v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Minea v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2023] NSWPIC 625 
CLAIMANT: Mao Minea
INSURER: Allianz
MEMBER: Stephen Boyd-Boland

DATE OF DECISION:

22 November 2023

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017, damages claim; liability issue; claimant involved in collision with the insured’s vehicle turning across oncoming traffic at traffic light; issue whether traffic light green or red; expert evidence on traffic light; Held – no negligence; claimant wholly at fault for accident.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

CERTIFICATE

In accordance with Division 7.6 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017, the Commission’s assessment is:

1.     On the issue of liability for the claim, the insured owed a duty of care to the claimant, but the insured did not breach that duty of care.

2.     The claimant has no entitlement to damages.

3.     No costs are assessed in favour of the claimant.


STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

Background

  1. The claimant is Mao Minea.

  2. On 6 July 2020 the claimant was involved in a collision with the insured driver’s vehicle.

  3. The claimant was taken to Westmead Hospital. The Discharge Summary provides that the claimant had slight chest discomfort on palpation of the lateral chest wall. A chest X-ray demonstrated no fracture of the pneumothorax, and the remainder of the assessment was unremarkable.

The Assessment conference

  1. Mr Petrushnko appeared for the claimant and Ms Allana for the insurer.

  2. The claimant had limited English, and a Khmer interpreter was required.

  3. At the commencement of the assessment conference there was some discussion in relation to the earnings of the claimant.

  4. Significantly there remained a dispute as to the circumstances immediately before the collision including the colour of the traffic signal observed by the claimant and the insured driver.

  5. At the assessment conference:

    (a)    Mao Minea, the claimant, gave oral evidence with the assistance of an interpreter and was questioned;

    (b)    Bilal Sabbagh, the insured driver, gave oral evidence and was questioned, and

    (c)    the passenger of the insured driver gave oral evidence and was questioned.

The documents

  1. The assessment conference focussed on the colour of the traffic light for the claimant and the insured driver and the documents provided the basis for that focus.

  2. The claimant’s version of events as set out in the incident report form as follows:

    “On the 6 of July 2020 at 9.30pm, I was driving on Chetwynd Rd when crossing to the traffic light I slow my car shown and signal right, I saw the round and arrow green light together then I turn right, suddenly I don’t even know where the car come from and hit me very strong. I was very panic and felt into dizzy and chest pain very hurt and very to breath in.”

  3. The interview with Constable Rachel Herne is partly based on information provided to Constable Benson. The interview includes in relation to the independent witness, Bosco Tran at A87 “… he wasn’t able to confirm who had a green light or anything like that …”.

  4. The interview with Constable…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minea v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 625
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Minea versus Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, the case was heard before the Supreme Court of Queensland. The plaintiff, Minea, sought compensation from the defendant, Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, following a motor accident. Minea was involved in a collision with a vehicle insured by Allianz, which was turning across oncoming traffic at a traffic light. The crux of the dispute was whether the traffic light was green or red at the time of the collision, which would determine liability for the accident. The primary issue before the court was to ascertain whether the plaintiff, Minea, was negligent in causing the accident, or if the driver of the Allianz-insured vehicle was at fault.

The court had to determine if Minea was negligent in colliding with the vehicle that was turning across oncoming traffic. This involved examining the evidence regarding the state of the traffic light at the time of the accident. Expert evidence was presented on the functionality and appearance of the traffic light. The court needed to evaluate this evidence to ascertain whether the traffic light was green or red, and thus whether Minea was negligent in proceeding through the intersection. The court also needed to consider whether the driver of the Allianz-insured vehicle was negligent in turning across oncoming traffic.

After evaluating the evidence, the court concluded that Minea was wholly at fault for the accident. The expert evidence indicated that the traffic light was green when Minea proceeded through the intersection, meaning that the driver of the Allianz-insured vehicle was not negligent in turning across oncoming traffic. Minea's decision to proceed despite the green light was deemed negligent. Therefore, the court found that Minea bore full responsibility for the collision, and Allianz Australia Insurance Limited was not liable for any damages claimed by Minea. The court's decision was based on the clear evidence that Minea was negligent, and no negligence was found on the part of the Allianz-insured driver.

The final order of the court was that Minea's claim against Allianz Australia Insurance Limited was dismissed, and no damages were awarded to Minea. The court held that Minea's negligence was the sole cause of the accident, and Allianz Australia Insurance Limited was not liable for any injuries or damages resulting from the collision.

Background

Background to the litigation

Minea, the claimant, was involved in a motor accident when their vehicle collided with a vehicle insured by Allianz Australia Insurance Limited. The collision occurred when the claimant attempted to turn across oncoming traffic at a traffic light. The central factual issue in dispute is whether the traffic light was green or red at the time of the accident. There is conflicting evidence on this point, with expert evidence presented by both parties. The claimant contends that the traffic light was green, allowing them to proceed, whereas Allianz argues that the traffic light was red, prohibiting the turn. This factual dispute is crucial to determining liability for the accident.

The case came before the court as a first-instance hearing concerning a damages claim under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017. The claimant filed a claim against Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, alleging negligence on the part of the insured driver. Allianz disputed the claim, arguing that the accident was due to the claimant's negligence. The matter proceeded to a full hearing, where evidence and expert testimony were presented on the state of the traffic light at the time of the accident. There were no prior decisions or appeals in other tribunals or courts relevant to this case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the traffic light green or red at the time of the accident, and what are the implications of this for liability?
2. Did the claimant act negligently by turning across oncoming traffic at the traffic light, and if so, does this absolve Allianz from liability under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017?
3. To what extent is the claimant entitled to damages under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017, considering the findings on negligence and liability?

Held
1. The court concluded that the traffic light was green at the time of the accident, which is a critical factor in determining liability.
2. The court found that the claimant acted negligently by turning across oncoming traffic at the traffic light, and this negligence absolves Allianz from liability under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.
3. Considering the findings on negligence and liability, the court ruled that the claimant is not entitled to any damages under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence provided regarding the state of the traffic light at the time of the accident. Expert evidence indicated that the traffic light was indeed green, contrary to the claimant's assertion. This finding was pivotal because it established that the claimant's actions were the direct cause of the collision. Under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017, a claimant's negligence can absolve an insurer from liability. The court considered the statutory provision that shields insurers when the insured party is not at fault due to the claimant's own negligence. The court cited relevant case law to support its conclusion that the claimant's decision to turn across oncoming traffic at a green light constituted negligence. This negligence was deemed the sole cause of the accident, leading to the dismissal of the claimant's damages claim. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a claimant's negligence in disregarding traffic signals can absolve an insurer from liability, aligning with the statutory provisions of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017.