Minamarc Pty Ltd v Gold Coast City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

[2010] QPEC 146

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT

JUDGE ROBIN QC

P & E Appeal No 3542 of 2009

MINAMARC PTY LTD Appellant

and

GOLD COAST CITY COUNCIL Respondent

and

THE DEPARTMENT OF MAIN ROADS Co-respondent

BRISBANE

..DATE 17/11/2010

ORDER

CATCHWORDS

Sustainable Planning Act 2009, s 350

Minor change, because not "a substantially different development" where within a reduced development footprint a proposal expanded from 96 dwellings to 125 (30% increase) - number of bedrooms increases by 17% - although some construction increased from 3 levels to 4 in context, this did not "dramatically change the built form"

HIS HONOUR:  The parties join in approaching the court with an invitation to resolve this developer appeal against the council's refusal of its original development application by allowing the appeal and granting an approval on conditions.

The issue for the court today is whether changes to the proposal which are no doubt what has led to the change in attitude of the council, and perhaps the co-respondent by election as well, although that is uncertain, represent minor change.

I think Mr Ure, for the appellant, accepts that under the former test in section 4.1.52.2(b) of the Integrated Planning Act 1997 (IPA), it might have been difficult to support a contention that what is happening represents minor change.

The Sustainable Planning Act 2009 (SPA) in section 819 and following sections regulates the conduct of the appeal. Section 819(2) requires the court to decide the appeal as if the SPA had not commenced. However, by section 821, relevantly, minor change issues are now dealt with by reference to a definition in section 350 of the SPA.

The only relevant consideration is that referred to in section 350(1)(d) and, in particular, in paragraph (i) which lets in as minor a change that "does not result in a substantially different development."

There has been some discussion this morning about paragraph (iv) and whether anything about the change requires impact assessment.  If the original application did not involve impact assessment, it is of some comfort in a context like this to note that the most significant change, which is the addition of a third level of residential to the original proposal for two levels above parking in a series of buildings proposed, does not take the proposal out of compliance with standards in the local area plan in which the relevant benchmark is four storeys.

The material presented by the appellant today goes to some trouble to indicate that although that extra level of construction is proposed, the visual impact, so far as one's appreciation of bulk and scale is concerned, will be much attenuated, given that those taller buildings are to be constructed in very low lying parts of the site.

It is of some assistance to me today to have recently decided Auspacific Engineers v. Scenic Rim Regional Council [2010] QPEC 117 which, in many respects, involved circumstances reflected in today's appeal. In particular, in that case there was a one-third increase in the number of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Minamarc Pty Ltd v Gold Coast City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] QPEC 146
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Minamarc Pty Ltd v Gold Coast City Council, the appellant, Minamarc, sought to appeal against the respondent, Gold Coast City Council's, refusal of its development application for a proposed residential development. The dispute centred on whether the changes made to the original proposal constituted a minor change under the Sustainable Planning Act 2009. The case was heard in the Queensland Planning and Environment Court, presided over by Judge Robin QCP & E.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the modifications to the proposed development constituted a minor change. This involved determining whether the changes to the proposal, which included an increase in the number of dwellings from 96 to 125 and an increase in building height from two to four storeys, resulted in a substantially different development. The court had to consider the definition of minor change in section 350 of the Sustainable Planning Act 2009, particularly focusing on whether the changes did not result in a substantially different development.

The court concluded that the changes made to the proposal did not result in a substantially different development. This decision was influenced by the case of Auspacific Engineers v Scenic Rim Regional Council, which involved similar circumstances. The court found that the changes, although they increased the number of dwellings by 30% and the number of bedrooms by 17%, did not dramatically change the built form in terms of scale, bulk, and appearance. Additionally, the court noted that the proposed development still complied with the local area plan standards, which had a benchmark of four storeys. The court also considered the visual impact of the taller buildings, which would be mitigated by their placement in low-lying parts of the site.

The court granted the appeal and approved the development on conditions. The final orders were made in line with the draft proffered by the appellant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established