Mina Farag and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

[2014] AATA 927

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/6704

Re

Mina Farag

APPLICANT

And

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President J W Constance

Date 12 December 2014  
Place Sydney

The Tribunal:

1.   sets aside the decision of the delegate of the Minister dated 18 November 2013 to refuse Mr Farag’s application for citizenship;

2.   remits the matter to the Minister for reconsideration in accordance with the direction that the period 28 November 2011 to 30 November 2011 is to be treated as if Mr Farag was not present in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen.

...........................[sgd]............................................

Deputy President J W Constance

Catchwords

CITIZENSHIP – residence requirement – applicant an unlawful non-citizen for three days in the four years prior to his application – whether discretion should be exercised to treat the period as if the Applicant was not present in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen – whether administrative error – advice in grant of bridging visa incomplete and misleading – administrative error caused the Applicant to become an unlawful non-citizen – decision set aside and remitted

Legislation

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) ss 21(2), 22(1), 22(4A), 24
Migration Act 1958 (Cth) s 13

Cases

Chaudhary and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 1006

Rogers and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2011] AATA 592

Secondary Materials

Australian Citizenship Instructions (Cth) (issued 4 July 2014)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J W Constance

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Farag lodged an application for Australian citizenship by conferral in November 2013.

  2. A delegate of the Minister refused Mr Farag’s application on the ground that he failed to satisfy the general residence requirement set out in section 22 of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth). This decision was made on the basis that Mr Farag was present in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen for a period of three days from 28 November 2011 to 30 November 2011.

  3. Mr Farag has applied to the Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s decision.  For the reasons which follow the decision under review will be set aside.

    BACKGROUND

  4. Mr Farag first arrived in Australia in 2006 on a student visa. Subsequently he was granted a series of student and bridging visas. 

  5. On 18 February 2010, Mr Farag was granted a Student (ClassTU) Subclass 572 visa.  It was a condition of this visa that he be enrolled in a registered course of study.

  6. Mr Farag applied for a Protection (Class XA) visa on 9 December 2010.  The making of this application did not affect the status of his Student visa which continued in force.

    The first letter: the grant of a Bridging visa

  7. On 10 December 2010, Mr Farag received a letter from the Department of Immigration and Citizenship confirming that he had made an application for a Protection visa. [1] On page 1 of the letter Mr Farag was advised:

    Your immigration status

    You have been granted a bridging visa.  This visa allows you to remain lawfully in Australia while your application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mina Farag and Minister for Immigration and Border Protectio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 927
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Mina Farag and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection, the primary issue before the court was whether the Minister should exercise his discretion to treat a period during which the applicant was an unlawful non-citizen as if he was not present in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen. This was due to the administrative error that led to the applicant becoming an unlawful non-citizen. The applicant, Mr Farag, had applied for citizenship but was deemed an unlawful non-citizen for three days within the four years prior to his application. This was the result of an administrative error which caused him to become an unlawful non-citizen. The court had to determine whether the Minister should exercise his discretion to treat this period as if Mr Farag was not present in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen.

The court found that the administrative error in the advice given to Mr Farag led to him becoming an unlawful non-citizen. The letter confirming the grant of a bridging visa was misleading as it did not clarify that the bridging visa would only come into effect once his Student visa ceased. Additionally, the letter advising of the intention to cancel his Student visa did not clarify that the cancellation would cause him to become an unlawful non-citizen. The court determined that these errors were significant and directly caused Mr Farag to become an unlawful non-citizen. As a result, the court found that the Minister should exercise his discretion to treat the period as if Mr Farag was not present in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen.

The court set aside the decision under review and remitted the matter back to the Minister for reconsideration in light of the findings. The court held that the administrative errors were significant and directly caused Mr Farag to become an unlawful non-citizen. As a result, the Minister should exercise his discretion to treat the period as if Mr Farag was not present in Australia as an unlawful non-citizen. The decision was set aside, and the matter was remitted back to the Minister for reconsideration. This decision highlights the importance of clear and accurate advice being given to applicants to ensure that they understand the implications of any decisions made about their visa status.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Farag has applied to the Tribunal for a review of the delegate’s decision. For the reasons which follow the decision under review will be set aside.BACKGROUND Mr Farag first arrived in Australia in 2006 on a student visa. Subsequently he was granted a series of student and bridging visas. On 18 February 2010, Mr Farag was granted a Student (ClassTU) Subclass 572 visa. It was a condition of this visa that he be enrolled in a registered course of study. Mr Farag applied for a Protection (Class XA) visa on 9 December 2010. The making of this application did not affect the status of his Student visa which continued in force.The first letter: the grant of a Bridging visa On 10 December 2010, Mr Farag received a letter from the Department of Immigration and Citizenship confirming that he had made an application for a Protection visa. [1] On page 1 of the letter Mr Farag was advised:Your immigration statusYou have been granted a bridging visa. This visa allows you to remain lawfully in Australia while your application is being processed. The bridging visa will only come into effect when any other substantive visa that you hold ceases. [Emphasis added][1] Exhibit R3 Page 2 of the letter contained the following advice to Mr Farag:Generally your bridging visa will remain in effect until 28 calendar days after you are notified of the decision on your application.It is not necessary for you to have a visa label placed in your passport, however, you should keep this letter with you for your reference. Further information about Bridging Visas is included in the attachment Form 1024i Bridging Visas.You have been required to provide personal identifiers and have not yet provided them. If you do not provide the required personal identifiers within the specified period, your application will be invalid. Your bridging visa will cease 28 days after you are notified of the invalidity of your application.Your bridging visa will cease if you leave Australia. ... [Emphasis added].The second letter: refusal of Mr Farag’s application for a Protection visa Mr Farag’s application for a Protection visa was refused in a decision made on 11 August 2011. In that decision, Mr Farag was advised of the following: … you are entitled to apply to the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) for a review of this decision. An application for review of this refusal decision must be given to the RRT within the prescribed timeframe. This timeframe commences on the day on which you are taken to have been notified of this decision, and ends at the end of 28 days. If you make a valid application for review of this decision, your bridging visa will remain in effect until 28 days after the RRT has notified you of its decision. If you withdraw your application for review to the RRT, your bridging visa will cease 28 days after that withdrawal…. [Emphasis added]. Mr Farag lodged a valid application for a review of the decision with the Refugee Review Tribunal on 5 September 2011.[2][2] Exhibit R2 p.8.The third letter: notice of intention to consider cancellation of Mr Farag’s Student visa

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Farag’s application for a Protection visa was refused in a decision made on 11 August 2011. In that decision, Mr Farag was advised of the following: … you are entitled to apply to the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) for a review of this decision. An application for review of this refusal decision must be given to the RRT within the prescribed timeframe. This timeframe commences on the day on which you are taken to have been notified of this decision, and ends at the end of 28 days. If you make a valid application for review of this decision, your bridging visa will remain in effect until 28 days after the RRT has notified you of its decision. If you withdraw your application for review to the RRT, your bridging visa will cease 28 days after that withdrawal…. [Emphasis added]. Mr Farag lodged a valid application for a review of the decision with the Refugee Review Tribunal on 5 September 2011.[2][2] Exhibit R2 p.8.The third letter: notice of intention to consider cancellation of Mr Farag’s Student visa On 20 October 2011, Mr Farag was sent a letter from the Department of Immigration and Citizenship notifying him of its intention to consider cancelling his Student visa as available records indicated that he was not enrolled in a registered course. On the fourth page of that letter Mr Farag was advised: If your visa is cancelled you will become an unlawful non-citizen, unless you are granted a further visa. If you have made a further substantive visa application since your arrival in Australia, any bridging visa you were granted in relation to that application will cease.[3][3] Exhibit R2, p.18. Mr Farag’s student visa was cancelled on 28 November 2011.[4] He was advised of this in a letter dated the same day. [5] On the third page of the letter the following appeared:If you have made a further substantive visa application since your arrival in Australia, any bridging visa you were granted in relation to that application also ceased when your visa was cancelled.[4] Exhibit R1, p.125, final paragraph.[5] Exhibit R1 p.124 The letter also included the statement that:As this letter was sent to you by Email, you are taken to have received this letter at the end of the day it was transmitted. Mr Farag first received notice that his Student visa had been cancelled and that his Bridging visa had ceased when he was so advised in a telephone call from an officer of the Department at 3pm on 29 November 2011. He had not had an opportunity to check his e-mails prior to this call. In any event, he had become an unlawful non-citizen from the time of the decision to cancel his Student visa, sometime the previous day.[6][6] Exhibit R1 p.5. During the telephone discussion on 29 November 2011, Mr Farag was advised to apply for another Bridging visa. He did this and a Bridging visa was granted to him on 30 November 2011. He has since been granted a Protection (Class XA) visa which he currently holds. Mr Farag gave evidence that, until he received the telephone call from the departmental officer on 29 November 2011, he did not realise that cancellation of his Student visa would immediately cause him to become an unlawful non-citizen. If he had he would have taken further steps to protect his immigration status based on his Student visa. Sometime between receiving the letter of 20 October 2011 and the cancellation of his visa he had submitted a medical certificate to the Department in relation to his lack of enrolment. Nevertheless, he believed that he was entitled to lawfully remain in Australia under his Bridging visa.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 10 December 2010, Mr Farag received a letter from the Department of Immigration and Citizenship confirming that he had made an application for a Protection visa. [1] On page 1 of the letter Mr Farag was advised:Your immigration statusYou have been granted a bridging visa. This visa allows you to remain lawfully in Australia while your application is being processed. The bridging visa will only come into effect when any other substantive visa that you hold ceases. [Emphasis added][1] Exhibit R3 Page 2 of the letter contained the following advice to Mr Farag:Generally your bridging visa will remain in effect until 28 calendar days after you are notified of the decision on your application.It is not necessary for you to have a visa label placed in your passport, however, you should keep this letter with you for your reference. Further information about Bridging Visas is included in the attachment Form 1024i Bridging Visas.You have been required to provide personal identifiers and have not yet provided them. If you do not provide the required personal identifiers within the specified period, your application will be invalid. Your bridging visa will cease 28 days after you are notified of the invalidity of your application.Your bridging visa will cease if you leave Australia. ... [Emphasis added].The second letter: refusal of Mr Farag’s application for a Protection visa Mr Farag’s application for a Protection visa was refused in a decision made on 11 August 2011. In that decision, Mr Farag was advised of the following: … you are entitled to apply to the Refugee Review Tribunal (RRT) for a review of this decision. An application for review of this refusal decision must be given to the RRT within the prescribed timeframe. This timeframe commences on the day on which you are taken to have been notified of this decision, and ends at the end of 28 days. If you make a valid application for review of this decision, your bridging visa will remain in effect until 28 days after the RRT has notified you of its decision. If you withdraw your application for review to the RRT, your bridging visa will cease 28 days after that withdrawal…. [Emphasis added]. Mr Farag lodged a valid application for a review of the decision with the Refugee Review Tribunal on 5 September 2011.[2][2] Exhibit R2 p.8.The third letter: notice of intention to consider cancellation of Mr Farag’s Student visa On 20 October 2011, Mr Farag was sent a letter from the Department of Immigration and Citizenship notifying him of its intention to consider cancelling his Student visa as available records indicated that he was not enrolled in a registered course. On the fourth page of that letter Mr Farag was advised: If your visa is cancelled you will become an unlawful non-citizen, unless you are granted a further visa. If you have made a further substantive visa application since your arrival in Australia, any bridging visa you were granted in relation to that application will cease.[3][3] Exhibit R2, p.18.