Milvan Frank Muto v Shepparton City Council and Robert Crow

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2018 0078

MILVAN FRANK MUTO Applicant
v
SHEPPARTON CITY COUNCIL and ROBERT CROW Respondents

---

JUDGES: BEACH JA and MACAULAY AJA
WHERE HELD: MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING: 24 October 2018
DATE OF JUDGMENT: 29 October 2018
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: [2018] VSCA 274
ORDER APPEALED FROM: Muto v City of Greater Shepparton & Anor (County Court of Victoria, Judge Saccardo, 29 May 2018)

---

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Application for leave to appeal – Primary judge directed registrar not to permit applicant to file writ – Whether proceeding if issued would be irregular or an abuse of process – No reasons given for order – Defective general endorsement – Endorsement not complying with r 5.04 of County Court Civil Procedure Rules 2008 – Not reasonably arguable that proceeding would not be irregular if writ permitted to be filed – Application for leave to appeal having no prospect of success – County Court Civil Procedure Rules 2008, rr 5.05 and 27.06.

---

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Applicant In person
For the Respondents No appearance Crow Legal Pty Ltd

BEACH JA

MACAULAY AJA:

  1. This is an application for leave to appeal from an order of a County Court judge directing the County Court Registrar not to permit the applicant to file a writ dated 7 May 2018 (‘the writ’).

The writ

  1. The writ names the applicant as plaintiff, the City of Greater Shepparton as the first defendant and Robert Murray Crow as the second defendant. In purported compliance with r 5.04 of the County Court Civil Procedure Rules 2008 (‘the County Court Rules’), the applicant endorsed the writ as follows:

The first defendant and the second defendant breached their obligations to properly indemnify the plaintiff pursuant to section 76 and section 76(A) of the Local Government Act 1989 and clause 46F of Schedule 1 of the VCAT Act 1998 with regard to liabilities properly incurred by the plaintiff in the course of his duties as a councillor of the City of Greater Shepparton, thereby causing the plaintiff loss and damage, particulars of which will be provided prior to the trial of this matter.

The applicant’s reference to ‘the VCAT Act 1998’ in his endorsement is a reference to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 (‘the VCAT Act’). 

Relevant background

  1. Some of the relevant background to the present application can be found in this Court’s decisions of Muto v Shepparton City Council[1] (‘Muto1’) and Muto v The City of Greater Shepparton[2] (‘Muto2’).

  1. Muto1 concerned two applications for leave to appeal brought by the applicant against the first respondent. The first application related to a decision made by Keogh J in the Trial Division,[3] and the second related to a decision made by Judge Marks in the County Court.[4]

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Milvan Frank Muto v Shepparton City Council and Robert Crow and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] VSCA 274
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Milvan Frank Muto brought an application for leave to appeal against a decision of the County Court of Victoria, which had dismissed his claim against Shepparton City Council and Robert Crow. The dispute originated from a claim Muto made against the Council and Crow, alleging breaches of statutory duty, nuisance and other tortious acts related to the operation of a piggery. The primary judge had directed the registrar not to permit Muto to file a writ of summons, on the basis that proceeding with the claim would be irregular or an abuse of process. The judge also noted a defect in the general endorsement of the writ, which did not comply with the relevant rules.

The central legal issues the court had to address were whether the proceeding, if issued, would be irregular or an abuse of process, and if the defect in the general endorsement could be rectified. Furthermore, the court had to determine if there was a reasonable arguability that the proceeding would not be irregular if the writ was permitted to be filed. Given the primary judge's findings and the lack of reasons provided, the court considered whether the application for leave to appeal had any prospect of success.

The Court of Appeal found that the application did not have a reasonable prospect of success. It noted that the primary judge's reasons suggested that proceeding with the claim would be irregular or an abuse of process, and the defect in the general endorsement was not minor or capable of being remedied. The Court held that it was not reasonably arguable that the proceeding would not be irregular if the writ was permitted to be filed. Therefore, the application for leave to appeal was dismissed. The Court also highlighted that the absence of reasons for the primary judge's order was not fatal to the application, but it did not assist Muto's case.

Background

Background to the litigation

Milvan Frank Muto, the applicant, filed an application for leave to appeal against an order made by a primary judge of the County Court of Victoria. The order directed the registrar not to permit the applicant to file a writ of summons against Shepparton City Council and Robert Crow, the respondents, unless leave was first obtained. The application arose from an earlier proceeding in which the applicant had sought an injunction against the respondents for alleged defamatory publications. The primary judge dismissed the injunction application on the basis that the applicant had not provided evidence to substantiate the claim. The applicant's subsequent attempt to file a writ of summons was met with the order in question, which was made without reasons and contained a defective general endorsement.

The case began when Milvan Frank Muto filed an application for an injunction against the Shepparton City Council and Robert Crow, alleging defamation. This application was dismissed by the primary judge of the County Court of Victoria. Following this dismissal, Muto attempted to file a writ of summons against the respondents. The registrar, however, refused to permit the writ to be filed due to an order made by the primary judge directing otherwise. Muto then filed an application for leave to appeal against this order. The application was heard by the County Court of Victoria, which was tasked with determining whether the proceeding, if issued, would be irregular or an abuse of process.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the proceeding, if issued, would be irregular or an abuse of process.
2. Whether the primary judge's order was justified in the absence of reasons and due to a defective general endorsement.
3. Whether it was reasonably arguable that the proceeding would not be irregular if the writ were permitted to be filed.
4. Whether the application for leave to appeal had a prospect of success.

Held
1. The court held that the proceeding, if issued, would be irregular or an abuse of process.
2. The primary judge's order was not justified in the absence of reasons and due to a defective general endorsement.
3. It was not reasonably arguable that the proceeding would not be irregular if the writ were permitted to be filed.
4. The application for leave to appeal had no prospect of success.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the application for leave to appeal by Mr Muto against the primary judge's order. The primary judge had directed the registrar not to permit Mr Muto to file a writ of summons without first obtaining leave. The primary judge's order lacked reasons and had a defective general endorsement, not complying with r 5.04 of the County Court Civil Procedure Rules 2008. Despite this, the court found that the proceeding would be irregular or an abuse of process if issued, as it was not reasonably arguable that the writ would not be irregular if filed. Consequently, the application for leave to appeal had no prospect of success. The court relied on r 27.06 and r 5.05 of the County Court Civil Procedure Rules 2008 in its reasoning, emphasising that the procedural fairness was not compromised by the lack of reasons, given the clear and serious nature of the irregularity or abuse. The binding principle established is that in cases of clear irregularity or abuse of process, the procedural defects in an order do not undermine the court's authority to prevent such proceedings.