Millennium CHPP Pty Ltd v Millennium Coal Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Millennium CHPP Pty Ltd v Millennium Coal Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 1556

MILLENNIUM CHPP PTY LTD, HUNTERCOAL PTY LTD, HELENSBURGH COAL PTY LTD, SOUTHCOAL PTY LTD, EXCEL EQUITIES PTY LTD, CUMBO LAND PTY LTD, EXCEL RESOURCES PTY LTD, EXCEL HOLDINGS PTY LTD, RFC ROYALTY INVESTMENTS PTY LTD, EXCEL INVESTMENTS (NSW) PTY LTD, CONEXCEL 2 PTY LTD, EXCEL EMPLOYMENT SERVICES PTY LTD, BURTON COAL PTY LTD, PEABODY ENERGY AUSTRALIA COAL PTY LTD, MITTERB PTY LIMITED, ELLENSFIELD PASTORAL PTY LTD, PEABODY SURAT PTY LTD, PEABODY FUELS PTY LTD, PEABODY AUSTRALIA MANAGEMENT SERVICES PTY LTD, COAL DEVELOPMENTS (GERMAN CREEK) PTY LTD and NORTH GOONYELLA COAL MINE MANAGEMENT PTY LTD v MILLENNIUM COAL PTY LTD, PEABODY AUSTRALIA MINING LIMITED, METROPOLITAN COLLIERIES PTY LTD, WILPINJONG COAL PTY LTD, PEABODY (BURTON COAL) PTY LTD, PEABODY ENERGY AUSTRALIA PTY LTD, PEABODY (BOWEN) PTY LTD and PEABODY ENERGY AUSTRALIA COAL PTY LIMITED

NSD 1379 of 2009

STONE J
21 DECEMBER 2009
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1379 of 2009

BETWEEN:

MILLENNIUM CHPP PTY LTD (ACN 117 688 696)
First Plaintiff

HUNTERCOAL PTY LTD (ACN 087 413 152)

Second Plaintiff

HELENSBURGH COAL PTY LTD (ACN 086 463 452)

Third Plaintiff

SOUTHCOAL PTY LTD (ACN 078 236 816)

Fourth Plaintiff

EXCEL EQUITIES PTY LTD (ACN 071 707 956)

Fifth Plaintiff

CUMBO LAND PTY LTD (ACN 077 362 746)

Sixth Plaintiff

EXCEL RESOURCES PTY LTD (ACN 071 905 774)

Seventh Plaintiff

EXCEL HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ACN 071 905 738)

Eighth Plaintiff

RFC ROYALTY INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 077 752 099)

Ninth Plaintiff

EXCEL INVESTMENTS (NSW) PTY LTD (ACN 107 987 897)

Tenth Plaintiff

CONEXCEL 2 PTY LTD (ACN 121 412 208)

Eleventh Plaintiff

EXCEL EMPLOYMENT SERVICES PTY LTD (ACN 104 594 489)

Twelfth Plaintiff

BURTON COAL PTY LTD (ACN 064 159 977)

Thirteenth Plaintiff

PEABODY ENERGY AUSTRALIA COAL PTY LTD (ACN 001 401 663)

Fourteenth Plaintiff

MITTERB PTY LIMITED (ACN 094 234 278)

Fifteenth Plaintiff

ELLENSFIELD PASTORAL PTY LTD (ACN 010 758 746)

Sixteenth Plaintiff

PEABODY SURAT PTY LTD (ACN 010 178 551)

Seventeeth Plaintiff

PEABODY FUELS PTY LTD (ACN 103 091 096)

Eighteenth Plaintiff

PEABODY AUSTRALIA MANAGEMENT SERVICES PTY LTD (ACN 003 181 217)

Nineteenth Plaintiff

COAL DEVELOPMENTS (GERMAN CREEK) PTY LTD (ACN 009 974 896)

Twentieth Plaintiff

NORTH GOONYELLA COAL MINE MANAGEMENT PTY LTD (ACN 103 803 354)

Twenty-First Plaintiff

AND:

MILLENNIUM COAL PTY LTD (ACN 089 566 021)

First Defendant

PEABODY AUSTRALIA MINING LIMITED (ACN 002 818 699)

Second Defendant

METROPOLITAN COLLIERIES PTY LTD (ACN 003 135 635)

Third Defendant

WILPINJONG COAL PTY LTD (ACN 104 594 694)

Fourth Defendant

PEABODY (BURTON COAL) PTY LTD (ACN 077 679 513)

Fifth Defendant

PEABODY ENERGY AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 096 909 410)

Sixth Defendant

PEABODY (BOWEN) PTY LTD (ACN 010 879 526)

Seventh Defendant

PEABODY ENERGY AUSTRALIA COAL PTY LIMITED (ACN 001 401 663)

Eighth Defendant

JUDGE:

STONE J

DATE OF ORDER:

16 DECEMBER 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to section 411(4)(b)

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Millennium CHPP Pty Ltd v Millennium Coal Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1556
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Millennium CHPP Pty Ltd and several other companies sought approval from the court for a series of schemes of arrangement under the Corporations Act 2001. The defendants, including Millennium Coal Pty Ltd and Peabody Australia Mining, did not oppose the application. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the schemes of arrangement proposed by the plaintiffs were fair and reasonable to the members and creditors of each company, and whether they should be approved under the Corporations Act. The court considered the evidence and submissions from the parties and found that the schemes were fair and reasonable. The court was satisfied that the schemes provided for an effective reorganisation of the companies, which was in the best interests of the members and creditors.

In approving the schemes, the court noted that the plaintiffs had taken into account the interests of all stakeholders, including minority shareholders, and had provided adequate information to enable an informed decision. The court also found that the schemes complied with the requirements of the Corporations Act and that there were no objections from any party. The court further found that the schemes would result in a more efficient and profitable business for the companies and their stakeholders. The court approved the schemes and made orders for their implementation, including the transfer of assets and liabilities and the deregistration of the companies. The court also made orders to continue pending legal proceedings and to allow the defendants to complete the transfer of assets and liabilities. Finally, the court reserved liberty to any party to apply for further orders under the Corporations Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to section 411(4)(b) Corporations Act 2001 (Act), the schemes of arrangement between each of the First to Eleventh, and Thirteenth to Twentieth Plaintiffs and its respective members, in the form set out in Annexure ‘A’ to these orders (each a Scheme and together the Schemes), be approved.

2. Pursuant to section 411(12) of the Act, the First to Eleventh, and Thirteenth to Twentieth Plaintiffs be exempted from compliance with the requirements of section 411(11) of the Act.

3. Pursuant to section 413(1) of the Act (and using the definitions in the Schemes), as from the Effective Time, each of the following transactions will occur, in relation to each Scheme, in the order set out below:

(a) Millennium CHPP Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the First Plaintiff, Millennium CHPP, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the First Defendant, Millennium Coal;

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Millennium CHPP will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Millennium Coal; and

(iii) third, Millennium CHPP will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(b) Huntercoal Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Second Plaintiff, Huntercoal, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Second Defendant, Peabody Australia Mining;

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Huntercoal will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody Australia Mining; and

(iii) third, Huntercoal will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(c) Helensburgh Coal Scheme

(i) first, all of the Helensburgh Scheme Assets will be transferred from the Third Plaintiff, Helensburgh Coal, to and become the Assets of the Ninth Defendant, Metropolitan Collieries; and

(ii) second, all of the Helensburgh Scheme Liabilities will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Metropolitan Collieries;

(d) Southcoal Scheme

(i) first, all of the shares in Helensburgh Coal, held by the Fourth Plaintiff, Southcoal, will be transferred to the Third Defendant, Metropolitan Collieries;

(ii) second, all of the Assets of Southcoal will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Second Defendant, Peabody Australia Mining;

(iii) third, all of the Liabilities of Southcoal will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody Australia Mining; and

(iv) fourth, Southcoal will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(e) Excel Equities Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Fifth Plaintiff, Excel Equities, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Second Defendant, Peabody Australia Mining;

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Excel Equities will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody Australia Mining; and

(iii) third, Excel Equities will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(f) Cumbo Land Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Sixth Plaintiff, Cumbo Land, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Fourth Defendant, Wilpinjong Coal;

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Cumbo Land will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Wilpinjong Coal; and

(iii) third, Cumbo Land will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act.

(g) Excel Resources Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Seventh Plaintiff, Excel Resources, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Second Defendant, Peabody Australia Mining;

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Excel Resources will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody Australia Mining; and

(iii) third, Excel Resources will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(h) Excel Holdings Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Eighth Plaintiff, Excel Holdings, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Second Defendant, Peabody Australia Mining;

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Excel Holdings will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody Australia Mining; and

(iii) third, Excel Holdings will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(i) RFC Royalty Investments Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Ninth Plaintiff, RFC Royalty Investments, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Second Defendant, Peabody Australia Mining;

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of RFC Royalty Investments will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody Australia Mining; and

(iii) third, RFC Royalty Investments will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(j) Excel Investments (NSW) Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Tenth Plaintiff, Excel Investments (NSW), will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Second Defendant, Peabody Australia Mining;

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Excel Investments (NSW) will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody Australia Mining; and

(iii) third, Excel Investments (NSW) will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(k) Conexcel 2 Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Eleventh Plaintiff, Conexcel 2, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Second Defendant, Peabody Australia Mining;

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Conexcel 2 will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody Australia Mining; and

(iii) third, Conexcel 2 will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(l) Burton Coal Scheme

(i) all of the shares in Peabody (Burton Coal) held by the Thirteenth Plaintiff, Burton Coal, will be transferred to the Sixth Defendant, PEA;

(m) Peabody Energy Australia Coal Scheme

(i) first, all of the shares in Burton Coal and the Burton Joint Venture Assets held by the Fourteenth Plaintiff/Eighth Defendant, Peabody Energy Australia Coal, will be transferred to the Fifth Defendant, Peabody (Burton Coal);

(ii) second, all the Burton Joint Venture Liabilities of Peabody Energy Australia Coal will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody (Burton Coal);

(iii) third, all the North Goonyella Joint Venture Assets held by Peabody Energy Australia Coal will be transferred to the Seventh Defendant, Peabody (Bowen);

(iv) fourth, all the North Goonyella Joint Venture Liabilities of Peabody Energy Australia Coal will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody (Bowen); and

(v) fifth, all of the shares in Peabody (Bowen) held by Peabody Energy Australia Coal will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Sixth Defendant, PEA;

(n) Mitterb Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Fifteenth Plaintiff, Mitterb, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Seventh Defendant, Peabody (Bowen);

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Mitterb will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody (Bowen); and

(iii) third, Mitterb will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(o) Ellensfield Pastoral Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Sixteenth Plaintiff, Ellensfield Pastoral, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Seventh Defendant, Peabody (Bowen);

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Ellensfield Pastoral will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody (Bowen); and

(iii) third, Ellensfield Pastoral will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(p) Peabody Surat Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Seventeenth Plaintiff, Peabody Surat, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Sixth Defendant, PEA;

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Peabody Surat will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of PEA; and

(iii) third, Peabody Surat will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(q) Peabody Fuels Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Eighteenth Plaintiff, Peabody Fuels, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Sixth Defendant, PEA;

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Peabody Fuels will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of PEA; and

(iii) third, Peabody Fuels will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(r) Peabody Australia Management Services Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Nineteenth Plaintiff, Peabody Australia Management Services, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Fourteenth Plaintiff/Eighth Defendant, Peabody Energy Australia Coal;

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Peabody Australia Management Services will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody Energy Australia Coal; and

(iii) third, Peabody Australia Management Services will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act;

(s) Coal Developments German Creek Scheme

(i) first, all of the Assets of the Twentieth Plaintiff, Coal Developments German Creek, will be transferred to and become the Assets of the Fourteenth Plaintiff/Eighth Defendant, Peabody Energy Australia Coal;

(ii) second, all of the Liabilities of Coal Developments German Creek will be transferred to and become the Liabilities of Peabody Energy Australia Coal; and

(iii) third, Coal Developments German Creek will be deregistered by ASIC without winding up pursuant to section 413(1)(d) of the Act.; and

4. Pursuant to section 413(1)(c) of the Act, as and from the Effective Time (as defined in the Schemes), any legal proceedings pending by or against:

(a) the First Plaintiff, Millennium CHPP, will be deemed continued by or against (as the case may be) the First Defendant, Millennium Coal;

(b) the Second Plaintiff, Huntercoal, the Fourth Plaintiff, Southcoal, the Fifth Plaintiff, Excel Equities, the Seventh Plaintiff, Excel Resources, the Eighth Plaintiff, Excel Holdings, the Ninth Plaintiff, RFC Royalty Investments, the Tenth Plaintiff, Excel Investments (NSW), or the Eleventh Plaintiff, Conexcel 2, will be deemed continued by or against (as the case may be) the Second Defendant, Peabody Australia Mining;

(c) the Sixth Plaintiff, Cumbo Land, will be deemed continued by or against (as the case may be) the Fourth Defendant, Wilpinjong Coal;

(d) the Seventeeth Plaintiff, Peabody Surat, or the Eighteenth Plaintiff, Peabody Fuels, will be deemed continued by or against (as the case may be) the Sixth Defendant, PEA;

(e) the Fifteenth Plaintiff, Mitterb, or the Sixteenth Plaintiff, Ellensfield Pastoral, will be deemed continued by or against (as the case may be) the Seventh Defendant, Peabody (Bowen); and

(f) the Nineteeth Plaintiff, Peabody Australia Management Services, or the Twentieth Plaintiff, Coal Developments German Creek, will be deemed continued by or against (as the case may be) the Fourteenth Plaintiff/Eighth Defendant, Peabody Energy Australia Coal,

without the need for any further act or deed, other than appropriate amendment of the record of the relevant court or tribunal.

5. Pursuant to section 413(1)(g) of the Act, as from the Effective Time (as defined in the Schemes), the defendant to whom the relevant Assets or Liabilities of a plaintiff are transferred under a Scheme, or any director of that defendant from time to time, may sign all documents and do all things required to be done by the relevant plaintiff to complete or perfect the transfer of the Assets and Liabilities of that plaintiff provided for in these orders, whether by lodgement, registration, notification or otherwise.

6. Liberty be reserved to any party to apply for any further orders as may be considered necessary or desirable under section 413 of the Act.

7. Without prejudice to the generality of Order 6, liberty to either the Twelfth Plaintiff or the Twenty-First Plaintiff, or both of them, to apply at any time for orders under sections 411 and 413 of the Act.

8. These orders be entered forthwith.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

STONE J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: STONE J

Full text does not contain this section.