SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Millar v Queensland Police Service [2019] QCA 211
PARTIES:
MILLAR, Andrew John
(applicant)
v
QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE
(respondent)FILE NO/S:
CA No 329 of 2018
CA No 155 of 2018
DC No 3602 of 2017
DC No 3601 of 2017DIVISION:
Court of Appeal
PROCEEDING:
Application for Leave s 118 DCA (Criminal)
ORIGINATING COURT:
District Court at Brisbane – [2018] QDC 219 (Rosengren DCJ)
District Court at Brisbane – Unreported, 28 March 2018 (Ryrie DCJ)DELIVERED ON:
11 October 2019
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
26 July 2019
JUDGES:
Gotterson and Philippides and McMurdo JJA
ORDERS:
In each application:
1. Application for leave to appeal refused.
CATCHWORDS:
APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – PROCEDURE – QUEENSLAND – WHEN APPEAL LIES – FROM DISTRICT COURT – where the applicant was convicted in the Magistrates Court of various offences – where the applicant’s appeals were dismissed by the District Court – whether leave to appeal against the decisions of the District Court should be granted – whether there is a reasonable argument that there is any error to be corrected
COUNSEL:
The applicant appeared on his own behalf
D Balic for the respondentSOLICITORS:
The applicant appeared on his own behalf
Director of Public Prosecutions (Queensland) for the respondent
GOTTERSON JA: The applicant, Andrew John Millar, has applied for leave pursuant to s 118 of the District Court of Queensland Act 1967 (Qld) to appeal to this Court against two decisions given by different judges of the District Court in two separate matters involving the applicant. In one of those decisions the subject of CA No 329/18, given on 7 November 2018, a judge of the District Court quashed a conviction for an offence of stealing but otherwise dismissed the appeal as it related to convictions for two other offences. In the other decision, the subject of CA No 155/18 which was given on 28 March 2018, a judge of the District Court ordered the applicant’s appeal be dismissed.
Both applications were heard on the same day. I propose to deal with them in the order in which they were addressed by the applicant at the hearing.
CA No 329/18
On 28 August 2017 in the Magistrates Court at Brisbane, the applicant was found guilty on one charge of entering premises and committing an indictable offence, one charge of stealing and one charge of fraud by dishonestly obtaining property from another.
It was alleged against the applicant that on 9 February 2017, he had entered the premises of Mr Daniel Van Hoof-Harkin and committed at these premises an indictable offence, namely, stealing a bicycle that belonged to Mr Van Hoof-Harkin. It was further alleged that between 9 and 19 February 2017, the applicant dishonestly obtained a sum of money from Mr Richard Weise by selling Mr Van Hoof-Harkin’s bicycle to Mr Weise.[1]
[1]AB 3-9.
Mr Van-Hoof Harkin gave evidence at the hearing in the Magistrates Court. He said that on 9 February 2017, he reported to police that…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Millar v Queensland Police Service and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] QCA 211
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to decide whether the applicant had presented a reasonable argument for an error to be corrected in the District Court's decisions. The court examined the applicant's submissions, which included challenges to the evidence given by witnesses in the Magistrates Court and findings of fact made by the Magistrate. However, the court found these submissions to be irrelevant to the application as they did not pertain to errors on the part of the District Court judge. Furthermore, the court found the applicant's complaints about the findings of fact to be without merit, as the findings were supported by the evidence.
The court held that the applicant's evidence did not constitute "alibi evidence" as defined in the Criminal Code (Qld), as it related to events outside the scope of the alleged offences. Additionally, the court found that the applicant's evidence was not accepted in either proceeding below. The court concluded that the District Court judge's reasons for judgment were sound, and there was no error of law.
As a result, the court refused the applicant's application for leave to appeal against the decisions of the District Court. The court held that there was no reasonable argument for an error to be corrected and that the applicant's grounds for appeal had no reasonable prospects of success. Consequently, the court dismissed the application for leave to appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
In each application:
1. Application for leave to appeal refused.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Consistently with the authorities, it is relevant to consider whether these grounds have any reasonable prospects of success.Consideration of the applicant’s submissions In his written outline of submissions to this Court, the applicant has provided commentary on the evidence given by the witnesses in the Magistrates Court hearing and on the findings of the Magistrate in his reasons for judgment.[27] These submissions are irrelevant to this application as they do not concern an error of a kind articulated in the above grounds of appeal on the part of the learned District Court judge.[27]Applicant’s Outline of Submissions (“AOS”) pages 1-7. The applicant’s written submissions also contained challenges to findings of fact made by her Honour. These include a complaint by the applicant that it is “disturbing” that her Honour found that the Avanti bicycle was sold to Mr Weise by him at “a little over 2 pm. About 2 pm” on 10 February 2017 and a further complaint that her Honour “misstated the dealings” Mr Weise had with the police in their investigation of the sale of the Avanti bicycle.[28][28]AOS pages 7-8. These complaints lack any merit as the applicant has not shown how her Honour made an error of fact having regard to the evidence available upon rehearing. To the contrary, the findings made by her Honour were supported by the evidence. As I understand his submissions, the applicant also challenges her Honour’s factual findings as being against the weight of the evidence, in light of what the applicant contends is “concrete alibi evidence” that was accepted by the magistrate below.[29][29]AOS pages 8-9. The applicant’s complaint is misguided in two respects. The first is that the evidence which the applicant contends is “alibi evidence” does not fall within the meaning of that term as it is used in the Criminal Code (Qld). Evidence in support of an alibi is defined in section 590A thereof as being evidence tending to show that because a person was at a particular area at a particular time, they could not, or it is unlikely that, they were at the place where the offence is alleged to have been committed. In the applicant’s case, it was found that the offence of stealing took place on 8 February 2017 and the offence of fraud occurred on 9 February 2017. Hence, the applicant’s evidence, which is detailed in the next paragraph, about his movements on 18 February 2017 falls outside the scope of alibi evidence as defined. Secondly, a review of the reasons demonstrates that the applicant’s evidence was not accepted in either proceeding below. It is convenient to set out the magistrate’s treatment of the applicant’s evidence in full:[30]“Mr Millar attempted to establish an alibi and the alibi is essentially raised by him in the following way. He provided documentation from his UBET account – UBET or TAB – his betting account – which shows bets being placed on a computer which he says is the computer of his girlfriend – partner, Ms Kim Spain – and I will speak about her evidence shortly. And that shows that he put a $10 bet on the 18th of February at 2.05, with a bet at 2 o’clock and a bet at 1.58. He says he subsequently went to the Valley, over the Story Bridge, and returned to the Lord Stanley Hotel where he put money on his account at 2.59 pm. He says that that shows, clearly – and if the evidence from the cameras on the Story Bridge were available, would show clearly that he did not go to the Holland Park Hotel at 2 o’clock as Mr Wiese said they did. It could not be suggested that Mr Millar did not have opportunity between 2.05 and 2.58 or 2.59 to go to the Holland Park Hotel and it is fair to say that there is no evidence to suggest that the transaction took place at exactly 2 o’clock, in any event, although the transaction register and the seller’s statement – both are timed at 2 pm. They are exhibit 2 and exhibit 3.The transaction register also shows the location that the document was filled out was “at shop”. In response, to which Mr Wiese said, in his evidence, that he had done the wrong thing in accepting the three bikes on that day and that there were two different places where the transactions had taken place so he wrote “at shop” on that document, which is not satisfactory from a legal point of view but would make me take the view that nothing significant turns on that entry.As I said – sorry – and as for the evidence given by the girlfriend, Ms Bain, she gave evidence that Mr Millar was at her place that weekend and I accept that that was – that her evidence is correct in that regard – no reason to believe that she was lying. However, she basically said that he regularly comes over and they basically do whatever each one wants to do, do not keep tabs on each other, they come and go as they please and that she does not like him using her computer to bet…… the clear evidence of hers, which I accept, is that he was at her house, he did put the bets on and that they do not keep tabs on each other and they come and go as they please and that, in fact, he did spend, on his own evidence, some time out of the house in Fortitude Valley. Mr Millar, in his extensive record of interview, speaks about finding a Avanti bike on the side of the road in what he described as a rubbish put out type situation but that was on the 6th or the 8th and, therefore, could not be the bike in question.Of course, once again, this is evidence by Mr Millar given in his own behalf and would, on one interpretation of it, put a bike of this type in his possession and even though he says it was on a different date, which, of course, would not be accepted by me. I am satisfied – Mr Millar also points to the fact that there is no phone calls from his phone to Mr Wiese on the 18th and that appears to be the case from the read outs of his telephone provider. However, once again, it seems to me that that is just one interpretation of how Mr Wiese may have been called and is not a full answer.And even though Mr Wiese was cross-examined in relation to both his credibility, his honesty and the events, he, as I said, impressed me as a witness of truth. He had learned his lesson, it seemed to me, from having falsified the documents and was disappointed that he had been caught up in doing something which he should not have done. He did admit that he had delayed in putting the report into [SPIR] from the first sale on the 10th. He said that he was busy in his IT business. In any event this evidence seems to me to set out a complete history of his dealings with Mr Millar and the bike. There was no reason why he should be discredited in that so that I should not believe his version of it, and I do believe it.”[30]AB 428 l12 – AB 429 l41.