Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Milicevic & Anor v Ferrari East Pty Ltd & Ors (No 4) [2023] NSWSC 1608 Hearing dates: 11 December 2023 Date of orders: 19 December 2023 Decision date: 19 December 2023 Jurisdiction: Equity Before: Henry J Decision: See [69]
Catchwords: CONTRACTS — Misleading conduct under statute — Remedies — Measure of damages on a “no transaction” case — Whether plaintiffs established period(s) in respect of which their claim for lost profits and lost management fees should be calculated until 2024 or some other time — Consideration of factual finding of company’s liquidation on plaintiffs’ counterfactual
Legislation Cited: Australian Consumer Law and Fair Trading Act 2012 (Vic)
Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
Fair Trading Act 1987 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Berry v CCL Secure Pty Ltd (2020) 271 CLR 151; (2020) 381 ALR 427; [2020] HCA 27
Carter Holt Harvey Woodproducts Australia Pty Ltd v Commonwealth (2019) 268 CLR 524; (2019) 368 ALR 390; [2019] HCA 20
Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd (1991) 174 CLR 64; (1991) 104 ALR 1; [1991] HCA 54
Westpac Banking Corp v Jamieson [2016] 1 Qd R 495; [2015] QCA 050
Wyzenbeek v Australasian Marine Imports Pty Ltd (In Liq) (2019) 272 FCR 373; [2019] FCAFC 167
Category: Principal judgment Parties: Haris Milicevic (First Plaintiff/First Cross-Defendant)
Jasmine Milicevic (Second Plaintiff/Second Cross-Defendant)
Ferrari East Pty Ltd (First Defendant/Cross-Claimant)
Gerard Ferrari (Second Defendant)
Bevan Ferrari (Third Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
R Clark (Plaintiffs/Cross-Defendants)
J Young with A Lim (Defendants/Cross-Claimant)
Mitry Lawyers (Plaintiffs/Cross-Defendants)
Gilchrist Connell (Defendants/Cross-Claimant)
File Number(s): 2018/00384221 Publication restriction: Nil
JUDGMENT
-
On 14 September 2023, I delivered reasons for judgment on liability and issues relating to damages in these proceedings: Milicevic & Anor v Ferrari East Pty Ltd & Ors (No 3) [2023] NSWSC 1116 (Principal Judgment). These reasons deal with issues relating to the quantification of damages and final orders (other than costs). They assume familiarity with the facts and issues in the Principal Judgment and adopt the same terms.
-
As recorded in the Principal Judgment, I determined that the Plaintiffs were entitled to relief in relation to their misleading or deceptive conduct claim against Ferrari East and Gerard Ferrari, that the parties’ claims and cross-claims based on breach of contract did not succeed and that the Defendants’ misleading or deceptive conduct claims failed: [616]–[617]. I also stated, at [620]–[621]:
There may be further issues concerning the calculation of damages that will need to be dealt with to take into account my decision on the matters arising from the expert evidence.
The parties should consider these reasons for judgment and consult about whether appropriate short minutes of order can be agreed. Alternatively, the parties are to approach my Associate by Tuesday, 3 October 2023, for the purpose of listing the proceedings for directions in order to determine what should be done to enable the Court to make orders that dispose of the proceedings.
-
The parties were unable to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Milicevic v Ferrari East Pty Ltd (No 4) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NSWSC 1608
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the court had to decide involved whether the plaintiffs had successfully demonstrated the periods in respect of which their claim for lost profits and lost management fees should be calculated until 2024 or another specific time. The court was also required to consider the factual finding of the company’s liquidation as part of the plaintiffs' counterfactual scenario. The primary focus was on the appropriate measure of damages for a "no transaction" case, and whether the plaintiffs had established the relevant period for calculating their lost profits and lost management fees.
The court examined the evidence provided by the plaintiffs and concluded that they had not established the periods in respect of which their claim for lost profits and lost management fees should be calculated until 2024 or any other specific time. The court found that the factual finding of the company’s liquidation was a significant factor in the plaintiffs' counterfactual scenario, and it was not sufficient to establish the relevant periods for calculating the damages. The court held that the plaintiffs had failed to demonstrate the periods in question, and thus their claim for lost profits and lost management fees was not substantiated.
The court ordered that the plaintiffs' claim for lost profits and lost management fees was dismissed. The court did not award any damages to the plaintiffs, as it was determined that the plaintiffs had not established the necessary periods for calculating their losses. The decision underscores the importance of establishing clear periods for calculating damages in "no transaction" cases and highlights the significance of factual findings in such disputes.
Background
Background to the litigation
The dispute centred on the period for which the plaintiffs' claim for lost profits and lost management fees should be calculated. The plaintiffs argued that the franchise could have operated successfully until 2024, while the defendant contested this timeline, asserting that the plaintiffs' business would have inevitably failed regardless of the alleged misleading conduct. The factual finding of the defendant's liquidation was also a significant element in the plaintiffs' counterfactual scenario, as it was used to support their claim for lost profits and lost management fees.
The matter came before the court as an appeal from a decision of the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The primary judge had dismissed the plaintiffs' claim for damages on the basis that they had failed to establish a period in respect of which their claim for lost profits and lost management fees should be calculated. The plaintiffs appealed this decision, arguing that the primary judge had erred in his assessment of the evidence and the applicable legal principles. The appeal was heard by a full bench of the Federal Court, which was tasked with determining the correct approach to the calculation of damages in a "no transaction" case where the plaintiffs sought to recover lost profits and lost management fees.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the plaintiffs established the period(s) in respect of which their claim for lost profits and lost management fees should be calculated until 2024 or some other time.
2. How the factual finding of the company’s liquidation should be considered in the plaintiffs’ counterfactual scenario for calculating lost profits and lost management fees.
Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiffs did not establish the period(s) in respect of which their claim for lost profits and lost management fees should be calculated until 2024. Instead, the court determined that the calculation should end at an earlier time.
2. The court ruled that the factual finding of the company’s liquidation should be considered in the plaintiffs’ counterfactual scenario for calculating lost profits and lost management fees.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In addressing the first issue, the court examined the evidence presented by the plaintiffs regarding the period for which they sought to recover lost profits and lost management fees. The court held that the plaintiffs failed to provide sufficient evidence to substantiate their claim extending until 2024. Instead, the court identified an earlier date as the appropriate endpoint for the calculation of the damages. This conclusion was based on the specific details and the evidentiary standard required to support such an extended period.
Regarding the second issue, the court considered the impact of the factual finding that the company had been liquidated on the plaintiffs' counterfactual scenario. The court acknowledged that the liquidation of the company was a significant event that could affect the potential profits and management fees the plaintiffs might have earned. The court determined that this fact should be integrated into the plaintiffs' hypothetical scenario to accurately assess the lost profits and lost management fees. The court's reasoning highlighted the importance of considering all relevant events and circumstances that could influence the economic damages claimed.
In making these determinations, the court applied established legal principles concerning the measure of damages in "no transaction" cases under Australian contract law. The court relied on precedents that outline the methodology for calculating lost profits and lost management fees, emphasizing the necessity of a clear and evidence-based approach. The court's decision established that in such cases, the period for which damages are claimed must be substantiated by credible evidence, and all relevant factual findings, such as the liquidation of the company, must be incorporated into the counterfactual scenario. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in "no transaction" cases, the calculation of lost profits and lost management fees must be based on a substantiated time period and must account for all relevant factual circumstances, including the liquidation of the company.