Miles v Sydney Meat-Preserving Company Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read
17 CLR 639

operate as an agreement only. Incorporeal hereditaments in themselves are not the subject of tenure. Paragraph 9 treats the bargain as an agreement only, and though that paragraph speaks of the purchase of crops-which means the purchase of Hind- marsh's crops-yet that is consistent with the crops being his by virtue of the agreement while it lasts.

Whichever way the matter is looked at, the defendant has no legal estate of any kind in the land. Since Doe v. Staple (1) it has been, except where altered by the Judicature Acts, firmly established law that the "jurisdiction" of the common law Courts was "confined to legal titles taking care that they do not intrude on the rules of law, nor discuss equitable titles." See per Lord Kenyon C.J. (2). To the same effect per Alderson B., in Due d. Hughes v. Jones (3). In other States of this Commonwealth, as in England, the jurisdiction of a Court is now not SO restricted, and the rights of the parties may in proper circumstances be adjusted in the one action, and at the one expense, but the inviolability of ejectment actions from the intrusion of all equit- able considerations, established in England in 1788, is retained in its full vigour and rigidity in New South Wales to-day. The action cannot be moulded or transformed to meet the circum- stances and SO the defendant entirely fails because the plaintiff has a legal title, and he has not, and because nothing but legal title to possession of the land itself can be considered in this action. The rights of the parties can, of course, if they can afford it, be ultimately determined by a separate formal suit in equity with its normal consequences.

I agree that this appeal should be dismissed. The judgment of GAVAN DUFFY and RICH JJ. was read by

RICH J. During the course of the argument in this case, the meaning of the agreement made between Lawrence Quinn and the defendant on 27th March 1911, and the rights of the parties to the agreement and of the plaintiff under it, were much discussed, but in the end the question was narrowed down to this -Had the defendant any legal title to or in respect of the land

(2) 2 T.R.. 684, at p. 696. (3) 9 M. &W., 372, at p. 377.

17 CLR 640

the subject matter of the action, which could displace the right to

possession claimed by the plaintiff as administratrix of the estate of Lawrence Quinn ? We say "legal title," because, according to the law of New South Wales, merely equitable rights cannot be QUINN.

recognized in this action. It was not contended that any tenancy had been created, but it was suggested that the agreement operated as a grant of a profit à prendre, and gave the defendant an irrevocable right to resist the plaintiff's claim for possession to the land. We do not think that it has any such operation,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Miles v Sydney Meat-Preserving Company Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1913] UKPCHCA 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Miles v Sydney Meat-Preserving Company Limited, the plaintiff, Miles, sought a declaration and injunction against the company and its directors. Miles argued that the company's business was being conducted for the benefit of certain shareholders, specifically graziers, rather than for the general profit of all shareholders, which would allow for dividend payments. Miles further claimed that the company's directors were misusing their powers and engaging in activities that were not in the true intent and meaning of the company's incorporation act. The case involved the interpretation of the company's incorporation act, the deed of settlement, and the rights of the minority shareholders.

The central legal issue was whether the company's business operations were being carried out with the intent of benefiting the general shareholder body by generating profits for dividends or if the operations were instead benefiting only the grazier shareholders. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the company's actions constituted a misuse of powers under the incorporation act and the deed of settlement. The court was also required to consider the rights of minority shareholders in the context of the company's operations and the directors' decisions.

The court, in its reasoning, found that the company's business operations were indeed conducted with the intent of generating profits for all shareholders, not merely for the benefit of the grazier shareholders. The evidence showed that the company had aimed to maintain a stable supply of raw materials and market prices, which indirectly benefited the graziers but ultimately served the company's broader profit-making objectives. The court also determined that the directors had not misused their powers and that the company's actions were within the scope of its incorporation act and the deed of settlement. Therefore, the plaintiff's appeal was dismissed, and the company's actions were upheld as lawful.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal by Miles against the Sydney Meat-Preserving Company Limited be dismissed with costs. The court affirmed that the company had been operating in the best interests of all its shareholders and that there had been no misuse of powers by the company's directors.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established