Mikajlo and Comcare (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

Mikajlo and Comcare (Compensation) [2017] AATA 61 (25 January 2017)

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number

2012/2819

Re

George Mikajlo

APPLICANT

And

Comcare

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President K Bean

Date:25 January 2017

Place:Adelaide

The decision under review is varied so as to provide that as at and from 23 June 2010, compensation liability pursuant to ss 16 and 29 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 was ongoing with respect to Mr Mikajlo’s left shoulder injury only.

.............. [Sgd] ...............................

Deputy President K Bean

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – Commonwealth employees – Injuries sustained to left and right shoulders – Whether ongoing entitlement to compensation under sections 16, 19 or 29 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 – Further claims for compensation in relation to a number of conditions and extent to which Tribunal had jurisdiction – Whether applicant continued to suffer from effects of compensable injury – Whether compensable left shoulder injury continued to result in incapacity, the need to obtain household services and/or treatment – Decision under review varied.

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, ss 4(9), 16, 19, 29 and 67(8)

CASES

Abrahams v Comcare (2006) 93 ALD 147

The Darling Island Stevedoring and Lighterage Co. Limited v Hankinson (1967) 117 CLR 19

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President K Bean

25 January 2017

  1. In July 2007, the applicant, Mr Mikajlo, was working for the Department of Defence in a clerical position at Edinburgh in South Australia when he suffered an injury to his shoulders.  In a compensation claim form dated 10 August 2007, Mr Mikajlo claimed compensation for “left shoulder/arm musculoligamentous injury and rt shoulder” which he indicated occurred on 16 July 2007.  He also said that he first received medical treatment for this injury on 23 July 2007.[1]

    [1]     Exhibit R1, T10/32.

  2. Mr Mikajlo attributed the injury to “lifting a box from a high shelf, weight of box >15kg and height coupled with unexpected weight of box.”[2]  He also provided a medical certificate dated 9 August 2007 from Dr Bruno Rositano, General Practitioner, which indicated that Mr Mikajlo was suffering “left shoulder/arm musculoskeletal injury and right shoulder injury”.[3]

    [2]     Ibid.

    [3]     Ibid.

  3. In a determination of 12 October 2007, a delegate of Comcare initially disallowed Mr Mikajlo’s compensation claim.  However, Mr Mikajlo sought reconsideration of that determination and a reconsideration was subsequently undertaken.  Mr Mikajlo was advised of the outcome of that reconsideration by letter dated 12 May 2008.[4]  The reconsideration delegate ultimately concluded:

    After reviewing the information contained on the employee’s claim file I am satisfied that he has sustained an injury to his left and right shoulders which has aggravated the underlying changes therein.  I am also satisfied that this aggravation occurred in the course of his employment.  I am further satisfied that the date of injury in this circumstance cannot be deemed under section 7(4) of the Act and have amended this to reflect the date the incident occurred, 10 July…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Mikajlo and Comcare (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 61
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Mikajlo against a decision by Comcare regarding his entitlement to compensation under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth) for injuries sustained to his left and right shoulders. The core of the dispute revolved around whether Mr Mikajlo continued to suffer from the effects of his compensable injury as at 23 June 2010, and if so, whether that injury continued to result in incapacity, the need for household services, or treatment. The decision was made by Deputy President K Bean of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were twofold: first, whether Mr Mikajlo was still suffering from the effects of his compensable injury as of 23 June 2010; and second, if he was, whether that injury continued to cause him incapacity, necessitate the procurement of household services, or require ongoing treatment. These questions were central to determining his ongoing entitlement to compensation under sections 16, 19, and 29 of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988*.

The Tribunal considered extensive medical evidence, noting a broad consensus among treating doctors that a lifting incident in June 2007 had affected both shoulders, with the left shoulder being more significantly injured. While some doctors noted pre-existing degenerative changes, the prevailing medical opinion, which the Tribunal preferred over that of Dr Haig, was that Mr Mikajlo developed symptomatic subacromial bursitis and impingement in his left shoulder immediately following the incident, which had not been present before. The Tribunal found overwhelming evidence of ongoing bursitis and impingement in the left shoulder since 2007. Regarding the right shoulder, the evidence suggested it was initially temporarily aggravated and recovered, but subsequently flared up due to overuse while compensating for the left shoulder's condition.

The Tribunal varied the decision under review, ordering that as at and from 23 June 2010, compensation liability pursuant to sections 16 and 29 of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* was ongoing with respect to Mr Mikajlo’s left shoulder only. No costs order was made at that stage, but Mr Mikajlo was advised that he could seek an order for reasonable disbursements incurred in the course of the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

It follows that, in broad terms, the issues for my determination are:(a)Whether, as at 23 June 2010, Mr Mikajlo continued to suffer from the effects of his compensable injury; and(b)If so, whether the compensable injury continued to result in incapacity, the need to obtain household services and/or treatment in relation to the injury.THE MEDICAL EVIDENCE There is a broad consensus among the doctors who have assessed Mr Mikajlo that the lifting incident affected his left and right shoulders differently. A majority of the doctors also agree that the symptoms Mr Mikajlo experienced in his shoulders after the incident were caused by damage to his shoulders, and that there was more damage done to the left shoulder than to the right. As alluded to above, Dr Rositano was Mr Mikajlo’s treating General Practitioner at the time of the injury and has continued to be his GP since then. A few months after the incident he provided a report dated 2 October 2007 in which he indicated:Mr. Mikajlo presented on the 23rd July, 2007 with a history of having lifted a box weighing around 30 kg., when he experienced left arm pain.…He presented on the 9th of August 2007 when the Physiotherapist felt he had sustained a torn muscle and he was feeling depressed as his right shoulder was also giving him problems, probably due to overuse.…He sustained a tear of his left rotator cuff and subacromial bursitis with impingement.The causative factor is the heavy lifting superimposed on pre-existing degenerative changes. He has a past history of osteoarthritis with cervical spondylosis.I feel the current condition is an aggravation of pre-existing degenerative conditions.There is a direct relationship with his condition and lifting a 30 kg. box at work.[10][10] Exhibit 2, Tab 28, p 1 and p 5. In his oral evidence at the hearing, Dr Rositano confirmed that as a result of the lifting accident in June 2007 he thought that Mr Mikajlo:… [s]uffered strain to his musculature in the shoulders, the supraspinatus, and he developed a bursitis and aggravated pre-existing degenerative changes in his shoulders.[11][11] Transcript, 9 March 2016, p 41. With respect to the impact of the lifting injury on each shoulder, Dr Rositano stated:Well the 2007 injury I think mainly his left shoulder was more affected. I think that the right shoulder was temporarily aggravated, but his left shoulder was – was the one that was injured more I think in that situation.[12][12] Ibid, p 42. With respect to the right shoulder he said:I think just strained the rotator cuff, just strained it, strained the muscles, and that seemed to settle down and then because the left shoulder was bad and he was overusing the right shoulder that flared up again. Shoulder injuries are notorious for doing that, they’re so unpredictable.[13][13] Ibid. He went on to confirm that in his opinion, immediately after the 2007 incident, Mr Mikajlo developed tendonitis, bursitis and an aggravation of pre-existing degenerative changes in his left shoulder. However, with respect to the right shoulder this was a soft tissue strain that recovered, or would have recovered but for problems which subsequently developed due to compensating for the inability to use the left shoulder. In his opinion, the need to compensate with the right shoulder ultimately led to the development of similar problems in the right shoulder to those which developed in the left shoulder immediately following the incident. He also indicated that he regarded the overuse aspect of the right shoulder condition as ongoing. In other words, his evidence was that the right shoulder condition may not have been as bad as it currently was if not for the overuse due to Mr Mikajlo’s left shoulder condition.[14][14] Ibid.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In view of my decision in his favour, I note that, pursuant to subs 67(8) of the SRC Act, Mr Mikajlo may be entitled to have any reasonable disbursements he has incurred paid by Comcare. As I am unaware as to what expenses Mr Mikajlo may have incurred, if any, I have decided not to make a costs order at this stage. However, it will be open to Mr Mikajlo to seek such an order if he has incurred disbursements in the course of the application. DECISION The decision under review is varied so as to provide that as at and from 23 June 2010, compensation liability pursuant to ss 16 and 29 of the SRC Act was ongoing with respect to Mr Mikajlo’s left shoulder only.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Mikajlo made only limited oral submissions at the hearing. However, he made detailed written submissions in response to Mr Krupka’s written submissions by way of a letter received by the Tribunal on 29 April 2016 in which he highlighted the relevance of his various medical “co-morbidities”. I have carefully read this letter and taken it into account in making my Decision.CONSIDERATION I will first address the question of whether the effects of Mr Mikajlo’s compensable injuries were continuing as at 23 June 2010, before turning to the issue of whether there was ongoing liability under ss 16, 19 and 29.As at 23 June 2010 did Mr Mikajlo continue to suffer the effects of his compensable injury? One of the difficulties I have with accepting the respondent’s submissions is that, as I have explained above, Mr Haig is the only doctor to have examined Mr Mikajlo and subsequently formed the opinion that his shoulder symptoms were attributable to his neck condition. Drs Atkinson, Awerbuch, Mills, Leonello and Rositano have all reached the conclusion that Mr Mikajlo’s shoulder symptoms are due to shoulder pathology, albeit they have expressed slightly different views as to the relative contributions to his symptoms from tendonitis, bursitis and rotator cuff pathology. The effect of the evidence is that Mr Mikajlo began to complain shortly after the lifting incident of shoulder pain which had developed at the time of that incident, and was affecting both shoulders. With respect to the left shoulder, Ds Rositano, Atkinson and Mills all consider that there was an interaction between the lifting incident and the state of Mr Mikajlo’s left shoulder at the time, such that he developed symptomatic left subacromial bursitis with impingement immediately following that incident. There is some evidence to suggest that the mechanism for this may have involved a partial tear of the left supraspinatus tendon. However, regardless of whether in fact Mr Mikajlo did tear his tendon in the incident, or whether this resulted in symptoms, these doctors all accept that he developed a symptomatic impingement syndrome immediately following the incident, which had not been present beforehand. In addition, in my view, there is overwhelming evidence that Mr Mikajlo has suffered from bursitis with a degree of impingement since 2007, particularly in his left shoulder. Furthermore, while there is one reference to “bilateral shoulder acromiohumeral rotator cuff impingement arthropathy” in Dr Bradley’s report of 17 August 2004,[64] there is no evidence of Mr Mikajlo suffering from symptomatic subacromial bursitis prior to the incident of 2007. The evidence is that although there may well have been some prior thickening of the left and/or right bursae prior to the incident, this did not appear to be causing symptoms, or at least was not causing any significant symptoms.[64] Exhibit 2, Tab 16, p 6. In light of this evidence, I have concluded that I prefer the evidence of all of the other doctors to that of Mr Haig with respect to the cause of Mr Mikajlo’s shoulder symptoms following the 2007 lifting incident. I do not accept Mr Haig’s opinion that Mr Mikajlo’s increased shoulder symptomatology related to his degenerative neck condition. Rather, I accept the opinion of the other doctors that the symptoms in Mr Mikajlo’s left shoulder were due to pathology in that shoulder, most likely some combination of subacromial bursitis, rotator cuff damage/degeneration and a degree of tendonitis.