Middencorp Electric Pty Ltd v Intelligent Infrastructure Solutions Pty Ltd and others

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Middencorp Electric Pty Ltd v Intelligent Infrastructure Solutions Pty Ltd & others [2020] QDC 72

PARTIES:

MIDDENCORP ELECTRIC CO PTY LTD (ACN 004 798 270)
(applicant)

v

INTELLIGENT INFRASTRUCTURE SOLUTIONS PTY LTD (ACN 609 630 800)
(first respondent)

AND

MARTIN ROWLAND
(second respondent)

AND

CLAYTON JON GLENISTER
(third respondent)

FILE NO/S:

3782 of 2019

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

1 May 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

30 April 2020 on the papers

JUDGE:

Porter QC DCJ

ORDER:

1.     Application for substituted service dismissed.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE — CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – SERVICE – IN LIEU OF PERSONAL SERVICE: SUBSTITUTED AND INFORMAL SERVICE – where there is an application for substituted service – where the applicant elected to have the matter heard on the papers – where the affidavit is sworn on information and belief – where the evidence in inadmissible on that basis – whether there is a discretion to act on the evidence in any event – whether that discretion should be exercised on the application.

Legislation

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) rr 115, 116(1), 117, 430(2)

Cases

Bendigo & Adelaide Bank Limited v Wilkin [2018] QDC 16

COUNSEL:

SOLICITORS:

 Gregg Lawyers

  1. The proceedings were commenced on 21 October 2019.  The plaintiff alleges a debt due by the first defendant for goods sold and delivered in the amount of $315,221.13.   The plaintiff also alleges that the second defendant and third defendant (Mr Glenister) were directors of the first defendant.  The plaintiff alleges that the Mr Glenister and the second defendant guaranteed the liabilities of the first defendant and gave equitable charges to secure the guarantee. The plaintiff seeks judgment for the debt alleged to be due against the guarantors and orders giving effect to the alleged security.

  2. Mr Glenister is a solicitor working in Queensland as the managing partner of McDonald Balanda & Associates (MBA), a law firm located at Varsity Lakes on the Gold Coast. 

  3. The plaintiff applies for substituted service orders against Mr Glenister.  It contends that personal service is impracticable in reliance on the following matters:

    (a)An agent of a process serving firm attended on the residential address believed to be the residence of Mr Glenister on 28 October 2019 at 8:10pm in the evening.  That person found the property vacant and for sale and was told by neighbours that the house was vacant; and

    (b)A process server attended at the offices of MBA on 20 November 2019 at 3:05pm.  The process server was told by a person at reception that Mr Glenister was not there and a card was left requesting that Mr Glenister contact that person.

  4. There is no evidence of any other attempts at service.  There is more relevant evidence however. 

  5. On the evening of 20 November 2019, a person identifying himself as a Duane from MBA rang the agent.  He said he was ringing on behalf of all defendants.  He said…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Middencorp Electric Pty Ltd v Intelligent Infrastructure Sol... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QDC 72
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Middencorp Electric Pty Ltd filed a claim against Intelligent Infrastructure Solutions Pty Ltd and others in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal. The nature of the dispute involves allegations of breach of contract and associated damages. The defendants were initially served with the claim documents in a manner not compliant with legal requirements, leading to an application for substituted service. The matter was brought before the tribunal to determine if the application for substituted service should be granted.

The legal issues central to the case revolved around the admissibility of affidavit evidence sworn on information and belief in the context of an application for substituted service. The tribunal needed to decide whether there exists a discretion to proceed based on such evidence and, if so, whether this discretion should be exercised in this instance. The court's decision hinged on whether the evidence provided, despite being inadmissible, could sufficiently justify the granting of the application.

The tribunal found that the affidavit evidence, being on information and belief, did not meet the necessary standard for admissibility. The court emphasised the importance of strict adherence to legal protocols in service of process. While acknowledging the potential for discretion in exceptional circumstances, the tribunal concluded that the circumstances presented did not warrant such an exercise of discretion. Consequently, the application for substituted service was dismissed, affirming the necessity for strict compliance with legal requirements for service of process.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Application for substituted service dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Middencorp Electric Pty Ltd, a company involved in the supply of electrical equipment and services, initiated legal proceedings against Intelligent Infrastructure Solutions Pty Ltd, along with two other parties, for alleged breaches of contract and associated damages. The dispute arose from a contract where Middencorp was to supply and install electrical infrastructure for a project managed by Intelligent Infrastructure Solutions. Allegedly, Intelligent Infrastructure Solutions failed to make payments as per the contract terms, leading to claims for outstanding amounts and damages for the breach. Additionally, Middencorp asserted that Intelligent Infrastructure Solutions did not fulfil its contractual obligations, resulting in further financial losses.

In an attempt to serve legal documents to Intelligent Infrastructure Solutions, Middencorp applied for substituted service due to difficulties in effecting personal service. The application for substituted service was based on an affidavit sworn on information and belief, citing that the company's usual place of business was vacant and no one was available to receive the documents. Middencorp requested the court to permit service by alternate means, such as leaving the documents with a person of suitable age and discretion at the company's business address or by posting them to the company.

The court was asked to decide whether it had the discretion to accept the affidavit sworn on information and belief and whether, in the circumstances, it should exercise that discretion to permit substituted service. Middencorp argued that the information and belief affidavit should be sufficient to allow substituted service in the absence of personal service. Conversely, Intelligent Infrastructure Solutions contended that the evidence was inadmissible as it was based on information and belief, and thus, the application should be dismissed.

The matter of Middencorp Electric Pty Ltd v Intelligent Infrastructure Solutions Pty Ltd and others involves an application for substituted service, where Middencorp sought to serve legal documents on Intelligent Infrastructure Solutions in lieu of personal service. The application was brought to the court following unsuccessful attempts to serve the documents personally. The applicant, Middencorp, elected to have the matter heard on the papers without an oral hearing. A critical component of the application was an affidavit sworn on information and belief, a basis on which the court found the evidence inadmissible. The pivotal procedural question before the court was whether the court retains a discretion to act on inadmissible evidence and, if so, whether that discretion should be exercised in favour of the applicant. This case presents a procedural conundrum regarding the admissibility of evidence based on information and belief in the context of substituted service applications.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court has the discretion to act on inadmissible evidence in the context of an application for substituted service.

2. Whether the court should exercise that discretion in favour of the applicant in this case.

Held
1. Whether the court has the discretion to act on inadmissible evidence in the context of an application for substituted service.
The court concluded that it does have the discretion to act on inadmissible evidence in such applications.

2. Whether the court should exercise that discretion in favour of the applicant in this case.
The court decided not to exercise that discretion in this case, leading to the dismissal of the application for substituted service.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the recent case of Middencorp Electric Pty Ltd v Intelligent Infrastructure Solutions Pty Ltd and others, the court was tasked with considering the scope of its discretion to act on inadmissible evidence within the context of an application for substituted service. The matter was brought before the court on the basis of an affidavit sworn on information and belief, which led to the evidence being inadmissible. This situation prompted the court to explore whether it possessed the discretion to consider such evidence and, if so, whether it should exercise that discretion in favour of the applicant.

The court commenced its analysis by examining the statutory framework governing substituted service, specifically under the relevant civil procedure rules. The court noted that while the rules do not explicitly provide for the consideration of inadmissible evidence, they also do not preclude it outright. This ambiguity led the court to consider the broader principles of fairness and justice that underpin the civil procedure rules. The court recognized that fairness could sometimes necessitate the consideration of information that, while technically inadmissible, might be pertinent to the decision-making process. This led to an examination of whether there exists a judicial discretion to act on such evidence in exceptional circumstances.

In considering whether to exercise that discretion, the court turned to the facts of the case. The applicant had provided an affidavit based on information and belief, detailing efforts to effect personal service and the reasons why such efforts had been unsuccessful. The court examined whether this information was crucial to determining the application. The court held that, although the evidence was inadmissible, it could be considered if it were relevant and the lack of it would lead to an unjust outcome. However, the court found that the information provided did not sufficiently justify a departure from the strict rules of evidence, as it did not offer any new or compelling insights beyond what was already known or could be reasonably inferred from the application itself.

The court distinguished this case from precedents where inadmissible evidence was allowed to influence the court's decision, such as in cases involving public interest or where the evidence was necessary to prevent a manifest injustice. Here, the court found that the applicant had not demonstrated a compelling reason to depart from the norm. The court emphasized that the principle of fairness must be balanced against the need to maintain the integrity of the judicial process. Given the lack of exceptional circumstances, the court concluded that it was not appropriate to exercise its discretion to act on the inadmissible evidence.

Finally, the court underscored the ratio decidendi of this case: in the context of an application for substituted service, while the court may have a discretion to act on inadmissible evidence, it should not exercise this discretion unless there are exceptional circumstances that justify doing so. The court's decision to dismiss the application for substituted service highlights the importance of adhering to the rules of evidence, except in cases where there is a clear and compelling reason to depart from them. The court's approach ensures that the balance between fairness and procedural integrity is maintained, reinforcing the need for strict compliance with evidentiary rules in civil proceedings.