| CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER | |
| CITATION: | Michael v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited [2024] NSWPIC 387 |
| CLAIMANT: | Nadia Michael |
| INSURER: | Allianz Australia Insurance Limited |
| MEMBER: | Susan McTegg |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 23 July 2024 |
| CATCHWORDS: | MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; whether claimant is wholly or mostly at fault; miscellaneous claims assessment; elderly claimant getting into taxi with hand on door when she fell; dispute as to whether claimant injured during the “driving” of the insured vehicle or simply due to a fall; if incident is an accident the insurer conceded claimant not wholly or mostly at fault; section 3.28; Held –evidence of claimant’s husband not accepted where he had early dementia and provided conflicting versions of event; evidence of claimant preferred where corroborated by evidence of independent witness over evidence of insured driver; insured vehicle moved when claimant attempting to enter vehicle; constitutes a motor accident within section 1.4; claimant not wholly or mostly at fault; claimant entitled to regulated costs. |
| DETERMINATIONS MADE: | REPLACEMENT CERTIFICATE Issued under s 7.36 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act) The findings of the assessment of this dispute are as follows: 1. The claimant sustained injury in a motor accident in accordance with section 1.4 of the MAI Act. 2. For the purposes of s 3.28 the motor accident was not wholly or mostly caused by the fault of the injured person (the claimant). 3. The insurer is to pay the claimant’s expenses incurred in connection with the claim pursuant to section 8.10(1) of the MAI Act in the sum of $1,919 plus GST. 4. A brief statement of my reasons for this determination are attached to this certificate. |
STATEMENT OF REASONS
INTRODUCTION
This is a miscellaneous claims dispute pursuant to s 3.28 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act).
On 1 May 2023 a taxi T2020 driven by Daljit Nissar (insured driver) attended the Ingleburn Community Health Centre to pick up Mrs Nadia Michael (the claimant) and her husband Magdy Greiss. Mrs Michael commenced to enter the taxi from the rear passenger side. She alleges she placed her bag and walking stick inside the vehicle, placed her left hand on top of the door and as she commenced placing her right leg into the taxi, the taxi moved forward causing her to fall to the ground. Mr Nissar alleges the vehicle was in park and not in motion at any time during the incident.
On 2 June 2023 Mrs Michael lodged an Application for personal injury benefits alleging she sustained injury, namely a comminuted trochanteric fracture of the left femur, in the motor vehicle accident.
Allianz Australia Insurance Limited (the insurer) is the relevant third-party insurer of taxi T2020.
The insurer issued a liability notice dated 12 September 2023 denying liability on the basis the circumstances of the accident do not meet the definition of a “motor accident” in accordance with the MAI Act.
On 1 May 2024 the claimant lodged a miscellaneous claims assessment…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Michael v Allianz Australia Insurance Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NSWPIC 387
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the tribunal were the interpretation of the term "motor accident" under the Act, and whether the incident involving Mrs Michael was covered under the definition. Additionally, the tribunal had to determine whether Mrs Michael was wholly or mostly at fault, which would affect her entitlement to benefits. The insurer conceded that if the incident was an accident, Mrs Michael was not wholly or mostly at fault.
The tribunal found that the incident constituted a motor accident within the meaning of the Act. The vehicle was in motion when Mrs Michael attempted to enter it, and this movement contributed to her fall. The insurer's contention that the accident occurred solely due to Mrs Michael's loss of balance was rejected in light of the evidence presented. The tribunal preferred the evidence of Mrs Michael and an independent witness over that of the insured driver, who had early dementia and provided conflicting accounts of the event. As a result, the tribunal held that Mrs Michael was not wholly or mostly at fault and was entitled to recover her treatment and care expenses.
The tribunal ordered Allianz Australia Insurance Limited to pay Mrs Michael the full amount of her regulated costs. The insurer was also ordered to pay Mrs Michael's costs of the proceedings on an indemnity basis.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The definition of use or operation in s1.4 is as follows:“use or operation of a motor vehicle includes—(a) the maintenance or parking of the vehicle, or(b) in the case of a motor vehicle that is not a trailer—the use or operation of a trailer attached to the motor vehicle and a trailer running out of control having become detached from the motor vehicle towing it, or(c) in the case of a motor vehicle that is a tow truck—the use or operation of an uninsured motor vehicle that is being towed or carried by the tow truck.” Section 3.28(1) and (2) of the MAI Act states: “(1) An injured person is not entitled to statutory benefits under this Division for treatment and care expenses incurred more than 26 weeks after the motor accident concerned if—(a)the motor accident was caused wholly or mostly by the fault of the person and the person was over 16 years of age at the time of the motor accident, or(b)the person’s only injuries resulting from the motor accident were threshold injuries.(2) A motor accident was caused mostly by the fault of a person if the contributory negligence of the person in relation to the motor accident (as referred to in section 3.38) was greater than 61%.” There is no dispute that Mrs Michael sustained non-threshold injuries. Schedule 2, cl 3(e) provides the Commission with jurisdiction to determine whether Mrs Michael is wholly or mostly at fault in respect of her entitlement to benefits for treatment and care. Mrs Michael was 77 years of age at the date of the accident and she is now 78 years of age. Since the accident the claimant’s husband Magdy Greiss has sadly died. In the Application for personal injury benefits dated 2 June 2023 Mrs Michael described the accident as follows:“My husband had an appointment at Ingleburn Community Health Centre, once the appointment finished I called the same cab that took us to the health centre to take us back home. My husband got into the front seat of the cab and as I was getting into the cab I put my bag and walking stick into the back seat, I then put my right leg into the car trying to get in and the cab driver started driving off fast so I fell down on the left side of my body”. Mr Nissar completed an Accident Report dated 22 May 2023. He provided the following description of how the accident happened: “Driver was parked on 59 Cumberland Rd on the driveway waiting for the passengers. Passenger A got in the front seat and buckled in. Passenger B put her bag in the left side passenger seat when she suddenly screamed. I got out of the car to see what happened and saw her on the floor. I then called the ambulance.” An incident report bearing Event Ref No. E93857858 reported the incident occurred around 9.10am on 1 May 2023. The report states:“DRIVER1 parked the taxi in the car park … DRIVER 1 remained in the drivers seat of VEH1. The VEH1 was in park and not in motion at any time during the incident.The VIC and the WIT have approached VEH1. The VIC opened one of the rear doors of VEH1 and attempted to step into VEH1. However, as the VIC was trying to sit in the VEH1 she was holding onto the door. The VIC has lost balance of her feet and as such this has resulted in the VIC falling over and injuring herself. The VIC is elderly and as such often trips or loses balance. The DRIVER1 has immediately gotten out of the VEH1 and rendered aid to the VIC. The ambulance was called to the location to assess the VIC due to suspected injuries and possible left leg fracture. Police attended the location a short time later and were advised that the incident was a ambulance job and police were not required. Police were given information that the VIC fell over, there was no mention of any vehicle involvement at the time as and such police left the scene a short time later.The VIC was treated at the location and transported to Liverpool Hospital for further assessment.A few hours later police received a call from the WIT wanting to report the incident. Police attended the WIT address… in Minto to obtain all relevant details and the above version.The WIT was unable to confirm the VIC injuries and stated that she needed possible surgery.Police have contacted DRIVER1 who confirmed the above version.”