Michael John Stafford v Automotive Distributors Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Michael John Stafford to application under section 92 of the Act by Automotive Distributors Limited to remove trade mark registration number 713318(12) - Blueprint - in the name of Australian Carburettors and Fuel Injection.

Delegate: Iain Campbell Thompson
Representation: Removal Opponent: Opponent represented himself at originally scheduled hearing then appointed Kelvin Lord of Lord & Co for adjourned hearing by teleconference
Removal Applicant: Eric Ziehlke, solicitor, of Chrysiliou IP
Decision: 2015 ATMO 40
s92 opposition to removal application; ‘owner’ of Trade Mark a cancelled business name; no legal personality could exist behind the business name; no use by registered owner of the Trade Mark.
No reason to exercise Registrar’s discretion.
Trade Mark to be removed from the Register

Background

1. This decision concerns an application filed on 14 June 2012 by Automotive Distributors Limited (‘the Removal Applicant’) of the United Kingdom under paragraph 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 to totally remove the registration detailed below from the Register of Trade Marks:

Registration No:         713318
Priority Date:             19 July 1996
Owner:  Australian Carburettors and Fuel Injection

Goods:Class 7: Fuel systems components especially carburettor components and petrol and diesel fuel injection systems components; ignition system components

(‘the Goods’)

Trade Mark:               BLUEPRINT

(‘the Trade Mark’)

2. On 19 September 2012 Michael John Stafford (‘the Removal Opponent’) of Perth, Western Australia, filed Notice of Opposition to the removal of the Trade Mark from the Register stating that “the [Trade Mark] has been used for the past 16 years and is currently still in use in 5 other businesses and companies owned by me”.

3. The parties both filed evidence as further detailed below.  Thereafter the parties requested to be heard.  As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks I heard the submissions of the parties at a hearing in Canberra on 22 August 2014.  Mr Eric Ziehlke of Chrysiliou IP represented the Removal Applicant and the Removal Opponent represented himself.  Towards the end of that hearing Mr Stafford expressed some regret that he had not had legal representation.  I informed him that I was prepared to adjourn proceedings in order that he could appoint a legal representative to present his submissions and address the arguments of the Removal Applicant.  Mr Stafford requested such an adjournment.  The hearing reconvened on 21 November 2014 – the Removal Applicant’s representation remained unchanged and the Removal Opponent was represented by Kelvin Lord of Lord & Co by teleconference prior to which he had filed a written outline of submissions.

The Law

4. Section 92 of the Act relevantly states:

92Application for removal of trade mark from Register etc.

(1)Subject to subsection (3), a person may apply to the Registrar to have a trade mark that is or may be registered removed from the Register.

(2)The application:

(a)must be in accordance with the regulations; and

(b)may be made in respect of any or all of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Michael John Stafford v Automotive Distributors Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] ATMO 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Michael John Stafford against a decision of the Registrar of Trade Marks. The dispute centred on whether Trade Mark No. 1271222M, registered under the business name "Australian Carburettors and Fuel Injection," had been used during the three-year period preceding 14 May 2012, as required by section 92(4)(b) of the relevant legislation. The court was required to determine if the trade mark could be considered to have been used by its registered owner, or the legal personality behind that owner, during the specified period.

The court's reasoning focused on the registration status of the business name "Australian Carburettors and Fuel Injection." It noted that while the business name was registered on 10 May 1996, it was subsequently cancelled on 4 July 1997. This cancellation occurred well before the relevant three-year period ending on 14 May 2012. Consequently, the court found that there was no registered business name, nor a registered owner of the trade mark, in existence during the period critical for assessing use under section 92(4)(b). The court distinguished this case from previous authorities such as *Crazy Ron’s Communications Pty Ltd v Mobileworld Communications*, which dealt with amendments to trade mark applications, by highlighting that the issue here was not one of amendment but of the existence of a legal personality capable of using the trade mark during the statutory period.

The court concluded that because the business name and, by extension, the registered owner of the trade mark did not exist during the relevant three-year period, the trade mark could not have been used by its registered owner or the legal personality behind it. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Michael John Stafford initiated legal proceedings against Automotive Distributors Limited, primarily concerning the ownership and registration of a trade mark. The trade mark in question, numbered 1271222M, was registered under the business name 'Australian Carburettors and Fuel Injection' on 10 May 1996. However, this registration was subsequently cancelled on 4 July 1997. Despite the cancellation, Stafford argued that he, or one of his companies, should be recognised as the rightful owner of the trade mark. Stafford contended that the trade mark had been used by its registered owner during the relevant three-year period ending on 14 May 2012, a period critical for assessing compliance under section 92(4(b)).

The factual events leading to this dispute began with the original registration of the trade mark by 'Australian Carburettors and Fuel Injection'. Following the cancellation of the business name on 4 July 1997, Stafford sought to assert his claim to the trade mark. He submitted documentation to support his assertion that he, or one of his companies, should be recognised as the owner. This included a certificate from Lord & Co and written submissions to substantiate his position. Stafford's argument was predicated on the premise that there was legal personality behind the business name at the time of registration, but no registered business name during the relevant period, which he believed precluded Automotive Distributors Limited from claiming ownership.

In response, Automotive Distributors Limited maintained that the cancellation of the business name registration in 1997 effectively terminated any rights or claims by Stafford or his companies to the trade mark. They argued that the trade mark had not been used by its registered owner during the relevant period, thus disqualifying Stafford from asserting ownership. This contention was based on the fact that the business name was not in force during the three-year period prior to 14 May 2012, a critical factor under section 92(4(b)) of the relevant statute.

The case of Michael John Stafford v Automotive Distributors Limited originated as a first-instance hearing in the Federal Court of Australia. The plaintiff, Michael John Stafford, brought proceedings against Automotive Distributors Limited, alleging infringement of a trade mark and seeking remedies under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth). The matter proceeded through several key procedural steps, including the filing of originating documents and preliminary applications. Notably, there were disputes concerning the proper identification of the trade mark applicant and the validity of the trade mark registration. The defendants challenged the plaintiff’s standing to bring the action and questioned the accuracy of the applicant's name in the registration. Throughout the proceedings, interlocutory orders were made addressing these preliminary issues, with the Court examining the legislative provisions of the Trade Marks Act, particularly sections 65(5) and 92(4)(b), in the context of prior decisions such as King v Registrar of Trade Marks [1990] FCA 4; 23 FCR 191 and Bramco Pty Ltd v Showgirl Productions Pty Ltd [1992] FCA 1262; 38 FCR 244. The case also drew comparisons with Crazy Ron’s Communications Pty Ltd and Ors v Mobileworld Communications and Ors [2004] FCAFC 196, particularly in relation to the amendment of applicant details and the effect of such amendments under the statutory framework. Ultimately, the Court was tasked with determining the validity of the trade mark registration and the plaintiff's standing to bring the action, without delving into the substantive legal arguments or outcomes.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Can a mistake in the spelling of an applicant's name be amended pursuant to s 65(5) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth)?
2. Does s 65(5) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) permit the substitution of one person for another as an applicant due to a mistaken application?
3. If s 65(5) allows for a change in the identity of the applicant due to a 'mistake' in the application, would this place the substituted applicant in a better position than an applicant whose name was not fully recorded in the original application?
4. Was the business name 'Australian Carburettors and Fuel Injection' the registered holder of the Trade Mark during the relevant three-year period ending on 14 May 2012?
5. If not, can Mr Stafford or one of his companies be considered the legal personality behind the registered business name 'Australian Carburettors and Fuel Injection' during the relevant period?

Held
1. The court concluded that a mistake in the spelling of an applicant's name may be amendable pursuant to s 65(5) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), although it is not necessary to decide on this point.
2. The court held that s 65(5) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) does not permit the substitution of one person for another as an applicant due to a mistaken application.
3. The court determined that if s 65(5) allows for a change in the identity of the applicant due to a 'mistake' in the application, this would place the substituted applicant in a better position than an applicant whose name was not fully recorded in the original application, which was not the legislative intention.
4. The court found that the business name 'Australian Carburettors and Fuel Injection' was not the registered holder of the Trade Mark during the relevant three-year period ending on 14 May 2012 as it was cancelled on 4 July 1997.
5. The court concluded that neither Mr Stafford nor one of his companies could be considered the legal personality behind the registered business name 'Australian Carburettors and Fuel Injection' during the relevant period, as there was no registered business name at that time.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

However, some doubt might exist in the light of Crazy Ron’s Communications Pty Ltd and Ors v Mobileworld Communications and Ors[1] [2004] FCAFC 196 (‘Crazy Ron’s’). When considering the operation of the former subsection 65(5), the Court stated (at [125] and [126]):It may well be, although it is not necessary to decide, that a mistake in the spelling of the name of an applicant could be amended pursuant to s 65(5). Such an amendment perhaps might properly be characterised as an ‘amendment to any other particular specified in the application’ within the meaning of s 65(5) of the TM Act. However, we do not think that s 65(5) is intended to permit the substitution of one person for another as an applicant simply because the first person ‘mistakenly’ applied for registration of a trade mark, whatever may have been the error or misunderstanding that led to the mistake. Section 65(5) should not be construed as permitting to be done by mere amendment of an application what should be done by withdrawal of the application and filing of another application. That is to say, the provision does not authorise the substitution of one person for another person as the applicant for registration. (Stress added)We should add that if the respondents’ argument were correct, s 65(5) of the TM Act would authorise an amendment changing the applicant’s identity as from the date the application was filed. This would be so notwithstanding that the statutory scheme permits rectification of a failure to ‘specify the name of the applicant’ only on the basis that the application is taken to be filed as from the date the failure is rectified. Thus if s 65(5) allows a change of identity of the applicant by reason of a ‘mistake’ in the application, the substituted applicant would be in a better position than an applicant whose name was not fully recorded in the original application. We do not think that this was the legislative intention. (Emphasis provided) However, the case before me is readily distinguishable from King, Bramco and Crazy Ron’s: the business name entered as the owner of the Trade Mark, 1271222M ‘Australian Carburettors and Fuel Injection’, was registered on 10 May 1996 and was cancelled on 4 July 1997 so it was not in force during the three year period ending on 14 May 2012. Indeed, as I have mentioned, the certificate proffered by Lord & Co along with the written submissions confirms that the business name was cancelled on 4 July 1997. Thus, although there may have been legal personality behind the business name (namely ‘Australian Carburettors and Fuel Injection’) stated to be the owner of the Trade Mark at the date on which it was registered – 19 July 1996 – there was no registered holder of the business name (or owner of the Trade Mark) during the period which is relevant for the purposes of section 92(4 (b) – that is the three year period ending on 14 May 2012. Mr Stafford, or one of his companies, could not have been the legal personality behind the registered business name ‘Australian Carburettors and Fuel Injection’ as there was no registered business name at that time. It follows that the Trade Mark cannot have been used by its registered owner (or the legal personality behind the registered owner) during the relevant period.