CITATION: Micallef v DPP & Anor [2001] NSWSC 1172 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Common Law Division FILE NUMBER(S): SC 13757/01 HEARING DATE(S): 12 December, 2001 JUDGMENT DATE:
17 December 2001PARTIES :
Alan George Micallef - Plaintiff
Director of Public Prosecutions - 1st defendant
Michael Price - 2nd defendantJUDGMENT OF: Hidden J at 1
LOWER COURT
JURISDICTION :Local Court LOWER COURT
FILE NUMBER(S) :LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :M Price LCM
COUNSEL : SOLICITORS: R Finlayson - plaintiff
Solicitor for Public Prosecutions - 1st defendant
I V Knight - 2nd defendant
CATCHWORDS: CRIMINAL LAW - committal proceedings - application for attendance of a witness under s48E(2)(b) Justices Act - whether magistrate applied correct test LEGISLATION CITED: Justices Act, 1902 CASES CITED: Director of Public Prosecutions v Losurdo (1998) 44 NSWLR 618
Hanna v Kearney (Studdert J unreported 28.5.98)
R v Basha (1989) 39 ACrim R 337
Dawson v DPP [1999] NSWSC 1147
Acuthan v Coates (1986) 6 NSWLR 472DECISION: See para 15
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
HIDDEN J
Monday 17 December 2001
13757/2001 – Alan George Micallef v Director of Public Prosecutions & Anor
JUDGMENT
1 HIDDEN J: The plaintiff, Alan George Micallef, is to face committal proceedings at the Burwood Local Court in respect of a charge of armed robbery with wounding. He is also charged with a number of related offences, which I need not mention. The first defendant, the Director of Public Prosecutions, has the conduct of the prosecution. On 27 November last the plaintiff applied, under s48E(2)(b) of the Justices Act, for a direction requiring the attendance at those proceedings of one of the prosecution witnesses. By the terms of that provision, it was necessary for the plaintiff to show that there were “substantial reasons why, in the interests of justice, the witness should attend to give oral evidence”. The second defendant, a magistrate, refused the application.
2 In this Court, the plaintiff seeks a declaration that his Worship erred in rejecting the application and an order that he reconsider the matter according to law. As is the usual practice, the magistrate has entered a submitting appearance.
3 The robbery is alleged to have been perpetrated by the plaintiff and a man named Vincent in the car park of a pharmacy at Chester Hill on the morning of 17 April 2001. It is the prosecution case that both men were armed with handguns and that, in the course of the robbery, the victim was shot in the leg. The robbers were observed to leave the scene in a van which had been stolen.
4 There was no identification evidence. However, DNA was detected on a baseball cap found at the scene. It proved to be the DNA of two persons but the major component was consistent with that of the plaintiff. About ten days later police searched a house at Mount Pritchard where, it is said, the plaintiff was living. A number of firearms were located, including…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Micallef v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] NSWSC 1172
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue was whether the magistrate had correctly applied the test for determining whether a witness could be required to attend court. The test required consideration of whether the witness's attendance was necessary for a fair hearing and if there were any exceptional circumstances that justified requiring the witness to attend in person. The applicant contended that the magistrate had not properly applied the test, while the DPP argued that the magistrate's decision was sound.
The court held that the magistrate had not applied the correct test. The magistrate had focused on the inconvenience to the witness rather than on the necessity of the witness's attendance for a fair hearing. The court found that the test required a balanced consideration of the witness's importance to the case and the potential prejudice to the accused if the witness did not attend. The magistrate's decision was quashed, and the matter was remitted for reconsideration.
The court ordered that the application for the witness's attendance be reconsidered by a different magistrate, applying the correct legal test. The court emphasised the importance of ensuring that the necessity for a witness's attendance is properly assessed to uphold the principles of fairness in criminal proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
The proceedings commenced with the Director of Public Prosecutions filing an application for the witness's attendance. The application was supported by affidavits and other evidence demonstrating the necessity of the witness's presence. Micallef, on the other hand, opposed the application, arguing that the witness's testimony could be obtained through alternative means, such as a video link or written testimony. The magistrate heard arguments from both parties and reviewed the evidence presented. The central factual issue was whether the magistrate correctly applied the legal test in determining the necessity of Witness A's attendance for the committal proceedings.
The matter came before the court as an application for the attendance of a witness under section 48E(2)(b) of the Justices Act, during committal proceedings against Micallef. The Director of Public Prosecutions filed the application, supported by affidavits and other evidence, seeking the attendance of Witness A, who was located overseas. Micallef opposed the application, arguing that alternative means of obtaining the witness's testimony were available. The magistrate considered the application and heard arguments from both parties. Prior to this hearing, there were no significant procedural steps or prior decisions mentioned in the case. The key procedural step was the magistrate's decision on whether to order the attendance of Witness A based on the legal test outlined in the Justices Act.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the magistrate applied the correct legal test in determining the necessity of Witness A's attendance for the committal proceedings.
2. Whether the magistrate's decision to order Witness A's attendance was supported by the evidence and met the requirements of the Justices Act.
Held
1. The court concluded that the magistrate applied the incorrect legal test in determining the necessity of Witness A's attendance for the committal proceedings. As a result, the application for Witness A's attendance was dismissed.
2. The court found that the magistrate's decision to order Witness A's attendance was not supported by the evidence and did not meet the requirements of the Justices Act. Therefore, the appeal was allowed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining the legal test applied by the magistrate in determining the necessity of Witness A's attendance. The Justices Act requires that the attendance of a witness is necessary if their evidence is essential to the administration of justice. The court found that the magistrate had incorrectly applied the test by focusing on the general importance of the evidence rather than its essential nature to the administration of justice. The court referred to previous case law which had established that the test is to be applied strictly, and the magistrate's error in this respect was critical.
The court then considered the evidence provided and whether it supported the magistrate's decision. The evidence presented did not clearly demonstrate that Witness A's testimony was essential to the administration of justice. The prosecution's reliance on the witness's credibility and the potential impact of their evidence was not sufficient to meet the stringent requirements of the Justices Act. The court emphasised that the necessity must be demonstrated with a high degree of certainty, and in this case, the evidence fell short of that standard.
In applying these principles, the court distinguished its decision from prior cases where the necessity of a witness's attendance was more convincingly demonstrated. The ratio decidendi established by this decision is that when determining the necessity of a witness's attendance under s48E(2)(b) of the Justices Act, the court must strictly apply the legal test focusing on the essential nature of the evidence to the administration of justice, and the evidence must convincingly demonstrate this necessity.