MGC Properties Pty Ltd v Tang

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  MGC Properties Pty Ltd v Tang [2009] QSC 322
PARTIES:  MGC PROPERTIES PTY LTD (ACN 109 247 878)
(applicant)
v
LLOYD LOK ING TANG
(respondent)
FILE NO:  BS6441/09
PARTIES:  Q.L.D. GROUP PTY LTD
(applicant)
v
LLOYD LOK ING TANG
(respondent)
FILE NO:  BS6443/09
PARTIES:  CANN ROAD DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
(applicant)
v
LLOYD LOK ING TANG
(respondent)
FILE NO:  BS6444/09
PARTIES:  HAVEN ROAD DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
(applicant)
v
LLOYD LOK ING TANG
(respondent)
FILE NO:  BS6445/09
PARTIES:  MGC HOLDINGS PTY LTD
(applicant)
v
LLOYD LOK ING TANG
(respondent)
FILE NO:  BS6446/09
PARTIES:  Q.L.D. DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD
(applicant)
v
LLOYD LOK ING TANG
(respondent)
FILE NO:  BS6447/09
DIVISION:  Trial Division
PROCEEDING:  Applications
ORIGINATING 
COURT: 
Supreme Court, Brisbane
DELIVERED ON:  6 October 2009
DELIVERED AT:  Supreme Court, Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  16 July 2009
JUDGE:  Douglas J
ORDER:  Applications dismissed.
CATCHWORDS:  CORPORATIONS – WINDING UP – WINDING UP IN
INSOLVENCY – STATUTORY DEMANDS –
APPLICATION TO SET ASIDE DEMANDS – where the
respondent has issued statutory demands against six different
companies – where the applicants have applied to set the
statutory demands aside – whether there is a genuine dispute
about the existence of the debt or some other reason.
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 459J(1)(b)
Environmental Systems Pty Ltd v Peerless Holdings Pty Ltd
(2008) 19 VR 358, 389 at [93] distinguished
SR Lumb for the applicants
COUNSEL:  AJH Morris QC and VG Brennan for the respondents
SOLICITORS:  Bain Gasteen for the applicants
Londy Lawyers for the respondents
  1. Douglas J: Dr Lloyd Lok Ing Tang has issued statutory demands against six different companies. Those companies have applied to set the statutory demands aside. The demands are each in the same form, for the same amount and rely upon the same agreements. Each application asserts that there is a genuine dispute about the existence of the debt and argues that there is some other reason for setting aside the demands. The demands are said to relate to the applicants’ liability under indemnities granted to secure the obligations of two principal debtors, George Anthony Cheihk and Collingwood Park Developments Pty Ltd (“CPD”) to Dr Tang.

  2. The demands rely upon three deeds, a deed of guarantee and indemnity dated 19 September 2006, a deed of settlement dated 19 September 2006 and a deed of variation dated 19 November 2008.

  3. The applicants argue that on the proper construction of cll. 1.5 and 5.1 of the deed of guarantee and indemnity the amounts the subject of the demands are not due and owing. They also argue that Dr Tang is not entitled to payment of those amounts by reason of cl. 4.2 of a priority and subordination deed also dated 19 November 2008.

    Background facts

  4. The applicants are named as guarantors under the guarantee and indemnity deed where Dr Tang is identified as the beneficiary and Mr Cheihk and CPD are named as the debtors. The relevant passages of the various agreements and the background facts, which were not in dispute,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read MGC Properties Pty Ltd v Tang and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] QSC 322
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of MGC Properties Pty Ltd v Tang involved the applicants, MGC Properties Pty Ltd and others, who sought to set aside statutory demands issued by Dr Tang. The dispute centred on the interpretation of certain clauses within a guarantee and indemnity deed, as well as a priority and subordination deed. The applicants argued that the amounts claimed by Dr Tang were not due and owing under the terms of the deeds, and that Dr Tang was not entitled to payment due to provisions in the subordination deed. The court was required to determine whether the applicants' interpretation of the deeds was correct and whether Dr Tang was entitled to the amounts claimed.

The court examined the relevant clauses of the guarantee and indemnity deed, particularly clauses 1.5 and 5.1, which outlined the guarantors' obligations in the event of a debtor's default. The court also considered clause 4.2 of the priority and subordination deed, which addressed the priority of debts. After reviewing the arguments and the relevant clauses, the court found that the applicants' interpretation of the deeds was incorrect and that Dr Tang was entitled to the amounts claimed. The court concluded that the applicants were not entitled to set aside the statutory demands issued by Dr Tang.

The court dismissed the applicants' applications and ordered that the statutory demands remain in effect. The applicants were also directed to pay Dr Tang's costs associated with the proceedings. This decision affirmed the enforceability of the guarantees and indemnities provided by the applicants and upheld Dr Tang's right to pursue the claimed amounts.

Orders

Orders of the court

Applications dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicants argue that on the proper construction of cll. 1.5 and 5.1 of the deed of guarantee and indemnity the amounts the subject of the demands are not due and owing. They also argue that Dr Tang is not entitled to payment of those amounts by reason of cl. 4.2 of a priority and subordination deed also dated 19 November 2008. Background facts The applicants are named as guarantors under the guarantee and indemnity deed where Dr Tang is identified as the beneficiary and Mr Cheihk and CPD are named as the debtors. The relevant passages of the various agreements and the background facts, which were not in dispute, were identified usefully in the applicant’s written submissions. Guarantee and Indemnity Deed The relevant clauses in the guarantee and indemnity deed included cl. 1.5 which provided: “If the Debtor defaults in the due and punctual performance of any of the Debtor’s Obligations, the Guarantor unconditionally indemnifies the Beneficiary against all consequential loss which the Beneficiary may suffer, and shall pay the amount of any such loss on demand to or as directed by the Beneficiary.” Clause 5.1 provided: “For the consideration mentioned in clause 2.1, the Guarantor unconditionally indemnifies the Beneficiary against any loss which the Beneficiary may suffer or Claim against it because: (a) the Debtor’s Obligations are unenforceable in whole or in part; or (b) the Guaranteed Moneys, in whole or in part, are not recoverable from the Debtor or having been recovered are repaid and restored.” “Debtor’s Obligations” was defined to mean: “the Obligations of the Debtor to pay the Guaranteed Moneys and all its other Obligations to the Beneficiary (present or future, actual or contingent) under or in connection with the Transaction Documents any agreement, Security Interest, Guarantee or instrument.” “Guaranteed Moneys” was defined to mean: “Transaction Documents” was defined to mean: The settlement deed was entered into between, among others, Dr Tang, Mr Cheihk, CPD and the applicants. In broad terms, under the settlement deed the parties agreed to the settlement of proceedings commenced by Dr Tang against various parties including Mr Cheihk, CPD and the applicants on the basis, inter alia, that Mr Cheihk and CPD pay to Dr Tang six instalments totalling $5.2 million (with security and guarantees for payment of the same to be provided) and that Dr Tang transfer 200 shares in CPD and 200 units in the Collingwood Park Unit Trust (“the trust”) to certain parties. Under the settlement deed, the fifth instalment of $720,000.00 was due on or before 31 July 2008 and the sixth instalment of $620,000.00 was due on or before 31 January 2009. The Deed of Variation The deed of variation was entered into between, among others, Dr Tang, Mr Cheihk, CPD and the applicants. The deed of variation varied terms of the settlement deed. Pursuant to the deed of variation Dr Tang agreed to vary the date for payment of the fifth instalment in consideration for which Mr Cheihk and CPD agreed to:

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Otherwise there was no dispute as to the amount of the debt claimed in each case. Conclusion and orders Accordingly I would dismiss the applications and shall hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established