Metso Minerals (Australia) Ltd v Kalra (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Metso Minerals (Australia) Ltd v Kalra (No 2) [2007] FCA 2108

Search order – Order 25B – subsequent variation – no continuing fear of evidence being destroyed

METSO MINERALS (AUSTRALIA) LTD (ACN 000197428) AND METSO MINERALS INDUSTRIES INC v RAJIV KALRA, MICHAEL RAUSCHER, TUCKWOOD DRAFTING PTY LTD AND STEVEN TUCKWOOD
NSD 2426 OF 2007

FLICK J
14 DECEMBER 2007
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 2426 OF 2007

BETWEEN:

METSO MINERALS (AUSTRALIA) LTD (ACN 000197428)
First Applicant

METSO MINERALS INDUSTRIES INC
Second Applicant

AND:

RAJIV KALRA
First Respondent

MICHAEL RAUSCHER
Second Respondent

TUCKWOOD DRAFTING PTY LTD
Third Respondent

STEVEN TUCKWOOD
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

FLICK J

DATE OF ORDER:

14 DECEMBER 2007

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Access to Documents and Materials Produced to the Court

1.Upon the undertakings in Schedule A being given to the Court, the Independent Solicitor be granted leave to uplift all electronic copies of computer hard drives and storage media (‘electronic copies’) produced to the Court today in accordance with Order 20(e) of the orders of the Court of 11 December, 2007 (‘Orders’) and to deliver all such electronic copies to the Independent Computer Expert for the purpose of the Independent Computer Expert recovering and examining the electronic copies to search for the listed things (as defined in the orders) in accordance with written instructions provided by the Applicants' solicitors and, if requested, by the Respondents' solicitors, in each case copied to all other solicitors.

2.The legal representatives for the parties be granted photocopy access to the hard copies of documents produced to the Court today in accordance with Order 20(e) of the Orders and access to the hard copies is limited to:

(a)the Applicants' legal representatives; and

(b)the Respondents' legal representatives,

save that leave is granted to the legal representatives to uplift any documents which are larger than A4 size for the sole purpose of photocopying and provided that they are returned to the registry within 2 business days. 

3.As soon as practical, and in any event on or before 8 February 2008, the Independent Computer Expert shall:

(a)provide a report to the Independent Solicitor of whether any listed things (as defined in the orders) were or had been located on any of the electronic copies;

(b)return to the Independent Solicitor all the electronic copies.

4.Within 2 business days of receipt by the Independent Solicitor of the further report of the Independent Computer Expert referred to in paragraph 3(a) herein, the Independent Solicitor shall:

(a)deliver to the Court all things received from the Independent Computer Expert in accordance with Order 3(b); and

(b)serve a copy of the further report in accordance with order 3(a) on all the parties’ legal representatives.

Extension of the Orders against the Third and Fourth Respondents

5.Upon the undertakings in Schedule A being given to the Court, the operation of the Orders as against the Third and Fourth Respondents be extended until 5:00 pm on 18 December 2007.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Metso Minerals (Australia) Ltd v Kalra (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FCA 2108
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Metso Minerals (Australia) Ltd v Kalra (No 2) involved a dispute between Metso Minerals (Australia) Ltd and Kalra, with additional parties, regarding access to and inspection of electronic documents. The case was heard in a court that granted specific orders to facilitate the search and recovery of electronic data from the respondent's premises. The legal issues before the court included the scope of the search order, the handling of electronic data, and the timing for the Independent Computer Expert to complete their tasks. The court had to determine whether the proposed methods for accessing and copying electronic data were appropriate and whether the deadlines set for the Independent Computer Expert were reasonable.

The court found that the proposed methods for accessing and copying the electronic data were acceptable, provided certain conditions were met. These conditions included the provision of undertakings to the court by the applicants, their solicitors, the independent solicitor, and the independent computer expert. The court also adjusted the deadlines for the Independent Computer Expert to complete their tasks, extending the time frames to ensure that the search was conducted thoroughly and efficiently. Additionally, the court granted the applicants leave to issue subpoenas for production as outlined in the affidavit, and it set a new date for the proceedings to be mentioned.

In summary, the court's decision allowed the applicants to access and copy electronic data from the respondent's premises under specific conditions and timelines. The court granted various orders to facilitate this process, including extensions for the Independent Computer Expert and the Independent Solicitor. The court also provided guidelines on how the electronic data and documents should be handled and reported, ensuring that the search was conducted in a manner that minimized disruption to the respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

Access to Documents and Materials Produced to the Court

1. Upon the undertakings in Schedule A being given to the Court, the Independent Solicitor be granted leave to uplift all electronic copies of computer hard drives and storage media (‘electronic copies’) produced to the Court today in accordance with Order 20(e) of the orders of the Court of 11 December, 2007 (‘Orders’) and to deliver all such electronic copies to the Independent Computer Expert for the purpose of the Independent Computer Expert recovering and examining the electronic copies to search for the listed things (as defined in the orders) in accordance with written instructions provided by the Applicants' solicitors and, if requested, by the Respondents' solicitors, in each case copied to all other solicitors.

2. The legal representatives for the parties be granted photocopy access to the hard copies of documents produced to the Court today in accordance with Order 20(e) of the Orders and access to the hard copies is limited to:

(a) the Applicants' legal representatives; and

(b) the Respondents' legal representatives,

save that leave is granted to the legal representatives to uplift any documents which are larger than A4 size for the sole purpose of photocopying and provided that they are returned to the registry within 2 business days.

3. As soon as practical, and in any event on or before 8 February 2008, the Independent Computer Expert shall:

(a) provide a report to the Independent Solicitor of whether any listed things (as defined in the orders) were or had been located on any of the electronic copies;

(b) return to the Independent Solicitor all the electronic copies.

4. Within 2 business days of receipt by the Independent Solicitor of the further report of the Independent Computer Expert referred to in paragraph 3(a) herein, the Independent Solicitor shall:

(a) deliver to the Court all things received from the Independent Computer Expert in accordance with Order 3(b); and

(b) serve a copy of the further report in accordance with order 3(a) on all the parties’ legal representatives.

Extension of the Orders against the Third and Fourth Respondents

5. Upon the undertakings in Schedule A being given to the Court, the operation of the Orders as against the Third and Fourth Respondents be extended until 5:00 pm on 18 December 2007.

6. The orders be amended as follows:

(a) the return date be 9:30am, 21 December 2007;

(b) a new Order 20(dd) be made as follows:

'If it will not be possible for the independent computer expert to make a complete copy of any computer hard drive or other storage media at the Tuckwood Drafting Premises before 6:00pm, Thursday 13 December 2007, the independent computer expert may remove the computer, computer hard drives or other storage media to make a complete copy of that removed item at the premises of the independent computer expert and return all things taken prior to 21 December 2007.';

(c) existing Order 20(e) be deleted.

(d) a new Order 20(e) is made as follows:

'The independent computer expert must as soon as practicable and, in any event, prior to 21 December 2007, deliver the copy or digital copy of the computer hard drive or other storage media, all items removed pursuant to Order 20(dd) above and all electronic and hard copies of listed things to the independent solicitor, together with a report of what the independent computer expert has done including a list of such electronic and hard copies.'

7. The time for compliance by the Independent Computer Expert with Order 20(e) of the orders in relation to copies or digital copies of the computer hard drive or other storage media removed from the Tuckwood Drafting Premises after 6:00pm, 13 December 2007 be extended to 6:00pm, 20 December 2007.

8. The time for compliance by the Independent Solicitor with Order 20(f) of the orders in relation to copies or digital copies of the computer hard drive or other storage media removed from the Tuckwood Drafting Premises after 6:00pm, 13 December 2007 be extended to on or prior to 9:30am, 21 December 2007.

Subpoenas

9. The Applicants be granted leave to issue subpoenas for production in the form annexed to the Affidavit of Astrid Van Esch sworn 7 December, 2007.

Adjourned Date

10. The proceedings be adjourned to 9:30am, 21 December 2007 for mention.

11. Costs be reserved.

12. Liberty to any party to apply.

SCHEDULE A - UNDERTAKINGS GIVEN TO THE COURT

Undertakings given to the Court by the applicants

(1) The applicants undertake to submit to such order (if any) as the Court may consider to be just for the payment of compensation (to be assessed by the Court or as it may direct) to any person (whether or not a party) affected by the operation of the order.

(2) The applicants will not, without leave of the Court, use any information, document or thing obtained as a result of the execution of this order for the purpose of any civil or criminal proceeding, either within or outside Australia, other than this proceeding.

(3) The applicants will insure the things removed from the premises against loss or damage for an amount that reasonably appears to the applicant to be their full value.

Undertakings given to the Court by the applicants' solicitors

(1) The applicants' solicitor will pay the reasonable costs and disbursements of the independent solicitor and of any independent computer expert.

(2) The applicant's solicitor will use his or her best endeavours to act in conformity with the order and to ensure that the order is executed in a courteous and orderly manner and in a manner that minimises disruption to the respondent.

(3) The applicants' solicitor will not, without leave of the Court, use any information, document or thing obtained as a result of the execution of this order for the purpose of any civil or criminal proceeding, either within or outside Australia, other than this proceeding.

(4) The applicants' solicitor will not disclose to the applicants any information that the solicitor acquires during or as a result of execution of the search order, save:

(a) as provided in Orders 2 and 3; and

(b) with the leave of the Court.

(5) The applicants' solicitor will use best endeavours to follow all directions of the independent solicitor.

Undertakings given to the Court by the independent solicitor

(1) The independent solicitor will retain custody of all things removed from the premises by the independent solicitor pursuant to this order until delivery to the Court or further order of the Court.

(2) At or before the hearing on 21 December 2007, the independent solicitor will provide a further written report to the Court on the carrying out of Orders 6 and 7 and provide a copy to the applicant's solicitors and to the respondent or the respondent's solicitors. The report will attach a copy of any list made pursuant to the order and a copy of any report received from an independent computer expert.

(3) The independent solicitor will use best endeavours to ensure that members of the search party act in conformity with Orders 6 and 7 and that Orders 6 and 7 are executed in a courteous and orderly manner and in a manner that minimises disruption to the respondents, and will give such reasonable directions to other members of the search party as are necessary or convenient for the execution of the order.

(4) The independent solicitor will not, without leave of the Court, use any information, document or thing obtained as a result of the execution of this order for the purpose of any civil or criminal proceeding, either within or outside Australia, other than this proceeding.

Undertakings given to the Court by the independent computer expert

(1) The independent computer expert will use his or her best endeavours to act in conformity with Orders 6 and 7 and to ensure that Orders 6 and 7, so far as they concern the independent computer expert, are executed in a courteous and orderly manner and in a manner that minimises disruption to the respondent.

(2) The independent computer expert will not, without leave of the Court, use any information, document or thing obtained as a result of the execution of this order for the purpose of any civil or criminal proceeding, either within or outside Australia, other than this proceeding.

(3) The independent computer expert will use best endeavours to follow all directions of the independent solicitor.

SCHEDULE B

Nominated Representative means:

(a) Mr Ross Wotherspoon of the First Applicant,

(b) Mr Alan Boughey, an independent contractor to the First Applicant; or

(c) Jeff Leonard of the Second Applicant,

and Nominated Representatives means all of them.

The Nominated Representative undertakes to the Court that, to the extent they have access to electronic or hard copies of documents obtained pursuant to the search order granted on 1 December 2007, they will:

(a) keep the documents and the information contained therein confidential;

(b) not use the documents and the information contained therein other than for the purposes of giving instructions to:

(i) the applicants' Solicitors and Counsel;

(ii) the independent solicitor; and

(iii) the independent computer expert.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FLICK J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FLICK J

Full text does not contain this section.