Metro Quarry Group Pty Ltd v Ingham

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

[2016] FWCFB 47

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009
s.604 - Appeal of decisions
Metro Quarry Group Pty Ltd
v
John Ingham
(C2015/6831)
VICE PRESIDENT WATSON
DEPUTY PRESIDENT HAMILTON MELBOURNE, 4 FEBRUARY 2016
COMMISSIONER JOHNS

Appeal against decision [2015] FWC 6472 of Commissioner Bissett at Melbourne on 29

September 2015 in matter number U2015/7306 – Permission to appeal – Whether termination

harsh and unjust – Consideration of criteria for considering harshness etc – Whether

appealable error – Significant mistake of fact – Fair Work Act 2009, ss. 387, 394, 400 and

604.

Introduction

[1]        This decision concerns an application for permission to appeal and an appeal against a

decision of Commissioner Bissett handed down on 29 September 2015.The decision of the

Commissioner concerned an unfair dismissal application made by John Ingham on 1 May

2015 under s.394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act) in relation to the termination of his

employment by Metro Quarry Group Pty Ltd (Metro Quarry).

[2]        The Commissioner found that Metro Quarry had a valid reason for terminating Mr

Ingham’s employment and that while Mr Ingham had a dismissive attitude to attempts by

Metro Quarry’s management to implement improved health and safety standards, the

termination of his employment was nevertheless harsh and unjust.

[3]        The Commissioner found that reinstatement was not an appropriate remedy in the

circumstances and ordered that compensation amounting to $11,507.16 be paid to Mr Ingham.

[4]        Permission to appeal was granted on transcript at the conclusion of the hearing before

the Full Bench held on 28 October 2015. Directions were subsequently issued for the filing of

written submissions in relation to the appeal on the basis that the matter was to be determined

on the papers. Mr Ingham did not file submissions in accordance with the directions issued.

Metro Quarry requested that the appeal be listed for an oral hearing to determine the matter as

it was not clear whether Mr Ingham had provided adequate consent to the determination of the

appeal without an oral hearing. The appeal matter was listed for hearing on 16 December

2015.
[2016] FWCFB 47

[5]        At the hearing of both the permission to appeal application and the appeal Mr A.

Aleksov, of counsel, appeared on behalf of Metro Quarry. There was no appearance on behalf

of Mr Ingham at either hearing before the Full Bench.

Background

[6]        Metro Quarry operates a sand mining operation at Nyora in the South Gippsland

region of Victoria and a related sand distribution business at Devon Meadows on the south

eastern outskirts of Melbourne. Approximately 70 employees are employed across the two

sites. Metro Quarry acquired the operations from a previous owner, TGS, in 2013. According

to Metro Quarry the previous owner had a “lackadaisical” safety culture with many

compliance issues. In 2010 a well-liked and long serving employee was killed while operating

an excavator when it was engulfed in a land slip when working beneath an unstable slope. The

previous owner directed employees to continue work the next day…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Metro Quarry Group Pty Ltd v Ingham and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FWCFB 47
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Metro Quarry Group Pty Ltd appealed against the decision of Commissioner Bissett that the dismissal of John Ingham was harsh and unjust. The Commissioner found that there was a valid reason for the dismissal, namely Mr Ingham's failure to comply with the company's drug and alcohol policy, and that he had been notified and given an opportunity to respond to this reason. However, the Commissioner found that the dismissal was harsh and unjust and ordered that compensation be paid to Mr Ingham. Metro Quarry Group argued that the Commissioner had erred in finding that a positive blood alcohol content test would lead to a stand down of an employee and not a dismissal under the company's Drug and Alcohol Policy, in refusing to accept documentary evidence in relation to a bagging machine incident, in treating numerous other safety breaches by Mr Ingham as not available for the company to rely on in the dismissal because he was not given formal warning in relation to those incidents, and in failing to appreciate that the decision to dismiss Mr Ingham was based on a loss of trust and confidence in his ability to comply with all safety policies, rather than a sanction for breaches of safety policies. The Full Bench found that the Commissioner had erred in finding that the bagging machine incident did not warrant a first and final warning, and in failing to properly consider the factors relevant to fairness. The Full Bench concluded that the dismissal was not harsh, unjust or unreasonable and dismissed Mr Ingham's application. Permission to appeal was granted and the appeal was allowed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established